I refused to finish. Rating: minus 5
I do not think that anyone will read this but am revising my reviews anyway. The writing was bad enough that I could not bring myself to finish, as short as the book is. Given my experiences on this site, I almost expect to receive abusive comments demanding an immediate retraction or worse. According to certain commenters I am an evil intellectual. This was based on my personal scribbles, expected to be read by none. Since my nasty commenters have been so mesmerized by my opinion, I admit that now I aim to misbehave.
Before I proceed I need some time on YouTube. This was brought to you by Cinzia Dubois, EarleWrites, Times Radio, SK Media, Flashmob Bella Ciao, Annie's Literary Empire, Owen Jones, Abney Park, Ben and Emily, Call of History, Autumn's Boutique, Viva La Dirt League, Second Thought, The Dadvocate, KernowDamo, Kristine Vike, Ash L G, ILona Millinery, Dungeon Dad, Quinn's Ideas, May, Lily Simpson, Nerd Cookies, Max Barskih - Don't F@ck with Ukraine, Spacedock, ATP Geopolitics, Hailey in Bookland, Some More News, Ben G Thomas, SandRhoman History, Leaf of Life, The Octupus Lady, Planarwalker, Geo Girl, Terrible Writing Advice, Paleo Analysis, Dungeons and Discourse, Venom Geek Media, Physics Girl.
This book has no world building. It seemed that the one government are the system authority. How that authority is structured is unknown and obviously unimportant to the writer. The human space fleet is the U.S. Navy. There are alien warships are invading the solar system for ..... Reasons. They are opposed by the U.S. Space Navy. I will not bother to refer to the human fleet, government or society since this and the many identical books do not pretend that Human and US space are not identical. That sums up the entire background universe.
We are told that the aliens and US have technological parity. "Show, don't tell" is not a dictum known to these low end writers, so in this regard the book is adhering to the standards. Given the technological parity, the force disparity in the initial battle should be decisive. However the aliens arrive with only 200+ large warships vs the US navy with 1 warship and its attached group of 8 space fighter planes each smaller than an F-35 or SU-57.
The battle is an effective draw due the decisive presence in the battle of multi-talented 17 year old Midshipman Gallant. Among his many qualifications despite having achieved only the rank of Midshipman are:
Space fighter pilot with veteran status (no explanation for his veteran status nor mention of any previous US navy space war);
Awarded the highest space fighter rating in the fleet;
Squadron command rated and served as Squadron commander, space fighter;
Rated as and serving as Senior Communications Officer, capital ship;
Rated as and serving as Senior Damage Control Officer;
Rated as and serving as Master Exterior Hull Repair Specialist;
Rated as and serving as Master Alien Technologist with associated backgrounds in physics, materials science, linguistics, etc;
Rated as and serving as Senior Medical and Surgical Trauma Specialist;
Rated as and serving as Senior Tactical Officer, space fighter;
Rated as and serving as Senior Tactical Officer, Capital Ship;
Rated as and serving as Senior Weapons Officer, space fighter
Rated as and serving as Senior Weapons Officer, Capital Ship;
Rated as and serving as Senior Navigation Officer, Capital Ship;
Rated as and serving as Master Zero G combat, ranged weapons against multiple opponents;
Rated as and serving as Master Zero G combat, close quarters against multiple opponents;
Rated as possessing Highest level Command ability;
Rated as possessing Superior strength of personality;
Superior Personal traits also include
- highest fleet Rating, physical attractiveness
- highest fleet Rating, hair to die for
- highest fleet Rating, charisma
- highest fleet Rating, proper ethnicity
- highest fleet Rating, proper genetic lineage.
I expect that the above will serve as a template for my future description of the main characters and background universe (since the two usually comprise the entirety of world building) for most of Amazon's military science fiction.
After listing the many talents and skills of the midshipman, I need a small break most probably with YouTube. This next was made possible by Ash L G, Ponderful, ThePrimeChronus, Shaun, Up and Atom, Cruising Alba, Travelling K, Interior Design Hub, Andrewism, New Economic Thinking, AllShorts, Daisy Bow, Dungeons and Discourse, The Sword and the Pen Reflections, Sophie from Mars, Kristine Vike, How to ADHD, Mandy -web series, Sci-Fi Odyssey, Double Down News, No Justice MTG, It's Black Friday, LuckyBlackCat, Dami Lee, Verilybitchie, Lisa Walton, Shannon Makes, The Closet Historian.
A teen or preteen boy might find the book exciting but most of that audience will still have trouble with the inconsistency and implausibility. As a child's adventure it fails because it will read as a silly recounting of the main character's rise to the recognition which he deserves because ....? It is written as bad YA fiction but it is really not. Originally I seriously imagined the writer as an enthusiastic but untalented thirteen year old boy.
This book's actual audience are 30+ year old gamer males. The setting is generic gamer universe. The combat and combatants have all the depth and logic found in a first person shooter. Halo and other games are designed by coders not writers, whose goals are to deliver an adrenaline filled thrill. They often succeed but novels they are not. Enjoying Star Citizen, Mass Effect or Space Engineer is perfectly fine but there is no reward in a book whose only significant character would be branded by the same audience as the worst "Mary Sue" if "Henry" were "Henrietta".
I might as well move on to the concept of space in these books. Space is immense distances speckled with clumps of matter, some having a mass an appreciable percentage of a stellar object and others the density of a beach pebble. This writer imagined that asteroid belt objects are sixty to seventy meters apart, instead of the average distance of millions of kilometres. The writer misplaced the entire asteroid belt at one point.
I was unable to picture the US space navy with a total of one cruiser and eight space planes. I could not imagine the role or roles a single ship was designed to fill across the distance of an entire solar system. The writer could not be bothered to give thought to the size of a star system. I tried to imagine a country on Earth with a navy/coast guard consisting of one ship. The inner system has thousands of commercial ships travelling to and fro while one spaceship is tasked with search and rescue, system police and defence force across hundreds of millions of miles of spherical Spaaaace.
Writers from Star Trek through current low end, low thought space adventures have no conception of the vastness of space. Writers and fans alike imagine a stellar system as something routinely traversed in several hours and 200 light years in several days or less. They are a far cry from Pournelle, Asimov, Cherryh, Weber and other more thoughtful writers. The difference seems to be that Pournelle and company are writing adult space novels which involve some grounding in current scientific understanding, big ideas about the nature of humanity, the possibilities of alien cultures, the various directions of future engineering and their effects on human society and more.
This book and its thousands of relatives both on screen and in print are fantastical preteen romps in spaceships. This writer and most of the Amazon catalogue pen, routinely display a lack of any understanding of the term dark matter, the engineering involved in terraforming, the reality of orbital mechanics, the basics of spaceflight, the complexity of life support systems, energy generation and waste heat management, micro-collisions and inertia, gravity well effects and other fundamentals of the environment, a description of which are the setting against which they write their adventure tales.
This series and most of the 1000+ recently published science fiction titles, which I have attempted over the last five years treat the safety of children in space as not a serious consideration but more a vacuum vacation trip. The travel is described as something akin to a ferry trip from England to Portugal. Teens in a space adventure are handled differently in the older YA series. Asimov and those other writers describe a darker, more dangerous universe when seen through the eyes of children and teens. Adults in those stories recognize a duty of care, even in the military setting.
I need another break before venting about the Spaceships. This next was brought to you by Jessie Gender, Alizee, Kidology, Fortress of Lugh, Books with Emily Fox, Gutsick Gibbon, Planarwalker, May, Welcome to Ukraine - Buff Bacon, The Kavernacle, Horses, The Green Wrapper, LuckyBlackCat, Bizarre Beasts, Cynthia Zhou, Daisy Viktoria, Raptor Chatter, Emma Thorne, Sarah Millican, Big Joel, NFKRZ, Extinction Rebellion UK, Not the Andrew Marr Show, Leeja Miller, Viva La Dirt League, Meidas Touch, Steve Shives, Northern Narrowboaters, Epicurious.
The following are among the most stupid scenes in this book. Spaceships need not worry about dumping their atmosphere or damaging their environmental system resulting from a lack of an airlock because ........ Star Wars. The midshipman can pop the canopy of his craft to examine an alien wreck, no airlock needed. Space plane fighters do not need a dedicated support ship, so no carrier. A small space fighter can travel multiple AU without refuelling or oxygen replenishment.
A Midshipman routinely argues with a senior captain, because rank is only a guideline. A 17 year old deciphered alien script and deduced alien technology and engineering from a single glance. Logically since the "Academy" graduates 17 year old junior officers, they must begin recruit training at age seven years or so. The fans of this type of fiction, have no issues with any of the above.
There is no explanation given for the failure of other nations to field a space fleet. It seems unfair that the entire solar system does not contribute to system defence. Those are the story elements that will turn away a reader like myself. The writing itself (prose, dialogue, interactions, character description) is juvenile. There are graphic novels with more character development than this book. There are Korean teen series with more mature characters and more rational dialogue. There are Marvel movies with stronger logic. Perhaps he should start again with postcards. Goodreads recently have given this writer some award or other for this series and promoted it on kindle.
US publishers and their editors demand this level of writing. It is almost as if there is a goal to limit imagination, reinforce unquestioned nationalism and further degrade critical thought. If so, I applaud their successful efforts. Current low end works are written to three categories - the No Effort; the Insulting; the Abhorrent. After four years I admit that I watch my fiction for the first time. For good or at least entertaining science fiction stories, the streaming services or YouTube short film channels DUST, Omeleto and others are far preferable to print.
Fortunately I found YouTube about 3 years ago at this point and moving from the toxic environment of Goodreads to the book tube was a real treat.😍 The communities hosted are comprised of readers, who are thoughtful, curious and love all aspects of the world of books. YouTube also introduced me to the educational video sites, as well as the many good informational channels on their site. I recommend a visit to several book channels for any reader and have listed some below. The educational video sites all offer documentaries, lecture series and some brilliant essayists. They are modestly priced and offer more value to me than most of the streaming services.
About Goodreads discourse. About eighteen months ago, I wrote a short negative review of Powers of the Earth, a poorly written salute to the January 6, 2021 hero by Travis Corcoran. He is a self-described Libertarian and vocal advocate for the return of chattel slavery - of course, a US veteran and supporter of Putin's Russia, an employee of an unnamed US agency. The details of that year long saga can be read in my review of "Dark Horse", a good novel by Diener, Powers above or Marine by Dalzelle. After my revision, Claes Rees Jr/cgr710 wrote a final comment declaring that They had "won" (?).
I discovered that They had launched a year long flood of foul sexual and racist comments against channels I mentioned and They no longer felt the need to continue. The fashion historian, the cultural historian, the science educator, the model builder and the many other female creators were not impressed. However increasing the world's store of ugliness, whilst simultaneously delivering a powerfully accurate self-portrait to a multinational audience, of the twisted American man-child must have seemed quite the elegant victory. Yay, Goodreads ?? Yay, USA ??
My YouTube picks of the moment.
Leeja Miller, It's Black Friday, Mandy - web series, Gemma Dyer, Ben and Emily, Shannon Makes. Deerstalker Pictures, Jean's Thoughts, Acollierastro, Kings and Generals, Alice Cappelle, France 24, Cruising Crafts, Omeleto, Times Radio.
As for Amazon/Goodreads, please consider treating this as a potentially hostile site. 😐
Ominous music begins. 🙄 There are a surprising number of nutcase members in the Goodreads membership. That they attempt to terrorize other members is bad but it seems few members respond to them and I have sometimes seen others defend them. It is more disturbing that they invariably claim to speak for all Americans without challenge. The Nazi mindset was not what I expected when I wrote my first review to this site.
Amazon/Goodreads openly supporting these very twisted members is more concerning. For details of harassment see those reviews I mentioned. Sharing my limited message history with those members led to Australia attempting to intrude into my private life. Apparently Australian Intelligence was providing a favour for US friends at Pine Gap Centre. My friend was very worried for my safety. What were they looking for and what harm were they planning. To my mind that describes a danger. This for a reviewer who writes that books suggesting overthrow attempts of the US government are dangerous fiction. That I am become a communist again is deliciously ironic.
I can not quite understand what is considered acceptable behaviour to American readers but surely there are some lines. You may feel yourself to be in a protected class and may be correct. Of course immunity at the whims of truly mental white American males, might not be as comforting as it sounds.
If not part of the protected classes of Goodreads membership, basic precautions seem prudent. I suggest to minimize profile information, remove lurkers (those friends who monitor but never post), be careful of using Goodreads messaging and screenshot the odd and the ugly. Bear in mind that these fascistic snowflakes, members and employees alike, are lacking in morality or restraint and are American. Ominous music ends. 🙂
May we all find Good Reading! 😊
My list is not the result of great study or brilliant insight but these are a sample of my favourite YouTube channel's
TVP News, Brittany Page, Leeja Miller, Meidas Touch, Annie's Literary Empire, Second Thought, Times Radio, The Juice Media, Owen Jones, Mia Mulder, Ship Happens, Philosophy Tube, Tom Nicholas, Tara Mooknee, DW News, Red Plateaus, Eleanor Morton, Munecat, No Justice MTG, Some More News, The Leftist Cooks, Novara Media, Rina Sayama, Swell Entertainment, The Little Platoon, May Moon Narrowboat, Narrowboat Pirate, Verilybitchie, Chloe Stafler, What Vivi did next, Books with Chloe, Sabine Hossenfelder, Historia Civilis, Kings and Generals, The Templin Institute, The Piano Guys, Lady knight the Brave, Hailey in Bookland, Lives and histories, Real Engineering, Narrowboat Girl, Real Time History, Between the Wars, The Angry Astronaut, Vlad Vexler, Morgan Donner, Ash L G, Omeleto, Eileen, Abney Park, HBomberGuy, Chill Goblin, Ben and Emily, Holly the Cafe Boat, Cruising Alba, Tiny Wee Boat, Boat Time, Prime of Midlife, Armor Cast, Task and Purpose, Interesting Engineering, Nerine Skinner Comedy, UATV, Epimetheus, Filaxim Historia, Austin McConnell, Caspian Report, Cruising the Cut, We're in Hell, Travelling K, Book Odyssey, Autumn's Boutique, Cari Can Read, Historian's Craft, Spacedock, Answer in Progress, Library Ladder, WION, The Stitchery, Fantasy and World Music by the Fletchers, DUST, 2 Cellos, Lily's expat life, Hello Future Me, Karolina Zebrowska, Art by Annamarie, A Clockwork Reader, Jabzy, Alice Cappelle, Alize, France 24, Epic History, Engineering with Rosie, Jill Bearup, Odyssey, Beautifully Bookish Bethany, Cecilia Blomdahl, Jessie Gender, SK Media, Depressed Russian, Noah Samsen, Sarah Z, Invicta, Lily Alexandre, Sci Trek, Camper Vibe, Double Down News, Kathy's Flog in France, Loving Anachronism, Cold Fusion, Denys Davydov, The People Profiles, Fall of Civilizations, Physics Girl, Tibees, Mythic Concepts, Adam Something, MWG Studios, Overly Sarcastic Productions, Tom Nicholas, The Present Past, Adult Wednesday Addams - 2 seasons, Then & Now, Philosophy Tube, Kelly loves Physics and History, Lily Simpson, Steve Shives,Certifiably Ingame, Perun, Pentatonix, Make Better Media, Northern Narrowboaters, Dr Becky, Event Horizon, Lady of the Library, Three Arrows, Noelle Gallagher, A Life of Lit, Adult Wednesday Addams, Double Down News, All Shorts, Diane Callahan Quotidian Writer, Asianometry, Truth to Power, Double Down News, Michael Lambert, Sailing Melody.
I wish you a sunny morning, a beautiful afternoon, a wonderful evening, a pleasant night and may we all continue learning.
Ad Astra, per Aspera
Pike's Number One