This has to be for kids a little older than Julia but every once in awhile she gets in the mood for a scary story or two (usually when she happens to notice a book or movie) so when we found this at the library we borrowed it.
There are 8 stories included and some are better than others of course.
The first story, 'On Brighton Road' by Richard Middleton was okay and I could see how it could be scary for a kid.
The second story, 'Selecting a Ghost' by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was more humorous than scary in our opinions and I didn't care for some of the text, the way that things were said, in a very old manner. A hard to understand manner for most kids I'd assume.
The third story, 'A Creature of Habit' by Ambrose Beirce was very short, the shortest included here I think, and borderline scary. The illustrations for a lot of the stories, including this one, are sometimes the "scariest" part.
Next comes 'Man-size in Marble' by Edith Nesbit and this story was one of the better ones we both agreed.
The fifth, 'Rose Rose' by Barry Pain was the only one we didn't totally agree on. Julia liked it more than I did. It's not a bad story, just not one of the best in my opinion while Julia put it in her top 3 (in this book).
The sixth story, 'The Upper Berth' by F. Marion Crawford was one of the scarier ones. I didn't like some of the "sea speak" but it was needed and I dealt with it. It's definitely one of the three scariest in this book though.
The seventh story, 'Lost Hearts' by M.R. James was the best in my opinion and it's in Julia's top 3 too. (She couldn't make up her mind if she liked this or the last the best.)
The last story is 'The Legend of Sleepy Hollow' by Washington Irving. Julia's always been interested in the Headless Horseman so I think that alone pulled her in with this one. I wouldn't mind finding a kids book but a little more in depth about this - I know Julia would love it.
I want to note for future reference that we read these as bedtime stories, one or two each night for a few nights, as opposed to the shorter books we read during the day.