I picked up this book with great anticipation after having read the first book Even Now which I could hardly put down. This one, however, falls short. There were long discourses of character reflection and introspection. That's my pet peeve. I prefer dialogue and more character action and interaction. Kingsbury does do a lot of these sorts of inner dialogues in her books, and they usually don't bother me. This time, however, it was too much of that and not enough action between people. I found Laura Gibbs' change of heart about the war forced, trite, and too fast. She and her hero, Shane Galanter, are at odds about the Iraq war throughout the entire book, then she changes her mind, he changes his mind, and that's that. In turn, the ending, while a happily ever after, was too quick and unsatisfying. If you are into tear jerkers, though, have a box of Kleenex handy because you'll need it for most of the last 1/3 of the book.