This comic's premise – graphic memoir about the author's teenage journey of discovery around Italy – is not one that especially appeals to me. I probably never would've read it, if not for the fact that I'm interested in checking out any German-language comic that gets international acclaim. Ulli Lust is of particular interest to me because she's from Austria, where I currently live.
The first 50-odd pages are interesting as an insight into Vienna's 1980s punk subculture, but that's it. After that, things pick up as Lust hits the road and the comic is infused with the thrill of adventure, freedom and youth. Unfortunately, my interest wanes as it becomes increasingly apparent that Lust's journey (or at least this comic) is first and foremost about one thing: sex. Of course, sex is an important subject; my objection doesn't come from a place of prudishness. However, (at least in the work's first half) Lust fails to make her sex life interesting. Moreover, it's disappointing to me that there isn't more focus on other aspects of the journey – such as the people she met, how she learnt Italian, or the practicalities of survival without any money. These things are addressed, but mostly only as a backdrop for Lust's sexual exploits.
Things get progressively darker as the story goes on, and there's a particularly dark turn around the midway mark, which lends the work more emotional resonance. The book's second half is also more interesting than the first thanks to an increased feminist focus, as well as insight provided into 1980s mafia-run Sicily.
Perhaps my biggest problem with this comic is that 17-year-old Lust is so damn irresponsible. Time and again, she makes terrible decisions – often just moments after having bad experiences. I would like to admire her lust for life (no pun intended), but it's not really possible when the negative consequences of her actions are made so readily apparent. Not only is she irresponsible, but she's also very selfish, and is driven by a boring, narrow idea of rebellion that I'm sure would have seemed no less immature to me at 17 than it does now. Moreover, there's little sense that she evolves or matures though her journey. By the story's end she may be a little harder and less naïve, but I can't really say she's become any more responsible.
The comic is drawn in a rough, punky style that suits the story, but mostly doesn't do much for me aesthetically. In general as I read, I found myself only cursorily taking in the images to the extent necessary to see what was happening. That said, the drawings are very expressive, and there are a handful of pages that are quite beautiful.
Overall, this comic isn't bad. The story being told is in itself remarkable enough to maintain the reader's interest. Plus the comic addresses some very important themes and is at times quite emotionally affecting. Nonetheless, it didn't resonate with me much, particularly due to a lack of interesting characters.