GENRE: AMISH ROMANCE
PUBLISHER: HARVEST HOUSE
PUBLICATION DATE: FEBRUARY 01, 2013
RATING: 4.5 OUT OF 5 – EXCELLENT
PROS: Setting of Pebble Creek comes alive; revisits characters from previous book, continuing to develop their story; touches on difficult topics such as drug abuse and illness; authentic details about tourism and Amish businesses; sweet, realistic romance
CONS: Took a while to warm up to Lydia and Aaron; romance sometimes took the backseat due to secondary storylines
Following on from the first volume in the Pebble Creek Amish series, A Home for Lydia keeps readers up to date with the lives of Miriam, Gabe and Grace, while introducing a new couple for them to fall in love with. Lydia Fisher’s family has fallen on hard times because of her father’s illness, and as a result, she’s had to work to support her parents and siblings, rather than enjoying the running around time that she would usually have been allowed. Thus she finds herself still unmarried at the age of twenty-two, and beginning to feel like an old maid, especially now that her younger sister, Clara, is starting to attend singings. She’s happily looked after the holiday cabins on the banks of Pebble Creek for years, and doesn’t appreciate the interference of Aaron Troyer, who has taken over the business following the death of his uncle.
Aaron doesn’t plan to stay in Pebble Creek for very long, but he realises that he has his work cut out for him when he sees the damage recent floods have done to the cabins. Determined to make his uncle’s business profitable enough to support his widow and daughters, Aaron throws himself into improving the cabins, despite Lydia’s protests. Considering that Aaron intends to return to Indiana as soon as possible, neither of them entertains the possibility of courting, but they find themselves forced to work together, both on the cabins and in order to protect their business from the threat of burglary. Over time, a fondness develops that neither of them can ignore.
Several members of the local Amish community, including Miriam and Gabe, step in to help refurbish the cabins and catch the burglar who is hindering their efforts at improving the business. But despite their desire to help Lydia and Aaron, Miriam and Gabe find that they have more pressing needs to address—namely, Miriam’s mother’s mysterious illness. Young Grace particularly struggles with the news of her grandmother’s illness, and throws herself into her drawing to distract herself. Like Lydia and Aaron, Grace and her family need to learn to trust in God for their future, and have faith that He will make everything right.
Although it had been a while since I’d read the first book in the Pebble Creek Amish series, I was immediately drawn back into the lives of the familiar characters living in the Amish community around Pebble Creek with this second instalment. This is a setting and community that all Amish fans are sure to enjoy, and A Home for Lydia reminded me of why the Amish genre is so appealing. I could easily visualise the cabins on the banks of Pebble Creek, as well as the fields that Gabe ploughed and Miriam’s mother’s garden and father’s workshop. I honestly believe that reading novels like A Home for Lydia make me appreciate the beauty of God’s creation more, simply because of the care and love that the Amish characters bestow upon their land.
I was pleasantly surprised by how large a part Miriam and Gabe’s family played in this book. Although a lot of Amish series throw in a few hints to how the lives of previous characters are progressing, Miriam, Gabe and Grace had nearly as much page-time as Lydia and Aaron. I appreciated being able to witness how the family had adjusted to the birth of Miriam and Gabe’s first child, Rachel, and the difficulties that had arisen as a result of her birth and the recent floods. Vannetta doesn’t sugar-coat the troubles a family can have after the birth of a child, and Miriam’s overwrought emotions and Gabe’s tiredness are sure to strike a chord with any parent reading this novel.
I particularly enjoyed being able to revisit Grace, who is honestly one of the best child characters I’ve come across. I truly felt like I was inside the head of a nine-year-old when reading her passages. The way that the community encouraged and utilised her drawing skill was interesting, and I hope we’ll get the chance to see how Grace uses her art in the next book in the series.
Another issue that Grace’s family has to overcome is Miriam’s mother’s illness. This, combined with Lydia’s father’s condition, provides readers with an insight into how Amish communities help those in need and the way in which they approach modern medicine. The reactions of Miriam’s family to her mother’s illness seemed realistic, and it as heart-warming to see how their family rallied around Abigail as she underwent treatment.
From what I’ve written so far, it almost seems as if Lydia and Aaron only played a small part in A Home for Lydia. To begin with it did feel like this, and as much as I enjoyed reading about Miriam and Gabe, I did find myself realising that I still knew very little about Lydia and Aaron, certainly not enough to really care about whether they would overcome their differences and fall in love. Thankfully, this changed in the last 40% of the novel, and Lydia and Aaron’s storyline regained its rightful front-seat position in the novel.
I particularly enjoyed the interactions between Lydia and her younger sister, Clara. This is the second novel I’ve read this month that contained a sibling rivalry, and I was relieved to find Lydia and Clara’s situation a lot more realistic than the one I’d previously encountered. Even though I don’t have a sister, I could understand Lydia’s resentment of her sister’s freedom and her worry that Clara would encroach upon her domain—the cabins. Lydia’s treatment of her sister revealed a lot about her own worries about her future, and that of her family. It pleased me to see that Lydia and Clara slowly came to appreciate each other more and work together to improve the cabins and catch the burglar.
Aaron’s character remained a little more mysterious than Lydia’s, even as the novel progressed, but I felt that his treatment of Lydia after she discovered that their shop and office had been burgled revealed a lot about his growing feelings for her. Like most men, he struggled with talking to Lydia about how he felt, and sometimes pushed her away in his attempts to protect her. He eventually endeared himself to me, and I’m sure his old-fashioned chivalric attempts to care for Lydia will please many a reader.
Lydia and Aaron’s romance was sweet, even if it took the backseat at times. The truth is, I’m struggling to criticise this book for not keeping the romance in the forefront because the elements that pushed it out of the way were equally compelling. The burglary plot in particular intrigued me, and while it did help Lydia and Aaron’s relationship to develop, it also brought to life some darker aspects of rumpspringe that I’m sure some readers will not have thought about. This angle of the story was dealt with very sensitively, and I hope that some of the characters involved—Seth, Clara and Mattie—will appear in a later novel, as I’d love to see how their lives develop.
As much as I loved all the combined elements of A Home for Lydia, I do wish more time could have been spent on Lydia and Aaron’s relationship. That said, I wouldn’t want any of the other storylines to be taken out in order to accommodate this, so perhaps Vannetta Chapman just needs to start writing longer novels! This addition to the Pebble Creek Amish series is sure to please fans of Vannetta’s work, and hopefully endear some new readers as well.
Review title provided by Harvest House.