Pearl S. Buck may have written some important novels in her day, but I can't say I like the prose or the stories of any that I've read. This is interesting, at least, in its set-up, as I have read almost nothing about the Communist Revolution in China, and had not thought about the plights of people who had lived there who were not Communists. However, the story is sort of toneless and ignorantly religious in a certain way. The priests insistence that characters must recognize sin when those same characters have renounced, or never known about, religion, is frustrating to say the least. Likewise, their blame of women for luring them into sinfulness. Likewise, their insistence that Siu-Lan marry the man that raped her. Whether it's the ignorance of the characters, or Buck's own beliefs, it is hard to say. In any case, I wasn't into it.