I am not much of a graphic novel reader. As a kid I was into a lot of Marvel comics, especially Thor and the X-men. In college I read a few graphic novels -- The Crow, Gregory, and V for Vendetta. Still later I briefly got into alternative comics -- R. Crumb and the sorts of things Fantagraphics was anthologizing. But I don't think I've read a graphic novel in at least 10 years, and closer to 20.
So I read this on a bit of a lark, as I've been seeing an explosion of graphic novels at work in the library and some of them have looked pretty interesting. Paul Pope's "Escapo" is the story of a circus escape artist, or at least a few episodes from his life, involving an unrequited love, his family legacy, and his fear of death. There are a few hallucinatory sequences, which explore the extreme isolation an escape artist might feel, and some compelling images, but overall I did not think there was much to the story, and at least a third of the book is "bonus material" -- the art, panels, and story sketches that were rejected or never made it into the final draft. I know comics fans love this stuff but I didn't think it added much, if anything to the story. There was not a lot of action, and that in itself is not a criticism, only I was expecting a little more of the protagonist's inner struggles to be explored. Instead, each of his escape acts is a sort of allegorical representation of his mental states. This is a clever idea, but laid end to end, as they are here, the technique seems gimmicky and repetitive.
My other minor grip would be the lettering, which was often ugly and sometimes aggravating to read. I may simply be used to cleaner lettering old school comics, though, and I'm not sure a regular graphic novel fan would be bothered.
Anyway, the book as a whole is worth checking out, especially if you are not that interested in caped superheroes. Whatever its limitations, "Escapo" is also a serious literary graphic novel, and cannot be dismissed as merely a comic book collection.
*I won a copy of this graphic novel through the Goodreads "first reads" giveaway, and while this review was voluntary, in the interest of full disclosure I must mention that my copy was free.*