What do you think?
Rate this book
Breaking Love #2
Breaking Silence
The long-awaited follow up to Breaking Giants...
Matt Sullivan is an indie rock god. With good reason, too: the lead guitarist of Breaking Giants is built like a Swedish underwear model. His fandom is rabid, his charisma unquestionable.
A million hearts broke last year when he asked his girlfriend to marry him. Including—if I’m honest—mine.
Not that I ever stood a chance with him, despite our brief encounter six years ago. An encounter I think of too often and I’m sure he’s completely forgotten.
Then five little words change my life.
“He’s back on the market.”
Suddenly Matt is everywhere I look.
And this time, he’s looking back.
Breaking Silence is a full-length standalone rockstar romance. Spice and HEA guaranteed. See author's website for trigger warnings.
Matt Sullivan is an indie rock god. With good reason, too: the lead guitarist of Breaking Giants is built like a Swedish underwear model. His fandom is rabid, his charisma unquestionable.
A million hearts broke last year when he asked his girlfriend to marry him. Including—if I’m honest—mine.
Not that I ever stood a chance with him, despite our brief encounter six years ago. An encounter I think of too often and I’m sure he’s completely forgotten.
Then five little words change my life.
“He’s back on the market.”
Suddenly Matt is everywhere I look.
And this time, he’s looking back.
Breaking Silence is a full-length standalone rockstar romance. Spice and HEA guaranteed. See author's website for trigger warnings.
338 pages, Kindle Edition
Published June 29, 2023
About the author
L.M. Halloran
21 books1,150 followersWhen she's not reading or writing, the author enjoys walking barefoot and chasing her spirited daughter. She's a rabid fan of coffee, moongazing, and small dogs that resemble Ewoks. She lives in Portland, OR.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 105 reviews
June 10, 2023
‘Love is more powerful than darkness anyway.’
It was like coming home reading Breaking Silence the new full-length standalone rockstar romance by L.M. Halloran. We’ve missed her stories, and Breaking Silence was a fabulous return. This book deals with some very sensitive themes, with trigger warnings available from the author's website. We absolutely LOVED this book! What a triumphant return!
Breaking Silence is an emotionally charged, raw, soulful, and highly emotive story. The rock star theme we desperately crave was perfectly executed in this story of love, trust, and healing. Everything about this story hit us in the hearts. We were riveted.
We first met Matthew (Matt) Sullivan, though somewhat briefly, in Breaking Giants which we read back in 2017, and it was great to be back with the boys from the band Breaking Giants who have success, and for some, their life partners. Matt, recently single, has sworn off relationships – he’s been burned one time too many, that is, until the gorgeous, yet troubled, Sophie Marshall.
“The strongest love comes when the heart is a little broken open. It means there’s space for deeper roots to grow.”
Sophie too, has sworn off relationships, though her fear comes from a deep, dark, troubled place, which, once uncovered broke our hearts, and cemented our love for Matt as he comforted, protected, and brought the love and safety Sophie so craved, yet was terrified to open herself up to the possibility.
Matt and Sophie’s story will touch your heart, their chemistry will set you alight. The way Matt handled Sophie was handled incredibly well. His patience, his tenderness, the way he gave her space when needed. This man was something else.
“I’ll take whatever you want to give me, Sophie Marshall.”
Available to purchase
Ebook
July 2, 2023
On a whole, some folks will like it while others like me who are safety readers, may not and here is why:
June 28, 2023
A new book by LM Halloran? Sign me up! Sophie and Matt’s story is a can’t miss! Sophie has endured unthinkable horror in her life. But she has had a great support system, especially from her brother, Josh. Then she meets Matt. He’s her friend…or is he? I love them together. They are the best at being friends and when toy becomes more the relationship is hot! Matt is the sweetest! Anyone would be lucky to have this guy. The things he does for Sophie are so heartwarming. And as usual, the writing is impeccable and it makes you really feel like these are real people, making the emotions that much more raw. What an amazing read that romance readers will not want to miss, especially if you like rockstar romance!
~Alexis💜
~Alexis💜
April 21, 2025
I love how L.M. Halloran weaves such heartbreaking backstories into such sweet love stories. I was captivated from the first page until the very last. Five Stars!
June 8, 2023
Ugh!! I absolutely adored this book! This was so well-written and beautifully told! Sophie’s story was incredibly heartbreaking. I’ve never experienced the kind of pain and suffering she had, but I felt all of her emotions and completely understood where she was coming from. And Matt… omg! I loved him from the beginning! Definitely not what you expect from a rock star romance, but he was so incredibly swoon worthy!! The way he was with her just completely melted my heart. This is definitely my kind of story - love when one of the main characters is emotionally unavailable (and for good reason!), especially when it’s done as well as this one! I loved Breaking Giants when I read it, but I’m pretty sure this one just topped it. Highly recommend this story!!
May 31, 2023
We make plans, we have hopes and dreams, and then life has other ideas. Dreams get dashed, hopes are left smoldering, and no one understands this better than our heroine, Sophie Marshall. Her past has taught her to build a wall around her heart and live a safe, simple life. The last thing she's looking for is attention from the charming, Viking-like a rock star, Matt Sullivan.
After being dumped by his fiancée, Matt has sworn off relationships for the foreseeable future. Meeting Sophie has him rethinking his female embargo, but Sophie is emotionally unavailable, so he proposes a friendship. In all honesty, this cinnamon roll hero is half gone already, and he'll take whatever parts of Sophie she's willing to share.
The road is certainly not an easy one for these two. There's Matt's fame and celebrity that follows him in public, and the demons from Sophie's past are never far away. Matt is honest and patient, and most of all, simply there for Sophie as she figures out how to overcome her past so they can share a future. Their story is both heartbreaking anguish and thrilling inspiration that made the rest of the world fall away as I gobbled through this in one sitting.
Let's face it. Pretty much no one makes it through this life unscathed, but it's how we respond to hardship that matters. Halloran gives us imperfect, broken characters we relate to and find a kinship with. We empathize with their challenges, take on their heartbreak as our own, and rejoice in their victories. They make us feel a little more seen in our struggles and a little less alone in our journey. They find optimism, healing, and love, daring us to dream and fanning our own embers of hope as we travel their road to forever.
It's been six years since Breaking Giants was released and, for that reason alone, this story may not make an enormous splash in the pond of contemporary romance. But for anyone fortunate enough to read it, its impact is immeasurable, so make sure you don’t pass it by. It will be one of your favorites, and one that will remain in your heart long after the last page.
After being dumped by his fiancée, Matt has sworn off relationships for the foreseeable future. Meeting Sophie has him rethinking his female embargo, but Sophie is emotionally unavailable, so he proposes a friendship. In all honesty, this cinnamon roll hero is half gone already, and he'll take whatever parts of Sophie she's willing to share.
The road is certainly not an easy one for these two. There's Matt's fame and celebrity that follows him in public, and the demons from Sophie's past are never far away. Matt is honest and patient, and most of all, simply there for Sophie as she figures out how to overcome her past so they can share a future. Their story is both heartbreaking anguish and thrilling inspiration that made the rest of the world fall away as I gobbled through this in one sitting.
Let's face it. Pretty much no one makes it through this life unscathed, but it's how we respond to hardship that matters. Halloran gives us imperfect, broken characters we relate to and find a kinship with. We empathize with their challenges, take on their heartbreak as our own, and rejoice in their victories. They make us feel a little more seen in our struggles and a little less alone in our journey. They find optimism, healing, and love, daring us to dream and fanning our own embers of hope as we travel their road to forever.
It's been six years since Breaking Giants was released and, for that reason alone, this story may not make an enormous splash in the pond of contemporary romance. But for anyone fortunate enough to read it, its impact is immeasurable, so make sure you don’t pass it by. It will be one of your favorites, and one that will remain in your heart long after the last page.
July 1, 2023
L.M. Halloran I have missed you and the stories you create!
What a beautiful story about broken hearts and love. Sophie has survived so much and has a walk so big around her heart. And Matt, who is a rockstar with a big heart, discover what love is really about.
This story was heartbreaking, but yet so sweet and full of love. What an emotional rollercoaster! I loved it!!
What a beautiful story about broken hearts and love. Sophie has survived so much and has a walk so big around her heart. And Matt, who is a rockstar with a big heart, discover what love is really about.
This story was heartbreaking, but yet so sweet and full of love. What an emotional rollercoaster! I loved it!!
March 12, 2024
4,5
Rollercoaster, emotional, traumatic triggers but so so good
Sophie brave, beautiful and Matt.. I want a Matt in my life . He plays the guitar and cooks.. Yeah..
Rollercoaster, emotional, traumatic triggers but so so good
Sophie brave, beautiful and Matt.. I want a Matt in my life . He plays the guitar and cooks.. Yeah..
October 31, 2024
A saw a video saying this was a super angsty romance and for me, it wasn’t. I gave up at 60%. There was nothing wrong with the book, I just wasn’t feeling super connected unfortunately.
December 2, 2023
It’s been a long time since I’ve been so over the moon about a book. Rockstars are my kryptonite, and Matt is my superhero!!! Nothing short of fabulous.
June 9, 2025
4.5⭐ I can't explain why but I just loved this one. Better than the first one which was also a good read but a bit more angsty. This was not a fluffy love story and I loved the realness of it all. Could not put it down.
July 26, 2023
Such a great book. Loved Matt and Sophie. Good to have a good story again from this author. Loved catching up with Rose and Julian from Breaking Giants.
Highly recommended 👌
Highly recommended 👌
February 29, 2024
We first meet Matt in Breaking Giants and I LOVED him immediately. He's that side character that you know you will protect at all costs. He was charming and sweet and funny and just swoonworthy. So when I discovered that THIS book was Matt's story, I almost tripped over myself to download it.
I'm honestly trying to space our Laura's books becuase when the day comes that I have nothing left to read of hers, I will be one sad book lover. But I had zero chill with this one.
Matt is absolutely one of my favorite MMCs of all time. I love him with every fiber of my being. And Sophie was just perfect for him. They also fought hard for their love but it was so worth it in the end. The emotional roller coaster that they went on was worth every stomach flip.
I'm honestly trying to space our Laura's books becuase when the day comes that I have nothing left to read of hers, I will be one sad book lover. But I had zero chill with this one.
Matt is absolutely one of my favorite MMCs of all time. I love him with every fiber of my being. And Sophie was just perfect for him. They also fought hard for their love but it was so worth it in the end. The emotional roller coaster that they went on was worth every stomach flip.
August 28, 2024
Felt that this was a decent read and touched on deep trauma and the journey to living with it/overcoming it.
While the book was good, it wasn’t great. I enjoyed the characters and the idea of the plot but there wasn’t enough drama for me. The book itself was pretty boring. The first half was decent and I thought they were building towards something, but just didn’t happen.
The main characters face road blocks in their relationship but they felt fairly minor and they overcame them within a few pages. Even at the end, felt like they threw in Melody, Matt’s ex-fiancé, very haphazardly and it was resolved within a few paragraphs, ultimately leaving you wondering why it was built into the plot at all.
While the book was good, it wasn’t great. I enjoyed the characters and the idea of the plot but there wasn’t enough drama for me. The book itself was pretty boring. The first half was decent and I thought they were building towards something, but just didn’t happen.
The main characters face road blocks in their relationship but they felt fairly minor and they overcame them within a few pages. Even at the end, felt like they threw in Melody, Matt’s ex-fiancé, very haphazardly and it was resolved within a few paragraphs, ultimately leaving you wondering why it was built into the plot at all.
August 28, 2023
love this rockstar world
Dang this is another great one!! I really love this rock star/coffee shop world and wish there would be a continuance of stories! I’m glad I stumbled across this author! Planning on reading more of her work!
Dang this is another great one!! I really love this rock star/coffee shop world and wish there would be a continuance of stories! I’m glad I stumbled across this author! Planning on reading more of her work!
June 9, 2025
Really enjoyed this. Gobbled it up in a day.
Quick and fun read. Great chemistry and banter. Really wanted the parent’s backstory before starting first verse!
Quick and fun read. Great chemistry and banter. Really wanted the parent’s backstory before starting first verse!
September 29, 2026
""Love is more powerful than darkness, anyway"
O Matt tornou-se o meu favorito de não há forma de conseguir mesmo refutar isto. Adorei-o até mais não. Acho que deste o primeiro livro que eu sabia que ele era fantástico e queria mesmo o seu happy ending. Quando terminei o primeiro livro tinha já presente na minha cabeça que queria que o Matt tivesse o seu final feliz.
Primeiro achei estranho porque ele estava com a Melody no primeiro livro e tudo parecia estar mesmo em good terms e realmente surpreendeu-me quando, ao ler a sinopse do segundo livro, percebi que ela não seria o seu end game.
Confesso que apesar de ter seguido muito pouco a primeira história de amor do Matt, esta segunda? A Sophie era a pessoa certa para ele!
Acho que das coisas que gostei foi o quanto eles cresceram no livro e em especial conseguiram mesmo criar uma amizade acima de tudo. Acima do sexo, acima da fama e isso sim acabou por ser das coisas que acabei por mais prezar ao longo de todo o livro. Gostei de como eles começaram acima de tudo por ser amigos, mesmo quando ambos sabiam já de antemão que havia algo mais entre eles.
Para ser honesta fiquei confusa com o comportamento final da Melody, não gostei para ser honesta. Acho que ficou um tanto desproporcional com aquilo que já tinha aprendido dela no outro livro e isso deixou-me desiludida.
O passado da Sophie é intenso e percebo porque ela não queria uma relação, mas ao mesmo tempo gosto de como ela se sentiu à vontade com o Matt (por isso é que disse que o mais importante foi mesmo a amizade que eles criaram). Além disso, adoro como o irmão dela está sempre lá para ela mesmo em todos os momentos. Também falando da Sophie e dos amigos mais importantes que são mesmo de valorizar.
Além disso, acho que foi importante como eles conseguiram dividir a relação que o irmão dela já tinha com o Matt (através da loja das tattoos enquanto cliente e tatuador) e da forma como já falavam um tanto sobre ele.
Adorei mesmo.
O Matt tornou-se o meu favorito de não há forma de conseguir mesmo refutar isto. Adorei-o até mais não. Acho que deste o primeiro livro que eu sabia que ele era fantástico e queria mesmo o seu happy ending. Quando terminei o primeiro livro tinha já presente na minha cabeça que queria que o Matt tivesse o seu final feliz.
Primeiro achei estranho porque ele estava com a Melody no primeiro livro e tudo parecia estar mesmo em good terms e realmente surpreendeu-me quando, ao ler a sinopse do segundo livro, percebi que ela não seria o seu end game.
Confesso que apesar de ter seguido muito pouco a primeira história de amor do Matt, esta segunda? A Sophie era a pessoa certa para ele!
Acho que das coisas que gostei foi o quanto eles cresceram no livro e em especial conseguiram mesmo criar uma amizade acima de tudo. Acima do sexo, acima da fama e isso sim acabou por ser das coisas que acabei por mais prezar ao longo de todo o livro. Gostei de como eles começaram acima de tudo por ser amigos, mesmo quando ambos sabiam já de antemão que havia algo mais entre eles.
Para ser honesta fiquei confusa com o comportamento final da Melody, não gostei para ser honesta. Acho que ficou um tanto desproporcional com aquilo que já tinha aprendido dela no outro livro e isso deixou-me desiludida.
O passado da Sophie é intenso e percebo porque ela não queria uma relação, mas ao mesmo tempo gosto de como ela se sentiu à vontade com o Matt (por isso é que disse que o mais importante foi mesmo a amizade que eles criaram). Além disso, adoro como o irmão dela está sempre lá para ela mesmo em todos os momentos. Também falando da Sophie e dos amigos mais importantes que são mesmo de valorizar.
Além disso, acho que foi importante como eles conseguiram dividir a relação que o irmão dela já tinha com o Matt (através da loja das tattoos enquanto cliente e tatuador) e da forma como já falavam um tanto sobre ele.
Adorei mesmo.
June 29, 2023
L.M. Halloran delivers a beautifully emotional tale of the most unexpected kind of love. The 2nd book in the Breaking Love series, this is the romance between rock group Breaking Giants' lead guitarist Matt Sullivan and the woman who manages to snag his heart, Sophie Marshall. Both have their reasons for not wanting any kind of relationship but as their paths can't help but cross not only surprisingly 6 years prior but now in the present it's almost as if the cosmos has other plans for putting these two together. Along with the help from those who know them best.
The story goes along at an easy pace yet Halloran somehow manages to dig deep with the trauma Sophie had suffered and the repercussions that followed. Matt is beyond patient with Sophie and her fear of falling for him and the demons that still haunt her. He's careful with a side of playful and imo there is no way Sophie would be able to resist him forever. And thank goodness, she doesn't.
We get just enough to glean just what happened to Sophie and how her brother Josh continues to be her confidante and thankful savior no matter what. But the romance between Matt and Sophie is what rocks this book and the way their chemistry cannot be denied even when maybe it shouldn't be.
Bandmates, best friends and a close family are always on hand for our couple when things start to get too complicated, especially for Sophie even when all she wants is Matt by her side curled up with her sweet cat, Pickle. I truly think Halloran does a great job of combining steamy scenes with poignant ones, proving the romance between Matt and Sophie is most definitely meant to be.
Although both have issues of trust, it was truly lovely to watch as they tear down each other's walls enough to realize that they belong together despite what might have happened in the past, hopeful for the future they deserve.
With an epilogue that subtly puts a spotlight of sorts on what so many suffer with even when they are at their happiest, Breaking Silence is one great beach read. It's witty, wonderful and will tug at your heartstrings.
4 big stars!
The story goes along at an easy pace yet Halloran somehow manages to dig deep with the trauma Sophie had suffered and the repercussions that followed. Matt is beyond patient with Sophie and her fear of falling for him and the demons that still haunt her. He's careful with a side of playful and imo there is no way Sophie would be able to resist him forever. And thank goodness, she doesn't.
We get just enough to glean just what happened to Sophie and how her brother Josh continues to be her confidante and thankful savior no matter what. But the romance between Matt and Sophie is what rocks this book and the way their chemistry cannot be denied even when maybe it shouldn't be.
Bandmates, best friends and a close family are always on hand for our couple when things start to get too complicated, especially for Sophie even when all she wants is Matt by her side curled up with her sweet cat, Pickle. I truly think Halloran does a great job of combining steamy scenes with poignant ones, proving the romance between Matt and Sophie is most definitely meant to be.
Although both have issues of trust, it was truly lovely to watch as they tear down each other's walls enough to realize that they belong together despite what might have happened in the past, hopeful for the future they deserve.
With an epilogue that subtly puts a spotlight of sorts on what so many suffer with even when they are at their happiest, Breaking Silence is one great beach read. It's witty, wonderful and will tug at your heartstrings.
4 big stars!
June 9, 2023
‘Love is more powerful than darkness anyway.’
It was like coming home reading Breaking Silence the new full-length standalone rockstar romance by L.M. Halloran. We’ve missed her stories, and Breaking Silence was a fabulous return. This book deals with some very sensitive themes, with trigger warnings available from the authors website. We absolutely LOVED this book! What a triumphant return!
Breaking Silence is an emotionally charged, raw, soulful, and highly emotive story. The rock star theme we desperately crave was perfectly executed in this story of love, trust, and healing. Everything about this story hit us in the hearts. We were riveted.
We first met Matthew (Matt) Sullivan, though somewhat briefly, in Breaking Giants which we read back in 2017, and it was great to be back with the boys from the band Breaking Giants who have success, and for some, their life partners. Matt, recently single, has sworn off relationships – he’s been burned one time too many, that is, until the gorgeous, yet troubled, Sophie Marshall.
“The strongest love comes when the heart is a little broken open. It means there’s space for deeper roots to grow.”
Sophie too, has sworn off relationships, though her fear comes from a deep, dark, troubled place, which, once uncovered broke our hearts, and cemented our love for Matt as he comforted, protected, and brought the love and safety Sophie so craved, yet was terrified to open herself up to the possibility.
Matt and Sophie’s story will touch your heart, their chemistry will set you alight. The way Matt handled Sophie was handled incredibly well. His patience, his tenderness, the way he gave her space when needed. This man was something else.
“I’ll take whatever you want to give me, Sophie Marshall.”
Ebook
April 23, 2025
Book 2 of the series and it’s honestly the best!
Oh my heart I'm done for with this book! L.M. Halloran grabbed me in a chokehold and held me there for the duration of this book. AND I LOVED IT!
First of all, I love rockstar romances. They are my favorite trope, hands down. There's usually so much angst and heartbreak in the story. Breaking Silence did not disappoint with either of these. I read the first book in this series and enjoyed it but this one took the cake and then some.
Matt is the lead guitarist in the band Breaking Giants. When he's not on tour, he lives a pretty normal life. He's spent hours in the chair of his tattoo artist, primarily working on his back artwork. Sophie is an artist but gave up on her dreams of doing it for a living when life took some unexpected curves. When she shows up for bowling because she promised a friend she'd be there, she finds out the guys from Breaking Giants are there and she'd paired up with Matt. She's not excited about this but Matt finds himself drawn to her. He makes it his life mission to be her BFF. Little does he know, they had an encounter with each other 6 years ago.
I can't say it enough that I highly recommend this book. It gave me all the feels. The first day I started reading it, it was about an hour before I usually go to sleep. I ended up reading like 45% of the book before finally retiring for the night. It was so hard to put this book down once I picked it up. I really had to pace myself so I wouldn't have too bad of a book hangover. Spoiler, I still had one. Matt is the nicest guy ever and works so hard to be there for Sophie. She's been through so much and pushes him away at every turn. He's not overbearing or crazy. He's just there for her when she needs him. He holds their friendship close to his heart and it's just so beautiful.
Oh my heart I'm done for with this book! L.M. Halloran grabbed me in a chokehold and held me there for the duration of this book. AND I LOVED IT!
First of all, I love rockstar romances. They are my favorite trope, hands down. There's usually so much angst and heartbreak in the story. Breaking Silence did not disappoint with either of these. I read the first book in this series and enjoyed it but this one took the cake and then some.
Matt is the lead guitarist in the band Breaking Giants. When he's not on tour, he lives a pretty normal life. He's spent hours in the chair of his tattoo artist, primarily working on his back artwork. Sophie is an artist but gave up on her dreams of doing it for a living when life took some unexpected curves. When she shows up for bowling because she promised a friend she'd be there, she finds out the guys from Breaking Giants are there and she'd paired up with Matt. She's not excited about this but Matt finds himself drawn to her. He makes it his life mission to be her BFF. Little does he know, they had an encounter with each other 6 years ago.
I can't say it enough that I highly recommend this book. It gave me all the feels. The first day I started reading it, it was about an hour before I usually go to sleep. I ended up reading like 45% of the book before finally retiring for the night. It was so hard to put this book down once I picked it up. I really had to pace myself so I wouldn't have too bad of a book hangover. Spoiler, I still had one. Matt is the nicest guy ever and works so hard to be there for Sophie. She's been through so much and pushes him away at every turn. He's not overbearing or crazy. He's just there for her when she needs him. He holds their friendship close to his heart and it's just so beautiful.
September 27, 2026
Sophie & Matt
Found Family
Friends to Lovers
Rockstar Romance
SA Survivor - off page
Trauma
PTSD
Book 2
In book 1, Matt was dating Melody and seemed pretty happy to finally get the girl he'd been crushing on. In book 2, we find him single and learn that Melody was not the girl for him. She basically tore him down and left him. It was definitely for the best because in book 2, he meets Sophie.
Right away, it's obvious these two have chemistry, and while they are both attracted to each other, they each have reasons for the why the timing is all wrong.
Matt just got out of a bad relationship, and Sophie suffers from terrible PTSD after being visciously assaulted years ago.
However, the two are drawn to each other, so they decide to be friends instead. They spend time doing simple things like watching movies, cooking, and going to concerts. All the while, Matt slowly builds a trust with Sophie, and she learns she is safe with him. Her walls come down a lot but often go right back up as she faces the miriad of things that trigger her PTSD. All the while, Matt is patient and tries to be there for her. As he learns about Sophie's history and terrible past trauma, he takes steps to ensure he can help her face the challenges she frequently faces. Ultimately, he show Sophie that she can love him without fear of betrayal or abandonment, and they get their HEA. This book has good communication between the characters and no third act breakup.
* This is a very oversimplified summary of what Matt and Sophie go through.
Matt is also the lead guitarist in Breaking Giants (Julian's book). However, this book puts little focus on that part of Matt's life. It focuses more on how he builds a relationship with Sophie.
Found Family
Friends to Lovers
Rockstar Romance
SA Survivor - off page
Trauma
PTSD
Book 2
In book 1, Matt was dating Melody and seemed pretty happy to finally get the girl he'd been crushing on. In book 2, we find him single and learn that Melody was not the girl for him. She basically tore him down and left him. It was definitely for the best because in book 2, he meets Sophie.
Right away, it's obvious these two have chemistry, and while they are both attracted to each other, they each have reasons for the why the timing is all wrong.
Matt just got out of a bad relationship, and Sophie suffers from terrible PTSD after being visciously assaulted years ago.
However, the two are drawn to each other, so they decide to be friends instead. They spend time doing simple things like watching movies, cooking, and going to concerts. All the while, Matt slowly builds a trust with Sophie, and she learns she is safe with him. Her walls come down a lot but often go right back up as she faces the miriad of things that trigger her PTSD. All the while, Matt is patient and tries to be there for her. As he learns about Sophie's history and terrible past trauma, he takes steps to ensure he can help her face the challenges she frequently faces. Ultimately, he show Sophie that she can love him without fear of betrayal or abandonment, and they get their HEA. This book has good communication between the characters and no third act breakup.
* This is a very oversimplified summary of what Matt and Sophie go through.
Matt is also the lead guitarist in Breaking Giants (Julian's book). However, this book puts little focus on that part of Matt's life. It focuses more on how he builds a relationship with Sophie.
June 21, 2026
Ahhhhhh! This book was everything!! Matt and Sophie’s story was every fucking thing I could’ve wanted and more in this sequel. Rock star books are my kryptonite. And as much as I loved Julian and Rose’s book previously, I always loved Matt more. He’s so special.
Sophie really helped him heal after a terrible breakup but he helped her learn to heal from her traumatic past. Both characters were so endearing and beautiful. They were absolutely made for each other. And their slow-burn love was incredible.
I loved this found family and how they were always there for each other when shit got rough. I loved how they accepted Sophie into their group and treated her like family. I loved how Matt was so attentive and supportive and thoughtful after learning what Sophie loved through. It was such a heartbreaking and emotional event she suffered, but she had the best support.
I loved both of their families coming together and accepting both Soph and Matt into their lives. I loved how Sophie was the only one, besides his family, that called him Matthew. His nickname for her was so endearing, too.
I cried for both Matt and Soph, but mostly happy tears. The last two chapters had my heart soaring in joy for them. The last chapter was prob my favorite. The epilogue was adorable. This book was just everything I wanted. Matt is definitely hot as hell but he’s such a beautiful soul of a man and his love for his Dollface made me swoon like crazy.
I’ve loved each book by Halloran that I’ve read so far, so this is not a surprise. Bravo, Laura. This was perfection 🥹
Sophie really helped him heal after a terrible breakup but he helped her learn to heal from her traumatic past. Both characters were so endearing and beautiful. They were absolutely made for each other. And their slow-burn love was incredible.
I loved this found family and how they were always there for each other when shit got rough. I loved how they accepted Sophie into their group and treated her like family. I loved how Matt was so attentive and supportive and thoughtful after learning what Sophie loved through. It was such a heartbreaking and emotional event she suffered, but she had the best support.
I loved both of their families coming together and accepting both Soph and Matt into their lives. I loved how Sophie was the only one, besides his family, that called him Matthew. His nickname for her was so endearing, too.
I cried for both Matt and Soph, but mostly happy tears. The last two chapters had my heart soaring in joy for them. The last chapter was prob my favorite. The epilogue was adorable. This book was just everything I wanted. Matt is definitely hot as hell but he’s such a beautiful soul of a man and his love for his Dollface made me swoon like crazy.
I’ve loved each book by Halloran that I’ve read so far, so this is not a surprise. Bravo, Laura. This was perfection 🥹
December 29, 2025
5⭐️|3🌶️ Another great read! I devoured this one in a single day because apparently I have no self‑control when it comes to fictional men with guitars.
This book follows Sophie Marshall, who’s now running the same café Rose did in book one. Sophie has survived more than anyone ever should, and while she’s got an amazing support system, she’s convinced romance is not in the cards for her. She’s perfectly content with her job, her sketchbook, and her cat Pickles—who honestly sounds like the only man she needs.
Enter Matt Callahan, the lead guitarist of Breaking Giants, freshly single after a brutal breakup with his ex fiancé and absolutely done with women after being burned too many times. (Famous last words, Matt. Famous. Last. Words.)
Naturally, the second these two meet, the chemistry is instant. But they’re both terrified of messing up something that feels too good to be real. So what do they do? They make a bet. A six‑month “just friends” pact. Weekly hangouts. No funny business. And if neither of them runs for the hills by the end… they’ll see what happens.
Will they break the bet? Will someone bolt? Will Pickles the cat approve?
This is a soft, healing love story with two people carrying heavy trauma and learning to trust again. I personally would’ve loved a bit more suspense sprinkled in, but honestly—it was still such a satisfying, heart-squeezing read.
This book follows Sophie Marshall, who’s now running the same café Rose did in book one. Sophie has survived more than anyone ever should, and while she’s got an amazing support system, she’s convinced romance is not in the cards for her. She’s perfectly content with her job, her sketchbook, and her cat Pickles—who honestly sounds like the only man she needs.
Enter Matt Callahan, the lead guitarist of Breaking Giants, freshly single after a brutal breakup with his ex fiancé and absolutely done with women after being burned too many times. (Famous last words, Matt. Famous. Last. Words.)
Naturally, the second these two meet, the chemistry is instant. But they’re both terrified of messing up something that feels too good to be real. So what do they do? They make a bet. A six‑month “just friends” pact. Weekly hangouts. No funny business. And if neither of them runs for the hills by the end… they’ll see what happens.
Will they break the bet? Will someone bolt? Will Pickles the cat approve?
This is a soft, healing love story with two people carrying heavy trauma and learning to trust again. I personally would’ve loved a bit more suspense sprinkled in, but honestly—it was still such a satisfying, heart-squeezing read.
July 3, 2023
Words cannot describe how incredible this story is. The depth of emotions that I felt while reading it is unreal. I laughed, I cried, my heart was broken and put back together. This isn’t just a story about second chances, it’s a story of finding oneself and overcoming a dark past. Sophie’s character is so endearing, and I couldn’t help but want to jump into the pages and hug her. She has had something happen in her past that no one should have to go through. But somehow, someway, she finds her way back. Could it be Matt, part of the Breaking Giants band, who helps her to see how amazing she is. He is instantly enamored with her but can sense that something has happened to her to make her wary of relationships. He is bound and determined to prove to her that he is someone she can trust and hopefully love and make a family with one day. Matt is such a kind, caring character who I couldn’t help but fall in love with. This story takes you on their journey and it’s one you never want to end. While some of the story is not for the feint of heart, this author tells it with such grace and dignity, and that’s what makes this the perfect story. Please do yourself a favor and read this brilliant story, you will not be disappointed.
June 3, 2025
"I'm in this for the long haul, Sophie. I love you like I've never loved anything or anyone."
- rockstar romance
- friends to lovers
- golden retriever MMC
- broken FMC
- he falls first
- no third-act breakup
- 🌶️🌶️/5
- dual pov
I enjoy Breaking Silence even more than the first book in the series. Matt already caught my attention in that one, so it's satisfying to see him get his happily ever after. I also like that we meet Melody in Breaking Giants and grow to like her, but she's not the FMC. Instead, the truth comes out years later, adding emotional weight to the story.
The actual FMC is Sophie, Matt's favourite tattoo artist's sister and the new manager at Rose's cafe. She's guarded, shaped by a traumatic past, but Matt connects with her instantly. He's still reeling from a breakup, so he takes things slowly. They agree to be friends, and Sophie gradually begins to open up.
Their bond builds with quiet moments, vulnerability, and simmering tension until the pull between them is undeniable. Sophie is afraid of love, afraid she'll drag Matt down, but he sees her clearly. He's patient, kind, and committed. I really appreciate that there's no third-act breakup. They face their challenges and grow through them together.
We also get a sneak peek at the kids featured in the upcoming duet, and I'm so excited to dive into their stories next.
- rockstar romance
- friends to lovers
- golden retriever MMC
- broken FMC
- he falls first
- no third-act breakup
- 🌶️🌶️/5
- dual pov
I enjoy Breaking Silence even more than the first book in the series. Matt already caught my attention in that one, so it's satisfying to see him get his happily ever after. I also like that we meet Melody in Breaking Giants and grow to like her, but she's not the FMC. Instead, the truth comes out years later, adding emotional weight to the story.
The actual FMC is Sophie, Matt's favourite tattoo artist's sister and the new manager at Rose's cafe. She's guarded, shaped by a traumatic past, but Matt connects with her instantly. He's still reeling from a breakup, so he takes things slowly. They agree to be friends, and Sophie gradually begins to open up.
Their bond builds with quiet moments, vulnerability, and simmering tension until the pull between them is undeniable. Sophie is afraid of love, afraid she'll drag Matt down, but he sees her clearly. He's patient, kind, and committed. I really appreciate that there's no third-act breakup. They face their challenges and grow through them together.
We also get a sneak peek at the kids featured in the upcoming duet, and I'm so excited to dive into their stories next.
September 6, 2026
I wanted more Matt, so thank you very much
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5
🌶️🌶️🌶️ 3/5
I loved Matt’s story!!
When I finished Breaking Giants, one of the things I wanted was MORE MATT. There just wasn’t enough of him for me, so finding out he got his own book made me ridiculously happy.
And then we got chapters from his POV?! YES. Although apparently I’m never satisfied because now I wish there had been even more of those. I loved getting inside his head and seeing his side of everything.
Breaking Silence wasn’t quite as laugh-out-loud funny as the first book, but it still had me laughing and smiling throughout. I just really love this world and these characters.
Also, I can now confirm my rockstar romance obsession is alive and well because I still secretly want a famous band member to fall madly in love with me. Completely reasonable life goal, right? 😂🎸
Unfortunately, this one didn’t have an audiobook, which was a little disappointing after loving the audio for Breaking Giants so much.
And now I get to move on to First Verse and start reading about the next generation (the children of these characters?!) Yeah, there was absolutely no chance I was leaving this world yet. I’m literally starting it as soon as I finish writing this review.
So I guess I live here now.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5
🌶️🌶️🌶️ 3/5
I loved Matt’s story!!
When I finished Breaking Giants, one of the things I wanted was MORE MATT. There just wasn’t enough of him for me, so finding out he got his own book made me ridiculously happy.
And then we got chapters from his POV?! YES. Although apparently I’m never satisfied because now I wish there had been even more of those. I loved getting inside his head and seeing his side of everything.
Breaking Silence wasn’t quite as laugh-out-loud funny as the first book, but it still had me laughing and smiling throughout. I just really love this world and these characters.
Also, I can now confirm my rockstar romance obsession is alive and well because I still secretly want a famous band member to fall madly in love with me. Completely reasonable life goal, right? 😂🎸
Unfortunately, this one didn’t have an audiobook, which was a little disappointing after loving the audio for Breaking Giants so much.
And now I get to move on to First Verse and start reading about the next generation (the children of these characters?!) Yeah, there was absolutely no chance I was leaving this world yet. I’m literally starting it as soon as I finish writing this review.
So I guess I live here now.
May 31, 2023
I am so in love with rockstar books and at the mention of this book I had to grab the opportunity to read it!! This author is actually new to me and I love how much this book already paved a spot in my heart for this author!!
Sophie has quite the past and during small moments you can already see it from the beginning. I loved her interaction with everyone she met though! It doesn’t seem like she would have the past she does and the start of their friendship had me so giddy!!
Matt doesn’t seem like I thought he would at the beginning and that was rather refreshing to witness and even better later on! I LOVED their banter so much and was just giddy from that in general! I kept waiting for a shoe to drop though and boy did it drop!
I would’ve read this in one day but told myself to wait to finish today. What a great book to start off with this author and I can’t wait to read more!! This had so many ups but also so many downs and while my heart felt at the edge of bursting of happiness, I also felt the intense feeling of dread! Thank you for such a great book and making me laugh, smile and all of the above!
Sophie has quite the past and during small moments you can already see it from the beginning. I loved her interaction with everyone she met though! It doesn’t seem like she would have the past she does and the start of their friendship had me so giddy!!
Matt doesn’t seem like I thought he would at the beginning and that was rather refreshing to witness and even better later on! I LOVED their banter so much and was just giddy from that in general! I kept waiting for a shoe to drop though and boy did it drop!
I would’ve read this in one day but told myself to wait to finish today. What a great book to start off with this author and I can’t wait to read more!! This had so many ups but also so many downs and while my heart felt at the edge of bursting of happiness, I also felt the intense feeling of dread! Thank you for such a great book and making me laugh, smile and all of the above!
April 14, 2024
Matt Sullivan is the lead guitarist for Breaking Giants but being a rock god doesn’t protect him from a broken engagement and a broken heart. He has sworn off dating and relationships but when he meets Sophie there’s just something about her that he can’t stop thinking about. Artist and coffee shop manager Sophie has been through a lot and has zero interest in dating, even someone as irresistible as Matt. Matt convinces her to hang out with him as friends and the more time they spend together the less they are able to resist the connection drawing them together.
This is another phenomenal book by LM! Matt is perfectly swoony, sweet, funny and protective. And he is so patient and understanding with Sophie, giving her the time and unwavering support she needs to find her way. Sophie has some heavy baggage for sure, but she slowly regains her inner strength and confidence and learns that your past doesn’t have to define your future.
The family of characters in this book is so special and I love them all! The way everyone is written, they just seem to come to life and leap off the page right into your heart. I think of them often and hope they are all doing well. ❤️
As in all of LM’s books, the writing in Breaking Silence has a beautiful, lyrical quality that pulls you in from the very first page. Some of the subjects she writes about are real and difficult and painful but are always handled with the utmost care and compassion. And the heavier topics are beautifully balanced with plenty of humor, heart and spice. I am officially an LM Halloran fan for life or longer!
This is another phenomenal book by LM! Matt is perfectly swoony, sweet, funny and protective. And he is so patient and understanding with Sophie, giving her the time and unwavering support she needs to find her way. Sophie has some heavy baggage for sure, but she slowly regains her inner strength and confidence and learns that your past doesn’t have to define your future.
The family of characters in this book is so special and I love them all! The way everyone is written, they just seem to come to life and leap off the page right into your heart. I think of them often and hope they are all doing well. ❤️
As in all of LM’s books, the writing in Breaking Silence has a beautiful, lyrical quality that pulls you in from the very first page. Some of the subjects she writes about are real and difficult and painful but are always handled with the utmost care and compassion. And the heavier topics are beautifully balanced with plenty of humor, heart and spice. I am officially an LM Halloran fan for life or longer!
November 5, 2024
🚨Spoilers🚨
This is about Matt and Sophie.
I have to be totally honest, i didn’t not expect much from this book. The first one was pretty good but felt rushed in a few places but still well worth my time. This book was published 6yrs later and felt like maybe a bit of an afterthought but i was very pleased to find i love it even more then the first one. I am not sure if maybe the older in wise thing applied or just time to sit and develop the characters a tad better or what but this book was amazing and made me feel like she really understood what her characters were going through. I still find it odd we know so little about the other band mates but then maybe we will get another one in 6yrs 😆🤷🏻♀️.
I will definitely look out for more books by this author!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️= very well done
🌶️= there are sex moments but its not over done or over detailed.
🔈= I listened to it with the speechify app
⚠️= very definitely some trigger warnings on this one. Suicidal ideation, rape, trafficking, PTSD trauma.
®️= rented this from the Kindle app.
Off to the next great 📖 book!
This is about Matt and Sophie.
I have to be totally honest, i didn’t not expect much from this book. The first one was pretty good but felt rushed in a few places but still well worth my time. This book was published 6yrs later and felt like maybe a bit of an afterthought but i was very pleased to find i love it even more then the first one. I am not sure if maybe the older in wise thing applied or just time to sit and develop the characters a tad better or what but this book was amazing and made me feel like she really understood what her characters were going through. I still find it odd we know so little about the other band mates but then maybe we will get another one in 6yrs 😆🤷🏻♀️.
I will definitely look out for more books by this author!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️= very well done
🌶️= there are sex moments but its not over done or over detailed.
🔈= I listened to it with the speechify app
⚠️= very definitely some trigger warnings on this one. Suicidal ideation, rape, trafficking, PTSD trauma.
®️= rented this from the Kindle app.
Off to the next great 📖 book!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 26, 2023
Chefs kiss!
I absolutely love the rockstar trope and the author didn't disappoint!
How does she come up with all these traumas as back story?!
The poor heroine finally found her happiness but good God it also unlocked a new fear in me I didn't even know was possible. Hope it's just her beautiful imagination and young girls aren't being betrayed like that in life!
That aside, I'm happy I picked up the book. At first I was like "but Matt and Melody are so good together already... Do I want to go into details about their life? Not sure I'm going to buy their drama..." turns out it's not Melody but an entirely new to us character. And Sophie is, as Halloran always writes, one tough cookie!
Great development for both characters (going deeper into Matt's life was great, he is as yummy as you think and then more), great steam and I loved the epilogue. Let's see how long until we get a book for Wilder and Eva to see the kids falling in love.
Read this and enjoy it!
I absolutely love the rockstar trope and the author didn't disappoint!
How does she come up with all these traumas as back story?!
The poor heroine finally found her happiness but good God it also unlocked a new fear in me I didn't even know was possible. Hope it's just her beautiful imagination and young girls aren't being betrayed like that in life!
That aside, I'm happy I picked up the book. At first I was like "but Matt and Melody are so good together already... Do I want to go into details about their life? Not sure I'm going to buy their drama..." turns out it's not Melody but an entirely new to us character. And Sophie is, as Halloran always writes, one tough cookie!
Great development for both characters (going deeper into Matt's life was great, he is as yummy as you think and then more), great steam and I loved the epilogue. Let's see how long until we get a book for Wilder and Eva to see the kids falling in love.
Read this and enjoy it!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 105 reviews