Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Lions, Donkeys and Dinosaurs: Blundering and Waste in the Armed Forces

Rate this book
Author Lewis Page set off a firestorm of controversy and accusations when he wrote an explosive story on the British military’s most useless and expensive hardware. In this puckish and provocative book, he tells the full story.

256 pages, Paperback

First published January 23, 2006

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Lewis Page

6 books2 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
18 (21%)
4 stars
39 (47%)
3 stars
16 (19%)
2 stars
7 (8%)
1 star
2 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews
Profile Image for Benjamin.
166 reviews4 followers
January 19, 2022
"Who is this book for?" was the question I found myself pondering as I finished reading it. One the one hand it felt too detailed for a casual reader but conversely not nearly detailed enough for someone with a more established understanding of military matters. The author starts off well with a detailed overview of the various branches of Britain's military and the challenges that make each unique and the decisions that have contributed to the state they find themselves in. As the book goes on however, I found myself frustrated by the facile analysis of the political, industrial and technological circumstances impacting Britain's attempts to maintain relevant armed forces and the minor inaccuracies and generalizations began to add up.

Of course, the geopolitical priorities foremost in the UK government's mind have changed significantly since the book was published, so some of the information would be out of date anyway. Even allowing for this, the author still takes far too long to make similar points and to my mind offers comparative information far too sparingly - though when he does it often misses the point or lacks depth, so maybe that's a blessing in disguise. The question that's often occupied my thoughts on the matter is "does Britain get value for money from defence spending, regardless of the overall spending level and if not why?" Unfortunately this book left me none the wiser on the point.

Finally, I would be remiss not to mention the one passage towards the end of the book that cast a shadow over the whole thing for me:
"The day will come when a lot of very worrying new players will be close to having some ability to drop nukes into London or New York. Players even more worrying, that is, than the governments of Israel and Pakistan - fortunately, neither of those two can hit London or New York quite yet."
This brought home to me how bad Israel's image may be in the UK, especially among political commentators. I've often felt Israeli military experience both in terms of lessons learned from the various conflicts and in terms of technological innovations does not get its full due in the rounds of UK security and defence deliberation, although the issue may run deeper than I thought. Setting that aside, I cannot fathom under what circumstances the Israeli government would ever nuke New York or London. Having previously lived in London and now living in Israel, I can only hope that should they decide upon such a course of action they would at least let me warn my relatives so an orderly evacuation of NW4 may commence.
Profile Image for Paula.
532 reviews4 followers
August 19, 2018
If you pay taxes in the UK, you should read this book.

Page writes about the inefficiencies of the MoD in an informative and amusing style, while hammering home the point quite clearly. In short, 30 BILLION pounds of taxpayer money is being almost wholly wasted on an unwieldy and inefficient military. This is not only a waste of money, but potentially a waste of lives, due to the substandard supply of equipment for those on the ground doing the dirty work.

Page illustrates his point thusly: instead of designing and building their own Apache helicopters in order to provide jobs for British taxpayers, the MoD could have bought Apaches from the US, paid all of the people who would have otherwise worked on building British ones a MILLION POUNDS EACH, and still have money left over.

If that doesn't make you mad, try reading the rest of the book. You'll get there. It took me MONTHS to read this book, simply because I was getting so frustrated and angry by all the stupidity at work.

The book is a about ten years old now, so I'm not too sure what has happened since, but my understanding is that Page is very keen to get taxpayers writing to their MPs to try and make the necessary changes.

If you live in the UK and you want to have an effective and cost-efficient military, then read this book and write some letters. As a country, you deserve better.
Profile Image for Tobias.
338 reviews1 follower
February 16, 2021
A superb book. Everyone should read this to get an understanding of how things are done right, done badly, and everything in between. Not everything Page says makes sense, and not everything he suggests would hold water if implemented, but he nails most of the big issues, and his analysis of the (multiple) failings that plague defence is as true today as it was when this was first published.
43 reviews1 follower
April 11, 2011
I became familiar with Lewis Page from his covering of the defense stories on The Register, and his unending rants on the extraordinary unnecessary burden shouldered by the British taxpayer to support the armed forces–an unusual position for an ex-naval officer. His coverage showed passion and strong opinions which piqued my interest, but they were limited in scope to the story at hand and did not form a coherent whole. This book, written before he acquired his full-time role at El Reg, lays out his position in detail.

Page argues that: UK defense spending is driven by historical & traditional motivations, largely geared to fight the Cold War; 2. the armed forces' ratio of manpower to men with guns is driven up by a large population of unnecessary senior ranks; 3. the defense budget is both inflated by the desire to "buy British" and watered down by the poor quality of the goods received from the same, as a side effect of nationalising then privatising the UK's military supplier market into the monolithic BAE.

I was disappointed that the UK's nuclear weapons are mentioned once, in an aside, as I am very unfamiliar with Trident (both the technology and cost), and would have enjoyed hearing his position on the matter. Page's arguments are still opinionated, but not as inflammatory as his Reg pieces; his arithmetic regarding budgets and manpower are generally good but not without fault; and his closing proposal detailing how to rescue the UK's military is idealistic.

The strong message I took away from the book was that, without public interest and discourse regarding defense and motivated members of parliament working to improve the UK armed forces, the MoD and BAE will happily continue to procure equipment past deadlines and over budget and not fit for task.
Profile Image for Neil.
2 reviews
August 18, 2013
It is an interesting book and the author makes a lot of good and valid points and it would certainly be interesting to hear his thoughts considering what has changed since the book was first written. Some of his points have unfortunately come true, i.e. in Syria, which he indicated was unlikely to happen and consequently there is no opinion about what should be used to defend against this. I also feel he misses the self defence measures he would put in place should missiles slip through the aircraft net sent from carriers or from a deterrent from a largish fleet, as well as omitting very expensive issues should as Trident and the very costly Astute. Although the latter is mentioned, it is only fleetingly.

The book reads more of a general rant until you get to the end of the book when you get his opinion of how things should be run. It would put a lot of people off reading it fully and would suggest that in the Introduction there is a note made that his opinion will be provided of what should happen.
Profile Image for Steve Switzer.
143 reviews2 followers
May 11, 2014
Superb really entertaining to read and having been in the army for 12 years
myself I can well believe the cockups in here
I remember in Germany we used to have 'fashion parades' where the bods with the
most patched acid splashed combats were whittled down to a few who would get
a new jacket.. the rest of us looked like 'patches' out of the song.
So the idea that the 3 tribes only care about each other and that we keep pointless
scouting armoured unit battalions so the pointless rodneys of the cavalry have a
job and for no other reason is entirely believable
Totally necessary reading for all
395 reviews1 follower
August 15, 2016
This is one of the best books I have read. From opinion on military strategy and how that filters out to the defense industry markets, along with some good reasoned proper out of the box thinking that is clearly ignored by the powers that be, all for selfish self preserving of the status quo reasons. I'd love to 'war game' some of the suggestions in here. Think how much we could save if we got rid of the RAF?
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews