I watched the calendar until release day for this book to come out, and then I read it sooner than I thought I would because a friend loved and recommended it.
It goes without saying, but I didn't like it as much. I have a lot of thoughts about this story but don't want my review to be scrambled, so I'm putting everything into a simple pros and cons categorization.
**A couple spoilers**
Pros:
~The concept. The idea of the odd woman and the gentle giant fake dating was one I was excited for.
~Hayes and Ellen's first, second, and third meetings.
~Ellen being the only woman Hayes chose at the speed dating event, but not telling her that until later.
~How Ellen and Hayes formed a solid friendship before they really fell in love.
~Hayes being in love with Ellen the entire time. Like, even since walking her home that night five years ago.
~It turning out how Hayes didn't drink and didn't even like his business.
~A few moments that made me laugh or smile.
Cons:
~Ellen. I related to her in a few ways, especially at the beginning. As the story progressed, though, she became annoying, repetitive, and nothing special.
~Hayes. As with Ellen, I liked him in the beginning, but as the pages passed, his larger-than-life character (pun intended) became flat. He became a love interest whose main goal of existence was to be there for Ellen, to love Ellen, to be what Ellen wanted, and to want what Ellen wanted.
~Hayes’ entire family. I felt no emotion toward them except indifference and skimmed almost every scene they were in.
~The never-ending conversations. The banter and interactions between Ellen and Hayes started out as cute but quickly turned into pages upon pages of dialogue about grammar lessons, moth and bug facts, mental disorders, exercise, and other mundane topics. I felt like I was skimming through Wikipedia rather than reading a romcom.
~Using the word consent. One of my bookish pet peeves is when we're shown how "good" a character (usually the guy) is because he says things like: "Don't worry about it me. I promise I will never kiss you without your consent." Or: "Guys who kiss a woman without asking her consent first are scum."
Have the people who do this never heard of the 90/10 rule? Asking without asking? Body language?
Characters asking to kiss the other character or talking about consent is unnecessary. I hate seeing it in books and movies. It takes me out of the story and totally kills the magic of it.
~How apologetic Hayes was. I get it, he was the gentle giant, but him constantly apologizing for absolutely nothing got on my nerves and made him look weak.
~Similarly, how Hayes seemed to make Ellen's personality his own. Like, when they were filling out the "romantic compatibility" list, and Hayes' answers were things like: "I like what you like" or "However many you want".
~That leads me to Ellen and her abominable lists. It started out as cute. Oh, she's a planner and prepares for every detail and setback. But it quickly got out of hand, with so much of the book being dedicated to her lists, how she couldn't simply talk things out with Hayes but had to interview him (in excessive detail) like she was looking for an employee instead of a husband. Even employers aren't that extreme.
~I also couldn't stand Ellen's pathetic behavior, how she was so upset about one thing, so she stayed in bed for days and days doing nothing. Yet she so regretted losing one night of her life while being drunk!
~If Hayes hated running the bar so much, why did he not sell it?
~The plot twist where Ellen's sweet and funny parents turned out to be babying, mistrusting, manipulative, nasty, and awful. It was generic, disappointing, and a poor choice on the author’s part.
~The last several chapters in general. I was skimming and outright skipping pages and pages and pages just waiting for it to be over.