This review can also be seen at topoftheheapreviews.com
Tess Tremaine moved to Goose Pimple Junction to get a way from life for a bit. But in her new home she finds a key that could hold the answers to an eighty year old mystery. Part romantic-comedy, part mystery, part southern comfort, does this book come together and keep you from cover to cover?
When this book came to me I was hesitant to really accept it and read it. It’s a whodunnit mystery, but it seemed to have a lot of romantic pieces to it, and that’s not really my style of book. I just don’t gel with the genre that well. I’m glad that I didn’t pass this book up.
Each chapter starts with a little saying that can be pretty unique to the small southern towns, things like “Who licked the red off of your candy cane”, or “We’ve howdied but we ain’t shook yet.” As well they have a word, and pronunciation, as well as the definition. It all is there to get your mind right and to add a little bit more understanding of the characters that inhabit Goose Pimple Junction.
You can gain everything you need to know about the plot from the book back or description, but what you can’t get from that is a sense of how alive these characters are in the book. Now, not every person in a southern town is going to talk the way the folks do at Goose Pimple Junction, so it’s kind of over the top, but that’s what is kind of endearing to the book. It really reminded me of simpler times, where everybody knew everybody (and their business), and the entire town was almost like a large family. You grew to love certain secondary characters in the book, like the book store owner Lou, and her cynical ways. Or even Junebug, owner of the Slick & Junebug’s Diner. It’s a really nice thing that you get to know everyone in the town despite how small their part in the story may be.
A mystery at it’s heart Amy Metz does a good job of throwing up quite a few red herrings to try and keep you off the path of who did what, and how they’re involved. It’s a mystery that is tied to a crime that happened in 1932, but reaches as far as today, and it’s a secret that somebody wants kept, for good. It keeps you reading along and you’ll probably second guess yourself more than once when you are trying to suss out just who did it.
The other side is that this is a romantic comedy. I admit, one of my guilty pleasures are watching some of the Sandra Bullock rom-com movies, and that’s pretty much who I imagined Tess Tremaine was this book. The romantic tension is high as she battles trying to deal with her divorce and being her own person, and the feelings she is having against her own will for the novelist that has come back to Goose Pimple Junction, Jackson Wright. The stumbling over words, and objects, and how she changes when he is around is very comedic, and more than once I was laughing at the pages. It’s not something I thought I would do during these parts of the novel, I’m not much of a reader of romance stuff, but it really worked. It worked because of Amy Metz’s characters.
The dialogue between the characters, all of them, is incredibly well written. That’s the single most important thing that I can point to in this book. It’s very dialogue driven, but it’s so spot on, and each character has their own distinct way of talking, that you could walk into a scene with nothing but dialogue and know who’s talking. That really brings each character to life.
The Bottom Line: Amy Metz could put on a clinic about dialogue and characterization. Even though the characters in this book all kinds of talked the same, and it will take you a while to get a hold of the language, just as if you were visiting in real life, each character has their own personality and unique way about them. The mystery is interesting enough to keep you wanting more, and the way she bounces back and forth from the 30′s to the happenings of today flows in a natural fashion. You get to know what happened in the past, but it only really serves to post more questions than answer up until the very end. I look forward to reading more about the folks in this town.
As a side note I should mention that this books is NOT available on Kindle at the moment! I really hope the publisher comes to their senses, fixes the formatting issues this book has on Kindle and puts it back up there. The formatting of the version I read was incredibly bad. Amy Metz knows this and was unhappy with the issues and informed the publisher about it. The publisher decided to just pull it from Amazon rather than fix it (from what I understand). I don’t know what the B&N version looks like, but I hope that it’s better.
Formatting is a very important thing for a lot of people, if it’s not right, it can ruin the reading experience. Fortunately I was able to edit my copy and make it right. Due to this I was able to really get into this gem of a story about a small town mystery, in the quaint corner of the country called Goose Pimple Junction.