This collection of essays highlights a dimension of Paul's theology of justification that has been neglected -- that his teaching emerged as an integral part of his understanding of his commission to preach the gospel to non-Jews and that his dismissal of justification "by works of the law" was directed not so much against Jewish legalism but rather against his fellow Jews' assumption that the law remained a dividing wall separating Christian Jews from Christian Gentiles.
James Dunn seeks to carry forward the debate on Jewish soteriology, on the relation of justification by faith to judgment "according to works," on Christian fulfillment of the law, and on the crucial role of Christ, his death and resurrection. Full of detail and intriguing thought, Dunn's collection will enlighten any scholar of the New Testament.
James D. G. ("Jimmy") Dunn (born 1939) was for many years the Lightfoot Professor of Divinity in the Department of Theology at the University of Durham. Since his retirement he has been made Emeritus Lightfoot Professor. He is a leading British New Testament scholar, broadly in the Protestant tradition. Dunn is especially associated with the New Perspective on Paul, along with N. T. (Tom) Wright and E. P. Sanders. He is credited with coining this phrase during his 1982 Manson Memorial Lecture.
Dunn has an MA and BD from the University of Glasgow and a PhD and DD from the University of Cambridge. For 2002, Dunn was the President of the Studiorum Novi Testamenti Societas, the leading international body for New Testament study. Only three other British scholars had been made President in the preceding 25 years.
In 2005 a festschrift was published dedicated to Dunn, comprising articles by 27 New Testament scholars, examining early Christian communities and their beliefs about the Holy Spirit. (edited by Graham N. Stanton, Bruce W. Longenecker & Stephen Barton (2004). The Holy Spirit and Christian origins: essays in honor of James D. G. Dunn. Grand Rapids, MI: W.B. Eerdmans Pub. Co. ISBN 0-8028-2822-1.)
Dunn has taken up E. P. Sanders' project of redefining Palestinian Judaism in order to correct the Christian view of Judaism as a religion of works-righteousness. One of the most important differences to Sanders is that Dunn perceives a fundamental coherence and consistency to Paul's thought. He furthermore criticizes Sanders' understanding of the term "justification", arguing that Sanders' understanding suffers from an "individualizing exegesis".
ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT EXPOSITIONS OF THE ‘NEW PERSPECTIVE’
James Douglas Grant Dunn (1939-2020) was a British New Testament scholar who was Professor of Theology at the University of Durham prior to his retirement; he was also a minister of the Church of Scotland.
He wrote in the Preface of the original (2005) edition of this book (the revised edition was published in 2008), “I chose this title, ‘The New Perspective on Paul’ … since my article of the same title… is regularly regarded as signaling a new phase in Pauline studies or a fresh way of looking at Paul’s gospel and theology (or at his teaching on justification by faith in particular)… the volume is [also] intended as my attempt to respond to the debate on the ‘new perspective,’ as well as providing a resource for any who might find it helpful to have ready access to a full range of my developing thoughts/insights on the subject… The title … indicates my continuing belief that the ‘new perspective’ has provided fresh and valuable insights into Paul’s theology and continues to contribute to a more rounded appreciation of the mission and theology of Saul the Pharisee [who became] Paul the Christian apostle.”
In Chapter 1, he recounts how studying E.P. Sanders’ book ‘Paul and Palestinian Judaism’ raised a question in his mind: “What was it that Paul was reacting against?” (Pg. 5) He continues, “Crucial to Sanders’ new perspective in Judaism was the recognition that in this ‘pattern of religion’ God did not require perfection, but allowed for failure, by providing means of atonement and forgiveness for those who repented of their sin… the overall balance of this new perspective [is] summed up in the most famous of Sanders’ phrases… ‘covenantal nomism.’ … I took Sanders to have made his case, and was more than ordinarily grateful for the correction he had provided to the traditionally more negative view of Judaism. Unfortunately, however, his treatment of Paul failed to answer my own key question. In fact… Sanders only increased the puzzle.’ (Pg. 6-7)
He outlines his own view on Paul: “1. It builds on Sanders’ new perspective on Second Temple Judaism… 2. It observes that a social function of the law was an integral aspect of Israel’s covenantal nomism, where separateness TO God (holiness) was understood to require separation FROM the (other) nations…3. .. Paul’s own teaching on justification focuses largely if not principally on the need to overcome the barrier which the law was seen to interpose between Jew and Gentile… 4. It suggests that ‘works of the law’ became a key slogan in Paul’s exposition of his justification gospel because so many of Paul’s fellow Jewish believers were insisting on certain works as indispensable to their own … standing within the covenant… 5. It protests that failure to recognize this major dimension of Paul’s doctrine of justification by faith may have ignored or excluded a vital factor in combating the nationalism and racialism which has so distorted and diminished Christianity past and present.” (Pg. 16-17)
He emphasizes, “The point… if the new perspective is to be properly appreciated, is to recognize the way by which such ‘attitudes,’ such ‘misunderstandings’ of God’s concern for the ‘other,’ the ‘outsider,’ were challenged was by means of Paul’s gospel of justification, of God’s acceptance, for ALL who believe, and on no other condition---not ethnicity, not color, not race, not class, not creed, not denomination.... This I say once again is what the ‘new perspective’ is all about for me…” (Pg. 35-36)
He states, “Even if Second Temple Judaism can be shown to be synergistic in its understanding of salvation, it will not be an adequate understanding of Paul’s response to deny that he called for obedience to God’s will on the part of his converts and made final salvation in some measure dependent on believers living according to the Spirit.” (Pg. 97)
He admits, “I must confess that I find Sanders’ Paul little more convincing (and much less attractive) than the Lutheran Paul. I am not convinced that we have yet been given the proper reading of Paul from the new perspective of 1st-century Palestinian Judaism… I believe that the new perspective on Paul does make better sense of Paul than either Sanders or his critics have so far realized.” (Pg. 105)
He states, “The major exegetical flaw of Sanders’ reconstruction of Paul’s view of the law … is his failure to perceive the significance of the little phrase ‘works of the law.’ … he is led to the false conclusion that in disparaging ‘works of the law’ Paul is disparaging law as such, has broken with Judaism as a whole.” (Pg. 118)
He summarizes, “with the law seen to commend and confirm the right priorities, of faith in God (and his Christ) and love of neighbor, the other priorities which emphasize national distinctiveness can be seen to be false priorities, and the ritual practices involved set on one side as matters of indifference which no one who exercises Abraham’s faith and rejoices in the promise given to Abraham should be required to observe.” (Pg. 140)
He asks, “How new then was Paul’s gospel? It was new in that it was focused on Jesus the Christ. It was new in that it came to sharpest focus in Christ’s death and resurrection as providing the decisive salvific key. It was new in that it understood the nations at large to be recipients of the blessing now available through Christ. Moreover, it was new in its claim of something having happened that had never happened before---God active in history in and through a man in a way only foreshadowed but not previously realized… yet, at the same time … Paul understood the newness as a fresh and final unfolding of ancient promise.” (Pg. 264)
He wonders, “Could it be then that the Christian claim that Jesus was Messiah was not so contentious after all in Jewish circles? How otherwise could the Jewish believers in Messiah Jesus have been left in Jerusalem as undisturbed as they seem to have been? … the claim that the crucified Jesus was Messiah was not in principle objectionable for a Jew to hold… It was more the Christian claim that … all Jews should also accept this Jesus as Messiah which was likely to have proved offensive.” (Pg. 352-353)
He contends, “Whatever else he had in mind when he wrote of ‘works of the law’… Paul certainly had in mind circumcision and food laws. I would hope that observation is beyond reasonable dispute.” (Pg. 415-416)
He summarizes, “Does Paul have a covenant theology?... Paul’s use of the term ‘covenant’ is surprisingly casual when we consider the weight of significance subsequent theology invested in it… the theme of ‘covenant’ was not a central or major category within his own theologizing.” (Pg. 444)
He concludes, “We are therefore driven to a twofold conclusion in regard to Paul’s theology of ‘works’: (1) the principle of justification by faith does not exclude the obligation to works, even works of the law; and (2) when Paul denies that justification depends on works of the law he had a more limited target in mind, particularly his fellow Jewish believers’ insistence that the practices which traditionally defined Israel must continue to be practiced by all those wanting to claim descent from Abraham.” (Pg. 466-467)
He observes “Paul’s emphasis that salvation was an ongoing process that the goal of salvation (being found in him having the righteousness from God, knowing him, complete conformity to his death, the resurrection from the dead, the prize of the upward calling) was still to be attained.” (Pg. 490)
This book will be of great interest to anyone studying the ‘new perspective.’
A collection of dense articles by the late Jimmy Dunn from ca. 1982-2005. The two first articles are classics and worth the read, and I really enjoyed the development of a more eirenic approach to the New Perspective that he developed throughout the years. I highly enjoyed the last essay on Phil 3. Editorially speaking, there were a number of typos in the book and it was written in Times New Roman (not my type for longer argumentative chunks), but it's still very readable.
Another reviewer noticed an important summary of the NPP with the privilege of hindsight by Dunn, writing in 2005: Dunn summarizes the New Perspective: “1. It builds on Sanders’ new perspective on Second Temple Judaism… 2. It observes that a social function of the law was an integral aspect of Israel’s covenantal nomism, where separateness to God (holiness) was understood to require separation from the (other) nations… 3. It notes that Paul’s own teaching on justification focuses largely… on the need to overcome the barrier which the law was seen to interposes between Jew and Gentile… 4. It suggests that ‘works of law’ became a key slogan in Paul’s exposition of his justification gospel… 5. It protests that failure to recognize this major dimension of Paul’s doctrine of justification by faith may have ignored or excluded a vital factor in combating the nationalism and racialism which has so distorted and diminished Christianity past and present.” (Pg. 16-17).
Two important caveats:
(1) This is NOT an introduction to the theme, but a series of academic essays that were 'blazing the trail' of pauline studies after E. P. Sanders. So they tend to be very academic, tentative and repetitive at times. They will, of course, sound outdated (with the exception of the first and last essays, which were produced for the publishing in 2015), but they were fascinatingly creative at their own time and for their internal logic. Whoever disagrees with Dunn will need to follow through his consistent arguing.
(2) The essays (just like most of Dunn's excellent work) focus primarily on Galatians and Romans, and, within these two letters, on the nuances of "works of the Law", "faith[fulness]" and "justification". This is where the real action happens. So hold the expectations of finding lengthy and meaty stuff on 1 Tess., Philemon or the disputed letters of Paul.
Other than that, I appreciated the challenging reading.
This series of letters blew my mind 20 years ago. We have much to thank Jimmy Dunn for. Often the level headed general in what is view as the quirky uncle in NT theology. Thankfully some have Dunn's acolytes have embraced the baton and are really adding to Pauline understanding in glorious ways. It was nice to follow his journey via various articles. Some of which have not aged particularly well.
James D.G. Dunn is one of the foremost proponents of the so-called school of the New Perspective on Paul (NPP). The NPP focuses upon Paul’s writing about the Law, with the concepts of “covenantal nomism” and “boundary markers” heavily promoted. This book may not be the best general introduction to the NPP because it has a narrower focus than the overall discipline, but it is a great introduction to Dunn’s own views, which are important in this academic niche. He has done top-notch work with this book, and I heartily recommend it to anyone wanting to learn more about the NPP, Dunn’s views, or both.
To start out, I want to cover the basics. The cover design and colour scheme is attractive. The text is easy to read, and Dunn has included ample and often personable footnotes. There is a Scriptural index, author index, and subject index; the presence of indices is important to me as a scholar, and Dunn passes this area with flying colours.
Dunn has a warm and easy-to-understand writing style. He is less forceful than some others of his NPP proponents such as N.T. Wright (to whom the book is dedicated), but does not shy away from conflict or controversy. He fairly acknowledges differing perspectives and explains why he thinks these perspectives are inaccurate or incomplete. He also acknowledges the complementary perspectives, addressing the shortcomings of such work where appropriate, which I like as it is evidence of his credibility.
The work is a long academic treatise, so it is a little heavy, and some slogging is unavoidable. The primary gripe I have with the book is that it is a collection of individual articles based around the same theme. Dunn, in my opinion, does not streamline these as well as he could have. There is a lot of repetition as he explains the same concept(s) in most of the sections. This explanation is necessary for a stand-alone article or paper, but it is not necessary with a compilation. Although I find myself unpersuaded by the general NPP argument as proposed by some of its authors, I find that Dunn has narrowed his focus sufficiently and addressed common concerns in such a gracious and open manner that I find myself not disagreeing with the major tenets of the book. There are some grammatical/linguistic evidence he uses that I am unqualified to judge as I lack the appropriate knowledge and skills. For the things I do understand, I think Dunn is on target, even though he may give greater import to the “boundary markers” than I think they warrant. The NPP, though, in this case and prefaced with the statement that Paul is not referring to them in all cases, as promoted by Dunn provides a fresh insight into the apostle and his writings.
Overall, I rank this book 5 stars. The only real issue I have with it is the repetitive nature of the compilation. Dunn’s careful research and warm, gracious style more than compensate for this. I realize this book is not light reading and will not appeal to everyone, but I recommend it to any seeking to learn more about the subject.
Extremely exhaustive look at Dunn's work over the years defending and supporting this new perspective on Paul to different critics. While a good majority of this book was either over my head or referenced works I was not incredibly familiar with this was still an amazing resource to try and get a better understanding of the debates and what's really at stake. The initial essay which is brand new for the book and I around 100 pages is really a crucial starting point and an amazing work that gracefully explains the debates that have been going in for a while and some of the origins. Really a fantastic book even if my lack of Greek limited my comprehension
Чудесна. Втората петица, която давам. Горещо я препоръчвам заедно с Jesus remembered и в по-малка степен Beginning from Jerusalem. Unity and diversity in the NT е по-друг въпрос.