I had to get out the laptop to write a thorough review. This book rubbed me the wrong way. It seemed like the author was greatly judging other parents. He has zero credentials for counseling, except that he is a pastor. He is not a licensed professional counselor or psychologist. I would read this book as completely anecdotal. His thoughts are not based on any research that he has completed. View this book as you friend giving you some unwanted and inexperienced advice. In other words, take it with a grain of salt. He has not even raised children through the difficult teenage years. You know how before you have kids you say, I WOULD NEVER X, Y, Z. He is completely doing that throughout the entire book.
He needs to edit the title, while he starts explaining his trophy child theory, then the book is all over the place. He could have written this novel in a few blog posts, and that might have been where this book came from.
Pros: I did like the chapter with the children's hands-on devotional. I might actually use that. I also like the last chapter with the practical things to strengthen your marriage. Except, it doesn't entirely fit with the novel. And then the book abruptly ends with the marriage advice chapter. I also like his point of view on explaining female and male genitalia. I think it's great to discuss sex and body parts early on with kids and remove the shame.
Chapter 2: Trophy Parents is a chapter based on hearsay. His case studies were based on his friend's clients that were sent to a clinic. He has zero interaction with these particular families, but this does not prevent him from laying down the judgement.
I felt like the entire book was commercial for his church and for the sleep away camp (again he's taking illustrations and examples from cases he doesn't really have direct influence with).
He is speaking from a place of privilege and that the rules don't apply to him. His wife basically rolls her eyes when parents try to get special class placement for Sunday school. And then at the ropes course, he asks for special treatment for his child.
I do not think his parenting advice is even that sound. He says that he doesn't mind laying down the law when his kids are not listening to his wife. Well, this can undermine his wife's authority, if he has to be the heavy hitter.