I shy away from doing reviews with plot outlines in them, mostly because I think they are unnecessary but also because I'm loathe to accidentally put in any spoilers. I feel the depth of this book warrants a more developed review than I might otherwise make.
This book is long, I'll just get that out of the way now. It's over 600 pages. I don't think it necessarily needs to be that long, with another round of editing, but I also don't think that it subtracts from the story in any way or makes it bogged down. The first two Harry Potter books could've been shaved down a hundred pages or so, so I don't slight this work and merely wanted to point it out. It's long.
The book is in three different parts and each part has its own feeling to it. That makes this book hard to review in its entirety, but I learned the author separated it into three separate books, which I agree with Anya's review, was a good idea. The parts are so different from each other that I could've read them as sequels and maybe felt more connected to each.
This is outside my normal realm of reading. I came across the book quite by chance or accident through a friend on FB. I then "followed" the author and he was giving away 5 books a month, and I won a copy. I didn't think too much of it when I received it as it's not on surface my cup of tea. I thought the cover was gorgeous but just outside of my genre. I started seeing the author's statuses pop up in my FB feed and more often than not they were hilarious and witty. So he got my attention a lot, which is hard to do, especially if I don't know someone. He mentioned an incident on here in which he and friends were called a "bully" author because they were appalled that people would leave low ratings or negative reviews for books by people who hadn't read them. Having been a member of this site many months ago and having left because (besides the Amazon acquisition), readers were acting like their words held more value than the authors themselves, I felt a bit kindred to the author and JA Huss, another author whose books I'll now be reading because of that exchange I witnessed.
I say all this because on the surface Veil is not my kind of book at all. It's not in my genre and it's not my cuppa tea. At least, that's what I thought.
The first part is the longest and a bit to trudge through, especially when he gets to explaining the technology of Veil. I suppose this was a necessary evil. Once I made it beyond chapter 4 or 5, I did notice the reading became much faster, and the action more obvious. Hidden inside this first part is one of the most emotional scenes I've read in any book and it left me feeling very raw and cut open.
My usual taste is for M/M. Curiously enough, while there is a M/M relationship in this book, the most emotional scene comes from one of the gay characters and his straight best friend. It also involves the gay character engaging in a M/F scene just for the benefit of his friend (I don't want to give any spoilers). In fact, there is very little mention of any M/M sex in this book, the only graphic scene is the M/F one. That usually wouldn't have been my cuppa tea at ALL because of my love for M/M but this book approaches sexuality in a way that makes it less of a spectacle and more of a human quality imbued with its own qualities that can't be pinned down or summed up. Refreshingly, the author deconstructs sexuality in a few different ways in this book and to be quite honest had he left that out, I don't think I would've been as interested in this book. It was one of its high points for me.
Going into part two, after their "goal" is completed in the first part, the second part begins in a much darker place. The characters have change and it's immediately noticeable. Many years have passed though so we find the characters with a new goal and in new relationships. Though I would say the entire book has its own form of ingenuity, I think it really starts to shine through in the second part and grows from there. The focus on the goal in the second part is to me masterful. The author could've gone so many predictable places using the kind of technology presented in the book but he remains focused on the main characters and paints a believable portrait of how their lives would progress in the situation.
This is where I want to speak of the characters. This truly seems to be Overfield's strongest ability. He KNOWS characters. He seems to know people very well, he makes convincing dynamics and his dialog is realistically spot-on. Overfield writes extremely well, if not a little wordy at times, but his true strength comes through in his characterizations. He masters nuances and real world relationships in which people love/hate each other and treat each other with irreverence. It was quite refreshing to see. One complaint is that it can border on parody at times, and one of the characters really started to remind me of Lafayette from True Blood, so I began to read his voice in the same manner, that made it hard to take him seriously when I needed to be able to. However the characters are some of the best I have read in a book in quite some time. And the way they are presented, with a slight shift in tone rather than a shift in POV, was masterful.
By the time the goal is reached in the 2nd part, my mind is blown. All hyperbole aside, I kept finding myself asking myself "How did he come up with this?" There is some heavy research into neuroscience and psychology at play here and I applaud the author for that. There is also some pure genius in where he takes the story because once things reach their conclusion I found myself thinking OF COURSE that is what would happen, it tended to make near-perfect sense. None of it felt contrived or seemed to be gimmicky. Events were natural progressions of other events, despite being in a totally speculative world where essentially anything could go. At the end of the 2nd part, I couldn't imagine what happened in the 3rd since, as another review pointed out, the book could have very well ended in the 2nd part.
Part 3 could very well be my favorite. It is here where I think Overfield grounded himself in his craft and having built this world had begun to really go how and where he wanted. It is the tone and style of the third part that makes me anxious to read the next book (get to that later). Part 3 and the group's new "goal" and how they go about achieving it is an example of Overfield's expansive imagination and I read with increasing stimulation, feeling like more and more was being revealed, it felt magical. The layers and layers of the story found its core in part 3 and it made so much sense linearly that after only reading one book of his (and many of his FB posts) I already consider Overfield to be a master of his craft. The author can weave a story, take the reader's mind on a journey, and inject a way of thinking into their mind. Layer after layer I began to understand that he was wanting the reader to THINK.
Possibly my only major gripe comes in the form of an Author Filibuster in part 3. There is one chapter in part 3 in which one of the main characters is being interviewed on TV. It is a perfect example of an Author Filibuster and while I felt it went along with the tone and pace of the story, I know it is a literary weakness in most instances and did pull me out of the story a little. It was by no means a John Galt moment but it was obvious for what it was. That being said, the information being covered and the ideas being presented are so intriguing to me that I did not mind the tactic, but I did notice it.
I can't say this book has an emotionally satisfying ending, but I don't think it was meant to. The book sets up a dystopia (which is an interesting way to lead into that), and by the end of the 3rd epilogue (did I mention there are 3 epilogues?), your heart has sank and your curiosity is piqued. It is because of how things are left at the end of the 3rd part that I'm very interested to see where the author goes with the 2nd book in the series. He has a lot of play room but he also has a lot of rope to hang himself with. I'm invested in the story enough to follow along and see where he takes the story, especially since the main characters will be years (decades? centuries?) in the past.
All in all, this is one of the best books I have read in quite some time. It's impossible to convey what this book did to me intellectually or emotionally, but I did find myself connect to (Some of) the characters very strongly and I felt the entire story developed here was something original, refreshing, and spun my mind in more ways than I'm used to. It's shown me I need to be reading outside of my preferred genre or because there are two sexy men on the book's cover. That's not to say I will stop reading M/M all the time but I will broaden my horizons once again. I could see this book being made into a movie, depending on how the next two go, and it will be exciting to know I had been there in the beginning. The only other time that's happened was with Harry Potter, and I felt the movies, while not adding anything to the actual story, breathed life into characters I grew to love. I can only hope to see some life breathed into Suren, Ken, Brock, and even that sassy Hunter.
I HIGHLY recommend this book to adult readers who can handle vulgarity and are interested in sci-fi enough to wade through some difficult material to understand a technology that has some serious implications.
This is a WONDERFUL read.