4.5⭐️ (Rounded up)
The Girls in the Cabin is a psychological survival thriller/horror with elements of domestic trauma and family drama. It’s a tense read from start to finish and has a few gruesome body horror scenes (late in the story) that sensitive readers should be aware of—but they don’t last long or overwhelm the story.
The story follows Chris, who takes his daughters on a rustic getaway to reconnect after the death of their wife/mother. A misstep on the trail leaves one girl injured, and the family seeks shelter in an isolated cabin when bad weather hits. The cabin’s occupant and the surrounding wilderness are not what they expect. As the storm and isolation tighten their grip, old trauma and shocking revelations surface, pushing the family to desperate measures!
The story has a small cast of characters, which makes it very easy to follow—Chris, the grieving father with regrets, his daughters, Kayla and Emma, along with the woman and her son who occupy the cabin. Chris’s wants nothing more than to make up for past mistakes and do better as a farther, but his decisions only seem to cause more problems as things go from bad to worse and his inner monologues spiral into guilt and defensiveness. The girls are contrasting characters—one is wounded physically which becomes the catalyst for bad luck, but both carry emotional wounds from their mother’s death that makes the story emotionally compelling. The cabin’s owner, Clara, is a compelling character with a complicated backstory and lots of unresolved trauma. Her son, who’s nearly a grown man, comes across as very childlike and odd—and dark truths slowly reveal themselves as the story unfolds. With such a small cast of characters, there’s a lot of rich character development, pronounced arcs, and texture given to each character’s flaws, making the horror scenes more emotionally resonant than sensational!
The book is fast-paced throughout—the opening chapters involving the family’s backstory, the injury, the storm, and the cabin appearing quickly hook readers. The middle section slows a bit but does a great job fleshing out Clara’s complex backstory (and her past relationships) and the fast-growing friction between Chris/his daughters and Clara. Once Emma disappears, the pacing ramps up again and doesn’t let go! Be prepared for simmering psychological tension to become outright gruesome horror by the final act—and readers will be furiously turning the pages to see how it all unfolds! The story culminates in a high-stakes confrontation that’s intense, emotional, and unnerving. The epilogue that follows gives some character resolution but may not give enough of what readers may be craving—especially with regards to Clara—but it will still leave readers memorable dread that lingers!
Fans of fast-paced psychological thrillers, “cabin in the woods” horror stories, and complex characters with haunting backstories will find a lot to love in this book! The book’s graphic scenes and some morally questionable themes can definitely make for an uncomfortable read! But overall it’s another strong offering from Caleb Stephens that will leave readers with a lot to discuss afterwards—and is the perfect choice for a (thriller/horror) book club!