Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Sartorialist #2

The Sartorialist: Closer

Rate this book
After the enormous success of  The Sartorialist , street style photogrpaher Scott Schuman is back with a completely new collection of beautiful images of the men and women who have caught his attention.

His much-loved blog, thesartorialist.com, remains one of the most-read in the fashion world and continues to grow in popularity as Scott travels further and more widely. This book emcompasses the diverse style and visual attitude of people as far afield as Japan, Korea, London, Milan, New York, Paris, and beyond.

In  The Closer , Scott Schuman looks deeper and with great breadth at human style, and the way it is expressed across the world. Always reacting to an inspirational moment, the images in his new book continue to reflect Scott's unique sensibility and vision.

Available with two different one featuring a woman, the other a man.

512 pages, Paperback

First published August 28, 2012

5 people are currently reading
461 people want to read

About the author

Scott Schuman

14 books27 followers
Scott Schuman is the creator of the popular fashion blog "The Sartorialist". After leaving his position as director of men's fashion at his showroom to take care of his daughter in September 2005, he began carrying a digital camera around and photographing people he saw on the street whose style he found striking. He then posted these to his blog, sometimes with short comments, always either favorable or open-minded. He is well known for photographing what have been described as 'real people.'

"The Sartorialist" quickly became a regular read for fashionistas, both on the street and in the upper echelons of the industry.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
197 (43%)
4 stars
155 (33%)
3 stars
90 (19%)
2 stars
13 (2%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
Profile Image for lucy black.
818 reviews44 followers
November 5, 2012
so this is pretty much like the first book. Maybe a bit better. There are a few more freaks, a bit more diversity. Still no fatties! what? and to my agravation Scott Schuman goes on about how to be fashionable one should find inspiration in someome with style who has a similar body shape to your own, well, no one in this book has a similar body shape to me. That makes me sad.

This is what I thought of the first one

K, so Scott Schuman is a blogger/ photographer who goes out on the streets (in big cool cities) and takes photos of 'the real people' to show as he put it: 'a two-way dialogue about the world of fashion and its relationship to daily life'

So, I like fashion and I wish I had enough money to dress myself the way I would like to and I love portrait photography so I was thinking I'd real like this book. Well, yeah, not so much.

Main gripe is that although Schuman says in the book that he tries to find a diverse range of people and fashions but he doesn't and he totally photographs a type. There were, like, two woman of fuller figure, a few more men, no one with visible physical disabilities and the majority of his subjects were classically good looking. They were mostly rich looking carefree types smoking and riding vintage bikes. Where are the tired commuters? Parents with their babies? Fashionable peeps actually doing their daily life? You don't have to be 'beautiful' to look good in clothes.

Another thing I found creepy was the way the majority of women posed themselves (or does he ask them to pose?) since when did everyday ladies stand around like vulnerable bambies with sad/scared eyes and turned in toes? It’s super creepy and sad. On the topic of creepy: the rich people trying to look slummy and hobo chic is fricking creepy too. It's so horribly bogus that rich fucks spend 100s if not 1000s of bucks on patchy falling apart retro type threads to look homeless when the actually homeless have 0 bucks and die because they cannot clothe themselves and stay warm.

I don't hate on Schuman, I think he is talented and he obviously leads an interesting life. I just think if he is going to claim to be some sort of social documenter he should pull his camera away from the shiny pretty things for a moment and document some of the marginalized too.
Profile Image for 7jane.
827 reviews367 followers
April 21, 2017
This follows the theme of the first book, so many observations I made of that is in my review of that apply here also. Still, I found once again new ideas and often got at least inspired (and made me consider dresses/skirst more seriously - I don't own any now). I really wonder why all the brown shoes caught my eye - those I can't wear though. Some pics are black and white.

Small writings here and there: on the '100 Burberry trech coats' project, how wearing out clothes by yourself beats buying the clothes ready-worn, examples pictures of certain people he founds inspiring (men and women), of people who look effortlessly dressed - really just have a knowledge of what works for them personally, seeing cowboy boots in a more positive like, on bullfighters' clothes, photographing in Venice and of family in Morocco, on horizontal stripes, subtle use of glitter on a certain older woman etc.

It's a thick book that can read quickly anyway (or not, if some photos cause you to pause, reflect and seek inspiriation). A lot of suit ideas, again, for men. Maybe this would make me seek out to pay more attention to what I wear? 8-)
Profile Image for Caro the Helmet Lady.
833 reviews464 followers
August 13, 2019
From the book:
"There is no such thing as effortless chic. If you are secretly harboring the dream that some day you will be able to consistently, thoughtlessly reach into your closet and pull out a super-chic ensemble, well, you are fighting a no-win battle with yourself.
The most stylish people I know have spent lifetimes searching for what complements their body shape, their professional and personal lifestyle, local climate and how much they can reasonably budget for this pursuit.
Let me stress that this is not about how much money they have, but how attuned they are to their reality. It's an almost zen-like sense of self-awareness.
They don't obsess daily about what they wear but they all tend to be cautious shoppers. They make the tough decisions in the dressing room, not in their closet. It stands to reason that if you only fill your closet with what works then just grabbing things from that closet will be a million times easier... hence the perception of 'effotlessness'

One can almost say the same about the books.
Profile Image for Rhode PVD.
2,469 reviews35 followers
July 12, 2020
I love individual fashion and street photography, so was excited to see this thick book of photos. As I began riffling through the pages though, my stomach dropped.

Why? The uniformity of the stick-like body types.

I saw no visibly pregnant people. I saw no fat people of any age. I saw no big boned people or people with a little extra padding. I saw no lusciously rounded people. Nor any visibly handicapped people.

Also, the near-uniformity of youth.

Roughly 80% if not more of the these stick thin people were under 35. Of the older people, most were men. The few older women were also stick thin and often with someone else (not a sole subject).

Consciously or not, the author is making an ugly statement about what sorts of people can look good. What sorts of people are worthy of being beautifully dressed. What sorts of people are worth looking at.

He has culled the pregnant, the older, the full bodied women. He has culled the body types that represent the overwhelming majority of women. He has culled the healthy, life affirming, joyful, glorious, wise and supremely elegant.

I have no time for this bigotry.
Profile Image for Ian.
110 reviews10 followers
October 4, 2012
Much in the same vein as his first book. If you're looking for a 'trend guide' or a collection of what's 'hot' in fashion, you'll probably be disappointed. But if you're open to learning about how Schuman's understanding of style and personal expression is growing and evolving as he continues to shoot street style images from around the world via the ones he has chosen to curate within this book and the sparse but incisive commentary he intersperses throughout to accompany them, you will probably enjoy this.
Profile Image for Phobean.
1,146 reviews44 followers
April 24, 2013
After enjoying these many expressions of fashion and personality, I feel a lot free-er to wear whatever I'd like, which is pretty much what I do anyway. Now with more license. :^)
Profile Image for Sara J. (kefuwa).
531 reviews49 followers
April 14, 2020
Cult. My Dad always used to say he didn't care at all about fashion. But he (and everyone I know) care deeply about style and what it says about who you are and the group you want to fit in with. Everyone from the Cowboy to Joe sixpack, the retiree to grumpy teen, dress in a way that clearly communicates to others their chosen group that they want to belong. My Dad would say, "I'm retired, I can wear whatever I want' but I never saw him wear a suit to play golf or an AC/DC concert T-shirt to the links. 'Style' as a concept has been hijacked to mean elite, refined and expensive when it should be thought of as a basic expression of life in much the same way as we all identify with music or speech. At the end of the day style is communication.”

I have been a long time follower of thesartorialist.com and I even have an on again/off again pinterest board for myself to pin my faves (dresses/skirts, no heels, no cigs, bicycle, wine) - and I was delighted (in an almost fangirl sense) to some of my favourite selections in this book. I don't know why, I just love to see the photos Schuman takes of people on the street. In the end I think this quote above sums up why. Its the people, those (sometimes) stylish characters walking down the street. There are a few paragraphs of insight from Schuman scattered throughout the book - which were wonderful (my favourite being that quote up there).

I am not a very "stylish" person and my dressing has been, what's the word, functional (?) & practical at best. But over time I have had my understanding of fashion evolve into a fundamental avenue of self expression and respect (for yourself and towards the people around you). Also - it does feel good to wear something you like and that makes you want to walk out and swish down the street. Haha.

I am interested in getting copies of his other two collections now as well. And yes this was an instabuy for me when I saw it at the Big Bad Wolf sale last year. An odd thing for me to instabuy all things considered (Threadless t-shirt wearing sff booknerd that I am) - but what have you.

First finished: 14th April 2020
Source: Big Bad Wolf KK 2019
Profile Image for Isobel Andrews.
192 reviews9 followers
August 14, 2020
This is a beautifully produced book full of beautiful photos of beautiful people and outfits. Every spread is so considered and cohesive, and as you flow on through the images your attention is naturally drawn to how the clothes are worn, how style interacts with context, how physicality influences fashion and vice-versa. Schuman's genuine fascination with the people he's photographing really comes across.

I have a huge gripe though: this book proudly calls itself diverse, and for the most part it is - the people are young and old, of many colours, cultures, and countries. But there is not one photo of a fat person in the whole collection, or of someone who is visibly physically disabled. Given that the book presents so many other interesting physicalities and asks you to think about how they play with style, it's a glaring omission and a slap in the face. At one point Schuman talks about how it can take time and maturity to see something in a different way. I hope that since this book was published he's developed the maturity to observe style in an even greater variety of bodies.
Profile Image for Alex Rankine.
476 reviews4 followers
May 18, 2020
some really great images here!! some of them were clearly dated from the early 2010s but were still fun, I especially liked the few from australia.

the writing was unfortunately quite weak, and sometimes detracted from the photos.

also a significant lack of body diversity, despite proclaiming to capture the everyday and normal
Profile Image for Nox.
28 reviews43 followers
April 1, 2016
I've been obsessed with the blog since it started, so I've seen most of these images before. They're even more captivating in print.
Profile Image for Dana_can_read.
84 reviews2 followers
October 24, 2022
This is a cool book with beautifully made pictures of stylish people in major cities in the world. It’s supposed to teach you about style through philosophical point of view, not technical one. And it has a tiny bit of interesting insights on personal style, spread throughout the book.
But the more I looked, the less diversity I found in all these pictures. I haven’t seen a single woman with curves, so not one of the styles shown will look good on me. Also, the photographer has a definite type he likes, and takes the pictures only of those who fit in it, with occasional splash of “exotic” and “ethnic” people to spice up the book. So, style-wise I found this book to be useless and pretentious, all the fits are also outdated (obviously, as it’s been 10 years).
But I still liked the book because the guy is a talented photographer, and I like looking at different people around the world, making myself familiar with unusual faces. It gives me a nice feeling that we’re all living together on this planet and share more in common than I could imagine.
Profile Image for Courtney.
1,610 reviews42 followers
January 4, 2026
It shouldn’t matter that I read X first, but it influenced me.
I felt like many of the photos were poorly posed with awkward feet or expressions that communicated tension, annoyance, nervousness, boredom. Lots of images of others, mostly women, with cameras. This volume had fewer outfits/design elements that wowed or impressed me.

I was confused when on page 442 ‘Design Diet’ Schuman talks about ‘never owning anything close to a striped t-shirt’ but on page 30 he talks of ‘how many times have I bought a horizontal navy-striped cashmere knit hoping to look just a little like Carry Grant…’
On both pages he makes decent points, questions fashion rules and find fashion inspirations that suit one’s body type, but the disparity in the claims about owning stripes is distracting and sloppy.
Profile Image for Joseph Lee.
186 reviews2 followers
December 18, 2022
Originated from a blog, the book is a photographic collection of people expressing themselves in fashion, particularly streetwear. There are a few written blurbs about certain photos that has inspired Schuman, but other than that, it’s all pictures. What I have gained from it though is that fashion is an ubiquitous art form that explores identity and visual story-telling whether we realize it or not; I was amused to see the power clothes has on people.
Profile Image for Karah.
Author 1 book28 followers
December 27, 2025
So delighted to have read two of his books without visiting the blog!!!! I would hope readers would come away with a heightened awareness of the potency of sartorial presentation. One glance= an iconic moment.
Profile Image for Patricia.
63 reviews
July 11, 2017
Great photographs, I like how some of them are grouped by colours and patterns/styles which was clever. Also enjoyed Scott's insightful commentary, wished there was more of it in the book.
Profile Image for Esther.
180 reviews2 followers
Read
January 16, 2020
Is it still a thing in this days of age to be a street style photographer?

Standout bullet points:
•androgyny
•proportion
•a certain grace, posture/movement
Profile Image for Kamryn.
543 reviews
December 18, 2021
It’s exactly what it says on the tin: photos of fashion on the street. Far from literary, but fun to flip through and look at all the different styles the subjects have.
Profile Image for Alaina.
423 reviews18 followers
December 31, 2025
I read this book directly after finishing the Humans of New York published around the same time. I know they have very different objectives, but it was hard not to compare them, and this book doesn't hold up as well.

Don't get me wrong, there are some wonderful images in this book. I am obsessed with the rich blue-green and rhubarb color combination on the woman somewhere near the center (page numbers would have been nice). But as others have noted everyone in this book has the same body type. All thin, often aristocratic. I see no inspiration for myself and my small round figure here (except for that marvelous blue and purple color combination...).

I'm keeping this volume on my shelf because it reminds me of early 2010s NYC, which was an exciting time in my life.
Profile Image for Neville.
69 reviews2 followers
September 6, 2012
'The Sartorialist' is the title of a street style photography website created by New York based photographer Scott Schuman. Since it's inception, the site has generated upwards of 14 million page views per month, and Mr Schuman, with style blogger Garance Doré, was recently awarded the 2012 Council of Fashion Designers of America (CFDA) Media Award.

'The Sartorialist' website was created to share photos of people on the street that Mr Schuman thought looked great. Over time, his content and narrative has evolved with a fascinating collection of people he's photographed around the world, especially in New York, Paris and Milan.

In August 2009, Mr Schuman published his first photography book, 'The Sartorialist', which featured many samples of his photographs, some of which had already been posted on his website, and many that had never been seen before.

The success of that publication has led to a second edition entitled 'The Sartorialist: Closer', which, like the first book, includes many photographs of people he's met and encountered going about their lives at work, on the streets and in café's.

Mr Schuman explains the reason he calls this book 'Closer' is that he has become driven to understand the individuals he's photographed better, to "bring me closer to the true essence of the person while still capturing them as stylish subjects."

Since creating the website, the author is also getting closer to exploring the character diversity that he had dreamed of. In this edition, there are more photographs of people from different walks of life, like shepherds, cowboys, nomads, house painters and bartenders, as well as New Yorkers and Parisians.

Like his first book, there are some images that will be familiar to followers of the website, but there are many more fascinating and remarkable photographs never published before.

There is very little narrative throughout the book. Except for a few explanatory passages, you are left to your own imagination to figure out where the photograph was taken and judge for yourself the true character of the people that grace the pages with their fashionable, and not-so fashionable clothes.

Mr Schuman has traveled the globe, capturing remarkable images of people as they were. The common denominator is that however they are dressed, or clothed, they all look so proud of their identities, of who they are, which brings us all closer together.

The book inspires us to find ourselves and forge our own identity. Being happy in our own suits is all that matters.
Profile Image for Shila Iris.
257 reviews35 followers
January 5, 2013
For starters, flipping through the book, I really love what I see and believe that he chose a great COVER photo- actually the best possible. I really like the girls face. The 45 things I liked about the book:

1. Boots- pg. 7
2. Entire outfit including the smile- pg. 8
3. Mixed up colors and purse- pg. 10
4. Ok, gold tooth- pg. 12
5. Scarf and face- pg. 42
6. Blue jean- pg. 45
7. Outfit- pg. 60
8. Hat and face- pg. 61-62
9. Coat- pg. 68
10. Photos- pg. 71, 72, 73, 74, 77
11. Shoes - pg. 78
12. Outfit- pg. 86, 89
13. Gloves- pg. 96-97
14. Photos- pg. 98, 99, 101, 102
15. Coat- pg. 104
16. Smile- pg. 105
17. Shoes- pg. 114-115 ( I love brown shoes)
18. Necklace- pg. 116
19. Dress- pg. 119 (lovely)
20. Photo- pg. 129, 140, 147, 148, 150, 151, 152
21. Leather pants- pg. 143
22. Smile- pg. 155
23. Photo- 156
24. Blue colors- 166, 167
25. Sandles- pg. 175
26. Children smiling- pg. 180-181
27. Face in black and white- pg. 202-203
28. Shoes- pg. 225
29. Photo- pg. 236, 240
30. Pose- pg. 257
31. Outfits- pg. 264, 265
32. Boots- pg. 268
33. Outfits- pg. 271, 272, 274, 281, 284, 285
34. Photo, guy dancing- pg. 287
35. Outfit- pg. 297, 298
36. Sweaters- pg. 330, 360
37. Photos- pg. 342, 347, 361, 370, 376 & 398 (beautiful)
38. Purse- pg. 400
39. Girl- pg. 422
40. Love the guy pointing- pg. 428
41. Love the guys outfit, especially the socks and shoes!- pg. 434
42. Dresses- pg. 448, 449, 456
43. Photo- pg. 461
44. Shoes- pg. 464
45. Photos- pg. 465, 468, 485, 488, 489, 490, 491

Schuman captures the simplicity of fashion in an age where people mistakenly believe that fashion is defined by the latest trends in the stores- skinny jeans, colorful socks, leggings; hairstyles- blond/brown striped mohawks (have gone too far I tell you!)and shaved heads... these things pretty much have taken over the identity of much of our society. This books reminds me that there is real fashion out there and it doesn't go beyond your own home. YOU ARE FASHION.
Profile Image for H.
1,283 reviews
May 20, 2015
Amazing quality photographs; I feel very lucky to have gotten a hold of the limited hardcover & slip case edition. It is worth the buy alone for the massive variety of people within its pages, but my god - the style!! Sublime. And completely inspiring to me both visually and in regards to my own personal style. I prefer it slightly over its predecessor The Sartorialist purely because Scott Schuman made a conscious effort to cast a wider net for his subjects outside the typical socialites/fashion icons/industry workers he has targeted in the past.

In other words, BRILLIANT FASHION PHOTOGRAPHY. Beg, borrow, or steal it ASAP!
Profile Image for Max Rocca.
188 reviews5 followers
September 29, 2012
Assolutamente imperdibili le immagini meravigliose di Scott Schuman...scatti fotografici immortalati per strada...eleganza e stile personale dei protagonisti ma soprattutto le doti di Scott, la capacità di giocare con le luci, le ombre i riflessi e gli sfondi..da sfogliare con attenzione per tutti i fashion-victims
Profile Image for Tam Starita.
14 reviews3 followers
January 13, 2013
This is my first book from the collection and I really enjoyed it. It is so inspirational! There is a difference when we see fashion trends in magazines and in the media versus seeing how 'real' people are interpreting and executing these styles to reflect their own sensibilities and lifestyle. It is a great resource for visual inspiration and to have a pulse on styles from all over the world.
Profile Image for Dominika Klekner.
38 reviews2 followers
January 6, 2013
woooooow. I love the project, I love the guy, I love the collection. And my flatmate the photographer bought the exact same lenses used by Scott Schuman the next day after I showed her the book. What can you say :)
Profile Image for MyOnly.
114 reviews
April 1, 2013
Wonderful pictures, it was hard to put down! Nicely done, with some written bits by the photographer. I loved what he had to say about personal style, and how it's not about owning what's trendy but about owning things you love and wearing them.
Profile Image for Nancy.
1,377 reviews23 followers
April 22, 2013
Again, the same pleasure as an ice cream sandwich. In fact, I stared at these people while eating ice cream sandwiches. I'm not sure anything was "closer" but that didn't matter. There could be a Closest and I'd happily stare at it.
Profile Image for Janet.
2,298 reviews27 followers
June 15, 2013
I loved looking at this book, portraits of people a la Bill Cunningham, or the Humans of New York blog. I didn't even know what the word sartorialist meant until today: Of or relating to a tailor, tailoring, or tailored clothing: sartorial elegance. This guy has an eye.
Profile Image for Dawn.
1,154 reviews53 followers
July 22, 2013
While I usually enjoy this sort of book, I frankly found this one to be a bit boring. Perhaps his tastes are too conservative for me, but I found this collection of street fashion photos totally uninspiring.
263 reviews3 followers
October 9, 2013
Overall the print quality and photo composition seems higher than the previous volume and that makes a good thing even better. My chief complaint with the original book, however, remains with this one - the physical sizing is too small to do the visuals justice.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.