What do you think?
Rate this book
Lady of Letters #2
Murder in Masquerade
Extra, extra, read all about it! Countess turned advice columnist Amelia Amesbury finds herself playing the role of sleuth when a night at the theatre turns deadly.
Victorian Countess Amelia Amesbury’s secret hobby, writing an advice column for a London penny paper, has gotten her into hot water before. After all, Amelia will do whatever it takes to help a reader in need. But now, handsome marquis Simon Bainbridge desperately requires her assistance. His beloved younger sister, Marielle, has written Amelia's Lady Agony column seeking advice on her plans to elope with a man her family does not approve of. Determined to save his sister from a scoundrel and the family from scandal, Simon asks Amelia to dissuade Marielle from the ill-advised gambit.
But when the scoundrel makes an untimely exit after a performance of Verdi’s Rigoletto, Amelia realizes there’s much more at stake than saving a young woman’s reputation from ruin. It’s going to take more than her letter-writing skills to help the dashing marquis, mend the familial bond, and find the murderer. Luckily, solving problems is her specialty!
Victorian Countess Amelia Amesbury’s secret hobby, writing an advice column for a London penny paper, has gotten her into hot water before. After all, Amelia will do whatever it takes to help a reader in need. But now, handsome marquis Simon Bainbridge desperately requires her assistance. His beloved younger sister, Marielle, has written Amelia's Lady Agony column seeking advice on her plans to elope with a man her family does not approve of. Determined to save his sister from a scoundrel and the family from scandal, Simon asks Amelia to dissuade Marielle from the ill-advised gambit.
But when the scoundrel makes an untimely exit after a performance of Verdi’s Rigoletto, Amelia realizes there’s much more at stake than saving a young woman’s reputation from ruin. It’s going to take more than her letter-writing skills to help the dashing marquis, mend the familial bond, and find the murderer. Luckily, solving problems is her specialty!
336 pages, Paperback
First published February 20, 2024
63 people are currently reading
938 people want to read
About the author
Mary Winters
4 books317 followersMary Winters is the Edgar-nominated author of the Lady of Letters historical mystery series. She also pens cozy mysteries under the name Mary Angela. A longtime reader and fan of historical fiction, Mary set her latest work in Victorian England after being inspired by a trip to London. Since then, she’s been busily planning her next mystery—and another trip! Find out more about Mary and her writing, reading, and teaching at marywintersauthor.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 143 reviews
May 21, 2024
These are just fun little mysteries to pass the time. I listened to the audiobook for both the first and second books. There wasn’t anything that really stood out to me but there wasn’t anything I necessarily didn’t like about them either so I think I’d give it a 3 or 3.5⭐️ rating.
October 7, 2024
This series is so charming. Yes, there’s a murder, an attempted murder, and a kidnapping, but we also have wonderful developments with the main characters.
Amelia is fully out of mourning and is participating in the social season. Simon reveals a bit more about his family and we meet his sister. Winifred makes a friend, shows more maturity, and there’s a change in how she addresses Amelia. Even Tabitha shows a little less starch by the end. There’s even a few fun developments in the romantic storyline.
What a fun second installment!
Amelia is fully out of mourning and is participating in the social season. Simon reveals a bit more about his family and we meet his sister. Winifred makes a friend, shows more maturity, and there’s a change in how she addresses Amelia. Even Tabitha shows a little less starch by the end. There’s even a few fun developments in the romantic storyline.
What a fun second installment!
June 8, 2024
Once again Countess Amelia Amesbury becomes involved in death. Her column Lady Agony has attracted the attention of the Marquis of Bainbridg’s sister Marielle. She wants advice on eloping to Gretna Green. When her swain is murdered in Covent Gardens, the Agony Lady puts on her sleuthing hat!
February 22, 2024
An enjoyable second book in a historical mystery romance series that keeps me wanting more! Unlike the first book, which seemed more focused on the mystery and establishing character relationships, this one had a more slice-of-life vibe that I appreciated. We got to see even more of the friendships, the budding romance, the backstories...it all added more color to the series as a whole. While the murder mystery was a focal point, it was interesting how I wasn't as invested in that as I was in seeing Kitty overcome her in-law concerns and seeing Amelia tackle motherhood in a very relatable way. There were so many micro-journeys the reader enjoyed as they went along, and by the end, I was very sorry to see the book conclude. Thankfully, I have full confidence that the author intends to keep right on writing.
To focus first on the romance, I loved how absolutely thirsty Amelia was for Simon in this book. We got a hint of it in the first book, but it was a very small part and just gave us a tiny taste. In this book, Amelia was clearly attracted to Simon in a more obvious and visceral way. She made several comments about his appearance, how she felt when she was around him, and at one point, she realized how strong he was and I could practically see her panting through the pages. I realize it's not the type of series where bones get jumped but...I hope she gets some soon...she has it bad. We see a little bit of Simon pining, but since it's single POV, we don't know for sure exactly how bad he has it for Amelia. There's definitely attraction and genuine affection, and I can absolutely see it continuing to be explored in subsequent books. Aside from their romance, the mystery was interesting to me. The victim wasn't a particularly likable fellow, and he seemed to be using Simon's sister for his own gain, so it wasn't a huge loss when he met his untimely end. Perhaps that why it didn't capture my attention as much. For me, it was almost like, hey look, someone died. That's sad. Now back to the romance! I was much more interested in other things. Thought I will say I didn't have the villain pegged at all, and that's always a mark of a good mystery to me. I like not knowing and the suspense of it all.
**I received a free copy via NetGalley, and this is my honest review.**
To focus first on the romance, I loved how absolutely thirsty Amelia was for Simon in this book. We got a hint of it in the first book, but it was a very small part and just gave us a tiny taste. In this book, Amelia was clearly attracted to Simon in a more obvious and visceral way. She made several comments about his appearance, how she felt when she was around him, and at one point, she realized how strong he was and I could practically see her panting through the pages. I realize it's not the type of series where bones get jumped but...I hope she gets some soon...she has it bad. We see a little bit of Simon pining, but since it's single POV, we don't know for sure exactly how bad he has it for Amelia. There's definitely attraction and genuine affection, and I can absolutely see it continuing to be explored in subsequent books. Aside from their romance, the mystery was interesting to me. The victim wasn't a particularly likable fellow, and he seemed to be using Simon's sister for his own gain, so it wasn't a huge loss when he met his untimely end. Perhaps that why it didn't capture my attention as much. For me, it was almost like, hey look, someone died. That's sad. Now back to the romance! I was much more interested in other things. Thought I will say I didn't have the villain pegged at all, and that's always a mark of a good mystery to me. I like not knowing and the suspense of it all.
**I received a free copy via NetGalley, and this is my honest review.**
February 24, 2024
I really enjoyed this book I love the authors Happy Camper series too so check that Out as well. it does have modern sensibilities but is a female Sleuth in Victorian times. Amelia and Simon male a great detective couple and maybe more!?!?! I like that no one is over the top rude and there is no love triangle. The mystery was interesting I did guess at about 80% the who and why but watching it play put was interesting.
December 26, 2024
I may have enjoyed this second in the series better than the first! Excited for the next book to come out.
October 4, 2024
The writing is a little cheesy and fluffy but these are so cute and fun that I'mma eat 'em up every time
August 18, 2025
It is truth universally acknowledged that murder solving in victorian era w a dash of romance makes for an entertaining experience.
January 30, 2024
This is the second book in the Lady of Letters cozy mystery series. It takes place in London in 1860. Amelia Amesbury is the widowed Countess of a man who died two years earlier of a degenerative disease. She filled the boring time of her mourning by writing an advice column in a penny paper. Each chapter begins with one of the letters and her answer.
The problem in this episode concerns the younger sister of her friend Simon Bainbridge who is being courted by an unsuitable man. Her brother wants to break up the relationship before George Davies, a social-climbing stable master, convinces his sister Marielle to flee to Gretna Green with him.
However, before he can convince her, someone solves the problem by stabbing Davies to death with a distinctive knife. Simon and Amelia are on the case to discover who killed Davies even though Simon thinks the death was helpful to him.
As the two track down various clues, Amelia begins to see Simon as something more than just a man who was a friend to her when her husband died. And he seems to return her regard.
This was just an okay historical mystery/romance for me. I didn't get any sense of the time period except for throwing in a few clothing descriptions. I had trouble believing that Amelia who is the daughter of rural innkeepers would ever have been allowed to marry a peer of the realm. And, having married him, I can't see her being accepted into high society as she seems to have done. I thought she seemed too modern in her outlook and actions for the time period. Many of the other characters were also unrealistic including an opera performer who is also a Lady and a street flower vender who is able to plan high class social events. It seems the author paid little attention to the rigid class system of the day.
The mystery was entertaining and the motive for the crime believable if one allows for a villain who is obsessed.
The problem in this episode concerns the younger sister of her friend Simon Bainbridge who is being courted by an unsuitable man. Her brother wants to break up the relationship before George Davies, a social-climbing stable master, convinces his sister Marielle to flee to Gretna Green with him.
However, before he can convince her, someone solves the problem by stabbing Davies to death with a distinctive knife. Simon and Amelia are on the case to discover who killed Davies even though Simon thinks the death was helpful to him.
As the two track down various clues, Amelia begins to see Simon as something more than just a man who was a friend to her when her husband died. And he seems to return her regard.
This was just an okay historical mystery/romance for me. I didn't get any sense of the time period except for throwing in a few clothing descriptions. I had trouble believing that Amelia who is the daughter of rural innkeepers would ever have been allowed to marry a peer of the realm. And, having married him, I can't see her being accepted into high society as she seems to have done. I thought she seemed too modern in her outlook and actions for the time period. Many of the other characters were also unrealistic including an opera performer who is also a Lady and a street flower vender who is able to plan high class social events. It seems the author paid little attention to the rigid class system of the day.
The mystery was entertaining and the motive for the crime believable if one allows for a villain who is obsessed.
December 20, 2023
*I received a copy of this via the publisher in exchange for an honest review*
Widowed countess Amelia Amesbury is used to being in sticky situations. She has gone to great lengths to uncover truths as the secret author of a popular advice column. Her latest escapade led her to join forces with Simon Bainbridge, a marquis and close friend of Amelia's late husband. But now it seems that Simon is the one in need of assistance. Simon discovers his younger sister has written to Lady Agony asking for advice on whether or not to elope with a man her family disapproves of, and he is desperate for Amelia to dissuade her. But when the man is found dead in an alleyway, Amelia believes there's more to the story. With Simon's family's reputation on the line, it'll take all of Amelia's know-how to solve the case.
I'm so glad I found this series. It's so fun! The characters are my favorite part. Amelia is so plucky, and I love how outspoken she is. Each chapter begins with her advice column, and her replies are blunt and amusing. And Simon is one of those characters that I dare anyone not to fall in love with. He's charming, handsome, and best of all, goes along with whatever scheme Amelia has in mind. I love how he tries to insist on protecting her but is then like, 'Oh, alright.' They play off each other so well, and I'm impatiently waiting for their romance to finally kick-off. We got little moments in here, but I want more. Like in the previous book, the mystery isn't mind-blowing, but it's entertaining. It's become one of my favorite cozy historical mystery series, and I can't wait for more.
Widowed countess Amelia Amesbury is used to being in sticky situations. She has gone to great lengths to uncover truths as the secret author of a popular advice column. Her latest escapade led her to join forces with Simon Bainbridge, a marquis and close friend of Amelia's late husband. But now it seems that Simon is the one in need of assistance. Simon discovers his younger sister has written to Lady Agony asking for advice on whether or not to elope with a man her family disapproves of, and he is desperate for Amelia to dissuade her. But when the man is found dead in an alleyway, Amelia believes there's more to the story. With Simon's family's reputation on the line, it'll take all of Amelia's know-how to solve the case.
I'm so glad I found this series. It's so fun! The characters are my favorite part. Amelia is so plucky, and I love how outspoken she is. Each chapter begins with her advice column, and her replies are blunt and amusing. And Simon is one of those characters that I dare anyone not to fall in love with. He's charming, handsome, and best of all, goes along with whatever scheme Amelia has in mind. I love how he tries to insist on protecting her but is then like, 'Oh, alright.' They play off each other so well, and I'm impatiently waiting for their romance to finally kick-off. We got little moments in here, but I want more. Like in the previous book, the mystery isn't mind-blowing, but it's entertaining. It's become one of my favorite cozy historical mystery series, and I can't wait for more.
September 3, 2025
Another delightful installment of The Lady of Letters historical mystery series. This is the second book, set to release Feb. 20, 2024. It reads as a standalone mystery but don’t miss book one (Murder in Postscript) for background details on how it all started. Both books are pure fun. Lady Amesbury is a 25 year old widow, recently out of mourning, living with her 11 year old stepdaughter and her husband’s prickly Aunt Tabitha. She was her husband’s devoted caretaker but is now ready to re-enter Victorian London’s high society. Through her anonymous Lady Agony column she gives out practical and sometimes controversial advice to her readers. With her late husband’s best friend Lord Simon Bainbridge at her side, she sets off to solve another murder mystery that this time hits close to Simon’s home. The characters in this series are fantastic. I enjoyed the mystery, manners, and hint of romance. 4.5/5 stars.
My thanks to the publisher for an eARC via NetGalley. A positive review was not required and all thoughts are my own.
My thanks to the publisher for an eARC via NetGalley. A positive review was not required and all thoughts are my own.
March 30, 2024
Rating : 2 ⭐
This book didn't manage to capture my interest. I found the mystery uninteresting and the romantic subplot just kept going in circles. The Lady Agony column was my favourite aspect of the first book, but in this one the column got on my nerves. There was a little bit too much modern feminist discourse woven into it to make it believable considering the Victorian setting. I guess there were just too many anachronisms for me to fully suspend my disbelief. I don't feel invested enough, therefore I will not be continuing in this series.
This book didn't manage to capture my interest. I found the mystery uninteresting and the romantic subplot just kept going in circles. The Lady Agony column was my favourite aspect of the first book, but in this one the column got on my nerves. There was a little bit too much modern feminist discourse woven into it to make it believable considering the Victorian setting. I guess there were just too many anachronisms for me to fully suspend my disbelief. I don't feel invested enough, therefore I will not be continuing in this series.
May 15, 2024
Good clean fun! This is a very enjoyable series. In the author’s note she talks about how history books don’t always have to focus on wars and politics. She’s done a great job of taking us into the details of the time period. Clothing, rules of etiquette, horses and the world of racing. Even the correct wording on a party invitation. I just love it all. And then there’s the murder to solve. Mary Winters is a must read author for me.
October 6, 2024
Lady Amelia Amesbury has a secret identity as Lady Agony, the advice columnist in the penny papers. When one of the letters she receives is from Simon Bainbridge's younger sister, who asks for advice about running away with a suitor, Amelia knows she must intervene. When the suitor is found murdered, Amelia and Simon must look for the real killer or else Marielle Bainbridge will always think it was her brother.
I enjoyed this book much more than the first book. The letters at the end of the chapter are always the best part and always compel me to keep reading. I was wondering why I like the advice columnist trope so much, and I think it's because we're always going to need or seek advice whether it's at the micro- or macro-level. The anonymous advice-seeking from the working-, middle-, and gentle-class seemed to connect everyone to an extent. And it's fun seeing someone like Amelia who is very witty and level-headed consistently offer good advice. As a very small complaint, I personally wish there were letters from the working and middle classes that were presented since they were Lady Agony's original audience.
I was entertained throughout the story and I think my main gripes from the first book were rectified. In which there was more emphasis on Amelia and Kitty's friendship and Simon Bainbridge didn't seem like he'd magically appear wherever Amelia happened to be. His strong motive to discover the identity of the killer justified his constant presence, and he showed up with purpose rather than coming off as coincidental to the point of disbelief. I even think the apprehension of the murderer was better this time around. The apprehension was rushed, but I don't think it was bad.
My complaints are the development between Amelia and Simon. The romance is okay. I don't dislike their coupling. However, I do think they need better build-up. Their first kiss progressed so clumsily. They were bickering in the carriage when a small remark led Simon to kiss Amelia's hand in retaliation, and then she kissed him properly to get him back. It was apparently heated and passionate, but I personally didn't think so, since it felt like it came out of nowhere.
And there was a scene where Amelia couldn't be seen in Simon's room, since she was looking for evidence if his family was involved in the murder after all. Simon discovered her and explained himself, but then Amelia couldn't leave his bedroom or else risk being seen by the staff, so she had to climb down a tree with Simon's help. She fell and landed on Simon, and of course Marielle and another guest came upon them in a compromising situation. This scene was supposed to be amusing as Amelia and Simon stumbled to explain themselves, but I didn't find it humourous or entertaining. I found it awkward. Very much like a scene from the first book where Amelia and Kitty were questioning some dock workers and Kitty fell into the water trying to retrieve her hat. Was supposed to add charm or humour, but came off awkward instead.
Looking forward to the next book!
I enjoyed this book much more than the first book. The letters at the end of the chapter are always the best part and always compel me to keep reading. I was wondering why I like the advice columnist trope so much, and I think it's because we're always going to need or seek advice whether it's at the micro- or macro-level. The anonymous advice-seeking from the working-, middle-, and gentle-class seemed to connect everyone to an extent. And it's fun seeing someone like Amelia who is very witty and level-headed consistently offer good advice. As a very small complaint, I personally wish there were letters from the working and middle classes that were presented since they were Lady Agony's original audience.
I was entertained throughout the story and I think my main gripes from the first book were rectified. In which there was more emphasis on Amelia and Kitty's friendship and Simon Bainbridge didn't seem like he'd magically appear wherever Amelia happened to be. His strong motive to discover the identity of the killer justified his constant presence, and he showed up with purpose rather than coming off as coincidental to the point of disbelief. I even think the apprehension of the murderer was better this time around. The apprehension was rushed, but I don't think it was bad.
My complaints are the development between Amelia and Simon. The romance is okay. I don't dislike their coupling. However, I do think they need better build-up. Their first kiss progressed so clumsily. They were bickering in the carriage when a small remark led Simon to kiss Amelia's hand in retaliation, and then she kissed him properly to get him back. It was apparently heated and passionate, but I personally didn't think so, since it felt like it came out of nowhere.
And there was a scene where Amelia couldn't be seen in Simon's room, since she was looking for evidence if his family was involved in the murder after all. Simon discovered her and explained himself, but then Amelia couldn't leave his bedroom or else risk being seen by the staff, so she had to climb down a tree with Simon's help. She fell and landed on Simon, and of course Marielle and another guest came upon them in a compromising situation. This scene was supposed to be amusing as Amelia and Simon stumbled to explain themselves, but I didn't find it humourous or entertaining. I found it awkward. Very much like a scene from the first book where Amelia and Kitty were questioning some dock workers and Kitty fell into the water trying to retrieve her hat. Was supposed to add charm or humour, but came off awkward instead.
Looking forward to the next book!
January 21, 2024
Just as enchanting as the first installment, Murder in Masquerade, charms from the first Lady Agony letter. Amelia, Lady Amesbury, writes an agony aunt column with plenty of good and often controversial advice. She’s also a mother to her niece, Winifred, and solves murders with a most handsome marquis named Simon Bainbridge. When his younger sister Lady Marielle gets entangled with a fortune hunter who is murdered; he turns to Amelia for help. Together they discover that the suitor had plenty of enemies and some dangerous friends. Red herrings, slow burn romance, and a first-rate mystery make this a must read!
Dear reader, you could read this installment as a standalone. However, the first book is so delightful that I recommend that you read it first, Murder in Postscript.
Dear reader, you could read this installment as a standalone. However, the first book is so delightful that I recommend that you read it first, Murder in Postscript.
April 2, 2024
Amelia started out as the daughter of a pubkeeper, married a viscount who died young, and now is an accepted part of Victorian London society, since almost no-one knows she also writes a cheeky advice column for a penny paper. When Marielle, the young sister of her husband's friend Simon, writes to the advice columnist saying she wants to elope, Amelia tells Simon and also tries to intercede. But the man in question , Marielle's former groom, is murdered after the opera, and Amelia and Simon try to investigate, to protect Marielle's reputation.
September 28, 2024
This one was an entertaining read! I’m not sure if reading the first one is necessary, but I don’t know what I don’t know. I did feel like I followed along just fine though. I thought Amelia and Simon’s blossoming romance was really cute, and got pretty hot at times; but I loved that the main focus stayed on the mystery. I truly hadn’t guessed the culprit, and who I kept thinking it was got “mythbusted” and I was back to square one. I thought it respectful that even though the murdered guy sucked, they still wanted to get down to the bottom of the murder to alleviate the lover’s grieving.
June 1, 2025
➳ four stars
countess turned advice columnist, amelia amesbury finds herself once again at the center of a mystery. this time, a man has been murdered and she must do her best to help simon and her sister. i really love mary winter’s writing, the story is engaging and i like all the characters. i enjoyed seeing the development of the relationship between amelia and simon and the interactions between winifred tabitha and amelia. lovely addition to the series!
countess turned advice columnist, amelia amesbury finds herself once again at the center of a mystery. this time, a man has been murdered and she must do her best to help simon and her sister. i really love mary winter’s writing, the story is engaging and i like all the characters. i enjoyed seeing the development of the relationship between amelia and simon and the interactions between winifred tabitha and amelia. lovely addition to the series!
December 9, 2023
Cute period mystery/ suspense/romance with witty dialog and engaging characters. The publisher's blurb is a good hook that keeps its promise.
Enjoyed it!
I requested and received an EARC from Berkley Publishing Group/Berkley via NetGalley.
Enjoyed it!
I requested and received an EARC from Berkley Publishing Group/Berkley via NetGalley.
February 24, 2025
Oh this series soooo fun! I absolutely love the story! I am loving the writing and all the ins and outs of the mystery to be solved!
Listened on Libby
Listened on Libby
June 6, 2024
3.5 A cute continuation to the series. I enjoyed the first a lot more though.
February 21, 2024
Murder in Masquerade is the second book in the A Lady Of Letters Mystery series by Mary Winters.
Widowed two years ago, Lady Amelia pens an advice column as Lady Agony in a penny weekly. Also living in Lady Amelia’s home is her Aunt Tabitha and Lady Amelia’s late husband’s niece, 11-year-old Winifred.
Amelia and her handsome neighbor, Lord Simon Bainbridge, will attend the opera. Simon is attending the opera to keep an eye on his sister, Marielle, who has been stepping out with George Davies. Davies is a former horse trainer for the Bainbridge family. Simon has recently learned that Davies wants Marielle to run off to Gretna Green and get married. Simon considers Davies a no-good gambler and social climber. When the opera ends, Simon notices that Davies has left and Marielle is still in Lord Burton’s box. He and Amelia collect Marielle and head for the carriage to return home. As they near the carriage, they see a disturbance in a nearby narrow alley. As they enter the alley, they find that Davies has been stabbed in the chest and is dead. They do find a large amount of cash on Davies. The question in their minds is whether it was a robbery gone wrong or a case of outright murder.
This book is an excellent start to an enjoyable new series. I particularly liked the letters to Lady Agony and also her replies. The story was well-written and plotted. I enjoyed the characters and thought they were well-developed and very believable.
I’m looking forward to the next book for more letters to Lady Agony and seeing if there will be a romantic connection between Amelia and Simon.
Widowed two years ago, Lady Amelia pens an advice column as Lady Agony in a penny weekly. Also living in Lady Amelia’s home is her Aunt Tabitha and Lady Amelia’s late husband’s niece, 11-year-old Winifred.
Amelia and her handsome neighbor, Lord Simon Bainbridge, will attend the opera. Simon is attending the opera to keep an eye on his sister, Marielle, who has been stepping out with George Davies. Davies is a former horse trainer for the Bainbridge family. Simon has recently learned that Davies wants Marielle to run off to Gretna Green and get married. Simon considers Davies a no-good gambler and social climber. When the opera ends, Simon notices that Davies has left and Marielle is still in Lord Burton’s box. He and Amelia collect Marielle and head for the carriage to return home. As they near the carriage, they see a disturbance in a nearby narrow alley. As they enter the alley, they find that Davies has been stabbed in the chest and is dead. They do find a large amount of cash on Davies. The question in their minds is whether it was a robbery gone wrong or a case of outright murder.
This book is an excellent start to an enjoyable new series. I particularly liked the letters to Lady Agony and also her replies. The story was well-written and plotted. I enjoyed the characters and thought they were well-developed and very believable.
I’m looking forward to the next book for more letters to Lady Agony and seeing if there will be a romantic connection between Amelia and Simon.
December 5, 2023
"Murder in Masquerade" is a mystery set in 1860 in England. Amelia's role as a advice column writer played very little role in this story beyond showing her progressive, feminist attitudes toward social norms. Her boyfriend's sister was going to run away with a man who's in debt and managed to anger a number of people on the racetrack. When they stumbled across his murdered body, Amelia and Simon felt like they had to discover whodunit. The police were pretty much missing from this scenario.
The main characters were likable. Amelia and Simon asked questions to discover who had a motive and was present when the murder happened. Amelia bickered a lot with Simon about who should question whom or go where. He hid something, so she snooped in his bedroom. When about to be found together in his room, rather than handling things an easier way, they climbed down a tree while she's wearing a crinoline dress. Frankly, it would have been even harder than described, but the author wanted a funny scene and so forced it.
I guessed whodunit jokingly and was surprised to be right as the motive was really weak. Amelia did finally figure it out based on one clue after several wrong guesses based on all the other clues. There was no sex. There were only a few uses of bad language. Overall, I didn't enjoy the characters as much as in the first story and wasn't impressed with the mystery.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
The main characters were likable. Amelia and Simon asked questions to discover who had a motive and was present when the murder happened. Amelia bickered a lot with Simon about who should question whom or go where. He hid something, so she snooped in his bedroom. When about to be found together in his room, rather than handling things an easier way, they climbed down a tree while she's wearing a crinoline dress. Frankly, it would have been even harder than described, but the author wanted a funny scene and so forced it.
I guessed whodunit jokingly and was surprised to be right as the motive was really weak. Amelia did finally figure it out based on one clue after several wrong guesses based on all the other clues. There was no sex. There were only a few uses of bad language. Overall, I didn't enjoy the characters as much as in the first story and wasn't impressed with the mystery.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
February 18, 2024
https://openbooksociety.com/article/m...
Brought to you by OBS Reviewer Jeanie
Welcome to London in 1860, early in the Victorian era! I enjoyed this second Lady of Letters mystery. The primary characters were defined well in the series debut, and the author grows their personalities in this mystery. The setting in some of London’s finest homes sounds lovely; I could almost picture and smell the gardens at the Amesbury home. The mystery was a challenge, and kept me guessing. I especially enjoyed the humor woven in; one scene in particular was an incredibly funny situation for a Lady and a Marquis to be found in!
Amelia was widowed after only a couple months of marriage to Edgar, one of the wealthiest men in London. He had chosen her to marry and to raise the niece he was guardian of, as he knew his genetic disorder would take his life long before Winifred, now twelve, was of age. Neither Amelia nor Winifred would ever have need of employment, but Amelia’s old friend Grady had asked for her help answering what were called “Agony” letters (think of Dear Abby) when in need of a new responder at the magazine. She brought a fresh, young viewpoint, but her responses were considered too progressive. Because of her position as Edgar’s widow, nobody could know she was Lady Agony, especially her late husband’s great aunt Tabitha, a pillar of society, and Winifred.
Amelia and Marquis Simon Bainbridge became friends in recent months, especially while they helped solve a series of local murders. He learned by accident of her secret identity as Lady Agony. His younger sister had been causing a bit of agony to him in recent months, and he turned to Amelia for help in how to handle her since their mother passed away years ago.
Marielle had been seeing George, a stableman who made a name for himself training Derby-winning horses. George was a womanizer and a gambler, someone who would do anything to get money and a title. Marielle has both, and her father learned, almost too late, that they planned to elope. The scoundrel had been doing his charming best to hide his temper and bad habits to win Marielle’s heart.
Simon invited Amelia to the opera one night after learning Marielle and George would attend. George stepped out when the opera was almost over, but Marielle did not know where he went. Simon, Marielle, and Amelia walked to the carriage, and Amelia tripped over a pair of legs sticking out from the alley. They were George’s legs; he had been murdered moments before. Marielle was devastated.
Simon wanted Amelia’s help to find George’s killer and try to salvage his relationship with Marielle. Her late husband’s Aunt Tabitha did not want anything going on between the two. Since Amelia was charged with raising Winifred, with whom she had established a loving mother/ daughter relationship, Tabitha took the responsibility of guarding the family’s good name. Simon was very well liked and respected and had been best friends with Amelia’s husband. Tabitha didn’t want them to be more than friends.
Simon and Kitty, Amelia’s best friend, are the only people who knew her Lady Agony persona. They are also the two people who helped her solve a recent series of murders. Kitty’s knowledge of local people and their backgrounds, as well as her talent at helping Amelia consider various scenarios, were vital to finding George’s killer.
Each character is designed with care as demonstrated through their conversations and actions. My favorites are Amelia and Winifred, Amelia sees the time passing quickly, knowing that her time enjoying Winifred will go by in a blur. It will be only a few short years before Winifred makes her debut in society. They had grown close when they mourned Amelia’s husband / Winifred’s uncle soon after the teen lost her parents and grandparents. Amelia also struggles to maintain the decorum required of society ladies and still celebrate life.
Finding the bad guy was not an easy task. Amelia, Simon, and Kitty learned enough about George to know he was worse than they thought. Simon suspected that his father could have been behind the murder so Marielle could not elope with him. The killer was not a complete surprise, as I had a growing suspicion about the person. All was resolved to this reader’s satisfaction, and I am looking forward to the next mystery in the series. I highly recommend this historical/ cozy mystery!
Brought to you by OBS Reviewer Jeanie
Welcome to London in 1860, early in the Victorian era! I enjoyed this second Lady of Letters mystery. The primary characters were defined well in the series debut, and the author grows their personalities in this mystery. The setting in some of London’s finest homes sounds lovely; I could almost picture and smell the gardens at the Amesbury home. The mystery was a challenge, and kept me guessing. I especially enjoyed the humor woven in; one scene in particular was an incredibly funny situation for a Lady and a Marquis to be found in!
Amelia was widowed after only a couple months of marriage to Edgar, one of the wealthiest men in London. He had chosen her to marry and to raise the niece he was guardian of, as he knew his genetic disorder would take his life long before Winifred, now twelve, was of age. Neither Amelia nor Winifred would ever have need of employment, but Amelia’s old friend Grady had asked for her help answering what were called “Agony” letters (think of Dear Abby) when in need of a new responder at the magazine. She brought a fresh, young viewpoint, but her responses were considered too progressive. Because of her position as Edgar’s widow, nobody could know she was Lady Agony, especially her late husband’s great aunt Tabitha, a pillar of society, and Winifred.
Amelia and Marquis Simon Bainbridge became friends in recent months, especially while they helped solve a series of local murders. He learned by accident of her secret identity as Lady Agony. His younger sister had been causing a bit of agony to him in recent months, and he turned to Amelia for help in how to handle her since their mother passed away years ago.
Marielle had been seeing George, a stableman who made a name for himself training Derby-winning horses. George was a womanizer and a gambler, someone who would do anything to get money and a title. Marielle has both, and her father learned, almost too late, that they planned to elope. The scoundrel had been doing his charming best to hide his temper and bad habits to win Marielle’s heart.
Simon invited Amelia to the opera one night after learning Marielle and George would attend. George stepped out when the opera was almost over, but Marielle did not know where he went. Simon, Marielle, and Amelia walked to the carriage, and Amelia tripped over a pair of legs sticking out from the alley. They were George’s legs; he had been murdered moments before. Marielle was devastated.
Simon wanted Amelia’s help to find George’s killer and try to salvage his relationship with Marielle. Her late husband’s Aunt Tabitha did not want anything going on between the two. Since Amelia was charged with raising Winifred, with whom she had established a loving mother/ daughter relationship, Tabitha took the responsibility of guarding the family’s good name. Simon was very well liked and respected and had been best friends with Amelia’s husband. Tabitha didn’t want them to be more than friends.
Simon and Kitty, Amelia’s best friend, are the only people who knew her Lady Agony persona. They are also the two people who helped her solve a recent series of murders. Kitty’s knowledge of local people and their backgrounds, as well as her talent at helping Amelia consider various scenarios, were vital to finding George’s killer.
Each character is designed with care as demonstrated through their conversations and actions. My favorites are Amelia and Winifred, Amelia sees the time passing quickly, knowing that her time enjoying Winifred will go by in a blur. It will be only a few short years before Winifred makes her debut in society. They had grown close when they mourned Amelia’s husband / Winifred’s uncle soon after the teen lost her parents and grandparents. Amelia also struggles to maintain the decorum required of society ladies and still celebrate life.
Finding the bad guy was not an easy task. Amelia, Simon, and Kitty learned enough about George to know he was worse than they thought. Simon suspected that his father could have been behind the murder so Marielle could not elope with him. The killer was not a complete surprise, as I had a growing suspicion about the person. All was resolved to this reader’s satisfaction, and I am looking forward to the next mystery in the series. I highly recommend this historical/ cozy mystery!
February 21, 2024
I absolutely adored the first book in this series! I loved the idea of an advice column as a catalyst for a murder investigation (which is how the first book starts!) and while I didn’t think I would like reading the advice columns at the beginning of each chapter—it grew on my and now I love it! A cozy mystery with some romance was just what I needed going into the long winter months. I started this book in early January and was done with it in a matter of days and naturally I am anxious for the next book in the series to come out and sadly I am going to have to wait another year I bet!
I know the reading market is somewhat saturated with historical cozy mysteries/romances, but for me this one stood out for the advice column as a way to get readers ‘in the door’ as it were—it had a little overtones of Bridgerton with the advice column—but readers will stay for the charming characters and mystery! That’s how this series got me, I liked the idea of the story, but fell in love with Amelia and Simon and now I have a new favorite series on my list!
While this is only the second book in this series, I hope that it will be a long running one! This one can be read as a standalone, but there are some elements that readers won’t fully appreciate unless they read it in order. Since this is only book two you obviously don’t have to go back and read a ton of books. So if you are new to the series, sure read this one but also go back and read the first book. You wont’ regret it!
I really love Amelia’s character. She is independent but not foolishly independent, she is plucky, and knows her own mind. I feel like she is older than she actually is and I love that she is basically a mother to her step daughter. It gives Amelia this maturity that I don’t always see in characters of this genre. Often the main characters feel overly stubborn and impetuous where as Amelia is stubborn in an understated and mature way so I really like that about her and this story. It makes it feel more about the mystery and less about Amelia trying to find out who she really is and where she fits in. In some ways she has already found her identity as a Countess, mother, and wife but having bene widowed early on in her marriage, she isn’t fully a ‘woman of the world’ though either. It makes for a compelling character that I just love seeing evolve.
For Simon, I love that he doesn’t try and change who Amelia is. He is protective sure, but he isn’t so overbearing that he becomes off putting. Sometimes I read these male love interests and I’m like ya sure I get it they want to protect their woman, but also like damn just let her do her thing and stop being in the way. In the books so far we see Simon being supportive and not stifling which I am really enjoying. The mystery in this book is also exciting and I think that there might be some cross over of characters in this book to future books. I have a feeling we haven’t heard the last from some of the supporting villains.
The wait for the next book is going to be tedious! While everything wrapped up nicely in this book, I can sense what the next book is going to focus on and I am eagerly awaiting for things to pick up between Simon and Amelia romantically. I enjoy a slow burn with the best of them but it’s clear what Simon’s intentions are toward Amelia and that she reciprocates, and this book certainly made sure we knew that. But I am ready for some stolen kisses and embraces for sure! This has been one of my favorite new historical mysteries to date and I cannot wait for more mysteries from our favorite advice columnist!
I know the reading market is somewhat saturated with historical cozy mysteries/romances, but for me this one stood out for the advice column as a way to get readers ‘in the door’ as it were—it had a little overtones of Bridgerton with the advice column—but readers will stay for the charming characters and mystery! That’s how this series got me, I liked the idea of the story, but fell in love with Amelia and Simon and now I have a new favorite series on my list!
While this is only the second book in this series, I hope that it will be a long running one! This one can be read as a standalone, but there are some elements that readers won’t fully appreciate unless they read it in order. Since this is only book two you obviously don’t have to go back and read a ton of books. So if you are new to the series, sure read this one but also go back and read the first book. You wont’ regret it!
I really love Amelia’s character. She is independent but not foolishly independent, she is plucky, and knows her own mind. I feel like she is older than she actually is and I love that she is basically a mother to her step daughter. It gives Amelia this maturity that I don’t always see in characters of this genre. Often the main characters feel overly stubborn and impetuous where as Amelia is stubborn in an understated and mature way so I really like that about her and this story. It makes it feel more about the mystery and less about Amelia trying to find out who she really is and where she fits in. In some ways she has already found her identity as a Countess, mother, and wife but having bene widowed early on in her marriage, she isn’t fully a ‘woman of the world’ though either. It makes for a compelling character that I just love seeing evolve.
For Simon, I love that he doesn’t try and change who Amelia is. He is protective sure, but he isn’t so overbearing that he becomes off putting. Sometimes I read these male love interests and I’m like ya sure I get it they want to protect their woman, but also like damn just let her do her thing and stop being in the way. In the books so far we see Simon being supportive and not stifling which I am really enjoying. The mystery in this book is also exciting and I think that there might be some cross over of characters in this book to future books. I have a feeling we haven’t heard the last from some of the supporting villains.
The wait for the next book is going to be tedious! While everything wrapped up nicely in this book, I can sense what the next book is going to focus on and I am eagerly awaiting for things to pick up between Simon and Amelia romantically. I enjoy a slow burn with the best of them but it’s clear what Simon’s intentions are toward Amelia and that she reciprocates, and this book certainly made sure we knew that. But I am ready for some stolen kisses and embraces for sure! This has been one of my favorite new historical mysteries to date and I cannot wait for more mysteries from our favorite advice columnist!
March 16, 2024
I adored the first book in this series, and I couldn’t wait to catch up with Amelia and Simon in Murder in Masquerade and see if there would be any progress on the romance front. Ok, yes, I love the mystery and the other characters and the Victorian setting too but when you tease me with such great romantical sparks and chemistry and possibilities, y’all know that’s what I’m returning for haha. I am also delighted to report that everything I adored about Murder in Postscript is still present in spades in Murder in Masquerade… and that there are indeed some lovely scenes with Simon that had my KissingBooks heart all twitterpated.
Mary Winters’ writing voice is warm and charming and witty and so are her characters. Even crusty Aunt Tabitha who continues to grow on me, especially in this book. Amelia is a wonderful protagonist, plucky and friendly and smart. Her responses as Lady Agony – wherein she is most herself – provide a unique insight into her personality, layers which are further developed by her interactions with the supporting characters and murder investigations she finds herself in. Simon is still dashing and kind and a fierce protector of the women he cares about, including his sister Marielle and Amelia, while still respecting their independence though his sister challenges his ability in both regards in this book. Well, ok, maybe Amelia does too lol. Poor Simon 🙂
Which brings us to the mystery involving the man who’s been trying to convince Marielle to elope to Gretna Green, a man who Simon suspects is a scoundrel and definitely not worthy to be Marielle’s husband. Nevertheless, when the rogue winds up dead, Simon and Amelia investigate his death to help bring Marielle some closure. The investigation spans the gamut of suspects from high society to the criminal underworld, and once again Simon and Amelia – and her endearing best friend Kitty – make a great sleuthing team. I did not even remotely suspect the culprit, and I loved it. Here is where I do recommend that you read Murder in Postscript before starting this second book, as you might feel lost otherwise. There’s sufficient background given, but it’s not immediate, and I had to reorient myself a little too, though I was able to do so fairly quickly.
Bottom Line: Mary Winters continues to deliver a clever and entertaining Victorian mystery in the Lady of Letters Mysteries’ sophomore novel, Murder in Masquerade. Vibrant characters, a well-plotted murder investigation, witty humor, and even some delicious dashes of romance had me wishing to stay in this world indefinitely, not wanting the story to end. I once again loved the Lady Agony column that begins each chapter, and I was positively gleeful about the swoony chemistry that keeps growing stronger between Simon and Amelia. (I want to know if this author writes romance under a pen name because if so I want to read it!) Already eager for future books and another chance to hang out with these great characters!
Reviewer’s Note: Followers of my reviews may want to be aware that there is one usage of the name of Christ as an expletive in this book.
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
Mary Winters’ writing voice is warm and charming and witty and so are her characters. Even crusty Aunt Tabitha who continues to grow on me, especially in this book. Amelia is a wonderful protagonist, plucky and friendly and smart. Her responses as Lady Agony – wherein she is most herself – provide a unique insight into her personality, layers which are further developed by her interactions with the supporting characters and murder investigations she finds herself in. Simon is still dashing and kind and a fierce protector of the women he cares about, including his sister Marielle and Amelia, while still respecting their independence though his sister challenges his ability in both regards in this book. Well, ok, maybe Amelia does too lol. Poor Simon 🙂
Which brings us to the mystery involving the man who’s been trying to convince Marielle to elope to Gretna Green, a man who Simon suspects is a scoundrel and definitely not worthy to be Marielle’s husband. Nevertheless, when the rogue winds up dead, Simon and Amelia investigate his death to help bring Marielle some closure. The investigation spans the gamut of suspects from high society to the criminal underworld, and once again Simon and Amelia – and her endearing best friend Kitty – make a great sleuthing team. I did not even remotely suspect the culprit, and I loved it. Here is where I do recommend that you read Murder in Postscript before starting this second book, as you might feel lost otherwise. There’s sufficient background given, but it’s not immediate, and I had to reorient myself a little too, though I was able to do so fairly quickly.
Bottom Line: Mary Winters continues to deliver a clever and entertaining Victorian mystery in the Lady of Letters Mysteries’ sophomore novel, Murder in Masquerade. Vibrant characters, a well-plotted murder investigation, witty humor, and even some delicious dashes of romance had me wishing to stay in this world indefinitely, not wanting the story to end. I once again loved the Lady Agony column that begins each chapter, and I was positively gleeful about the swoony chemistry that keeps growing stronger between Simon and Amelia. (I want to know if this author writes romance under a pen name because if so I want to read it!) Already eager for future books and another chance to hang out with these great characters!
Reviewer’s Note: Followers of my reviews may want to be aware that there is one usage of the name of Christ as an expletive in this book.
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
October 3, 2024
Barbara’s rating: 5 out of 5 Stars
Series: Lady of Letters #2
Publication Date: 2/20/24
Period: Victorian
Number of Pages: 331
This series features Amelia, Countess of Amesbury, a widow after only two months of marriage. Yes, she knew all along her husband wouldn’t be long in this world because he had a degenerative disease that would take him quickly. She loved him and nursed him night and day for those two months – and then he was gone. Aside from money and a title, he left her with two priceless gifts – his formidable Aunt Tabitha and his lovely, sweet niece, Winifred. However, widowhood and mourning can be very taxing on a young woman’s spirits, so, when her good friend suggested she answer a few ‘advice’ letters his newspaper had received, she took him up on the suggestion. Thus, Amelia, a countess, became the very popular Lady Agony – and that identity must remain a secret! Well, mostly a secret anyway.
Marquis Simon Bainbridge was a great friend to Edgar – and to Amelia – and he is one of the few people who know of her secret identity. Who would have ever thought Simon would require advice from Lady Agony? Yet, here he is – in desperate need. You see, his beloved sister, Marielle, has fallen, hard, for a scoundrel. Not only has she fallen for him, but she is prepared to run away to Gretna Green with him because she knows her family will never approve. Simon knows he has to tread carefully. He has to persuade Marielle her beau, George, is a scoundrel of the first order, yet not tip her over the edge of running away with him. What to do? What to do?
When George’s lifeless body is found in a dirty alley, with a knife protruding from its chest, Simon can breathe a sigh of relief. Or can he? Who murdered George – and why? Will the murderer come after Marielle next? Does she know something she shouldn’t? Could their father have taken matters into his own hands?
Simon and Amelia work tirelessly to find the answers and protect those they love. Yet, the more they learn about George and his underhanded, nefarious schemes, the more suspects they have – including those in their own family.
This fast-paced, well-plotted murder mystery will keep you guessing – because lots of people could want George dead. You’ll see the logic behind each potential suspect and why they could or would have done it – right up until the last Ah! Ha! moment when it all comes together. Murder in Masquerade was a fun, quick read with great main characters and lovely supporting characters. I can hardly wait for the third book in the series to release.
Series: Lady of Letters #2
Publication Date: 2/20/24
Period: Victorian
Number of Pages: 331
This series features Amelia, Countess of Amesbury, a widow after only two months of marriage. Yes, she knew all along her husband wouldn’t be long in this world because he had a degenerative disease that would take him quickly. She loved him and nursed him night and day for those two months – and then he was gone. Aside from money and a title, he left her with two priceless gifts – his formidable Aunt Tabitha and his lovely, sweet niece, Winifred. However, widowhood and mourning can be very taxing on a young woman’s spirits, so, when her good friend suggested she answer a few ‘advice’ letters his newspaper had received, she took him up on the suggestion. Thus, Amelia, a countess, became the very popular Lady Agony – and that identity must remain a secret! Well, mostly a secret anyway.
Marquis Simon Bainbridge was a great friend to Edgar – and to Amelia – and he is one of the few people who know of her secret identity. Who would have ever thought Simon would require advice from Lady Agony? Yet, here he is – in desperate need. You see, his beloved sister, Marielle, has fallen, hard, for a scoundrel. Not only has she fallen for him, but she is prepared to run away to Gretna Green with him because she knows her family will never approve. Simon knows he has to tread carefully. He has to persuade Marielle her beau, George, is a scoundrel of the first order, yet not tip her over the edge of running away with him. What to do? What to do?
When George’s lifeless body is found in a dirty alley, with a knife protruding from its chest, Simon can breathe a sigh of relief. Or can he? Who murdered George – and why? Will the murderer come after Marielle next? Does she know something she shouldn’t? Could their father have taken matters into his own hands?
Simon and Amelia work tirelessly to find the answers and protect those they love. Yet, the more they learn about George and his underhanded, nefarious schemes, the more suspects they have – including those in their own family.
This fast-paced, well-plotted murder mystery will keep you guessing – because lots of people could want George dead. You’ll see the logic behind each potential suspect and why they could or would have done it – right up until the last Ah! Ha! moment when it all comes together. Murder in Masquerade was a fun, quick read with great main characters and lovely supporting characters. I can hardly wait for the third book in the series to release.
November 2, 2024
I enjoyed this second episode of this series! One thing I enjoyed is that, at the start of each chapter, a short letter to Lady Agony and her response is included. The subject of the writer is typically something that will occur in that chapter to demonstrate it. Many of these letters are quite humorous, and the absolute funniest scene (to me) occurred later in the novel that demonstrates the opening letter.
Another thing I appreciated was how Countess Amelia, a young widow and the guardian of her late husband’s precocious niece, kept the secret of her letters secret from all except her long-time friend and editor, and the best friend she has in London, Kitty. Marquis Simon Bainbridge, the beset friend of Amelia’s late husband and an acquaintance from the series of murders he helped her solve, has become a friend who discovered on his own that she is Lady Agony. An interesting man, I would love it if he asked her on a real date rather than as a friend to accompany him.
This time, Simon is in desperate need of her assistance. His younger sister, Marielle, is in love with a stable man who became a trainer of Derby-quality horses. Marielle doesn’t believe the kind of man others tell her that George is a ladies’ man and gambler with a fiery temper. They have plans to elope that the family discovers it, they think, in time to stop it. Simon and Amelia went to the theatre one night when Marielle and George were to be there to see what they can learn. Before the evening was over, George was dead, his legs left sticking out of an alley.
Simon’s father is at risk of being accused of hiring the person who killed George, and Simon wants to find whodunit and try to repair his relationship with Marielle. Amelia has her hands full this time, especially with her late husband’s Aunt Tabitha trying to keep an eye on the pretty young widow and respected Marquis. Tabitha has the future of Amelia’s niece, Winifred, at heart as making her debut will be there before they know it. Amelia and Winifred are as close as mother and daughter, and trust Tabitha’s knowledge of London society.
I was very appreciative of the process of the investigation and the resolution, as well as the restoration of Simon and Marielle’s relationship. Overall, I am becoming attached to the characters and the mysteries are fabulous in this series! I highly recommend this to those who appreciate Victorian mysteries, possible romance, wrapped in luxurious (and sometimes nosy!) London society.
Another thing I appreciated was how Countess Amelia, a young widow and the guardian of her late husband’s precocious niece, kept the secret of her letters secret from all except her long-time friend and editor, and the best friend she has in London, Kitty. Marquis Simon Bainbridge, the beset friend of Amelia’s late husband and an acquaintance from the series of murders he helped her solve, has become a friend who discovered on his own that she is Lady Agony. An interesting man, I would love it if he asked her on a real date rather than as a friend to accompany him.
This time, Simon is in desperate need of her assistance. His younger sister, Marielle, is in love with a stable man who became a trainer of Derby-quality horses. Marielle doesn’t believe the kind of man others tell her that George is a ladies’ man and gambler with a fiery temper. They have plans to elope that the family discovers it, they think, in time to stop it. Simon and Amelia went to the theatre one night when Marielle and George were to be there to see what they can learn. Before the evening was over, George was dead, his legs left sticking out of an alley.
Simon’s father is at risk of being accused of hiring the person who killed George, and Simon wants to find whodunit and try to repair his relationship with Marielle. Amelia has her hands full this time, especially with her late husband’s Aunt Tabitha trying to keep an eye on the pretty young widow and respected Marquis. Tabitha has the future of Amelia’s niece, Winifred, at heart as making her debut will be there before they know it. Amelia and Winifred are as close as mother and daughter, and trust Tabitha’s knowledge of London society.
I was very appreciative of the process of the investigation and the resolution, as well as the restoration of Simon and Marielle’s relationship. Overall, I am becoming attached to the characters and the mysteries are fabulous in this series! I highly recommend this to those who appreciate Victorian mysteries, possible romance, wrapped in luxurious (and sometimes nosy!) London society.
March 15, 2024
Lady Amelia Amesbury is a young widow living with her aunt by marriage and raising her late husband’s niece. Amelia has a friend who is a newspaper editor, and he gave Amelia the job of responding to letters written to the paper’s advice column. However, “society” would not approve of someone of her social standing responding to these “Lady Agony” letters, so she must keep her involvement a secret. Things get complicated when one of the people asking for help is the younger sister of Amelia’s friend, Marquis Simon Bainbridge. Marielle is falling for an inappropriate man, but when the potential gold-digger is murdered, Amelia and Simon are on the case to find the killer.
This is the second book in the Lady of Letter series and although the case stands on its own, I think reading the first book will help you to really get to know and love the main characters. The book takes place in London in the year 1860. Amelia is definitely ahead of her time when it comes to what women should and shouldn’t do. She is rarely hesitant to express her opinions, especially in the responses to her readers that begin each chapter. The letters are definitely the highlight of the book. The subject of the letters is usually related to the events happening in that chapter. They give the reader a look at the customs during this period and how Amelia’s advice is often contrary to how most “ladies” would behave.
As Amelia and Simon investigate the murder and try to protect Marielle, the intelligence and the personality of both characters shine through. What is also apparent is the chemistry between Simon and Amelia. One of them makes a surprising move, but it’s too soon to tell if they will be able to overcome the obstacles in their way to actually begin a relationship. Except for a couple of missteps, they work well together in the investigation as they weed out the suspects in the murder of a man who made several enemies. Although I didn’t find this book as engaging as the first one, this is still a charming series with a unique premise that I recommend to cozy mystery and historical mystery fans.
~ Christine
This is the second book in the Lady of Letter series and although the case stands on its own, I think reading the first book will help you to really get to know and love the main characters. The book takes place in London in the year 1860. Amelia is definitely ahead of her time when it comes to what women should and shouldn’t do. She is rarely hesitant to express her opinions, especially in the responses to her readers that begin each chapter. The letters are definitely the highlight of the book. The subject of the letters is usually related to the events happening in that chapter. They give the reader a look at the customs during this period and how Amelia’s advice is often contrary to how most “ladies” would behave.
As Amelia and Simon investigate the murder and try to protect Marielle, the intelligence and the personality of both characters shine through. What is also apparent is the chemistry between Simon and Amelia. One of them makes a surprising move, but it’s too soon to tell if they will be able to overcome the obstacles in their way to actually begin a relationship. Except for a couple of missteps, they work well together in the investigation as they weed out the suspects in the murder of a man who made several enemies. Although I didn’t find this book as engaging as the first one, this is still a charming series with a unique premise that I recommend to cozy mystery and historical mystery fans.
~ Christine
Displaying 1 - 30 of 143 reviews