One of my winter reads, and I can't think how this one escaped me - probably because it is a children's book, I imagine. I am immediately drawn into timeslip stories, mainly because I think it is genuinely possible to pull back the curtain that separates past and present. In a recent TV dramatisation of The Amazing Mr Blunden, Simon Callow, in character, says that "time is not a straight line, it's more like a vast wheel on which we stand at different points, rarely meeting", and I agree with him.
The tale begins when Catherine Tebbutt, who is about 13, is out on a walk with her parents and two younger siblings Patsy and Andrew on the moors several miles from Sheffield when a storm suddenly whips up and the children take shelter in an old cruck barn. Catherine knows it is there, but cannot explain how she knows, never having seen it before. Once inside, the children play a game in which they imagine they are characters from the past, of the same ages as themselves, who also took shelter in the barn to escape the plague 320 years earlier. Their parents have told them to stay there until they receive a message that it is safe to leave; and not to let anyone in.
Catherine imagines herself as a previous Catherine Tebbutt and the story shows the resourcefulness of and relationship between the siblings as they survive a winter on limited supplies of food, not knowing what each day will bring, or what has happened to their family, friends and neighbours. They learn to forage, to run a home, focus on the important things, entertain themselves and each other and to hope; keeping a candle burning the whole time they are there. It gives a good insight into history in a way that is understandable. The present day storm acts as a metaphor for the plague, and the story ends when their parents appear at the barn door to tell the children the storm is over, mirroring the end of the plague in the 17th century; the knock comes when the candle finally blows out.
I like that the ending is ambiguous without any obvious happy ending; a good children's tale should entertain, but also make you think and question, stretch and challenge. This works well whilst remaining within the levels of understanding of the target age group. I think that Catherine survived the plague, though, because of the strong implication of the contemporary family being her descendants. However, I would have liked to see the impact on the 'now' children, as this wasn't presented at all. What did they learn, think, and consider as a result of their journey into the past? The Children of Winter uses the timeslip device, but here it is simply used as a vehicle to tell the story of the plague of 1665/6, rather than to change or understand history or impact on the present. Again, of course, this is a children's story.
It was good to read a solid traditional story for kids and the illustrations brought it to life - these were really cool. I also found a video of the Channel 4 dramatisation on YouTube which was very faithful to the story and worth a watch.