3.5
Let me start by saying this is overall an enjoyable read. The heroine Beatrice is quite lovely and feisty, exactly the kind of female protagonist I love. The dialogues are funny, especially the witty banter between Bea and her husband Kesgrave, it always earns a small chuckle from me. The curtain scene when they set a trap to catch the killer is like watching a British comedy and I love it.
The plot is actually pretty decent for a cozy mystery. (I usually have low standards for this genre, as long as they are not too stupid and blatantly obvious it’s fine by me.) Not so much of a well-crafted scheme from the murderer so it’s no Agatha Christie sort of whodunnit, but we have a resourceful, tactical detective that more or less makes up for that, and most importantly, she knows what she’s doing.
There isn’t much romance for the protagonists (a plus for me in mysteries). I’ve never read the previous books in this series, so I have zero knowledge of the characters. It is a bit of a red flag for me at first to see the duke Kesgrave holding his former mistress in his arms in his own house (dude wth). But as the story progresses, Bea and Kesgrave make a lovely couple. They understand each other, he doesn’t try to stop Bea from doing her detective work, and there is no miscommunication troupe because they talk about their problems like a mature couple should! It also occasionally makes satirical social commentaries on women’s status and plight in the Regency era mainly through Bea’s inner observation and Penny’s complaints, which is also quite interesting to see this subject through two women’s eyes who have very different social statuses.
But there are quite a few things I do not enjoy. One, the first half of the book is delightful, with all the interesting characters and amusing conversations, but it becomes a bit dragged out in my opinion in the second half. It might be because it introduced some characters and stories from previous books that I never read, so it gets a wee bit confusing and boring to me. But also some of the suspects honestly are just the same type and I don’t see the necessity of creating multiple just to make it look like a lot of people are trying to kill the victim. I skimmed out most of it because I lost my patience. Two, I have no problem whatsoever against courtesans, but I really, really do not like Penelope Taylor as a character for one bit. She was fun at first but then it got a bit too self-righteous for my taste.
The third one is mostly a me-problem. Even though most reviews said it’s fine to just read this as a standalone, it sometimes still confuses me when it mentions something from the previous works like I said, and it mentions quite a lot. It does not help my reading experience. And it also does not make me scream “omg I wanna read more of this asap”, so.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing this eARC.