Do I think Carpool to Christmas is a super well-written novel that will someday become a classic?
No. Not at all.
But did I enjoy reading it?
Surprisingly, yes!
First things first: the book description literally tells you 90% of the plot. Overall the story is a little predictable.
But! That doesn't mean it isn't worth reading.
Quinn Hughes is a creative high school junior who apparently can't survive unless her sister Cricket is there to tell her how to live her life. When Cricket goes away to college, Quinn falls apart and becomes completely incapable of doing anything by herself. Quinn's absurdly obnoxious and nosy helicopter parents threaten to drag the girls to the beach for Christmas if Quinn doesn't pull herself together. So Cricket bribes Quinn's incredibly weird neighbor Jesse Winer to be Quinn's (only) friend and her #1 supporter (so basically, replacement Cricket). Of course, after all of Cricket's twisted plots to fix Quinn's life work, about 90% of the way through the book Quinn discovers Cricket's scheme and has a meltdown. No spoilers for the ending...but you can probably guess how it ends.
But. Even though the plot wasn't the best, I still enjoyed reading it! Here are some reasons why:
The characters! Specifically Jesse. He was actually hilarious! He was super weird and funny and sweet and I really enjoyed reading the scenes he was in. I cannot emphasize just how weird he was, though. For example, he has a crush on Quinn (why? She has almost no personality!) and he wants to create a symphony inspired by her. So when Quinn throws her homemade lemon-spice bars into a bush, (why, you ask? because she makes terrible decisions, that's why.) Jesse rescues them from the bush and takes them home. Then he proceeds to eat all of them, keep the dish, and TIE A STRING TO IT AND HANG IT FROM HIS CEILING ALONG WITH A WHISK AND A NAPKIN LIKE A LITTLE MOBILE AND CALL IT "INSPIRATION FOR HIS SYMPHONY"
This is how he responds when Cricket sees the mobile and is understandably weirded out by it:
"It's my inspiration right now." Jesse declared, looking up at the dish from the floor. "For a symphony. The sweet and the spice and the warm, cozy autumn smells and the vibe. And Quinn with her auburn hair like fire." ... "Don't worry, I'll get the dish back to you guys soon." he assured Cricket. "I got photos. Not the same, but good enough."
I'm not going to lie, I was laughing hysterically for a solid minute after I read this. Mostly because of how unexpected it was.
But as the novel went on, I realized this was actually quite in character for Jesse. Here's another part that Jesse thought that made laugh:
"His mom said that when people criticise, it's because they're insecure and has nothing to do with you, like when his sister Audrey installed padded insulation on her wall to shut out his piano playing and refused to acknowledge him at the dinner table."
So, yeah. Jesse was definitely my favorite character. Not really book-boyfriend quality, but he was a good friend and comic relief.
Now, onto Quinn, our protagonist. I'm kind of split on how I feel about her; half the time she was whining and hiding from people and pining after Cricket and being really pathetic, and the other half of the time she was pretty cool. My favorite thing about her was her love for architecture. So many books go for the "I'm an introverted bookworm who loves books!" trope, and while I do love that, I think that an architect was nice for a change. And I LOVED her mini chalet and treehouse. I too love making mini houses and things. (Actually, I would love to be an architect...except it involves too much math.) So Quinn's cool designer-architect stuff was really fun.
Cricket...first of all, why on earth was her name Cricket??? Did her parents actually name her that??? (Mr. and Mrs. Hughes: Ah yes, our two children. We shall give one a nice, normal name, like Quinn, and the other...Cricket. Like the bug.)
Anyway...what you need to know is that Cricket is not a kind, selfless, amazing big sister who always deserves Quinn's attention. She's really an attention-seeking, selfish, manipulative brat who only helps Quinn because she doesn't want to spend Christmas at the beach with her family, she'd rather go skiing with her friends and her rude boyfriend. And she didn't even really "help" Quinn, she just tried to force her sister to follow in her footsteps, when what Quinn really wanted to do was be herself.
But her faults did kind of make her feel more realistic, I guess.
Don't even get me started on the parents...Quinn and Cricket unironically call their parents "Mom-Mom and Dad-Pop." Why? WHY??? How can they do that with a straight face??? Also the parents were super annoying and nosy. For example, Quinn was having a romantic moment with Jesse when Dad-Pop interrupts, saying "Go to your own house Jesse, it's Christmas Eve!" and totally ruining the romantic atmosphere!
Some of the side characters were funny too. I particularly liked The Jesse Winer Quartet. I wish they'd had more page time. I liked Wes, too. He was pretty nice, just not super interesting. I liked Olivia, I don't get why Quinn was all "uGh i HaTe oLiViA sHe'S sO mEaN aNd AnNoYiNg." She was honestly pretty cool. And I thought Rylee and Dax were funny too, even though they only appeared like twice. And I liked Jesse's sister Audrey, but that's only because she shares my name 😂
My biggest annoyance with the book is has no sentence variation whatsoever. Every time a character says something, it goes "dialogue." character [insert verb for said]
Maybe I'm just a nitpicky editor person, but I prefer to not have everything set up the exact same way like that.
Other than that the writing style was okay. The number of times Quinn and Cricket used the word "hot" when describing Wes was actually surprisingly realistic for teenage girls lol
Also, the number of times it said "Cricket chirped" when Cricket said something was HILARIOUS!
I also appreciated how it was totally clean! Nothing questionable, which is rare in a young adult book. The only thing to note is the use of a few very mild curse words, nothing too bad though.
So. While I think it's not the most well-written book ever, I did still find it very enjoyable to read and I would probably read it again. 3.75 stars!