Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Box with the Sunflower Clasp: Uncovering a Jewish Family's Flight to Wartime Shanghai

Rate this book
' A transfixingly readable amalgam of memoir and history... Superbly written and researched .... [Meller] has turned the raw material of her life into literature'
Ian Thomson, author of Primo Levi

Rachel Meller was never close to her aunt Lisbeth, a cool, unemotional woman with a drawling Viennese-Californian accent, a cigarette in her hand. But when Lisbeth died, she left Rachel an intricately carved Chinese box with a sunflower clasp. Inside the box were photographs, letters and documents that led Rachel to uncover a story she had never that of a passionate Jewish teenager growing up in elegant Vienna, who was caught up by war, and forced to flee to Shanghai.

Far from home, in a strange city, Lisbeth and her parents build a new life - a life of small joys and great hardship, surrounded by many others who, like them, have fled Hitler and the Nazis. 1930s Shanghai is a metropolis where the old rules do not apply - a city of fabulous wealth and crushing poverty, where disease is rife, and gangsters rub shoulders with rich emigrés; where summer brings unspeakable heat, and winter is bitterly cold; and where European refugees build community and, maybe, a young woman can find love.

Set against a backdrop of the war in the Far East, The Box with the Sunflower Clasp is a sweeping family memoir that tells the hidden history of the Jews of Shanghai. Rachel Meller writes with elegance and insight as she examines what it means to survive, and what the legacy of displacement and war might mean for the generation that comes afterwards.

336 pages, Hardcover

Published May 18, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Rachel Meller

1 book1 follower

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
17 (62%)
4 stars
7 (25%)
3 stars
2 (7%)
2 stars
1 (3%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews
Profile Image for Nicole.
8 reviews
December 4, 2023
I recommend this sensitive and intelligent book that makes history come alive in such an intimate way. Every page made me want to know more and I think that people from all backgrounds will appreciate this little-known story with universal connections and relevance. I loved this book. The last page was perfect and I marvelled at how difficult it must be to write an ending to a story such as this one. However, it doesn't end, does it? With this wonderful book, the story lives and grows. Thank you so much for writing this.
Profile Image for Mike Scialom.
Author 3 books5 followers
June 1, 2023
Why does it say 'author unknown'? Yes it is her first published book, but Rachel Meller is not a pseudonym, nor is she in hiding. It's pretty clear on the cover who the author is. I mention this because this is a remarkable book about a remarkable and little-known aspect of 1930s/1940s history - the flight of German Jews from their homeland to Shanghai. Did you even know this had happened? I didn't, but more than 5,000 German Jews made it to Shanghai in the late 1930s and the early 1940s, before the concentration camp system became industrialised in 1941. It's an astonishing story, or stories, and it's told as part-memoir, part-documentary, part-history and part-family story. A must-read for anyone interested in the survival of the human spirit in the most challenging set of circumstances imaginable.
https://www.cambridgeindependent.co.u...
3 reviews
July 23, 2023
I absolutely loved this book and couldn't put it down once I started reading it. I was going to a book launch for it and was concerned from the cover of the book that it may be very harrowing, as it is about a family's flight to wartime Shanghai. But it is a fantastic story, gleaned from postcards and documents found when the author was gifted her Aunt's box with the sunflower clasp. It is so beautifully written that it draws you into the family story whilst telling the largely unknown story of the flight to Shanghai. It is enhanced by historic facts and figures and although what happened there was harrowing, the family's story, in the face of such adversity, is what makes this book such an excellent read.
1 review
July 4, 2023
This book is a lively and personal account of a family’s uprooting from their home, their culture, and everything familiar. Fiendishly researched and written in a compelling authoritative style it remains highly readable and deserves a wide audience. Rachel’s humanity is clear and the last sentence alone is worth many other whole books.
Profile Image for East West Notes.
127 reviews35 followers
June 21, 2023
The Box with the Sunflower Clasp by Rachel Meller is an absorbing family memoir centring on the wartime experience of Jewish refugees in Shanghai. This multi-generational story mainly profiles author Rachel Meller's aunt Lisbeth who fled from Vienna to Shanghai. After her death, she left Rachel a Chinese lacquered cabinet full of family documents, which led to the publication of this book. It is carefully researched, both in describing their family history and in outlining the political and cultural context of that time. The author acknowledges that her aunt shared her experiences with others rather than with her own family: "I was filled with excitement, but also with shame. Lisbeth had never breathed a word to either Claudia or me about her years in Shanghai. Yet she had clearly spent hours opening up to a stranger, a man who now knew more of her life history than we ever had. Had we not tried hard enough to find out?"

The atmospheric settings, whether it's in the cafes of Vienna or Shanghai's hospitals, come alive on the page. It is a fascinating tour of Shanghai's International Settlement and French Concession during World War II. While the book is a family saga, it generally presents the history of Shanghai under Japanese occupation. Much of this is from the perspective of the primarily German and Austrian refugees. "What lay before the young woman was the aftermath of the battle of Shanghai, a conflict of almost three years earlier. The fighting between disciplined Japanese and poorly trained Chinese soldiers had laid waste to many parts of the city; fierce hand-to-hand and house-to-house combat was later described as ‘the most intense conflict since Verdun in World War I’, and ‘Stalingrad on the Yangtze’."

It describes in vivid detail the increasing restrictions the Jewish people faced in Europe and after arriving in Shanghai. I especially liked how it described in detail the financial restrictions placed on the refugees for how much money and personal possessions they were able to take both to Shanghai and out of Shanghai. It carefully describes the agony of queuing for visas or day passes out of the Shanghai ghetto. Every day offered a fresh humiliation for the Jewish people.

Suicide, child loss and miscarriage are the major themes in The Box with the Sunflower Clasp. I believe this book is an important contribution to an emerging area of holocaust history that examines a unique female experience and explores frequently overlooked aspects of mental health in refugee communities. For example, Lisbeth learnt to walk carefully around bundles of wrapped newspaper on the street, because they were likely to be Chinese infants whose parents could not afford to bury them. This was likely a daily reminder of the children the family had previously lost themselves. The lasting emotional and psychological impact of child loss was a trauma these families were already carrying before becoming displaced. Many could not stand the loss of their family members or their lives as they knew them. Muller describes how she "felt icy fingers run over my skin as I recalled yet another thread of suicide running through our family tapestry." It is a reminder that many families who escaped the holocaust still suffered from extreme hunger, disease and violence. The author considerately describes their feelings of profound emptiness, grief and anger.

These cruel experiences also united the Jewish and Chinese people. The book takes the time to describe the severe poverty and discrimination the Chinese faced in their own home. "The scant square mile of the Designated Area now had Chinese and Europeans packed cheek by jowl, neighbours in poverty. For the most part, the population of around 100,000 Chinese tolerated their uninvited neighbours (now totalling at least 18,000 Jews), and some friendships were formed between the communities; there were even some marriages." There is a very moving scene where Jewish doctors tended to their Chinese neighbours after the Americans bombed the Shanghai ghetto: "Many of the victims pulled out of the debris were Chinese. Unused to being helped by strangers, as soon as their heads were cleared from the rubble they would ask, ‘How much?’ One man asked this question, and pulled out his wallet, while his leg was being amputated… Refugee doctors carried out major procedures with no pain relief – neither morphine nor anaesthesia – on stoical Chinese… The next morning, Chinese residents of Hongkew came to the refugees with rickshaws loaded with food and offers of money for the Heime. When the cash was politely refused, they brought fruit and cakes instead. The ghetto bombing marked a change in the attitude of many Chinese to the Jews: from being neutral, even occasionally hostile, they now warmed to their uninvited neighbours."

For those with an interest in Jewish history, this book takes a nuanced look at the different types of Jewish people living in Shanghai. Readers may have preconceived notions that the Jewish refugees were the first Jews to live in Shanghai or that the wartime experience was the same for all Jews. This memoir takes the time to clarify the differences between Sephardic and Ashkenazi Jews and to describe some of the prominent Jewish families who had established synagogues, hotels, schools, cultural organisations and charities in China well before their fellow Jews started fleeing from Nazi-controlled territories. Some Jewish groups were sent to the ghetto, others were not. "… the Japanese did not view all the city’s Jews equally. Shanghai’s Russian Ashkenazi Jews had been permitted to keep their old identity cards. And now this group was exempt again, this time from the restrictions of the ghetto… To the fury of the immigrants who had only recently fled Hitler, this ‘authoritative Jewish body for all Refugee affairs’ was to be run by the Russians on the behalf of the Japanese, widening the rift between the two Jewish groups."

While The Box with the Sunflower Clasp primarily focuses on the author's aunt, the narrative does occasionally step back to describe Meller's childhood memories, experiences of motherhood and visits to China. These reflections are tightly weaved in and do not interrupt the overall flow of the story. If there's one minor drawback to the book, it's that many notable people of Shanghai were profiled and those sections sometimes felt a little overlong. On the other hand, it does give an understanding of the place the family had moved to and culture shock they might have experienced.

This book will appeal to those interested in Jewish history, old Shanghai and WWII history. It's a fascinating look at issues related to class, citizenship, race and identity. Overall, it provides a unique look at the experience of Jews in Shanghai with a special focus on mental health and the complexities of loss. It discusses how family trauma can affect individuals differently and shape family dynamics for generations. Finally, it highlights the shared values of resilience and commitment to education and community between the Chinese and Jewish people.

This book was provided by Icon Books for review.
114 reviews
March 1, 2026
This is an amazing story of a jewish family's survival in Shanghai during the holocaust years.

As someone who has never read about the Shanghai experience during the holocaust I thoroughly enjoyed this book.

The author does a good job filling in the historical context around what's happening.

The only critic I have is that it was very drawn out at times which made me lose interest but overall is was an enjoyable read.

I would recommend this to anyone wanting to get more familiar with this aspect of the holocaust.
1 review
January 10, 2024
Excellent balance between a personal account and historical facts!

I liked this book very much. It is well written and can be read without putting it down. The personal account is warm and vivid and there is a great balance between it and a good light-shedding on the history of the Jewish community in Shanghai during that period, a history that is not well known.

I am looking forward to more writings from this writer.
Profile Image for Lesley Lambourne.
149 reviews
March 16, 2024
I loved everything about this book, from the cover to the style of writing!
I knew nothing about the flight of the Austrian Jews to Shanghai, nor anything about Shanghai in the war, so discovering this book (via a Facebook advert) has been plugged has been an education - literally!

Thank you Rachel for the time and effort you have put into researching such an emotionally difficult subject.
Profile Image for Hayley.
209 reviews10 followers
November 7, 2024
4.5 ⭐️

This book is a heartfelt account of a Jewish family from Vienna, so well written that it felt like reading fiction in parts, but sadly, the events are all verified to be true. The account begins before the start of WWII and documents their struggles through and after the war, their desperate flight to Shanghai, and to a lesser degree events up until their deaths.

I have read a lot of WWII fiction and some nonfiction, and I was impressed by this, especially for an author who comes from a different field of work. It is clear that the book was loved and laboured over, and I would imagine it was somewhat of a work of personal therapy. The book was generous with its insight into many areas of not only the wider scope of her family's life but also that of the author's personal life and feelings. There were heart-rending reveals throughout the story.

A personal thank you to the author for the family tree at the beginning of the book, I frequently went back to remind myself of family names and dates, I would have struggled without it.

'Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it' - a quote by George Santayana in 1905. The wrong people choose not to remember as the world has suffered many atrocities since then. Maybe one day people will learn to love one another and our planet and not dwell on matters such as race, religion, and gender.
322 reviews2 followers
June 25, 2023
A very moving book charting the fate and journey of Rachel's maternal family from Vienna to Shanghai. A story of heartache and drama told with great humanity. Brought about by the inheritance of documents and letters (in the eponymous box of the title) from her aunt Lisbeth, Rachel unravels the many mysteries and events in her aunt's life which help her to gain a deep understanding what made Lisbeth the complex character she became.
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews