An unflattering portrayal
Did not finish it. ------ Rating: --- minus 3
I read the third book of the series on a whim and it was great. I went back to the first book a second time and still couldn't finish it. This book also had me bailing by the 50% mark. This reads more like a bad romance rather than an urban fantasy. For some reason I just had a soft spot for Kingsolver.
I was fairly bored at the time as I remember, which is my only excuse for trying this book or the next. I sometimes wish that Amazon had begun to not "Allow" me to see other reviewers, to see commenter's names and now grays out "like" buttons sometimes. 🤔
The above and more all began after I wrote a brutal review of a "sorry salute to the January 6, 2021 hero". It then seems Amazon took issue with my being a communist. 🙂
For more Amazon, see my review of "Stellar Heritage #1", a white working class US males literally control all of space book (a subgenre of its own) or Powers of the Earth (a sorry salute to the January 6, 2021 hero) and the comments of a Claes Rees Jr/cgr710 (a self-identified NeoNazi and US patriot).
To Claes Rees Jr/cgr710
Don't be a numpty. Be a smarty. Come and join the Communist Party. 🙂
These US patriots (Tucker Carlson, Claes Rees Jr and US Republican Party, for example) all seem to favor suppressing opposing opinions and increasing the powerlessness of the working class. I begin to think that the US constitution must be a truly dark document.
SLAVA UKRAINI !!! -----TA---- SLAVA GEROYAM !!!
Was tempted to reread this book because this and the third seem to blend together in my memory. My memory of this book was tainted by the misogynistic silliness of the first and I had not finished the first, so was "missing" some of the plot. The background world of supernatural and human power struggles is much better defined in this book. 🤗
The setting moving to Eire and the more generally European interactions and reactions did make for a much better set of characters. The writer's descriptive skills are shown to good advantage, I think.
I made the original notes to myself about teenage conversations (probably about boys) and an obsession with clothes shopping. I was bored by the shopping montage as remembered, that being outside my experience with women friends, including exes. Shoes, occasional dresses, skirts or tops were my experience but this emphasis on all things female apparel, just was not something that I ever experienced. 🤔
My class background and those of women I encountered from academia to work might make a difference. I say that to say that it might not be as annoying to some readers. It struck me as a sexist stereotype and I had been known to watch and like some episodes of "Sex and the City". Make of that what you will.
My other notes were that as a continuation of the first book, there was an epidemic of body image obsession among the female characters. I might have missed the accuracy of that, since it was not my lived experience but to me it seemed sad if accurate or just overtly misogynistic.
The telepathic and other powers were something of a strange blend. I had trouble at the time, understanding the boundaries of the clans or their powers. I would have thought that the nature and boundaries of all supernatural factions were more clearly defined by that point in the series. 😐
The sexual encounters were well handled it seems but they did not advance the plot as much as they might. The sex scene does not by itself count as character development. I thought at the time that they were a shallow substitute for character work. I also did not recognize much character growth.
This might be the writer's view of an immature US culture or a nod to mandatory sex talk in woman centered novels. This could appeal to some readers and not so much to others. I have my impression and would ask that you not judge the book solely on my opinion. 😊
The next book was different in pacing and setting with more serious character definition. It also involves awesome action arcs. You might want to try it, whether or not you were satisfied with this book. The Dresden, Junkyard Druid or Heartstriker series might also be entertaining. They are definitely better written than most of the genre.
I have more faith in print fantasy than film or TV but both seem to have devolved to romance novel or D&D adventure. Urban fantasy has survived better but still is not as inventive or interesting as what I recall. For science fiction, I generally prefer video to print at this moment. The bulk of low end print is just dismal.
I began listing YouTube channels in the hope that some low end writers might look to historical, philosophical or scientific sources to ground their books. I had received responses from seven or eight writers to my reviews, so I thought it might be a social good. I suspect that I have failed in that regard. If anyone should read this, you might find it an entertaining or interesting mix. 🤗
I began using YouTube in search of science fiction more than two years ago to search for science fiction-ey things. I was pleasantly surprised by the overwhelming number of special unrest channels. I expected several science fiction channels embedded in a sea of cute pet and music videos. I was nned to discover that the sire hosted so very many book channels. 😍😍
I do not hold myself or any other reviewer on Amazon to put much effort into one of these reviews. We write reviews with no expectation that any other reader will actually see them. If Amazon should want professional opinions, they should really hire experts to give professional analyses for their products (they distribute them, it is their product). The book channels provide all manner of views and some in-depth exploration of the best fiction and critiques of the different genre.
The hosted communities are thoughtful, cosmopolitan, enjoy varied types of books but most of all, love the entirety of bookish things. 😍 I recommend a visit to several book channels for any reader and have listed some below.
The experience is far different to that of Amazon (a site, which features unsolicited reader comments ranging from "You are stupid" to "You are reacting to recent anal rape". I have seen the insulting and the awful in response to many reviews written by both male female readers, when I was "Allowed" to see other reviews. 😑
As for Amazon, between the nutjob aggrieved members and the site's tech employees' out of control insanity, please consider treating this site as potentially hostile. 😐
I also came across the dedicated educational.video sites through sponsor sites on various channels. Wondrium, Epic History TV and others are wonderful and all worth a look. 😊
My YouTube picks of the moment.
Brittany Page, Red Plateaus, Folklore Worldwide, Zoe Bee, Tom Nicholas, Julie Nolke, Let's Talk Mythology, Books with Chloe, Munecat, Overthink Podcast, Cruising on the Border, 2Cellos, The Science of Science Fiction.
Again I ask that patriotic US readers who are offended by my reviews, to not read them. That is what the rest of us tend to do. I also do not believe that even US patriots, fail to realize that attacking content creators to "prove" ????? is just wrong. 🤔 It certainly does not make american culture more appealing. 🙂
Some of my favorite YouTube channels are.
Cruising Alba, Sarah Z, Mia Mulder, Ship Happens, Kings and Generals, Tom Nicholas, The Juice Media, Novara Media, Tara Mooknee, Owen Jones, Austin McConnell, The Little Platoon, A Day of Small Things, Lady knight the Brave, Library Ladder, Jean's Thoughts, With Olivia, Zoe Bee, Practical Engineering, Steve Shives, Jessie Gender, Alice Cappelle, Mythology and Fiction Explained, ARTiculations, Lex Fridman, Maria Dela Torre, Digital Engine, Ben and Emily, Mia Mulder, Sabine Hossenfelder, See U in History -Mythology, Plasma Channel, HackE4, Veritasium, The Templin Institute, Books with Emily Fox, Fraser Cain, Prime of Midlife, Lola Sebastian, OrangeRiver, EarleWrites, Between the Wars, Half as Interesting, Second Thought, Abby Cox, Karolina Zebrowska, Camper Vibe, Kathy's Flog in France, Double Down News, Alt Shift X, Ben G Thomas, Kraut, Then & Now, Nomadic Crobot, Real Time History, Epimetheus, Natasha's Adventures, Robbie Cummings, Sort of Interesting, What Vivi did next, SciTrek, Beautifully Bookish Bethany, Cari Can Read, GeoGirl, Joe Scott, Overly Sarcastic Productions, Asianometry, Jessica Gagnon, Just Write, The Researcher, Renegade Cut.
I wish you a pleasant morning, an enjoyable afternoon, a cozy evening, a wonderful night and may we all continue learning.
When we allow another to speak for us unchallenged, we adopt their sins.
My Catholic Grandmother