#Binge Reviewing my previous Reads # Buddhism, Buddha’s Biography & Retellings
Ambedkar’s The Buddha & His Dhamma is his final major work, completed shortly before his death in 1956, and published posthumously in 1957. It is ambitious: part biography of the Buddha, part philosophical treatise, and part manifesto for a socially engaged Buddhism. Ambedkar writes not merely to recount the life of Siddhartha Gautama but to distill what he considers to be the authentic teachings of the Buddha (the “Dhamma”) stripped from later accretions—ritual, caste, superstition—and to offer them as a framework for modern society, especially for those historically marginalized in India.
One of the most striking elements of the book is the way Ambedkar sees the Buddha as a social revolutionary as well as a spiritual teacher. For Ambedkar, the Dhamma is not a private, ascetic path alone, but a public, secular‐ethical project: it must address injustice, equality, dignity. The caste system, which in Ambedkar’s view distorted Indian society and embedded inequality, becomes a central concern. Ambedkar treats many doctrines—karma, rebirth, notions of soul—with both respect to Buddhist sources and a critical eye, seeking what he considers to be their meaning for a modern, rational, and scientifically aware readership.
Ambedkar’s style is both powerful and demanding. He doesn’t indulge in poetic mythologizing or devotional lyricism; instead, his prose is direct, analytical, and sometimes polemical. He often draws contrasts between what Buddhist texts say and what later Buddhist communities might have adopted or allowed; in his view, practices that drift away from what the Buddha originally taught. In doing so, he sometimes challenges traditional interpretations and common beliefs, which can be both stimulating and controversial. For readers looking for a conventional devotional tale of the Buddha, this book will feel different—less about awe, more about scrutiny and reform. This is not a weakness so much as a deliberate posture.
That said, the book has its complexities and points of tension. One is that Ambedkar’s strong sociopolitical critique sometimes overshadows or simplifies certain doctrinal subtleties. Concepts like rebirth, karma, or non‐self are reinterpreted through a lens that demands compatibility with rationalism and modernity. This leads Ambedkar to reject or reinterpret supernatural elements, or metaphysics, in favour of ethical, moral, and social consequences.
Some readers argue, for example, that he downplays or rejects the traditional supernatural cosmology that many Buddhist traditions accept. That approach makes the book especially compelling to those who want Buddhism to align with modern secular values, but it also means that The Buddha & His Dhamma is not a neutral retelling; it is shaped by Ambedkar’s vision of what Buddhism should be, not only what it historically has been. This makes the work somewhat hybrid: part history, part reform movement guide, part personal philosophy.
Another issue is with the source‐criticism and scholarship. While Ambedkar makes a serious effort, the original version lacked extensive citations or a scholarly apparatus. Later editions and critical editions have tried to supply references, clarify where Ambedkar is drawing from texts, and highlight where he diverges from canonical sources.
For a reader deeply steeped in Pāli sources, Mahayana sutras, or historical-critical studies, some of Ambedkar’s assertions may seem debatable. Nonetheless, many appreciate the clarity and accessibility of his record: much of the narrative is organised, each part dealing with explicit doctrinal claims, life episodes, and social implications.
Despite these tensions, the book’s strengths are deep. Ambedkar’s vision for Buddhism as a tool of social emancipation gives the work urgent relevance. For Dalits (formerly “untouchables”) and other oppressed communities in India, The Buddha & His Dhamma has been foundational: it provides theological and philosophical affirmation, dignity, and a reinterpretation of religious identity that affirms human equality. The way Ambedkar places ethics, rationality, and justice at the centre is inspiring. He doesn’t treat Buddhism as escapism; he treats it as a framework for living in society, for political action, and for moral accountability.
Also, his account of the Buddha’s life is sober: he presents Siddhartha not as a mythic superman but as a man making choices, facing contradictions, and making breaks with tradition—this human portrait is one of the book’s emotional strengths.
For contemporary readers, The Buddha & His Dhamma poses a challenge: how to hold both respect for the breadth of Buddhist tradition and openness to reform. It asks whether Buddhism can be made fully compatible with modern values—scientific thinking, equality, secularism—without losing its vital core. It also invites reflection on what teachings are central: are the Four Noble Truths, karma, rebirth, meditation, non-self, compassion, and the Sangha—the essence—and which parts are later interpretations? Ambedkar pushes us to think about these questions rather than accept tradition uncritically.
In the landscape of your #Binge Reviewing series on Buddhism and Buddha’s biographies, this book could serve as a contrasting “pole” — not simply a devotional or literary retelling, but one that interrogates, reinterprets, and reimagines Buddhism for modern, socially engaged life. It is a corrective to romantic or mythic biographies: it insists on grounding the Buddha’s teachings in social reality.
If I were to rate it roughly, I’d say: for moral, philosophical, and social resonance, The Buddha & His Dhamma is a 4.5/5; for historical-scholarly precision, maybe a 3/5; overall—a deeply important, personal, provocative read.