I'd give this 3 stars but for the characterisation of the heroine who is the obligatory beauty of such novels and in addition is a wise, resourceful, compassionate and courageous person. The dignity with which she deals with the very difficult and depressing situations she finds herself in due to poverty and the importunate actions of different men, is impressive and very attractive. That said I couldn't understand what the author was trying to depict as Philip's character - it seemed ungentlemanly and exploitative to me... maybe that's what she wanted us to know - that noblemen of the time could get away with really bad behaviour and finally it was some innate morality in some that came to the fore and rescued them.