Clearly there is much to be inspired by in the life of St. Francis. No one could ever question his passion and commitment to the Lord. He was certainly “all in” and then some. Reading this at times made my own life with God seemed timid and hesitant. But there’s a quote on page 100 which possibly reveals what was driving Francis so hard. “Obedience, poverty, chastity, prayer, loyalty and all the rest were means by which his brothers could atone for their defilement, conquer temptation and give themselves completely to God.”
There is a lot in this statement but to break it down into the three things listed. These things can certainly be ways “to giving yourself completely to God” and to a lesser degree “conquering temptation” (a better way would include the Holy Spirit in the process) BUT, no matter how sincere or passionate, this is not a way to find atonement with God. Placing your faith in Christ and his finished work on the cross and resurrection is the only way to find atonement with God. One verse among literally hundreds is Galatians 2:16b “For no one will ever be made right with God by obeying the law.” It’s sad to me that someone with such determination and passion and desire to be right with God was not guided better into the so much better way of The Gospel. This book makes it seem that Francis literally killed himself trying to be right with God in this way. Too bad, because with his obvious charisma and passion he could done so much to free people with the freedom of the actual Gospel.