Much of this book is appealing. I'd probably give it to a friend to read. The arguments for viewing life as a story are helpful. The author constantly references popular Christian (dare I say edgy?) authors (especially Donald Miller and yes, I saw Rob Bell in there). He uses the good ole' 'action stories' of our day (Star Wars and Lord of the Rings) as examples for 'living life at its fullest'. And he uses the Message for Bible quotation. In short, Tell Me A Story is a compilation of what Christians fancy make a good, thought-provoking book. Even the recommendations from authors like Jon Acuff, Amena Brown, and Brad Lomenick scream 'cool, edgy, on the ball' if you have your ears tuned the right direction. Yet, somehow, it fails to come near that.
In fact, I'd say despite my appreciation for it, the book is entirely mediocre. The very 'topic' is hardly original, as McClellan admits. It's the 'popular' conversation topic of the day (viewing your life as a story), made popular by Donald Miller. He is not alone, though. As great as the topic of this little book is, it offers nothing to the ongoing conversation.
There is very little original from McClellan. He's constantly quoting, referencing, summarizing...but stating nothing originally useful. Sure, its thin enough to make an easy read. But to what end? Maybe as an introduction?
I was willing to appreciate the book, even lend it out, until I got to the chapter on Conflict. The story of the ants and the worms? What the heck?! For someone trying to use biography to convey truths about the usefulness of story, the only major pain McClellan turns to as an example is journey towards adoption. Truly, a tumultuous experience for him and his wife, I believe it. However, it had a happy ending. Not all stories can be neatly wrapped in a bow because you are 'in the middle of it' and will rejoice later. His chapter on conflict, on pain, does not seem to honestly grasp the depth of pain humanity experiences. Conflict may make the story better, but that is hardly a mindset someone deeply grieving wants to carry. That's where he lost me. From chapter 5 on out, I couldn't really appreciate what he had to say. Eating a giant cheeseburger was the worst mistake?
This book has all the trimmings of a pop-Christian win. It doesn't live up to it. Its content is unoriginal, its author either has led a very calm life or doesn't want to give a peek into how grief plays a part in life. Story can be very useful, but it isn't the only or even ultimate lens to view life with.
Yet it isn't a bad book. I'm grateful for the free copy through the Goodreads first-reads. I just feel like it could have been a better read. Or perhaps maybe wasn't much needed as a read at all.