Gillian Bagwell has spent most of her life in the theatre, and effectively applies her sense of drama, her ear for crisp dialogue, and her feel for character development, to her new career as novelist. This historical tale – her second novel - kept me interested from beginning to end, although it struck me as a heartbreakingly sad story, since the stage on which the romance plays out, is a political struggle over power, money, and rulership of Great Britain. I cannot feel that the sacrifice of so many lives, and the ruin of many more people’s hopes and happiness, could ever be warranted in the interest of securing glory, power, and extravagant self-indulgence for a handful of inbred people who happen to have pedigrees. However, the story is true to its time; in that day, many people did feel that being ruled by their “rightful king” was worth suffering or death.
The protagonist of the title, Jane Lane (a real historical personage, youngest daughter of a staunch royalist family), succumbs almost immediately to seduction by the deposed Stuart King, Charles II (who at twenty-one, is already a rather infamous womanizer). Thenceforth, she risks health, character, social position, and her very life, in the name of an all-consuming passion for a man whom she knows to be far too much of a politician to ever marry a woman who can bring him neither wealth nor power as dowry.
The story is wonderfully well-researched, and from what I already knew of that period and of British history, right on the money in terms of cultural details – costuming, household décor, and even snatches of folk songs, ring true and create a rich mise-en-scene. Just as impressive is Ms. Bagwell’s painstaking research of the social history (using eyewitness reportage of events, actual letters, and other such documentation) – to bring to life details of battles, political maneuverings, intrigues among the nobility of Europe, and of course, King Charles’s daring escape from England in which Jane Lane assists. The scenes of the story unrolled across my mental ‘screen’ with all the color and pageantry of a BBC miniseries (in fact, I hope some British producer is smart enough to option this novel!).
Jane has her share of ecstatic moments in the king’s arms (when he’s not bedding one of half a dozen other mistresses). But tragedy never quite exits the stage in this romantic drama, as many people close to both Jane and the King suffer a variety of unpleasant fates and untimely deaths. What distresses me in this story, is that while Jane is established from the first as highly educated, rational, strong, and independent-minded, yet she cannot manage to see her own situation clearly enough to realize that her dream of being acknowledged as Charles’s “one and only” is nothing but a wishful fantasy. She is highly admirable when doggedly escaping across England, nursing a friend stricken with plague, or defending a young woman from scandal. I find her much less admirable in her constant rationalizations to excuse the King’s unfeeling behavior towards both herself and others. That is, of course, one drawback in telling real-life stories; real people rarely act in the way that we would have them choose.
Nevertheless, I found the story engrossing, in the vivid way it brings this episode of British history to life. I certainly feel indebted to Ms. Bagwell for a vastly increased clarity regarding the Stuart succession, and many other historical realities. Particularly interesting are the details of the exiled English court’s abject poverty and embarrassing dependence upon their noble European kin, since it is an aspect of monarchy in absentia to which I had never given any thought. I also enjoyed Ms. Bagwell’s entertaining device of a through-line in which apposite quotes from Shakespeare turn up in Jane’s mind or mouth at timely moments, reflecting upon events rather in the manner of a Greek chorus. And I found myself pulling for Jane throughout the book, liking her so much as a person, that I kept hoping that with another turn of the page, she would finally wake up and smell the hot chocolate, and write finis to her star-crossed love affair. Does she? To know that, you’ll have to read it yourself, which is something I can recommend without reservation.