What do you think?
Rate this book
Biblical Sexuality: Why the Church of the Nazarene is Right
As American culture has embraced a wide variety of sexual expressions, some in the church have followed suit and affirmed a broken and false view of human sexuality.Thankfully, the Bible provides clear and compelling teaching about human sexuality. And this is the position that the Church of the Nazarene - along with the Church throughout history - has embraced.The Nazarene stance on sexuality provides life-giving boundaries that elevate us to abundance and freedom in Christ.In this volume, 20 Nazarene elders and scholars present arguments and perspectives affirming the biblical view of human sexuality - that sexual intimacy should only be expressed in a marriage between one man and one woman.This book will expand your understanding of biblical teaching, deepen your theological knowledge, and increase your capacity for faithful ministry.ABOUT THE EDITORSMatt Friedeman is the John M. Case Chair of Evangelism and Discipleship at Wesley Biblical Seminary. He also is the founding pastor of DaySpring Community Church of the Nazarene in Clinton, MS, and the author of several books. He and his wife Mary have raised six children together. His podcast is "LifeChanging Discipleship".Elijah Friedeman is the Vice-President of Enrollment at Wesley Biblical Seminary. He is also the founding pastor of Foundry Church of the Nazarene in Flowood, MS.
160 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 18, 2023
16 people are currently reading
7 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
April 22, 2024
I will give commentary on this book later. However, I will say that it's level of academic integrity matches that of its political rival, 'Why the Church of the Nazarene Should Be Fully LGBTQ+ Affirming.'
What both of these books have revealed to me is that the Nazarene academy has significant work to do on "both sides" of this issue if we desire to be faithful witnesses to Christ for persons in LGBTQ+ communities. The traditionalist side needs to move towards nuance on supposedly concrete texts (i.e. Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve rhetoric), and liberal side needs to move beyond comparing this issue to slavery and playing blackjack.
To be quite frank, both books have made me feel embarrassed to be someone who desires to be a Nazarene academic.
What both of these books have revealed to me is that the Nazarene academy has significant work to do on "both sides" of this issue if we desire to be faithful witnesses to Christ for persons in LGBTQ+ communities. The traditionalist side needs to move towards nuance on supposedly concrete texts (i.e. Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve rhetoric), and liberal side needs to move beyond comparing this issue to slavery and playing blackjack.
To be quite frank, both books have made me feel embarrassed to be someone who desires to be a Nazarene academic.
May 25, 2023
The editors of Biblical Sexuality write that one purpose of the book is in response to those wanting to make the case for changes in the current understanding of human sexuality and within the Church of the Nazarene. This purpose is laid out in the introduction: “Some members of the Nazarene tribe have sought to amplify their opinions regarding sex and gender issues in an attempt to liberalize the Church of the Nazarene statement concerning sexuality. While the majority of the denomination and her leaders disagree, the lack of direct response to the recent publication by those contesting the holiness tradition on this matter has been disappointing. A loving but firm rebuttal is good and necessary, and contributors to this volume have decided to engage that task.” The book is also purported to be a response to the recently releases book Why The Church of the Nazarene Should be Fully LGBTQ+ Affirming edited by Tom and Alexa Oord.
As a response to the book on being fully affirming, Biblical Sexuality may be found by many to be lacking. This is partly because of the obvious haste of compilation and publishing; but also because the book it is responding to is much larger and more ambitious in its undertaking. The two books are very different in structure, so it is more of an alternative than a response. But that is mostly structural and aspirational.
The title of the reviewed book gives context Biblical Sexuality: Why the Church of the Nazarene is Right. I would have chosen a much more inviting title, such as Sexuality Within a Holiness Denomination: Why the Church of the Nazarene’s View of Human Sexuality is Sufficient or similar. The word biblical as and adjective is imprecise and sexuality as shown in the pages of scripture can have ideas Christians would reject. As it is, the title alone pushes against an invitation to read. Ironically, a few of the essays within the book make arguments that align with proposed changes to the current statement on human sexuality within the Church of the Nazarene (COTN); which begs the question whether the authors of the essays believe the COTN is right currently. Multiple authors are within districts that have submitted changes to that statement that would strip it of its current middle way and toward a more restrictive understanding of sexuality. If the authors believe the COTN to be right, why are they using arguments that contradict the current statements on human sexuality or, with a few, sponsoring resolutions before the General Assembly of the COTN to change those statements?
Consistency is important when attempting to make cogent arguments for the status quo. When some of those arguments are contrary to the status quo, that consistency is gone. Many of the essays in Biblical Sexuality reflect the current statements on human sexuality in the COTN and make the case for those statements. However, some are not cogent or make claims that are not the current understanding of the COTN. That makes this book a mixed bag and affects my review stars. Besides the outlier essays, I found a few disappointing aspects of the book. The opening interview with Robert Gagnon continually uses the phrase “same-sex intercourse” and within a legalistic understanding, one may mistake that for the prohibition rather than same-sex sexual activity. Gagnon also skews illiberal and leans into political ideology rather than a pastoral understanding (but that is to be expected). At least one contributor to the book has made arguments against the COTN Article of Faith on scripture and based on the point of this book, that is a concern for credibility when accusing others of being outside our doctrines. Another essayist misuses scientific terms and appears to completely misunderstand the science being discussed. If this book were not as rushed as it appears, I would hold the editors accountable for that scientific falsehood. But because it was rushed, the author should have spent more time understanding the subject being written about which is intersex human beings.
I can only assume there is a confusion of transgenderism with intersex, but intersex is not transgender and is a chromosomal and biological reality. The insistence that all humans must be in a binary is not a factual insistence. Nor is it a scriptural understanding of humanity (see Matt 19). This was also an understanding of ancient Rabbis who worked out how to deal with what we call intersex within the Law, which appeared binary. They addressed the Law within that reality. checked with a geneticist and biologist and the claim that all cells carry X or Y chromosomes is not factually accurate. Maybe the reality is that unless we spend a lot of time studying these ideas, we might need to approach a discussion of them with extreme caution. Here is the offending statement:
“Second is the biological reason. Literally every cell in our bodies has DNA that marks our sex. XX is female and XY is male. Every cell details this. To be clear, we understand that there are some individuals who are born with deformed genitals, but that does not change their biological sex. Some are also born with genetic deformities that include Klinefelters (sic) syndrome (which contains an extra X chromosome) and Turner’s syndrome (which has only one X chromosome). Individuals who are born with such have difficulty developing physically and often struggle socially. They also deserve love and compassion as they work through such difficulties. While their struggles are real, their sex is still not up for debate: a Y chromosome denotes a male and lack of a Y chromosome denotes a female.”
Read this book with some caution and check sources carefully. While many of the essays are standard and illuminate the current understanding of human sexuality within the COTN, many also argue points contrary to the current statements and even contain non factual science.
As a response to the book on being fully affirming, Biblical Sexuality may be found by many to be lacking. This is partly because of the obvious haste of compilation and publishing; but also because the book it is responding to is much larger and more ambitious in its undertaking. The two books are very different in structure, so it is more of an alternative than a response. But that is mostly structural and aspirational.
The title of the reviewed book gives context Biblical Sexuality: Why the Church of the Nazarene is Right. I would have chosen a much more inviting title, such as Sexuality Within a Holiness Denomination: Why the Church of the Nazarene’s View of Human Sexuality is Sufficient or similar. The word biblical as and adjective is imprecise and sexuality as shown in the pages of scripture can have ideas Christians would reject. As it is, the title alone pushes against an invitation to read. Ironically, a few of the essays within the book make arguments that align with proposed changes to the current statement on human sexuality within the Church of the Nazarene (COTN); which begs the question whether the authors of the essays believe the COTN is right currently. Multiple authors are within districts that have submitted changes to that statement that would strip it of its current middle way and toward a more restrictive understanding of sexuality. If the authors believe the COTN to be right, why are they using arguments that contradict the current statements on human sexuality or, with a few, sponsoring resolutions before the General Assembly of the COTN to change those statements?
Consistency is important when attempting to make cogent arguments for the status quo. When some of those arguments are contrary to the status quo, that consistency is gone. Many of the essays in Biblical Sexuality reflect the current statements on human sexuality in the COTN and make the case for those statements. However, some are not cogent or make claims that are not the current understanding of the COTN. That makes this book a mixed bag and affects my review stars. Besides the outlier essays, I found a few disappointing aspects of the book. The opening interview with Robert Gagnon continually uses the phrase “same-sex intercourse” and within a legalistic understanding, one may mistake that for the prohibition rather than same-sex sexual activity. Gagnon also skews illiberal and leans into political ideology rather than a pastoral understanding (but that is to be expected). At least one contributor to the book has made arguments against the COTN Article of Faith on scripture and based on the point of this book, that is a concern for credibility when accusing others of being outside our doctrines. Another essayist misuses scientific terms and appears to completely misunderstand the science being discussed. If this book were not as rushed as it appears, I would hold the editors accountable for that scientific falsehood. But because it was rushed, the author should have spent more time understanding the subject being written about which is intersex human beings.
I can only assume there is a confusion of transgenderism with intersex, but intersex is not transgender and is a chromosomal and biological reality. The insistence that all humans must be in a binary is not a factual insistence. Nor is it a scriptural understanding of humanity (see Matt 19). This was also an understanding of ancient Rabbis who worked out how to deal with what we call intersex within the Law, which appeared binary. They addressed the Law within that reality. checked with a geneticist and biologist and the claim that all cells carry X or Y chromosomes is not factually accurate. Maybe the reality is that unless we spend a lot of time studying these ideas, we might need to approach a discussion of them with extreme caution. Here is the offending statement:
“Second is the biological reason. Literally every cell in our bodies has DNA that marks our sex. XX is female and XY is male. Every cell details this. To be clear, we understand that there are some individuals who are born with deformed genitals, but that does not change their biological sex. Some are also born with genetic deformities that include Klinefelters (sic) syndrome (which contains an extra X chromosome) and Turner’s syndrome (which has only one X chromosome). Individuals who are born with such have difficulty developing physically and often struggle socially. They also deserve love and compassion as they work through such difficulties. While their struggles are real, their sex is still not up for debate: a Y chromosome denotes a male and lack of a Y chromosome denotes a female.”
Read this book with some caution and check sources carefully. While many of the essays are standard and illuminate the current understanding of human sexuality within the COTN, many also argue points contrary to the current statements and even contain non factual science.
June 15, 2023
Amazing book
This book is extremely helpful in thinking through the issue of human sexuality and the church. Anyone considering the issue of human sexuality and Christianity should definitely read this book. The numerous authors give a very wide but healthy perspective on this issue.
This book is extremely helpful in thinking through the issue of human sexuality and the church. Anyone considering the issue of human sexuality and Christianity should definitely read this book. The numerous authors give a very wide but healthy perspective on this issue.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews