I'm actually giving this 4.5 stars, but unusually, am rounding up rather than down. Why? Two words. Harry. Pye.
This book has been on my TBR pile for quite some time, so when I saw that one of the prompts for the AAR Days of the Week Reading Challenge was to read a book in which the hero or heroine is a landowner, a farmer, a gardener, a botanist, or a book that has the words "garden" or "flower" in its title, or the book is set in the country side, I immediately added the book to my list.
There are many historical romances which feature a central couple of unequal status or fortune. Dukes, Earls and Marquesses fall in love with governesses and companions all the time, but it is less usual to find the inequality working the other way, and have a wealthy, titled heroine falling for a commoner and working man. But that’s the premise here, and Ms Hoyt explores the double standard – held to an extent by the protagonists themselves as well as by wider society - in a way which feels quite realistic.
Lady Georgina (known as “George”) Maitland is the daughter of an earl who has spent most of her twenty-eight years in the thick of London society. Unusually for the time, she owns property in her own right, having recently been bequeathed an estate – Woldsly Manor - in Yorkshire, and when the book opens, is travelling there in the company of her land steward of six months, Mr Harry Pye.
Soon after their arrival, they discover that all is not well, both on the Woldsly estate and others in the locality. Large numbers of sheep are being poisoned – and the local squire and magistrate, Silas Granville, who has a long-standing grudge against Harry, insists that he is responsible.
Georgina, who is quite capable of making her own judgement as to the character of her steward, does not believe this for an instant, which rather surprises Harry. He’s well aware of the fact that the upper classes are far more likely to take the word of one of their own than to take the part of a servant – something which is borne out by his own experience.
But George is not your average aristocrat. She’s independent – both of mind and financially – clever and a bit of a free-thinker, and isn’t prepared to let an innocent man be wrongly accused. She is also strongly attracted to Harry (who may be described as unremarkable, but who is seriously HOT), as is he to her – but the huge difference in their stations presents something of an obstacle.
Harry is very much his own man. The son of a gamekeeper, he spent time in the poorhouse before leaving when he was old enough and, because of his good instinct for land management rose quickly to become a land steward at a young age. He’s intelligent, hard-working, honourable and blessed with a good dose of common sense. He might not be a gentleman by birth, but he is frequently shown to advantage when contrasted against Granville and his eldest son, who are indolent, greedy and selfish, the worst kind of landowner and surely, the type of man least deserving of the label of “gentleman”.
George and Harry are in the grip of a lust like they’ve never before experienced – but George knows that she will have to make the first move. The problem is, she has no idea how to go about it and Harry isn’t going to make it easy for her. He’s a proud man, and even though he wants George desperately, he also isn’t prepared to be taken up as a bit of rough on the side and discarded when his lady has sated her curiosity.
I thoroughly enjoyed the way the relationship between Harry and George developed. Their growing awareness of each other, their deepening attraction – and the eventual and combustible consummation were all very well written, and Elizabeth Hoyt certainly delivers in the combustible department! The build-up of sexual tension between the pair is very skilfully done and the sex scenes are deliciously earthy and hot. I think the book’s being set in the mid 18th century and away from London made a romance between the pair more believable than if it had been set in the more obsessively “proper” 19th century among the hotbed of London society.
The suspense plot is well handled, too, with plenty of twists, turns and the odd red herring; and there is a strong cast of secondary characters, not least of which are Granville’s two sons, whose characteristics and actions do much to illuminate the extremely unpleasant character of their father.
Up until the last 15 or 20 percent of the book, I was convinced it was going to be a 5 star read – until George does something so completely out of character that it left me scratching my head. It didn’t ruin the book, but it did draw out the ending unnecessarily and made no sense, so I had to knock off half a star.
Other than that, however, this is a wonderful book, and Harry is one swoonworthy hero. I hope to be able to get to the other two books in the series soon.