*This is a review of the whole series, not just Book 1. However, it is completely spoiler-free.*
Every time I decide to revisit a book from childhood, there are two intermingled emotions brewing inside of me. One is the expected happiness, a comforting grip of nostalgia that invariably follows all enjoyable memories of the past. It serves as a memento, a remnant of the times long gone. A little time machine showing us that time is not an entirely one-way street. This re-reading act is reassuring and soothing and the main reason why I do it.
The other emotion is not as encouraging. One could even say it is unpleasant. It is the fear that the book won’t stand the test of time.
The mind of a ten-year-old is not the same as that of a thirty-year-old. Things that we find enchanting and grand dwindle in size when seen by the eyes of a grown-up. An apple tree in the garden that once served as a child’s whole playground is now a minuscule, worn-out plant. The same things happen with books. An adult notices plot holes that a child would miss. He notices faulty logic. Lack of character development. Because of that and with no ill intention, he is quick to cast judgment and discard the once-beloved book to the forgotten and dusty shelves, a place where memories disappear.
You can just imagine my delight when I understood that my fears proved unfounded. Although he is not among the most distinguished fantasy authors, Chris Wooding crafted book series that I found as captivating now as I did twenty years ago. His characters are lovable, fun and undergo meaningful development and progress. The plot is entertaining and fluid, containing all the important elements of young adult fiction. There is action, romance, suspense, twists and secrets, combined with small alcoves of intricate life philosophy. His worldbuilding skills are way above most of his contemporaries that just recycle prosaic fantasy concepts and creatures. Mr. Wooding did a great job with Broken Sky.
Of course, this book didn’t pass my self-constructed test with 100% success. There are some rough edges that I notice now that I haven’t paid attention to as a kid. Some dialogues are childish. Some motivations are inconclusive. But none of these details are enough to give me even a shred of doubt that I will be re-reading this series in a couple of years again and thoroughly enjoying it once more.