What do you think?
Rate this book
Liaden Universe, Chronological #17
Necessity's Child
The kompani see none as an enemy, and yet few as friend. The kompani exist in many places, living quietly in the shadows, thriving off the bounty that others have no wit to secure, nor skill to defend. Their private history is unwritten; their recall rooted in dance and dream. The Clan Korval is in many ways the opposite of the kompani. The interstellar trading clan is wealthy in enemies, and fortunate in friends. Korval protects itself with vigor, and teaches even its youngest children the art of war. And when representatives of Clan Korval arrive on the planet Surebleak where the kompani has lived, secret and aloof, the lives of three people intersect—Kezzi, apprentice to the kompani's grandmother; Syl Vor, Clan Korval's youngest warrior; and Rys, a man without a world, or a past.
Necessity's Child is a standalone adventure in the popular and exciting Liaden Universe.
Necessity's Child is a standalone adventure in the popular and exciting Liaden Universe.
336 pages, Hardcover
First published February 1, 2013
58 people are currently reading
402 people want to read
About the author
Sharon Lee
166 books789 followersSharon Lee has been married to her first husband for more than half her lifetime; she is a friend to cats, a member of the National Carousel Association, and oversees the dubious investment schemes of an improbable number of stuffed animals.
Despite having been born in a year of the dragon, Sharon is an introvert. She lives in Maine because she likes it there. In fact, she likes it so much that she has written five novels set in Maine; contemporary fantasy trilogy Carousel Tides, Carousel Sun, Carousel Seas, and mysteries Barnburner and Gunshy.
With the aforementioned first husband, Steve Miller, Sharon has written twenty novels of science fiction and fantasy — many of them set in the Liaden Universe® — and numerous short stories. She has occasionally been an advertising copywriter, a reporter, photographer, book reviewer, and secretary. She was for three years Executive Director of the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, Inc., and was subsequently elected vice president and then president of that organization.
Despite having been born in a year of the dragon, Sharon is an introvert. She lives in Maine because she likes it there. In fact, she likes it so much that she has written five novels set in Maine; contemporary fantasy trilogy Carousel Tides, Carousel Sun, Carousel Seas, and mysteries Barnburner and Gunshy.
With the aforementioned first husband, Steve Miller, Sharon has written twenty novels of science fiction and fantasy — many of them set in the Liaden Universe® — and numerous short stories. She has occasionally been an advertising copywriter, a reporter, photographer, book reviewer, and secretary. She was for three years Executive Director of the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, Inc., and was subsequently elected vice president and then president of that organization.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 138 reviews
June 7, 2017
4.5 stars. I both read and listened to this wonderful book. My Audible review is detailed in the last paragraph. Also see my quiz for this book.
Contents: One sex scene, fairly graphic (felt gratuitous). If not for that scene, NC would suit adolescents. No profanity. Some violence and death. Few (if any) typos in e-book.
I have read most of the books in this series, and Necessity's Child is among my favorites, even though the main protagonists are prolly pre-adolescents and the POV hops like a maddened jitterbug. The story feels complete and satisfying. The pace is fairly even, interrupted by several suddenly intense scenes. It gets a bit slow in a few brief spots, but not a problem. In the end, everything comes to a fine boil. Also, we get to see Boss Conrad a few times. Nice scene talking with Nova in the predawn hours.
Necessity's Child is heartwarming, rich with character-and-relationship development, and lightly steeped in suspense, augmented by several sudden action scenes. There is just a hint of sci-fi/ fantasy. It feels more realistic than paranormal, in large part because there is no galactic space travel. Also, Necessity's Child stands apart from the rest of the series, in that there are no major miraculous "saves" enacted by a goddess or a dramliza /wizard. No walking through walls. Rather, the protagonists (children and adult) are forced to fight with heart and soul, blood and bone, concentration, will, and force of character. Much more satisfying! More character driven, too.
This delightfully domestic tale is set entirely on planet Surebleak, just before Miri gives birth to Talizea / Lizzy, which occurs at the end of this book, and also at the end of Ghost Ship. The timelines overlap.
I adored the main character, Syl Vor yos'Phelium. Granted, he's only a child, but such a fierce and honorable little dragon. By necessity, he was forced to grow up too quickly (see Hidden Resources in "Halfling Moon") yet he is still a boy, needing to play. Loved the interaction between Syl Vor and his mother, Nova. Also, enjoyed his relationship with Beck the cook and with Nova's capable and likable hand Mike Golden. (Is something brewing between Mike and Nova? And by the way, Nova has finally become personable and likable.)
There is another fabulous character, a feisty young girl named Kezzi (aka Anna). Kezzi is of the Bedel people, and apprenticed to old Silain, the grandmotherly luthia, a gifted healer and seer. The Bedel are futuristic Romany people, somewhat techno-savvy but still mystical and old fashioned. I thoroughly enjoyed the growing relationship between Kezzi and Syl Vor (the scenes immediately after the first day Kezzi went to school are hysterical).
Many scenes occur at the local school, where Syl Vor must prove that he's not just a pampered Boss's brat. Also, he must test his mettle against some big bullies. These schoolyard brawls felt authentic, if extreme (but this is wild wild Surebleak, and Syl Vor has been trained in battle "dances" and recently nourished with a special seed pod, so I buy it).
Another key character is Rys Lin pen'Chala. Sympathetic but unpredictable is Rys, dubbed Agent of Change by the racist Department of the Interior for whom he works, pressed mendaciously into service. The authors did a superb job portraying the agonizing mental battles he endures, and his developing relationship with the Kompani of Bedel — Udari, Kezzi, Silain, Rafin, etc. Heartwarming but sad.
Korval characters in NC: Syl Vor and Nova play lead roles – especially Syl Vor. Don't expect to see more than a glimpse of Daav, with brief appearances by Kareen, Pat Rin, young Padi (Shan's teenage daughter), Anthora and her lifemate Ren Zel, and Val Con and Miri. Tree takes part in a few tender scenes. We also see a promising glimpse of the neighbor, Mr. Shaper. Natesa, Priscilla, and Theo Waitley are no-shows.
Minor Quibbles:
As with all Liaden books, the scenes jump back and forth, sometimes after only a page. I don't care for that.
Necessity's Child doesn't appear to add much to the larger plot — but time will tell.
See Li's review and our comments for more on stereotyping the Rom /"space gypsies" as light fingered: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Several Cross-Series Timeline Discrepancies: On their website, the authors place NC between Ghost Ship and Dragon Ship, even though they very recently published it, after Dragon Ship. Sigh. They further state that it occurs concurrent with Ghost Ship. However, this timeline doesn't fit quite right, for various reasons:
In chapter 5, Pat Rin says, "It is, according to my household, very nearly spring" but this conflicts with Ghost Ship Theo Waitley 3 which states that it is already spring when they first arrive on the planet, and Miri is still preggies (she gives birth at the end of both books, NC and GS).
Also, echoing a similar scene in Dragon Ship (Theo Waitley, #4), early in NC, Val Con is playing the omnichora in intense grief because — he tells Syl Vor — he "lost" something precious: .
Another cross-series timeline glitch: In Skyblaze (chapbook) there is only one taxi on the planet, Jemie's taxi. It is winter in Skyblaze, so Miri's baby must already be born, since Korval arrived on Surebleak in spring, and Miri was already well into her gestation period. However, in Necessity's Child, a whole slew of taxi cabs arrive at the new school, before Talizea is born. Huh?
Another misalignment is that Tree glows with a soft green light when Syl Vor goes to see it, late at night. However, at 18% into Ghost Ship Theo Waitley 3 Miri and Val Con approach Tree at night, "crossing the grass at the garden's dark center, to the greater blackness that was the Tree's monumental bulk." (Tree was not glowing. Does it only glow when a beloved child is alone outside, late at night? If so, the text itself is mum.)
Another cross-series discrepancy: In Hidden Resources (see chapbook Halfling Moon) Daav first meets the kids at Surebleak Spaceport, but in Necessity's Child, Syl Vor remembers how they first met Daav at the house: "He had been in house when Syl Vor and Padi and Quinn arrived from The Rock, and had immediately made himself known to them."
A point of cross-series confusion: The warehouses on Surebleak were already explored and put to use for a shipyard in one of the prequels, I Dare (see Day 31 chapter). Cheever tells Pat Rin that he needs money to pay his work crew, for all the construction they have been doing in the warehouse district. "Got the rubbish cleared out...got a couple building squads throwing us up some bays and dorms...Ain't gonna be pretty, least not at first, but we'll have ourselves a working yard that ain't dependent on the port." Pat Rin ponders: "The warehouse district they had taken over for Korval's first shipyard on Surebleak had been burned out...and remained unclaimed...Pat Rin had annexed it and sent a work crew to the area with the goal of cleaning it up." (This does not necessarily have to conflict with the warehouse district in Necessity's Child, used for hydroponics, but...).
Plot improbability: It's fairly unbelievable, that Despite the improbability, I do accept this plot twist. Maybe the power pod he ate did the trick.
Questions: How old is Syl Vor? I guessed 12, but could not find his age in the text. What is the "missing ship" Kezzi referred to? How is Daav? Hope these questions are addressed sooner rather than later, but not holding my breath — the next book is aligned with characters and events uncovered in Balance of Trade. Hopefully, the upcoming sequel will somehow relate to the present sequence of events.
Prediction:
________________
ps. Baen offers a free short story, Eleutherios, written by Lee and Miller, featuring the Bedel People, a Friar, and a wondrous organ. It is not set on Surebleak, nor does it involve Korval, but it does offer insights regarding the Kompani. Thanks to Elaine for sharing the link with me. We can download the collection of short stories to an e-reader or read it online. Go here: http://www.baenebooks.com/p-1886-free...
Also see a short story about Diglon Rifle, Miri's Yxtrang. Diglon plays a role in NECESSITY'S CHILD, so his story would make a nice chaser. The short story, THE RIFLE'S FIRST WIFE, was first posted on Splinter Universe . It's been removed from the website and will probably be sold in the next compilation or "Constellation" of short stories. In the story, we learn more about Diglon's life under Tree. A new character is introduced. We also see a little of Miri, little Lizzy, Jeeves, and Mr. pel'Kana the butler.
***** I also listened to the Audible version of Necessity's Child, when it was selling for $1.99, at least to members who bought the e-book. The narrator (Eileen Stevens) did an acceptable job. Not great, just okay... but why doesn't she know how to pronounce Nova and Caleb? I would pronounce the baby's name differently, too, but who knows? Also, she makes Jeeves sound like a robot, when he should have a plummy Terran accent. She was easy to listen to, except for when she would put the stress on the wrong word in the sentence, which is misleading. Also, she suddenly makes her voice significantly louder, depending on who is speaking. It was a little irritating, because it made me jump, startled (but it didn't happen too often, mainly when portraying the teacher).
Contents: One sex scene, fairly graphic (felt gratuitous). If not for that scene, NC would suit adolescents. No profanity. Some violence and death. Few (if any) typos in e-book.
I have read most of the books in this series, and Necessity's Child is among my favorites, even though the main protagonists are prolly pre-adolescents and the POV hops like a maddened jitterbug. The story feels complete and satisfying. The pace is fairly even, interrupted by several suddenly intense scenes. It gets a bit slow in a few brief spots, but not a problem. In the end, everything comes to a fine boil. Also, we get to see Boss Conrad a few times. Nice scene talking with Nova in the predawn hours.
Necessity's Child is heartwarming, rich with character-and-relationship development, and lightly steeped in suspense, augmented by several sudden action scenes. There is just a hint of sci-fi/ fantasy. It feels more realistic than paranormal, in large part because there is no galactic space travel. Also, Necessity's Child stands apart from the rest of the series, in that there are no major miraculous "saves" enacted by a goddess or a dramliza /wizard. No walking through walls. Rather, the protagonists (children and adult) are forced to fight with heart and soul, blood and bone, concentration, will, and force of character. Much more satisfying! More character driven, too.
This delightfully domestic tale is set entirely on planet Surebleak, just before Miri gives birth to Talizea / Lizzy, which occurs at the end of this book, and also at the end of Ghost Ship. The timelines overlap.
I adored the main character, Syl Vor yos'Phelium. Granted, he's only a child, but such a fierce and honorable little dragon. By necessity, he was forced to grow up too quickly (see Hidden Resources in "Halfling Moon") yet he is still a boy, needing to play. Loved the interaction between Syl Vor and his mother, Nova. Also, enjoyed his relationship with Beck the cook and with Nova's capable and likable hand Mike Golden. (Is something brewing between Mike and Nova? And by the way, Nova has finally become personable and likable.)
There is another fabulous character, a feisty young girl named Kezzi (aka Anna). Kezzi is of the Bedel people, and apprenticed to old Silain, the grandmotherly luthia, a gifted healer and seer. The Bedel are futuristic Romany people, somewhat techno-savvy but still mystical and old fashioned. I thoroughly enjoyed the growing relationship between Kezzi and Syl Vor (the scenes immediately after the first day Kezzi went to school are hysterical).
Many scenes occur at the local school, where Syl Vor must prove that he's not just a pampered Boss's brat. Also, he must test his mettle against some big bullies. These schoolyard brawls felt authentic, if extreme (but this is wild wild Surebleak, and Syl Vor has been trained in battle "dances" and recently nourished with a special seed pod, so I buy it).
Another key character is Rys Lin pen'Chala. Sympathetic but unpredictable is Rys, dubbed Agent of Change by the racist Department of the Interior for whom he works, pressed mendaciously into service. The authors did a superb job portraying the agonizing mental battles he endures, and his developing relationship with the Kompani of Bedel — Udari, Kezzi, Silain, Rafin, etc. Heartwarming but sad.
Korval characters in NC: Syl Vor and Nova play lead roles – especially Syl Vor. Don't expect to see more than a glimpse of Daav, with brief appearances by Kareen, Pat Rin, young Padi (Shan's teenage daughter), Anthora and her lifemate Ren Zel, and Val Con and Miri. Tree takes part in a few tender scenes. We also see a promising glimpse of the neighbor, Mr. Shaper. Natesa, Priscilla, and Theo Waitley are no-shows.
Minor Quibbles:
As with all Liaden books, the scenes jump back and forth, sometimes after only a page. I don't care for that.
Necessity's Child doesn't appear to add much to the larger plot — but time will tell.
See Li's review and our comments for more on stereotyping the Rom /"space gypsies" as light fingered: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Several Cross-Series Timeline Discrepancies: On their website, the authors place NC between Ghost Ship and Dragon Ship, even though they very recently published it, after Dragon Ship. Sigh. They further state that it occurs concurrent with Ghost Ship. However, this timeline doesn't fit quite right, for various reasons:
In chapter 5, Pat Rin says, "It is, according to my household, very nearly spring" but this conflicts with Ghost Ship Theo Waitley 3 which states that it is already spring when they first arrive on the planet, and Miri is still preggies (she gives birth at the end of both books, NC and GS).
Also, echoing a similar scene in Dragon Ship (Theo Waitley, #4), early in NC, Val Con is playing the omnichora in intense grief because — he tells Syl Vor — he "lost" something precious: .
Another cross-series timeline glitch: In Skyblaze (chapbook) there is only one taxi on the planet, Jemie's taxi. It is winter in Skyblaze, so Miri's baby must already be born, since Korval arrived on Surebleak in spring, and Miri was already well into her gestation period. However, in Necessity's Child, a whole slew of taxi cabs arrive at the new school, before Talizea is born. Huh?
Another misalignment is that Tree glows with a soft green light when Syl Vor goes to see it, late at night. However, at 18% into Ghost Ship Theo Waitley 3 Miri and Val Con approach Tree at night, "crossing the grass at the garden's dark center, to the greater blackness that was the Tree's monumental bulk." (Tree was not glowing. Does it only glow when a beloved child is alone outside, late at night? If so, the text itself is mum.)
Another cross-series discrepancy: In Hidden Resources (see chapbook Halfling Moon) Daav first meets the kids at Surebleak Spaceport, but in Necessity's Child, Syl Vor remembers how they first met Daav at the house: "He had been in house when Syl Vor and Padi and Quinn arrived from The Rock, and had immediately made himself known to them."
A point of cross-series confusion: The warehouses on Surebleak were already explored and put to use for a shipyard in one of the prequels, I Dare (see Day 31 chapter). Cheever tells Pat Rin that he needs money to pay his work crew, for all the construction they have been doing in the warehouse district. "Got the rubbish cleared out...got a couple building squads throwing us up some bays and dorms...Ain't gonna be pretty, least not at first, but we'll have ourselves a working yard that ain't dependent on the port." Pat Rin ponders: "The warehouse district they had taken over for Korval's first shipyard on Surebleak had been burned out...and remained unclaimed...Pat Rin had annexed it and sent a work crew to the area with the goal of cleaning it up." (This does not necessarily have to conflict with the warehouse district in Necessity's Child, used for hydroponics, but...).
Plot improbability: It's fairly unbelievable, that Despite the improbability, I do accept this plot twist. Maybe the power pod he ate did the trick.
Questions: How old is Syl Vor? I guessed 12, but could not find his age in the text. What is the "missing ship" Kezzi referred to? How is Daav? Hope these questions are addressed sooner rather than later, but not holding my breath — the next book is aligned with characters and events uncovered in Balance of Trade. Hopefully, the upcoming sequel will somehow relate to the present sequence of events.
Prediction:
________________
ps. Baen offers a free short story, Eleutherios, written by Lee and Miller, featuring the Bedel People, a Friar, and a wondrous organ. It is not set on Surebleak, nor does it involve Korval, but it does offer insights regarding the Kompani. Thanks to Elaine for sharing the link with me. We can download the collection of short stories to an e-reader or read it online. Go here: http://www.baenebooks.com/p-1886-free...
Also see a short story about Diglon Rifle, Miri's Yxtrang. Diglon plays a role in NECESSITY'S CHILD, so his story would make a nice chaser. The short story, THE RIFLE'S FIRST WIFE, was first posted on Splinter Universe . It's been removed from the website and will probably be sold in the next compilation or "Constellation" of short stories. In the story, we learn more about Diglon's life under Tree. A new character is introduced. We also see a little of Miri, little Lizzy, Jeeves, and Mr. pel'Kana the butler.
***** I also listened to the Audible version of Necessity's Child, when it was selling for $1.99, at least to members who bought the e-book. The narrator (Eileen Stevens) did an acceptable job. Not great, just okay... but why doesn't she know how to pronounce Nova and Caleb? I would pronounce the baby's name differently, too, but who knows? Also, she makes Jeeves sound like a robot, when he should have a plummy Terran accent. She was easy to listen to, except for when she would put the stress on the wrong word in the sentence, which is misleading. Also, she suddenly makes her voice significantly louder, depending on who is speaking. It was a little irritating, because it made me jump, startled (but it didn't happen too often, mainly when portraying the teacher).
August 3, 2025
I couldn't resist dipping my toes back into the Liaden universe and was glad to have this book on hand from the library. It is billed as a standalone, but if you aren't aware of the history of Clan Korval and their persecution by the Department of the Interior, a lot of the details will make little sense. I believe that it is standalone in that the main character, Rys, only occurs in this volume. He is found by a member of the kompani, a population who live in the literal underground and who are written to remind one of the Roma, though their customs hint at interesting origins on Surebleak.
We also get to know Syl Vor, the youngest Korval left on Surebleak (excepting baby Lizzie) as he seeks to find a place for himself. Separated from his cousins, Syl Vor is more than willing to attend school with the other children of Surebleak. Though not without its risks, it is deemed a good idea, and it is here that he comes into contact with Kezzi, a girl from the kompani. She becomes the link between Rys and the Korval.
All the action takes place on planet and it mostly concerns characters outside the usual focus of the series. It is refreshing to see the situation from a different perspective. One must wonder what exactly launched the DOI on this mission to eliminate Clan Korval?
Book number 496 of my Science Fiction and Fantasy Reading Project
We also get to know Syl Vor, the youngest Korval left on Surebleak (excepting baby Lizzie) as he seeks to find a place for himself. Separated from his cousins, Syl Vor is more than willing to attend school with the other children of Surebleak. Though not without its risks, it is deemed a good idea, and it is here that he comes into contact with Kezzi, a girl from the kompani. She becomes the link between Rys and the Korval.
All the action takes place on planet and it mostly concerns characters outside the usual focus of the series. It is refreshing to see the situation from a different perspective. One must wonder what exactly launched the DOI on this mission to eliminate Clan Korval?
Book number 496 of my Science Fiction and Fantasy Reading Project
February 10, 2013
While this was a nice side-story in the larger Clan Korval saga, it was definitely minor caliber. Slow-moving, introspective and slight at 328 pages, the plot, such as it was didn't really get into gear until the last third of the book, and then was closed very abruptly. If you are new to the Liaden Universe, this would not be the place to start, as the family history and the various characters' back stories are assumed to be known to the reader.
On the upside, we get a novel that brings more characterization and story time to Nova yos'Galan, one of the more opaque and unknowable of Korval's vast clan. Although she remains an icy force of nature, her true love and regard for her young son Syl Vor shines through nicely. Others of the Clan are seen at a remove by Syl Vor, and we get some hints of what transpired during Plan B with the children under Aunt Kareen and Luken's care and it was perhaps, not all that it could be.
We are introduced to Syl Vor yos'Galan, Nova's young heir, and though him we meet the Bedel, in the form of their youngest daughter, Kezzi. The Bedel are a sort of interstellar Gypsy or Romany analog, who are living semi-secretly under the surface of Surebleak. In another tangent we spend time with Rys, an Agent of Change who on the brink of death ends up being cared for by the Bedel.
Although the main plot is very minor indeed, I suspect that several threads begun here will be important to the overarching narrative. I foresee the Bedel's healing being instrumental to salvaging the DOI's agents, and perhaps their unusual facility with tech playing a role in Theo's ship. Here's hoping Lee & Miller will take the time they need to craft a fitting story for their next installment in the main thread.
On the upside, we get a novel that brings more characterization and story time to Nova yos'Galan, one of the more opaque and unknowable of Korval's vast clan. Although she remains an icy force of nature, her true love and regard for her young son Syl Vor shines through nicely. Others of the Clan are seen at a remove by Syl Vor, and we get some hints of what transpired during Plan B with the children under Aunt Kareen and Luken's care and it was perhaps, not all that it could be.
We are introduced to Syl Vor yos'Galan, Nova's young heir, and though him we meet the Bedel, in the form of their youngest daughter, Kezzi. The Bedel are a sort of interstellar Gypsy or Romany analog, who are living semi-secretly under the surface of Surebleak. In another tangent we spend time with Rys, an Agent of Change who on the brink of death ends up being cared for by the Bedel.
Although the main plot is very minor indeed, I suspect that several threads begun here will be important to the overarching narrative. I foresee the Bedel's healing being instrumental to salvaging the DOI's agents, and perhaps their unusual facility with tech playing a role in Theo's ship. Here's hoping Lee & Miller will take the time they need to craft a fitting story for their next installment in the main thread.
November 30, 2015
4/5; 4 stars; A-
This is the review of the audio version.
I gave 5 stars to the book format. Why? Well, I have to say the way that Lee and Miller write can sometimes be confusing, especially on audio. They often have long, long chapters with lots of 'scene breaks' throughout. In the audio version of this book, its easy to get lost. As I listened I found myself thinking, more than once, that I was glad I had already read the book. I don't know if the narrator could have done a better job or not. I liked Eileen Stevens narration overall.
I LOVED this story, don't get me wrong. Here is my review of the actual story.
This is the review of the audio version.
I gave 5 stars to the book format. Why? Well, I have to say the way that Lee and Miller write can sometimes be confusing, especially on audio. They often have long, long chapters with lots of 'scene breaks' throughout. In the audio version of this book, its easy to get lost. As I listened I found myself thinking, more than once, that I was glad I had already read the book. I don't know if the narrator could have done a better job or not. I liked Eileen Stevens narration overall.
I LOVED this story, don't get me wrong. Here is my review of the actual story.
May 10, 2020
Such a great story, with new main characters. Very very enjoyable! 4/28/16 re-read: I look forward to future developments with the new characters, and Surebleak itself.
November 30, 2015
4.5/5; 5 stars; A
The concepts and characters introduced in this book open up a whole new range of intriguing possibilities for future Liaden Universe stories. I thought the idea of the Bedel people living on Surebleak as a separate society was brilliant. What better place to find dramliza than in a group of 'gypsy' type people, imbued with various gifts such as the sight and far seeing. I liked the variety of characters in the Bedel clan.
I thought that Syl Vor yos'Galan stole the show in this book. He was such a great character. (When I recently re-read Crystal Dragon I saw that Syl Vor is a a yos'Galan family name from way back. Tor An yos'Galan thinks about his grandfather Syl Vor living in his bedroom at the clanhome which was ultimately destroyed by the sheriekas) Although the story takes place after the Korval clan has been kicked off Liad, a person could read this book without having read any of the previous books and still feel satisfied. Reading the short story "Hidden Resources" would give a bit of backstory on where the clan's children were situated before they got settled on Surebleak. In the course of Necessity's Child, there is mention of the strain of the situation on Syl Vor and the dark time before which seemed to make him so somber. (Hidden Resources can be found in the chapbook 'Halfing Moon', available from Smashwords and other ebook sellers).
Another character I really liked was Rhys. His virtual re-birth in the Bedel clan was bitter sweet.
This book didn't really move the overall Korval/DOI battle forward, some of that is going on in other books thats run concurrently, but I thought it enriched the picture of the world being created on Surebleak and set the stage for interesting future developments.
I love this series. I really do.
The concepts and characters introduced in this book open up a whole new range of intriguing possibilities for future Liaden Universe stories. I thought the idea of the Bedel people living on Surebleak as a separate society was brilliant. What better place to find dramliza than in a group of 'gypsy' type people, imbued with various gifts such as the sight and far seeing. I liked the variety of characters in the Bedel clan.
I thought that Syl Vor yos'Galan stole the show in this book. He was such a great character. (When I recently re-read Crystal Dragon I saw that Syl Vor is a a yos'Galan family name from way back. Tor An yos'Galan thinks about his grandfather Syl Vor living in his bedroom at the clanhome which was ultimately destroyed by the sheriekas) Although the story takes place after the Korval clan has been kicked off Liad, a person could read this book without having read any of the previous books and still feel satisfied. Reading the short story "Hidden Resources" would give a bit of backstory on where the clan's children were situated before they got settled on Surebleak. In the course of Necessity's Child, there is mention of the strain of the situation on Syl Vor and the dark time before which seemed to make him so somber. (Hidden Resources can be found in the chapbook 'Halfing Moon', available from Smashwords and other ebook sellers).
Another character I really liked was Rhys. His virtual re-birth in the Bedel clan was bitter sweet.
This book didn't really move the overall Korval/DOI battle forward, some of that is going on in other books thats run concurrently, but I thought it enriched the picture of the world being created on Surebleak and set the stage for interesting future developments.
I love this series. I really do.
January 17, 2013
17 Jan 2013 - The latest in Lee and Miller's Liaden series won't be officially published until 5 Feb 2013 but, thanks to Baen Monthly Bundles, e-book readers get it first. Clan Korval has moved from Liad to Surebleak and it appears our authors want to introduce us to some new faces. So the first chapter throws us headlong into an entirely new society! The Bedel of the kompani have apparently been on Surebleak a lot longer than Korval, however nobody knows that but the Bedel. Lee and Miller's sure hand and excellent skill at worldbuilding bring us right into the thick of things. As soon as we've met the Bedel, it's back to the Clan, but in the voice of Syl Vor yos'Galan, Nova's son who has up until now been only a minor character. Exact ages for Syl Vor and Kezzi, the youngest of the Bedel he soon meets, are never given, but they appear to be the equivalent of human tweenagers. Please note, despite the age of a couple of the main characters, this is not a children’s or YA title. Lee and Miller are never that easy to categorize.
The cast includes oldsters and youngsters and relatives of all stripes. There is plenty of action, manners, of COURSE a cat and even a DOG, but no Turtles. Surebleak continues to become, if not Liad, at least somewhat more civilized. We are brought up to date on a number of characters who have been out of the limelight the last few books.
In short, this is a story to gather up the narrative threads for yet another new direction in the Liaden saga. (Since we're no longer on Liad, do we need a new series title?) Great for us fans, this will be pretty much incomprehensible to the uninitiated. If you are new to the series, start with Partners in Necessity. At least go back as far as I Dare to find out who all these people ARE, because this book won't tell you. As a long term fan, I love it. Hope you will, too.
The cast includes oldsters and youngsters and relatives of all stripes. There is plenty of action, manners, of COURSE a cat and even a DOG, but no Turtles. Surebleak continues to become, if not Liad, at least somewhat more civilized. We are brought up to date on a number of characters who have been out of the limelight the last few books.
In short, this is a story to gather up the narrative threads for yet another new direction in the Liaden saga. (Since we're no longer on Liad, do we need a new series title?) Great for us fans, this will be pretty much incomprehensible to the uninitiated. If you are new to the series, start with Partners in Necessity. At least go back as far as I Dare to find out who all these people ARE, because this book won't tell you. As a long term fan, I love it. Hope you will, too.
October 29, 2012
This will be one of my favourites to reread, because it is a story closed in itself, while advancing more of an impression of the settling of Clan Korval on Surebleak and dealing with the situation there.
If you look for Val Con or Pat Rin, you won't get much of them. What you get, in the persona of Syl Vor is a new point of view of Korval on Surebleak, of clan life as such, of life as a youngster in Korval, and of Nova (whom we really haven't seen much of yet) who is the Korval Boss presence (Pat Rin, after all, runs Surebleak as Boss of Bosses).
The most fun for me were those aspects, the attempts to nurture change in the cultures, the attempts to reach across barriers of customs, the connection with an all new culture - the Bedel (surely somewhat modelled on the Rom of our world) and exploring that.
Rhys I found most interesting as the interacting character with a reason to try to accustom himself to the Bedel. Kezzi was a great mirror in importance for Syl Vor and just a joy as someone he could be a child with, eventually. Syl Vor's development arc from crisis-expecting traumatized protector to young, confident dragon child was a joy to see (I can understand why the adults decided to take that last memory away).
Honestly: what I didn't need was the eventual suspense Department of the Interior subplot. I could have read the slice-of-life getting aquainted, respecting each other with mistakes bit for all of the book - but I'm sure it would not be as commercially valid if the authors had left it out.
If you look for Val Con or Pat Rin, you won't get much of them. What you get, in the persona of Syl Vor is a new point of view of Korval on Surebleak, of clan life as such, of life as a youngster in Korval, and of Nova (whom we really haven't seen much of yet) who is the Korval Boss presence (Pat Rin, after all, runs Surebleak as Boss of Bosses).
The most fun for me were those aspects, the attempts to nurture change in the cultures, the attempts to reach across barriers of customs, the connection with an all new culture - the Bedel (surely somewhat modelled on the Rom of our world) and exploring that.
Rhys I found most interesting as the interacting character with a reason to try to accustom himself to the Bedel. Kezzi was a great mirror in importance for Syl Vor and just a joy as someone he could be a child with, eventually. Syl Vor's development arc from crisis-expecting traumatized protector to young, confident dragon child was a joy to see (I can understand why the adults decided to take that last memory away).
Honestly: what I didn't need was the eventual suspense Department of the Interior subplot. I could have read the slice-of-life getting aquainted, respecting each other with mistakes bit for all of the book - but I'm sure it would not be as commercially valid if the authors had left it out.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 31, 2012
I just can't get enough of Lee and Miller's Liaden stories. This book centers around the next generation, and carries on the rebirth of Surebleak and Boss Conrad's dream for the betterment of the world Korval now calls home.
Nova's son, Syl Vor, has been marked by his experiences under Plan B. Though young, he had a lot of responsibility while the Clan was in hiding, and he doesn't quite know what to do now. Safe among family on Surebleak, he is at loose ends with his older cousins gone and nothing to do. His mother enrolls him in public school.
Kezzi is the daughter of a hidden people called the Beled, who reminded me strongly of gypsies. They interact with outsiders, the gadje, only to fleece them in shoplifting and fortune telling. She is the only child among the Beled, and through a fluke is enrolled in school with Syl Vor.
Rys is discovered by another of the Beled, near death, and is nursed back to health by them. He recoveres his health, but he has lost his memory. He is gradually absorbed into the Beled community, but his past holds terrible secrets.
This book isn't out yet, so I don't want to give spoilers. I bought this as an eARC from Baen.com (love Baen!)What I love about all the Lee and Miller books is the relationships between the characters, which depend greatly on the cultures and customs of the worlds the authors have created. The world of the Beled is very distinct. I hope we'll see more of Syl Vor and Kezzi.
Nova's son, Syl Vor, has been marked by his experiences under Plan B. Though young, he had a lot of responsibility while the Clan was in hiding, and he doesn't quite know what to do now. Safe among family on Surebleak, he is at loose ends with his older cousins gone and nothing to do. His mother enrolls him in public school.
Kezzi is the daughter of a hidden people called the Beled, who reminded me strongly of gypsies. They interact with outsiders, the gadje, only to fleece them in shoplifting and fortune telling. She is the only child among the Beled, and through a fluke is enrolled in school with Syl Vor.
Rys is discovered by another of the Beled, near death, and is nursed back to health by them. He recoveres his health, but he has lost his memory. He is gradually absorbed into the Beled community, but his past holds terrible secrets.
This book isn't out yet, so I don't want to give spoilers. I bought this as an eARC from Baen.com (love Baen!)What I love about all the Lee and Miller books is the relationships between the characters, which depend greatly on the cultures and customs of the worlds the authors have created. The world of the Beled is very distinct. I hope we'll see more of Syl Vor and Kezzi.
October 24, 2012
This book takes place on Surebleak, after the attempt was made on Miri's life during the welcome celebration party. One of the main characters is Syl Vor, who is Nova's heir and a pre-teen (I don't recall seeing his age but he's old enough for school but not yet a halfling) at this time.
I found the book quite interesting, however I would not recommend it as an entry point into the Liaden Universe. Yes it is quite possible to start here, but the book is far more enjoyable if you already know the background and I would think it would be confusing without that background. Since the point of view character changes frequently, the first few chapters are a bit confusing even if you are familiar with the series.
There were some typos of course, but not many of them. I read the Kindle version on my Kindle Fire, and for some reason was not able to customize the typeface or the line spacing, which made for a bit of eyestrain until I increased the font size.
I do highly recommend the entire Liaden Universe. If you haven't read any of them yet, there are multiple good entry points.
I assume that one or more of the sequels to Dragon Ship will include some of the new characters introduced in Necessity's Child.
I found the book quite interesting, however I would not recommend it as an entry point into the Liaden Universe. Yes it is quite possible to start here, but the book is far more enjoyable if you already know the background and I would think it would be confusing without that background. Since the point of view character changes frequently, the first few chapters are a bit confusing even if you are familiar with the series.
There were some typos of course, but not many of them. I read the Kindle version on my Kindle Fire, and for some reason was not able to customize the typeface or the line spacing, which made for a bit of eyestrain until I increased the font size.
I do highly recommend the entire Liaden Universe. If you haven't read any of them yet, there are multiple good entry points.
I assume that one or more of the sequels to Dragon Ship will include some of the new characters introduced in Necessity's Child.
February 7, 2013
A wonderful addition to the Liaden universe. A new race is added, the kompania of the Betel, kind of a reworking of gypsies. The main storyline is going on in the back ground. This story is kind of meanwhile, back at the ranch... The main characters here are a young boy of Korval at loose ends on Surebleak, one of the kompania, and an agent of change who is suffering from amnesia. I loved serious little Syl Vor, Nova's son. He was wonderfully written as a lonely little boy who was too serious for his age. And the poor agent of change who of course had been drafted into the program against his will, as we know by now many are, was a lovely character who couldn't remember why he was afraid of Dragons.
If you're a fan of the Liaden stories, you'll love this one. No slow areas, lots of fun Liaden dialog and mannerisms.
If you haven't started this series yet, what the heck are you waiting for? I've been telling you for years. Come meet Korval already.
If you're a fan of the Liaden stories, you'll love this one. No slow areas, lots of fun Liaden dialog and mannerisms.
If you haven't started this series yet, what the heck are you waiting for? I've been telling you for years. Come meet Korval already.
June 21, 2024
I have to admit that it took me a little bit to get into the story after reading Ghost Ship. In the end, I did enjoy the book.
04/04/2020: I re-read this book again.
05/9/2023: Re-read this again.
06/20/24: When I finished this, yet again, I realized how much I enjoyed this entry in the Liaden Universe, so I gave this an additional star
04/04/2020: I re-read this book again.
05/9/2023: Re-read this again.
06/20/24: When I finished this, yet again, I realized how much I enjoyed this entry in the Liaden Universe, so I gave this an additional star
June 19, 2024
This story takes place on Surebleak shortly after Clan Korval has arrived. It is told from three points of view. The narrator most known to readers of the Liaden series of books is Syl Vor yos'Galan Clan Korval. Syl Vor is a child who is somewhere between eight and ten. Syl Vor has recently come to Korval from the place where he, his cousins, and his great-aunt and uncle were hidden while Plan B was in effect. He lived under the constant threat of danger. Now that the immediate threat has passed, his older cousins have gone off to their aprenticeships and Syl Vor is at loose ends. He wants to be of use.
The second point of view is that of Kezzi who is a daughter of the Bedel who have been hidden on Surebleak for a number of years. They have taken space under some old, abandoned warehouses and come out only to steal stuff they need from the unsuspecting gadjes in the City Above. Kezzi is the youngest of the Bedel and apprentice to the tribe's wisewoman—Silain the luthia.
The third point of view is that of Rys Lin pen'Chela. We first meet Rys when he is found beaten almost to death outside one of the entrances to the Bedel's hidden home. He is taken in and cared for by the wisewoman and befriended by the Bedel. He has been so damaged both physically and mentally that he doesn't remember his past or how he came to be where he now is. We watch him heal and come to feel that the Bedel could be a replacement for the clan he lost. But his past, once remembered isn't ready to let him go.
These three characters come together when Syl Vor begins to attend school with other Surebleak natives. Kezzi is found on the street and brought to the school too. Syl Vor is determined to befriend her and make her his sister. Kezzi just wants to get back to her own people and leave all this school stuff far behind her.
It is the thinking of the adult leaders of Surebleak that they way to make life better for all citizens and to change the social culture is for all the kids to go to school at a consolidated school. They can learn that kids from one Boss's turf aren't different than kids from another. However some adults—notably the remains of the Department of the Interior—do not want Korval's plans for social engineering to succeed. Street patrols have managed to stop most of the sabotage around the new school and capture most of the Department's agents but there is no guarantee that the school will be safe.
There fears are justified because the leader of those agents from the Department of the Interior has one more plan in mind and intends to use Agent of Change Rys Lin pen'Chela to carry it out—no matter how he might feel about massacring a bunch of children including his young sister Kezzi and her friend Syl Vor.
The story was exciting and we did get some cameos by characters we learned to know in earlier books in the series including Daav yos'Phelium, Val Con yos'Phelium, Miri, Nova, Anthora and Ren Zel. I really enjoyed getting to know at least one member of the next generation of Clan Korval and am eager for more adventures.
The second point of view is that of Kezzi who is a daughter of the Bedel who have been hidden on Surebleak for a number of years. They have taken space under some old, abandoned warehouses and come out only to steal stuff they need from the unsuspecting gadjes in the City Above. Kezzi is the youngest of the Bedel and apprentice to the tribe's wisewoman—Silain the luthia.
The third point of view is that of Rys Lin pen'Chela. We first meet Rys when he is found beaten almost to death outside one of the entrances to the Bedel's hidden home. He is taken in and cared for by the wisewoman and befriended by the Bedel. He has been so damaged both physically and mentally that he doesn't remember his past or how he came to be where he now is. We watch him heal and come to feel that the Bedel could be a replacement for the clan he lost. But his past, once remembered isn't ready to let him go.
These three characters come together when Syl Vor begins to attend school with other Surebleak natives. Kezzi is found on the street and brought to the school too. Syl Vor is determined to befriend her and make her his sister. Kezzi just wants to get back to her own people and leave all this school stuff far behind her.
It is the thinking of the adult leaders of Surebleak that they way to make life better for all citizens and to change the social culture is for all the kids to go to school at a consolidated school. They can learn that kids from one Boss's turf aren't different than kids from another. However some adults—notably the remains of the Department of the Interior—do not want Korval's plans for social engineering to succeed. Street patrols have managed to stop most of the sabotage around the new school and capture most of the Department's agents but there is no guarantee that the school will be safe.
There fears are justified because the leader of those agents from the Department of the Interior has one more plan in mind and intends to use Agent of Change Rys Lin pen'Chela to carry it out—no matter how he might feel about massacring a bunch of children including his young sister Kezzi and her friend Syl Vor.
The story was exciting and we did get some cameos by characters we learned to know in earlier books in the series including Daav yos'Phelium, Val Con yos'Phelium, Miri, Nova, Anthora and Ren Zel. I really enjoyed getting to know at least one member of the next generation of Clan Korval and am eager for more adventures.
February 13, 2013
As close as you will get to a stand alone story in the long-running Liaden Universe series.
Clan Korval is now on Surebleak and going about its business. Young Syl Vor, Nova yos Galen's son, is at loose ends and wants something, anything!, to do. To which end, he finds himself attending the local school. It seems so simple--he gets to spend more time with his mother and meet other kids.
However, nothing is ever simple where Korval is involved.
The authors introduce us to hitherto unknown residents of the city--the gypsy-like kompani. Marvelous characters, especially young Kezzi, who somehow finds herself going to school with Syl Vor.
Last element in the mix is the mysterious Rys, who is found battered, almost dead, on the kompnai's doorstep and is taken in by them and healed. Rys has a fear of dragons.....
The story is very low-key--lots of day to day goings-on, but never boring. We get glimpses of Nova becoming a more involved mother to her child. We get a bit more of just what it takes to run a city--just what do the bosses do all day? The school sessions are interesting--fascinating what a Surebleak child is expected to know! And we get a slowly building tension, as it becomes apparent that the dear old Department of the Interior has in no way given up in its efforts to destroy Korval.
The ending is a real doozy, as all the threads come together.
Just lovely, lovely, all around. Happy sigh.
Clan Korval is now on Surebleak and going about its business. Young Syl Vor, Nova yos Galen's son, is at loose ends and wants something, anything!, to do. To which end, he finds himself attending the local school. It seems so simple--he gets to spend more time with his mother and meet other kids.
However, nothing is ever simple where Korval is involved.
The authors introduce us to hitherto unknown residents of the city--the gypsy-like kompani. Marvelous characters, especially young Kezzi, who somehow finds herself going to school with Syl Vor.
Last element in the mix is the mysterious Rys, who is found battered, almost dead, on the kompnai's doorstep and is taken in by them and healed. Rys has a fear of dragons.....
The story is very low-key--lots of day to day goings-on, but never boring. We get glimpses of Nova becoming a more involved mother to her child. We get a bit more of just what it takes to run a city--just what do the bosses do all day? The school sessions are interesting--fascinating what a Surebleak child is expected to know! And we get a slowly building tension, as it becomes apparent that the dear old Department of the Interior has in no way given up in its efforts to destroy Korval.
The ending is a real doozy, as all the threads come together.
Just lovely, lovely, all around. Happy sigh.
November 11, 2012
This was actually not my favorite so far. Don't get me wrong, it was definitely a good book. The rating is in comparison to previous novels in THIS series. Compared to all books I've read, it'd definitely get a 4. I just felt that not enough was going on in this book. The new race of people were fascinating to meet, and learn about; I loved the twist on classic gypsy culture. And it was fun to check in on Surebleak and see how that's progressing. But I feel that the plot would have been more appropriately paced as a short story or novella. There was just not enough happening to keep me interested for a full length novel.
I guess that becomes the dilemma of any series that goes on long enough. Epic fights for freedom and happiness can't occur every day of the week, even with a family as extended and far reaching as this one. I recognize that Lee & Miller wanted to give some time and space, and are probably building up to a more involved storyline for future novels. But still... I want to read it noooooow! (Perhaps I get a bit childish and greedy when it comes to books.)
I guess that becomes the dilemma of any series that goes on long enough. Epic fights for freedom and happiness can't occur every day of the week, even with a family as extended and far reaching as this one. I recognize that Lee & Miller wanted to give some time and space, and are probably building up to a more involved storyline for future novels. But still... I want to read it noooooow! (Perhaps I get a bit childish and greedy when it comes to books.)
November 14, 2013
As a long-time Liaden reader, I have a soft spot for Pat Rin and his Surebleak world (yes, the extended family are now there, but it was his first...), so I was already pre-disposed to enjoy this. Which I did - I liked revisiting Pat Rin and seeing how Surebleak has grown into a community. I think I was probably not as engaged than in previous stories because we saw less of the more-established characters - on the other hand, I loved seeing a totally different facet of Nova, and I like that we are getting to know the younger Korval generation a bit better.
Not directly related to the story, so I'll put it behind a spoiler tag:
Not directly related to the story, so I'll put it behind a spoiler tag:
February 7, 2013
Picks up on Surebleak, but introduces some new characters and situations. Reads like the beginning of a series--mostly set-up with the action just getting started. Syl Vor, Kezzi, and Rys are, however, interesting enough I'd like to read more about them.
September 27, 2020
This moves fairly slowly, but the character development is, as usual for Ms Lee, excellent. She definitely has set up story lines that will support a sequel or two. The end wraps up in just a couple of pages, so you'll be going "What? Wait! There has to be more!"
Read
February 25, 2024DNF
I don't like children protagonists. I'm too old for that, so they bore me.
I don't like children protagonists. I'm too old for that, so they bore me.
June 8, 2015
Lee and Miller have a habit of throwing the reader into new worlds and situations without any warning and leaving them to sink or swim. If, as the reader, you can float or dog paddle for a while, then everything does come together and make sense (even if occasionally you need a life jacket so you have time for a reread; I found that was the case with the Great Migration books). This book is one of those.
We meet the kompani of the Bedel right away and spend a good part of the book figuring out just who they are. This is also a book about Rys, a former DOI operative who may (or may not) survive his former comrades, the wrath of Korval and his own physical and mental injuries. Life is not easy for Rys right now.
The other two characters figuring out their own necessities, are Pat Rin's son, Syl Vor, as he adjusts to like on Surebleak and the pressures of growing up, and Kezzi, daughter of the Bedel who, through Syl Vor, brings the Bedel into contact with the outside world.
I have a feeling that when this was published, it was suggested it was a stand alone, or at least not an integral part of the ongoing storyline. I only read it now, shortly before the next Liaden book, Dragon in Exile, was published. Having done that, I can firmly suggest that you don't miss this one in the temptation of the next "arc" book. There is set up, especially in meeting new characters who are clearly going to be significant in future books.
We meet the kompani of the Bedel right away and spend a good part of the book figuring out just who they are. This is also a book about Rys, a former DOI operative who may (or may not) survive his former comrades, the wrath of Korval and his own physical and mental injuries. Life is not easy for Rys right now.
The other two characters figuring out their own necessities, are Pat Rin's son, Syl Vor, as he adjusts to like on Surebleak and the pressures of growing up, and Kezzi, daughter of the Bedel who, through Syl Vor, brings the Bedel into contact with the outside world.
I have a feeling that when this was published, it was suggested it was a stand alone, or at least not an integral part of the ongoing storyline. I only read it now, shortly before the next Liaden book, Dragon in Exile, was published. Having done that, I can firmly suggest that you don't miss this one in the temptation of the next "arc" book. There is set up, especially in meeting new characters who are clearly going to be significant in future books.
March 3, 2013
In this chapter we follow the adventures of three characters from different worlds, different cultures and the alchemy that occurs when they intersect, first by twos and finally all three together. At first we are introduced to Syl Vor yos'Galan Clan Korval, a young man (tween-age if I had to guess, and you must for we are never given his true age) who is at loose ends on Surebleak. Everyone else has a place, a direction and tasks they're responsible for. Syl Vor has himself, until events collide that offer him distraction by going to school in town. Then we meet Kezzie of the kompanie, and she is the center of the Venn diagram the characters make in this story. Also a young tween, as youngest of her people, she is learning her place within the Bedel; who live apart from The Others, the gadje, the people of Surebleak. Finally we meet Rhys, battered, broken and left for dead, he is rescued by the Bedel. It takes until the final pages of the story for his mysteries to be solved. Between the going to school and the revelation of Rhys lies the soul of the novel; the story of the Bedel, how they came to Surebleak and why they remain apart.
Necessity's Child is another great addition to the Liaden canon.
Necessity's Child is another great addition to the Liaden canon.
May 1, 2015
Clan Korval is on, but not of, Surebleak; there is a need for Korval to integrate, to mesh, with the people already there – not just the Bosses. Nova’s son, finds purpose and a sister in attending the new school system being established. The Bedel, the kompani (think gypsies), must find their way in a rapidly changing world and a DOI Agent must survive. Kezzi, Syl Vor and Rys Lin pen’Chala try to find their way on a world turned upside down.
Again, Lee and Miller, give us interesting situations and characters to care about – good stroytelling.
Of course, this story sets up a third storyline in the currently ongoing Clan Korval saga. The first seems to deal with the clan's business offworld and with the DOI; the second with Theo's coming of age story; the third with Korval on Surebleak.
With this story and Dragon Ship a universe of opportunity beckons: How do you establish an educational system on a backwater planet? Hire a just arrived Professor of Educational History. Will Uncle put Daav and Aelliana back together in separate bodies again? What will Kamele think of this? Will Daav opt for Honor Harrington's solution? If so, can he survive it? What will the Tree think? Is there one Tree or two?
Comment
Again, Lee and Miller, give us interesting situations and characters to care about – good stroytelling.
Of course, this story sets up a third storyline in the currently ongoing Clan Korval saga. The first seems to deal with the clan's business offworld and with the DOI; the second with Theo's coming of age story; the third with Korval on Surebleak.
With this story and Dragon Ship a universe of opportunity beckons: How do you establish an educational system on a backwater planet? Hire a just arrived Professor of Educational History. Will Uncle put Daav and Aelliana back together in separate bodies again? What will Kamele think of this? Will Daav opt for Honor Harrington's solution? If so, can he survive it? What will the Tree think? Is there one Tree or two?
Comment
March 24, 2013
Very slow, big amounts of detail about ultimately unimportant things, far more excessively formal characters than in past books ( as in people obsessively and scrupulously minding their manners) and just dull. The story is mainly about two children, their ages are not given, but 10 years old maybe? which is why it's very strange to then suddenly have the most explicit sex scene these authors have ever done inserted into the middle of it ... and between 2 adult who barely know and dont even like one another.
I was a huge fan of these books for years, but now they are each successively duller and thinner of plot line. I wonder if the authors have just run out of steam, but have to pay the mortgage.
I was a huge fan of these books for years, but now they are each successively duller and thinner of plot line. I wonder if the authors have just run out of steam, but have to pay the mortgage.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 9, 2013
This is a collateral book in the Liaden World series by Sharon Lee & Steve Miller. Two of the major POV characters are children, albeit children who have faced adult problems and concerns. But the third major POV is adult (very adult at times) so can't call this a book for middle grade.
An interesting segue on Surebleak, with all the curious touches of culture examination that Miller & Lee are so well known to use. Another Agent of Change has slipped the leash--can he stay off it? We get to know Boss Nova and her gang a bit better, too!
An interesting segue on Surebleak, with all the curious touches of culture examination that Miller & Lee are so well known to use. Another Agent of Change has slipped the leash--can he stay off it? We get to know Boss Nova and her gang a bit better, too!
December 7, 2022
4 stars.
Dec 2022 - re-listened. Syl Vor is one of my favourite characters.
_______________________
Re-listened in Sept 2021. I really enjoyed the book this time around. The impact on the young members of the Korval Clan was starkly told. Syl Vor is such a serious little man.... so cute.
_______________________
Apart from a jarringly out of place s*x scene, this was quite a cute book.
Dec 2022 - re-listened. Syl Vor is one of my favourite characters.
_______________________
Re-listened in Sept 2021. I really enjoyed the book this time around. The impact on the young members of the Korval Clan was starkly told. Syl Vor is such a serious little man.... so cute.
_______________________
Apart from a jarringly out of place s*x scene, this was quite a cute book.
February 10, 2013
The development of a multicultural society on the planet Surebleak continues to fascinate me. This is a great addition to the books of the Liaden Universe and the story of clan Korval. The new story thread of the Bedel people works and I hope we will hear more about their interactions with the gadje on Surebleak. Great stuff.
February 16, 2013
Highly enjoyable sci-fi story centered around 2 young teenagers who would most likely never have met if there hadn't been such a push to get a school going that would include all the children on the planet. Now I want to get my hands on the rest of the series; unfortunately our library only carries the newer titles. Guess it's time to hit the book stores :)
March 26, 2013
This review fairly much covers it for me. I did find it slow getting into, and would definitely not recommend this as an entry book for the series; established readers and fans will enjoy this plot from a different viewpoint.
September 10, 2019
eArc.
Lee & Miller on top form (when are they ever on anything else?)
Lee & Miller on top form (when are they ever on anything else?)
April 18, 2016
Bought the e-Arc from Webscriptions.
Re-read after the latest E-Arc release Dragon in Exile. :)
Read Feb 16/15
Read Oct 24/12
Re-read after the latest E-Arc release Dragon in Exile. :)
Read Feb 16/15
Read Oct 24/12
Displaying 1 - 30 of 138 reviews