5 stars because it’s so, so much better than your usual urban fantasy especially at 14 books and counting. Shade still solves her mysteries more with intelligence and grunt work as opposed to the easier-to-write magic solutions that become more common in a lot of series as they age and as usual, there are rewarding parallels to find between the main characters and the side characters making up the mystery part of the plot. I’m torn between wanting answers now and wanting the series to go on and on as long as it keeps up the quality abandoned by so many UF series.
The compulsion keeping Shade from asking questions is falling apart (seems like a sort of look-away spell—the exact mechanism is yet to be explained) so we do get a lot of answers in this book with the promise of a lot more in future books. We see the emotional toll this has had on all of the characters and a breaking point is reached. The prospects of seeing what exactly happened with Scath, Shade facing and reconciling her darker side, Anton and Liam finally in the same room together and what Flint’s up to have me more anxious for the next book than I’ve been in some time. I know Andy’s off doing his own thing, but hopefully the possible openings for him to be more active in the upcoming books pan out. The series has toyed with some philosophical and moral questions and I’m looking forward to seeing the characters deal with these now that the issues have been brought forward more explicitly.
My one issue with the series is Shade’s romantic relationship. There are few substantive scenes between them in the whole series that aren’t strictly professional, and fewer yet that are meaningful in a way that is personal to these 2 characters beyond generic romance that could be between any 2 people, anytime, anywhere if you swap out names and a few details. It’s too close to a doormat-like Very Supportive Boyfriend situation. Shade/Andy, Shade/Peasblossom, Shade/Flint, Shade/Scath, and well, Shade/just about everyone else, are written with detail, thought, and uniqueness which draw a lot more emotion from Shade while her romantic relationship is just so white-bread blah. And they shouldn’t be blah at all. They have a lot of problems and red flags to work through and both are interesting characters. Liam is a lot more than the usual just-add-water insta-alpha character who’s basically interchangeable with any other alpha type that I see all too often in a UF series.
That said, I feel like (ok, hope) the author is making a point here as I can see several interesting character-based reasons why the romantic relationship is this way and it’ll make sense later but it worries me the longer they dodge their very long list of problems because other authors have drug out blah Very Supportive Boyfriend relationships in the past with promises of introducing something more interesting but ended their series without actually going there. Keeping things nice and cutesy by avoiding problems and unfortunately necessary confrontations is both boring and disturbing especially if it’s being held up as a good example of a how a relationship should work. Frankly, there was more substance to the interactions between these 2 earlier in the series when he was a total asshole who needed her magical help to hold his pack in line and she just used him because he was a police contact for her investigations. I want them to be real and work through their issues or just end it already. Romance for the sake of romance isn't enough for me.