Ok, ok, I’ll admit it: I didn’t love this as much as everyone else in the world seems to have done!
Having got that out of the way: this book offers a tour around the world of contemporary art through the lenses of selected players within that subculture, including artists, gallerists and dealers, and spectators and buyers, with whom the author endeavors to deeply embed herself. It’s sort of like Nelly Bly going rogue at Bellevue, only without the undercover guise or high stakes social justice aims and outcomes.
If you already have some familiarity with contemporary art and the aesthetic or intellectual challenges it may present to some viewers, and if you don’t harbor any great objections to any of this and especially if you already appreciate this type of art - then you may not be the primary audience for this book. The book very much operates from the stance that contemporary art is SO WEIRD, and what possibly gives?! Aside from that, it mostly offers a variety of character sketches from the art world combined with progress updates on Bosker’s journey toward appreciating the art itself: the author and her reporting project and corresponding personal growth and learning process seemed the subject of the book more than anything else to me.
I’ll give Bosker this: she genuinely seems personally invested in connecting with what makes all these folks flip their expensive, avant-garde lids over making, selling, viewing, and purchasing art that many might perceive as impractical, challengingly opaque, and perhaps even offputting. And “deeply invested” is an understatement: Bosker is like a dog with a bone here. I have to admit that while on some level I admired her commitment to her project, at times her breathless and Bradshaw-esque, “I couldn’t help but wonder…?!”- style enthusiasm grated on me and I wanted to tell her to just cool it. Sometimes the level-11-out-of-10 intensity and tone (and this was on audio for me, notably) presented like she was sending dispatches to Earth while exploring the topography and denizens of Venus. Calm down!
I know the contemporary art subculture is unusual and interesting and all, but - is it truly THAT unusual and interesting anymore? Especially relative to other contemporary subcultures? You could argue that it’s actually a little old-fashioned, traditional, and quaintly tame. Part of me wanted to say, people have been making art since the beginning of time, plus add capitalism, classism, exclusionary elitism and its fashion trends, and this is what happens, so chill. Nothing much new to see here.
Despite its spiritual and intellectual swathings, art and its market and production unfortunately do not exist outside of the framework of patriarchy and racism, and the parts of the book that focused on this, particularly on the struggles of women and women of color and younger women to break into the nouveau art world’s very old-world gatekeeping, were the most interesting for me.
The continued reign of old-world elitist, patriarchal gate-keeping is especially evident in Bosker’s decision to begin the book with an extended segment detailing her time with a wealthy young white male gallerist who, if the portrayal is accurate, comes off as exactly the sort of verbally and emotionally abusive, hateful, scornful, top-notch snob that you might expect as a stereotypical worst-case scenario perpetrator of this ugliest part of the art world.
I am still curious about the choice to give such a seemingly detestable, distasteful trash person so much space and voice - and therefore power - in this narrative. I… couldn’t help but wonder (?!) about leading with this Mean Boi and allowing him this front and center representation when the rest of the book presents far more complex, interesting, unexpected, sympathetic, and relatable, if quirky, characters. I suppose this framework is meant to help convey the message of yes, there is some of the bullshit and assholery you’d fully expect here, but there is also so much more beauty and humanity and passion! But still, this felt unfair to the overall subject of the art itself and to the many others in the book, especially the artists themselves, who allowed Bosker access to their lives and thoughts. And for me, this section was so hard to get through that I almost didn’t make it to the other side where I was able to meet them too.
Anywho, I hope the villagers don’t come for me with the flaming torches here! It really is a perfectly fine book, don’t get me wrong. I guess I just didn’t get all the fuss. But good for her that she found something to be excited and passionate about: such is the point of life!