I was really looking forward to this book, as someone who's interest in sociology affects the way I read children's and young adult fiction. And there were some really good ones in here, that made me see the wizarding world in a new light. But too often, the essays were either too puny - look, let me show off how this isn't a regular boring academic essay by constantly defining everything as Muggle - or far-reaching - dementors are symbols of our dread of government surveillance, Voldemort really molested the two children in the cave when he was younger and his suppressed homosexuality is what made him so evil... I'd say of the 22, about four or five of them I found enlightening and insightful, and the others were either too gimmicky or far-reaching.