What do you think?
Rate this book
Miss Marple #6
Kieszeń pełna żyta
Bogaty przedsiębiorca z londyńskiego City, właściciel wspaniałej rezydencji "Domek pod Cisami", ginie otruty jagodami cisa. Zbrodniarz nie poprzestaje jednak na jednym morderstwie. W żmudnym śledztwie inspektorów Scotland Yardu pomaga nieoceniona panna Marple.
178 pages, Paperback
First published November 9, 1953
1444 people are currently reading
19614 people want to read
About the author
Agatha Christie
5,177 books75.5k followersAgatha Christie also wrote romance novels under the pseudonym Mary Westmacott, and was occasionally published under the name Agatha Christie Mallowan.
Dame Agatha Mary Clarissa Christie, Lady Mallowan, DBE (née Miller) was an English writer known for her 66 detective novels and 14 short story collections, particularly those revolving around fictional detectives Hercule Poirot and Miss Marple. She also wrote the world's longest-running play, the murder mystery The Mousetrap, which has been performed in the West End of London since 1952. A writer during the "Golden Age of Detective Fiction", Christie has been called the "Queen of Crime". She also wrote six novels under the pseudonym Mary Westmacott. In 1971, she was made a Dame (DBE) by Queen Elizabeth II for her contributions to literature. Guinness World Records lists Christie as the best-selling fiction writer of all time, her novels having sold more than two billion copies.
This best-selling author of all time wrote 66 crime novels and story collections, fourteen plays, and six novels under a pseudonym in romance. Her books sold more than a billion copies in the English language and a billion in translation. According to Index Translationum, people translated her works into 103 languages at least, the most for an individual author. Of the most enduring figures in crime literature, she created Hercule Poirot and Miss Jane Marple. She atuhored The Mousetrap, the longest-running play in the history of modern theater.
Associated Names:
Agata Christie
Agata Kristi
Агата Кристи (Russian)
Агата Крісті (Ukrainian)
Αγκάθα Κρίστι (Greek)
アガサ クリスティ (Japanese)
阿嘉莎·克莉絲蒂 (Chinese)
Dame Agatha Mary Clarissa Christie, Lady Mallowan, DBE (née Miller) was an English writer known for her 66 detective novels and 14 short story collections, particularly those revolving around fictional detectives Hercule Poirot and Miss Marple. She also wrote the world's longest-running play, the murder mystery The Mousetrap, which has been performed in the West End of London since 1952. A writer during the "Golden Age of Detective Fiction", Christie has been called the "Queen of Crime". She also wrote six novels under the pseudonym Mary Westmacott. In 1971, she was made a Dame (DBE) by Queen Elizabeth II for her contributions to literature. Guinness World Records lists Christie as the best-selling fiction writer of all time, her novels having sold more than two billion copies.
This best-selling author of all time wrote 66 crime novels and story collections, fourteen plays, and six novels under a pseudonym in romance. Her books sold more than a billion copies in the English language and a billion in translation. According to Index Translationum, people translated her works into 103 languages at least, the most for an individual author. Of the most enduring figures in crime literature, she created Hercule Poirot and Miss Jane Marple. She atuhored The Mousetrap, the longest-running play in the history of modern theater.
Associated Names:
Agata Christie
Agata Kristi
Агата Кристи (Russian)
Агата Крісті (Ukrainian)
Αγκάθα Κρίστι (Greek)
アガサ クリスティ (Japanese)
阿嘉莎·克莉絲蒂 (Chinese)
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 3,330 reviews
July 1, 2021
“o que dizer deste livro que mal li e já gostei pakas?”
Na noite fria do dia 25 junho, fazendo aproximadamente 4° com sensação de -35° (caso você durma perto do pé de bel rodrigues). Eu, editheus, discípulo dos otários por Agatha Christie, termina de ler o livro Porção de Centeio
Existe algo de muito belo na arte de ver família rica se brigando por dinheiro, e ainda mais, quando um livro inteiro se desenvolve em cima dessa trama. Toda vez que a futricaiagem começava, parecia que eu estava distante vendo um artista muito talentoso pintando um quadro, pois é fascinante a forma como a veia constrói as fofocas, é o puro suco do confronto verbal e do julgamento das reações dos personagens.
Inúmeras vezes tive certeza de quem era o assassino em questão, mas bastava uma olhadela pro lado, ou um risinho fora de contexto, para que toda a minha teoria que desenvolvi por horas fosse por água abaixo, a forma como pequenos detalhes são inseridos em momentos inesperados ajudam a criar essa sensação de que ninguém é confiável.
Reitero aqui diante deste amável público, que sou simpatizante do OAC - Otários por Agatha Christie, pois mais uma vez fui friamente enganado pela veia, tive muitos suspeitos em minha mente, até algumas vezes suspeitei do real assassino, porém é aquela coisa, por fora bela viola, por dentro pão bolorento.
Ao invés de uma porção de centeio, tive uma porção de diálogos muito bem construídos e um drama policial intrigante, logo deixo minha avaliação com uma nota de 4.3 edistrelas obrigado veia lendária por entregar mais uma história pitoresca.
Para mais resenhas, me siga no kwai #edi812-#*%$ e também no meu vine @vouditheus.
Na noite fria do dia 25 junho, fazendo aproximadamente 4° com sensação de -35° (caso você durma perto do pé de bel rodrigues). Eu, editheus, discípulo dos otários por Agatha Christie, termina de ler o livro Porção de Centeio
Existe algo de muito belo na arte de ver família rica se brigando por dinheiro, e ainda mais, quando um livro inteiro se desenvolve em cima dessa trama. Toda vez que a futricaiagem começava, parecia que eu estava distante vendo um artista muito talentoso pintando um quadro, pois é fascinante a forma como a veia constrói as fofocas, é o puro suco do confronto verbal e do julgamento das reações dos personagens.
Inúmeras vezes tive certeza de quem era o assassino em questão, mas bastava uma olhadela pro lado, ou um risinho fora de contexto, para que toda a minha teoria que desenvolvi por horas fosse por água abaixo, a forma como pequenos detalhes são inseridos em momentos inesperados ajudam a criar essa sensação de que ninguém é confiável.
Reitero aqui diante deste amável público, que sou simpatizante do OAC - Otários por Agatha Christie, pois mais uma vez fui friamente enganado pela veia, tive muitos suspeitos em minha mente, até algumas vezes suspeitei do real assassino, porém é aquela coisa, por fora bela viola, por dentro pão bolorento.
Ao invés de uma porção de centeio, tive uma porção de diálogos muito bem construídos e um drama policial intrigante, logo deixo minha avaliação com uma nota de 4.3 edistrelas obrigado veia lendária por entregar mais uma história pitoresca.
Para mais resenhas, me siga no kwai #edi812-#*%$ e também no meu vine @vouditheus.
July 10, 2021
dessa vez, nem tão palhaça assim.
(mas ainda bem palhaça)
(mas ainda bem palhaça)
September 30, 2025
Sing a song of sixpence,
A pocket full of rye.
Four and twenty blackbirds,
Baked in a pie.
When the pie was opened
The birds began to sing;
Wasn't that a dainty dish,
To set before the king.
The king was in his counting house,
Counting out his money;
The queen was in the parlour,
Eating bread and honey.
The maid was in the garden,
Hanging out the clothes,
When down came a blackbird
And pecked off her nose.
The title and parts of the plot of the novel refer to the nursery rhyme quoted above.
Originally I gave this book 3 stars, but upon re-reading I decided it deserves a 4th. :)
The only problem I have with the book is that almost all characters are unlikeable. Apart from Miss Marple, Inspector Neele and Pat Fortescue , the rest are a nasty, unsympathetic bunch. (OK, maybe Elaine Fortescue is just simply pathetic, but still unlikeable.) They are very well described: precisely and concisely and you can imagine any of them doing the killing all right.
And hats off to Agatha Christie's brilliancy, for queerly enough, she manages what no others (according to my limited knowledge) can, namely, making the first victim's dying and the subsequent pathological consultation the funniest part of the book. This she does, not with malice or morbidity, but with an irresistible, gentle irony, concentrating on the various reactions of the other people around: a bunch of secretaries and typists at a loss what to do in time of crisis and the professional satisfaction the pathologist takes in the "unusual" method of poisoning.
Miss Marple does her usual stuff to satisfaction: knitting baby-things, drawing references to characters of her native village St. Mary Mead & eventually finding the murderer.
A pocket full of rye.
Four and twenty blackbirds,
Baked in a pie.
When the pie was opened
The birds began to sing;
Wasn't that a dainty dish,
To set before the king.
The king was in his counting house,
Counting out his money;
The queen was in the parlour,
Eating bread and honey.
The maid was in the garden,
Hanging out the clothes,
When down came a blackbird
And pecked off her nose.
The title and parts of the plot of the novel refer to the nursery rhyme quoted above.
Originally I gave this book 3 stars, but upon re-reading I decided it deserves a 4th. :)
The only problem I have with the book is that almost all characters are unlikeable. Apart from Miss Marple, Inspector Neele and Pat Fortescue , the rest are a nasty, unsympathetic bunch. (OK, maybe Elaine Fortescue is just simply pathetic, but still unlikeable.) They are very well described: precisely and concisely and you can imagine any of them doing the killing all right.
And hats off to Agatha Christie's brilliancy, for queerly enough, she manages what no others (according to my limited knowledge) can, namely, making the first victim's dying and the subsequent pathological consultation the funniest part of the book. This she does, not with malice or morbidity, but with an irresistible, gentle irony, concentrating on the various reactions of the other people around: a bunch of secretaries and typists at a loss what to do in time of crisis and the professional satisfaction the pathologist takes in the "unusual" method of poisoning.
Miss Marple does her usual stuff to satisfaction: knitting baby-things, drawing references to characters of her native village St. Mary Mead & eventually finding the murderer.
April 22, 2025
A rich dude chokes on his tea, and in his pocket the fuzz find...RYE.
Nefarious, I say!
Or maybe not.
For some reason, Pocket Full of Rye seemed like a more complex story than what you normally get from one of Agatha's murder mysteries. <--I have no evidence for that statement, it's just this feeling I got while I was reading it.
I mean, there are always red herrings in Christie's books. Sometimes even blue and yellow herrings.
All those delicious, delicious herrings...
But there were a lot of people who wanted this guy dead for one reason or another, and all of them looked guilty. I didn't figure it out till the endwhen Miss Marple revealed the killer but I still (as always) had fun trying my hand at being an amateur literature sleuth.
Good stuff.
Richard E. Grant was the narrator, and he did a lovely job.
Nefarious, I say!
Or maybe not.
For some reason, Pocket Full of Rye seemed like a more complex story than what you normally get from one of Agatha's murder mysteries. <--I have no evidence for that statement, it's just this feeling I got while I was reading it.
I mean, there are always red herrings in Christie's books. Sometimes even blue and yellow herrings.
All those delicious, delicious herrings...
But there were a lot of people who wanted this guy dead for one reason or another, and all of them looked guilty. I didn't figure it out till the end
Good stuff.
Richard E. Grant was the narrator, and he did a lovely job.
July 25, 2014
It’s been a long time since I’ve read any Agatha Christie and it’s easy to let one’s brain flow back into her story telling style. Her books do have a comforting familiarity. Dry humor to set the scene; the murder; the investigation; more dead bodies; the red herrings; the revealing.
No heavy lifting required. Like a pleasant spring day. This one is a Miss Marple and a decent read. It also provides an unexpected and emotional denouement.
Here’s the kicker for me: I find it very quaint that the British police force let an old lady (their term: old pussy. Yikes!) wander into a crime scene and start sorting things out and offering clues. Here’s the way it would go down in America: Old lady wanders onto multiple murder scene, annoys American cops, American cops plant crack pipe on old lady, subject her to a strip search and interrogation, drop her 20 miles outside of town, murder, of course, remains unsolved. If this were James Ellroy, they’d slip her a mickey and film her having sex with a camel, just for good measure.
No heavy lifting required. Like a pleasant spring day. This one is a Miss Marple and a decent read. It also provides an unexpected and emotional denouement.
Here’s the kicker for me: I find it very quaint that the British police force let an old lady (their term: old pussy. Yikes!) wander into a crime scene and start sorting things out and offering clues. Here’s the way it would go down in America: Old lady wanders onto multiple murder scene, annoys American cops, American cops plant crack pipe on old lady, subject her to a strip search and interrogation, drop her 20 miles outside of town, murder, of course, remains unsolved. If this were James Ellroy, they’d slip her a mickey and film her having sex with a camel, just for good measure.
December 10, 2021
Loved it! I watched the TV series version years ago but hadn't read A Pocket Full of Rye by Agatha Christie. I'm working my way through all the Miss Marple books over the next few months. Such a great way to spend a few hours. To have lived in that time, briefly, just to see the different aspects of life, would be wonderful. I love her insights on people. Miss Marple only appears in the latter half, and only for a few scenes, but she's incredibly gifted. Classic mystery. Wealthy patriarch poisoned. Was it the new younger wife? A greedy child? A colleague? Then someone else dies. And the staff at the country estate begin to look guilty. Except there's a nursery rhyme being followed. How will it all come together? Brilliantly. Can't wait to get to the next one in the coming days.
April 29, 2024
2024 April Lunchtime Listen
I think if I hadn't read this and given it 5 stars , I would drop it to 4 stars for the audiobook. Unfortunately the reason is Richard E Grant as the narrator. whilst some of his "voices" are good, others are just , I'm sorry to say, completely ridiculous. A female middle-aged cook, who sounded like Ray Winstone, what ?!?!?!?!?! And then by the end sounded like Penelope Keith.
Anyway, that distraction aside, it is as ever an excellent book, and was an enjoyable lunchtime listen in what has been an incredibly fraught time due to the house move.
2017 Series Group Read
Without a doubt this has been one of my favourite books in the Miss Marple challenge. It is not a novel I remembered reading and so it was wonderful to experience for the first time (maybe ?)
As with a lot of the novels, Miss M is in it only fleetingly, but each appearance is worth waiting for in terms of insight and revelation, and yes I still see Joan Hickson every time.
I think if I hadn't read this and given it 5 stars , I would drop it to 4 stars for the audiobook. Unfortunately the reason is Richard E Grant as the narrator. whilst some of his "voices" are good, others are just , I'm sorry to say, completely ridiculous. A female middle-aged cook, who sounded like Ray Winstone, what ?!?!?!?!?! And then by the end sounded like Penelope Keith.
Anyway, that distraction aside, it is as ever an excellent book, and was an enjoyable lunchtime listen in what has been an incredibly fraught time due to the house move.
2017 Series Group Read
Without a doubt this has been one of my favourite books in the Miss Marple challenge. It is not a novel I remembered reading and so it was wonderful to experience for the first time (maybe ?)
As with a lot of the novels, Miss M is in it only fleetingly, but each appearance is worth waiting for in terms of insight and revelation, and yes I still see Joan Hickson every time.
July 17, 2020
When life ever gets back to “normal,” I think one of the best things to come out of quarantine is that I have discovered Agatha Christie mysteries again. Last year was primarily a nonfiction reading year for me. I read a number of celebrity memoirs in between denser reads to clear my head. While I enjoy learning about celebrities away from the camera, my favorite genre to read in between heavier books has always been mysteries. The quick pace of determining whodunit keeps me on my toes and my brain working so that I don’t fall into the proverbial book slump. I just completed a non-fiction book, a rarity for me these days, so it was time for another mystery. A Pocket Full of Rye is the fourth Agatha Christie book i have read this year, but the first Miss Marple case. Needless to say, I was excited to reacquaint myself with the charming older woman.
Miss Marple travels to Yew Lodge in Braydon Heath to assist Inspector Neele in solving the Fortescue murders. The third victim was one Gladys Martin who used to be Miss Marple’s housekeeper. Although Miss Marple is a sharp woman, she has been getting older and her nephew and niece have insisted that she keep a housekeeper to handle domestic chores. This would free up Miss Marple for her gardening and of course solving the murders that always seem to disrupt the life in St Mary Mead. Gladys Martin has been in Miss Marple’s service so the older woman felt responsible for bringing the girl’s murderer to justice. While Inspector Neele has a sharper mind than most of the Scotland Yard detectives featured in Christie’s books, he still needed Miss Marple to help him solve this peculiar case. An older woman like Miss Marple is unassuming and can talk to distraught family members in ways that the police cannot. What the family does not realize is that Miss Marple is of a sharp mind and often solves murders before the police have an idea as to what happens.
Rex Fortescue is found murdered at his desk with a shirt pocket full of rye seeds. His wife Adele is found murdered in her library having tea. The third murder is that of Gladys Martin, who was found near a clothesline with a clothespin on her nose. In Miss Marple’s words, a crude thing to do. Immediately, what comes to her mind is the Mother Goose rhyme, “six pence, a pocket full of rye, four and twenty blackbirds found in a pie.” The murders fit the rhyme down to the King at his counting house with a pocket full of rye, the Queen found with honey, and the maid near a clothesline. Miss Marple alerts Inspector Neele that blackbirds must be involved in this case, and indeed they are. Neele is incredulous that a nursery rhyme would give revealing clues as to whodunit, but he examines the blackbird angle nonetheless. Now, to question all members of the Fortescue household and acquaintances until they discover who is responsible for these murders.
In Poirot cases, Dame Christie omits an important clue until the end in order to keep readers guessing. Miss Marple is sharp as a tack and figures out all clues for herself well before the end of the book. The thing that makes her cases charming is that she figures immediately whodunit, even giving her opinions, usually the correct one, to the police, and it takes them awhile to catch up. Here, Inspector Neele kept getting held up with the rye in the pocket and the yew berry trees, which contain a fast working poison, on the Fortescue property. Miss Marple pieced together whodunit from her brief examination of Gladys Martin, and only needed to question the remaining members of the Fortescue household in order to verify her hunches. That is what makes Miss Marple a change of pace from Poirot, that she gets to the root of the matter and then goes back to her quiet life in St Mary Mead. Poirot examines every angle with his gray cells and continues to take on new cases as his reputation grows with each one. Although both detectives are among my favorite characters, I find myself enjoying the company of Miss Marple more than Poirot because she has a lifetime worth of wisdom and would be a lovely companion to invite to tea.
A quick read, Miss Marple solved whodunit and life at both Yew Berry Lodge and St Mary Mead get back to normal. I am hoping that real life gets back to normal soon as well; however, reading Agatha Christie cases is never going to go out of style. After reading many cases of both Poirot and Miss Marple, I have yet to figure out whodunit before the detective unless the book is a reread. Mysteries keep me on my toes and allow me to use my gray cells even if the books are fast paced brain candy. Even if her books are easy reading, Christie’s two sleuths are timeless. Miss Marple is always refreshing to visit with because she is a charming lady, and I learn a lot from her character. Until another murder case that warrants solving finds Miss Marple in St Mary Mead, I will move on to my next book.
3.75 stars
Miss Marple travels to Yew Lodge in Braydon Heath to assist Inspector Neele in solving the Fortescue murders. The third victim was one Gladys Martin who used to be Miss Marple’s housekeeper. Although Miss Marple is a sharp woman, she has been getting older and her nephew and niece have insisted that she keep a housekeeper to handle domestic chores. This would free up Miss Marple for her gardening and of course solving the murders that always seem to disrupt the life in St Mary Mead. Gladys Martin has been in Miss Marple’s service so the older woman felt responsible for bringing the girl’s murderer to justice. While Inspector Neele has a sharper mind than most of the Scotland Yard detectives featured in Christie’s books, he still needed Miss Marple to help him solve this peculiar case. An older woman like Miss Marple is unassuming and can talk to distraught family members in ways that the police cannot. What the family does not realize is that Miss Marple is of a sharp mind and often solves murders before the police have an idea as to what happens.
Rex Fortescue is found murdered at his desk with a shirt pocket full of rye seeds. His wife Adele is found murdered in her library having tea. The third murder is that of Gladys Martin, who was found near a clothesline with a clothespin on her nose. In Miss Marple’s words, a crude thing to do. Immediately, what comes to her mind is the Mother Goose rhyme, “six pence, a pocket full of rye, four and twenty blackbirds found in a pie.” The murders fit the rhyme down to the King at his counting house with a pocket full of rye, the Queen found with honey, and the maid near a clothesline. Miss Marple alerts Inspector Neele that blackbirds must be involved in this case, and indeed they are. Neele is incredulous that a nursery rhyme would give revealing clues as to whodunit, but he examines the blackbird angle nonetheless. Now, to question all members of the Fortescue household and acquaintances until they discover who is responsible for these murders.
In Poirot cases, Dame Christie omits an important clue until the end in order to keep readers guessing. Miss Marple is sharp as a tack and figures out all clues for herself well before the end of the book. The thing that makes her cases charming is that she figures immediately whodunit, even giving her opinions, usually the correct one, to the police, and it takes them awhile to catch up. Here, Inspector Neele kept getting held up with the rye in the pocket and the yew berry trees, which contain a fast working poison, on the Fortescue property. Miss Marple pieced together whodunit from her brief examination of Gladys Martin, and only needed to question the remaining members of the Fortescue household in order to verify her hunches. That is what makes Miss Marple a change of pace from Poirot, that she gets to the root of the matter and then goes back to her quiet life in St Mary Mead. Poirot examines every angle with his gray cells and continues to take on new cases as his reputation grows with each one. Although both detectives are among my favorite characters, I find myself enjoying the company of Miss Marple more than Poirot because she has a lifetime worth of wisdom and would be a lovely companion to invite to tea.
A quick read, Miss Marple solved whodunit and life at both Yew Berry Lodge and St Mary Mead get back to normal. I am hoping that real life gets back to normal soon as well; however, reading Agatha Christie cases is never going to go out of style. After reading many cases of both Poirot and Miss Marple, I have yet to figure out whodunit before the detective unless the book is a reread. Mysteries keep me on my toes and allow me to use my gray cells even if the books are fast paced brain candy. Even if her books are easy reading, Christie’s two sleuths are timeless. Miss Marple is always refreshing to visit with because she is a charming lady, and I learn a lot from her character. Until another murder case that warrants solving finds Miss Marple in St Mary Mead, I will move on to my next book.
3.75 stars
September 15, 2025
„Джоб, пълен с ръж“ е поредното чудесно съчетание на криминална мистерия и семейна драма, елегантно поднесено от Агата Кристи! Богат бизнесмен е отровен и полицията започва да разследва случая, като заподозрени са най-вече хората от неговото семейство. На по-късен етап мис Марпъл се включва в разплитането на сложната загадка...
„А старите грехове, както се казва, имат дълги сенки.“
„У нея имаше нещо необяснимо, нещо незадоволително. Някакъв лек, ироничен антагонизъм.“
„Вътрешното му чувство му бе подсказало, че единствената пукнатина в бронята на непроницаемата Мери Дъв е удоволствието, което тя изпитва от собствената си експедитивност.“
„— Вие ме заплашвате — каза той. — Заплашвате ме.
— Не, не, нищо подобно. — Тонът на инспектор Нийл изразяваше изненада. — Нищо подобно не ни е позволено да правим. Точно обратното. В действителност ви напомням, че имате известни права.“
„Мис Марпъл се наклони напред и внимателно и убедително, като човек, който обяснява прости аритметични факти на малко дете, изложи теорията си.“
„Мога ли да се осмеля да ви дам съвет, ако някога нещо в живота ви се обърка — мисля, че най-голямото щастие ще намерите там, където сте били щастлива като дете.“
„А старите грехове, както се казва, имат дълги сенки.“
„У нея имаше нещо необяснимо, нещо незадоволително. Някакъв лек, ироничен антагонизъм.“
„Вътрешното му чувство му бе подсказало, че единствената пукнатина в бронята на непроницаемата Мери Дъв е удоволствието, което тя изпитва от собствената си експедитивност.“
„— Вие ме заплашвате — каза той. — Заплашвате ме.
— Не, не, нищо подобно. — Тонът на инспектор Нийл изразяваше изненада. — Нищо подобно не ни е позволено да правим. Точно обратното. В действителност ви напомням, че имате известни права.“
„Мис Марпъл се наклони напред и внимателно и убедително, като човек, който обяснява прости аритметични факти на малко дете, изложи теорията си.“
„Мога ли да се осмеля да ви дам съвет, ако някога нещо в живота ви се обърка — мисля, че най-голямото щастие ще намерите там, където сте били щастлива като дете.“
November 5, 2023
3.5 stars
short review for busy readers: one of Miss Marple's best.
In detail:
After a rather rough start with some eyebrow-raising police work and highly stilted dialogue, the plot clamps down and delivers a rather satisfying mystery...especially after Miss Marple shows up.
The clues are all there, but quite difficult to patch together as necessary details are absent until the very end. You can sense a dangerous inconsistency to the left or to the right, but can't make full cloth out of the odds and ends until Miss Marple explains it all to both you AND the police.
Adding to the difficulty, the mystery contains my very fave mystery structure I clued into that being a possibility early, and was delighted to find that guess was correct!
For that reason, on the "ease of solving" scale for mysteries (1 being easiest), this one ranks about an 8, so really only for advanced amateur sleuths.
short review for busy readers: one of Miss Marple's best.
In detail:
After a rather rough start with some eyebrow-raising police work and highly stilted dialogue, the plot clamps down and delivers a rather satisfying mystery...especially after Miss Marple shows up.
The clues are all there, but quite difficult to patch together as necessary details are absent until the very end. You can sense a dangerous inconsistency to the left or to the right, but can't make full cloth out of the odds and ends until Miss Marple explains it all to both you AND the police.
Adding to the difficulty, the mystery contains my very fave mystery structure I clued into that being a possibility early, and was delighted to find that guess was correct!
For that reason, on the "ease of solving" scale for mysteries (1 being easiest), this one ranks about an 8, so really only for advanced amateur sleuths.
October 7, 2017
As anybody who reads the Miss Marple books knows, she often trains young housemaids, so they can go into service. When Miss Marple reads that one of the young maids she trained, Gladys Martin, has been found strangled - a clothes peg left on her nose - in the garden of the house where she worked, she sets off at once to see who did such a wicked thing. Murder had already visited the family, as the head of the household, Mr Rex Fortecue, was poisoned at work and, in his pocket, was a handful of rye…
The crimes in this novel are all lined to the nursery rhyme, “Sing a song of sixpence…” and yet it all seems unbelievable to Detective Inspector Neele, who is sent to investigate. However, as Miss Marple points out to him, there must be blackbird and, indeed, there are blackbirds. She quickly gets to know the members of the family and, of course, manages to unravel the reasons behind the murders. Meanwhile, D.I. Neele, having heard of Miss Marple’s reputation, is quite happy to listen to what she has to say.
This is one of my favourite Miss Marple mysteries. I love the opening of the book, the characters and the way Christie deftly creates the various plot twists. Miss Marple is also very involved in the storyline and her outrage on Gladys behalf is wonderful to see. Although never emotional, she is obviously quite attached to those young girls who pass through her little cottage in St Mary Mead, and she is determined to see justice done.
The crimes in this novel are all lined to the nursery rhyme, “Sing a song of sixpence…” and yet it all seems unbelievable to Detective Inspector Neele, who is sent to investigate. However, as Miss Marple points out to him, there must be blackbird and, indeed, there are blackbirds. She quickly gets to know the members of the family and, of course, manages to unravel the reasons behind the murders. Meanwhile, D.I. Neele, having heard of Miss Marple’s reputation, is quite happy to listen to what she has to say.
This is one of my favourite Miss Marple mysteries. I love the opening of the book, the characters and the way Christie deftly creates the various plot twists. Miss Marple is also very involved in the storyline and her outrage on Gladys behalf is wonderful to see. Although never emotional, she is obviously quite attached to those young girls who pass through her little cottage in St Mary Mead, and she is determined to see justice done.
July 9, 2021
Dilim tutuldu.😶 Bayıldım. Gerçekten inanılmaz bir olay örgüsü ve sondu! Keşke Marple daha fazla işin içine girmiş olsaydı diyorum o kadar 🤭 Onun dışında yaldızlı bir 5 veriyorum!✨💫
September 27, 2022
Last book review of the day! Huzzah. This will also teach me to next time make sure my books are downloaded on my Kindle before going back to my hometown where WiFi is not a thing apparently. I was so mad at myself. Will get back to the other books I had planned to read for Halloween Bingo, but didn't want to just not read anything to keep up with my planned reading schedule. Thank goodness I had so many King and Christie books already downloaded on my Kindle, even though I also have this and some of the others on my permanent book shelves. Quick note, I need to stop buying books before checking to see if they are already in my house somewhere. No idea how that Tremblay book was on my Kindle, I recall not even being able to finish that book my first time through, but I must have bought it and forgot about it.
Updated review: September 26, 2022: Honestly this is a great who dun it and it's a wonderful book to read for a variety of squares if you are playing Halloween Book bingo, are need a book to just fit a list you may be going through. Miss Marple takes a while to get on the scene in this one, but once she does, she starts to quickly put things together. I felt for the character Gladys in this one, a former maid of Miss Marple. Miss Marple feels obligated to find out who murdered her and why. And unlike with Poirot, I like that Marple is okay with murderers getting what's coming to them. I felt a few times that Poirot was like, eh what is murder. Drove me up the wall. How this ended up being solved was great though. I honestly did not get it until the reveal which was great.
Update: September 20, 2020-Still one of my favorites. Re-read for comfort read.
I weirdly have some Miss Marple in paperback format and some that are not. I have no idea why. So realizing that I had this on my bookshelf, I decided to read it for Halloween Bingo.
This was done really well. Christie starts the book off with us following an Inspector Nettle to figure out who murdered Rex Fortescue and his second wife, Adele. Initially, it appears that Adele and the man who she is having an affair with are the perpetrators behind the crimes. When the maid is found strangled to death, Nettle is baffled by who is behind these crimes. Then enter, Miss Marple.
We find out that the maid, Gladys worked for Miss Marple, and once Miss Marple found out about her death, she arrives at home of the Fortescue's (Yewtree Lodge).
This is Miss Marple at her best. She and Nettle work well together and even though Nettle is behind Miss Marple in figuring out who is the murderer and the reasons why, it was a fun book to read and try guess who did it and why. Without giving away the ending, I loved how Miss Marple fixates on the rightful murderer and the reasons why.
Christie does a great job of setting up all of the characters before Miss Marple shows up. Sometimes I find myself bored with Marple or Poirot books until they show up, this was not one of those times.
The setting of Yewtree Lodge is good and there are so many people who are viable suspects, Rex had two sons, a daughter, two daughters in laws and a general housekeeper that you are going to wonder if they are behind things or not.
The ending doesn't give you a cut and dried solution though. Things are left at loose ends. You can guess what is going to happen next though.
Updated review: September 26, 2022: Honestly this is a great who dun it and it's a wonderful book to read for a variety of squares if you are playing Halloween Book bingo, are need a book to just fit a list you may be going through. Miss Marple takes a while to get on the scene in this one, but once she does, she starts to quickly put things together. I felt for the character Gladys in this one, a former maid of Miss Marple. Miss Marple feels obligated to find out who murdered her and why. And unlike with Poirot, I like that Marple is okay with murderers getting what's coming to them. I felt a few times that Poirot was like, eh what is murder. Drove me up the wall. How this ended up being solved was great though. I honestly did not get it until the reveal which was great.
Update: September 20, 2020-Still one of my favorites. Re-read for comfort read.
I weirdly have some Miss Marple in paperback format and some that are not. I have no idea why. So realizing that I had this on my bookshelf, I decided to read it for Halloween Bingo.
This was done really well. Christie starts the book off with us following an Inspector Nettle to figure out who murdered Rex Fortescue and his second wife, Adele. Initially, it appears that Adele and the man who she is having an affair with are the perpetrators behind the crimes. When the maid is found strangled to death, Nettle is baffled by who is behind these crimes. Then enter, Miss Marple.
We find out that the maid, Gladys worked for Miss Marple, and once Miss Marple found out about her death, she arrives at home of the Fortescue's (Yewtree Lodge).
This is Miss Marple at her best. She and Nettle work well together and even though Nettle is behind Miss Marple in figuring out who is the murderer and the reasons why, it was a fun book to read and try guess who did it and why. Without giving away the ending, I loved how Miss Marple fixates on the rightful murderer and the reasons why.
Christie does a great job of setting up all of the characters before Miss Marple shows up. Sometimes I find myself bored with Marple or Poirot books until they show up, this was not one of those times.
The setting of Yewtree Lodge is good and there are so many people who are viable suspects, Rex had two sons, a daughter, two daughters in laws and a general housekeeper that you are going to wonder if they are behind things or not.
The ending doesn't give you a cut and dried solution though. Things are left at loose ends. You can guess what is going to happen next though.
August 30, 2021
Same old good Agatha Christie book. Easy read and impossible to be put down. I really missed reading the Agatha Christie books :D
March 8, 2018
B.R.A.CE. 2018 δεύτερο βιβλίο για την τετράδα των συγγραφέων διαφορετικής εθνικότητας
αν και δεν μου αρέσουν οι ιστορίες της Μις Μαρπλ, ευτυχώς εδώ εμφανίζεται ελάχιστα ;)
αν και δεν μου αρέσουν οι ιστορίες της Μις Μαρπλ, ευτυχώς εδώ εμφανίζεται ελάχιστα ;)
September 11, 2024
This is one of the interesting ones of the Miss Marple series. Falling into the formulaic pattern of murder, police investigation, more murders, and final revelation, Christie weaves a clever story of mystery and intrigue. The common theme of family disputes, the return of the prodigal son, and the usual drama that follows returns in this story as well, yet the similarity didn't make the story suffer.
It was a quick page-turner with events taking place at quite a fast pace. I liked that about it, unlike some of the Christie mysteries that drag in the middle.
Miss Marple's role in this was a small one, but enough to justify her involvement in the case and to show her cleverness to the utmost. This story is one where Miss Marple shines her best. She puts the clever yet blundering inspector to the right. And what more, she provides him with proof too. Such a clever dear old pussy! :)
This was decidedly an entertaining read and one that deserves four stars. However, the ending was abrupt, leaving behind a sense of incompletion. The mystery was solved, and the criminal was identified; yet, there were some ends that needed tying up but were left hanging. A nice epilogue could have come in handy to complete and compliment the story.
Taking everything into account, I can safely say that this is one of the best I've read in the Marple series. With this reading, I've come to realize that Marple stories are incredibly clever than most of the Christie mysteries, including many Poirots. Miss Marple was no professional detective and not one that can be summoned when a crime is committed. So, Christie had to come up with a plausible cause to help Miss Marple enter the scene of a crime. I don't think it was such an easy task. And credit certainly goes to Christie for taking up the burden and executing it well.
It was a quick page-turner with events taking place at quite a fast pace. I liked that about it, unlike some of the Christie mysteries that drag in the middle.
Miss Marple's role in this was a small one, but enough to justify her involvement in the case and to show her cleverness to the utmost. This story is one where Miss Marple shines her best. She puts the clever yet blundering inspector to the right. And what more, she provides him with proof too. Such a clever dear old pussy! :)
This was decidedly an entertaining read and one that deserves four stars. However, the ending was abrupt, leaving behind a sense of incompletion. The mystery was solved, and the criminal was identified; yet, there were some ends that needed tying up but were left hanging. A nice epilogue could have come in handy to complete and compliment the story.
Taking everything into account, I can safely say that this is one of the best I've read in the Marple series. With this reading, I've come to realize that Marple stories are incredibly clever than most of the Christie mysteries, including many Poirots. Miss Marple was no professional detective and not one that can be summoned when a crime is committed. So, Christie had to come up with a plausible cause to help Miss Marple enter the scene of a crime. I don't think it was such an easy task. And credit certainly goes to Christie for taking up the burden and executing it well.
March 12, 2021
Christie's various attempts to incorporate Nursery Rhymes into her plots has a varied degree of success.
It actually seems quite fitting for a Miss Marple story that it works rather well.
Both the childish rhyme and the elderly spinster appearances are always deceiving!
It's of course Jane herself that connects the three murders to the song:
As London businessman Rex Fortescue dies in his office drinking tea.
(The king was in his counting house, Counting out his money.)
His wife then follows the same fate...
(The queen was in the the parlour,
Eating bread and honey.)
Whilst housemaid Gladys Martin is found strangled in the yard with a clothespin put on her nose.
(The maid was in the garden
Hanging out the clothes
When down came a blackbird
And pecked off her nose.)
It certainly perplexed both Inspector Neele and the reader.
Once Miss Marple was aware of her former trainee maid's demise, she was desperate to solve the mystery.
When Miss Marple is on the case you know things are serious.
Whilst our series main character only nominally appears in the story, she makes such an impact - in truth the family at the centre of this tale are pretty hard to like, though the enjoyment here is seeing how the rhyme seems to fit so perfectly to the case.
Yet again Christie certainly fooled me with another brilliant reveal.
It actually seems quite fitting for a Miss Marple story that it works rather well.
Both the childish rhyme and the elderly spinster appearances are always deceiving!
It's of course Jane herself that connects the three murders to the song:
As London businessman Rex Fortescue dies in his office drinking tea.
(The king was in his counting house, Counting out his money.)
His wife then follows the same fate...
(The queen was in the the parlour,
Eating bread and honey.)
Whilst housemaid Gladys Martin is found strangled in the yard with a clothespin put on her nose.
(The maid was in the garden
Hanging out the clothes
When down came a blackbird
And pecked off her nose.)
It certainly perplexed both Inspector Neele and the reader.
Once Miss Marple was aware of her former trainee maid's demise, she was desperate to solve the mystery.
When Miss Marple is on the case you know things are serious.
Whilst our series main character only nominally appears in the story, she makes such an impact - in truth the family at the centre of this tale are pretty hard to like, though the enjoyment here is seeing how the rhyme seems to fit so perfectly to the case.
Yet again Christie certainly fooled me with another brilliant reveal.
April 17, 2019
I was right! I figured out this mystery's culprit. And I also figured the identity of the person who had the grudge against the Fortescue family.
Though Miss Marple doesn't show up till maybe halfway (and figures things out, of course), I did enjoy following Inspector Neal about as he questioned the family members about old nasty Rex's habits and behaviours.
I really enjoyed how Miss Marple does her twittery thing at first, until the inspector really begins taking her seriously. Then we see the Jane I love; tough as nails and very sure in her assessments, never mind her "pink cheeks" and bag of yarn.
Though Miss Marple doesn't show up till maybe halfway (and figures things out, of course), I did enjoy following Inspector Neal about as he questioned the family members about old nasty Rex's habits and behaviours.
I really enjoyed how Miss Marple does her twittery thing at first, until the inspector really begins taking her seriously. Then we see the Jane I love; tough as nails and very sure in her assessments, never mind her "pink cheeks" and bag of yarn.
January 15, 2018
It was Miss Somers' turn to make the tea. Miss Somers was the newest and the most inefficient of typists. She was no longer young and had a mild worried face like a sheep. The kettle was not quite boiling when Miss Somers poured the water on the tea, but poor Miss Somers was never quite sure when a kettle was boiling. It was one of the many worries that afflicted her in life.
She poured out the tea and took the cups round with a couple of limp, sweet biscuits in each saucer.
That quote has very little to do with the plot of A Pocket Full of Rye, but it does set the tone of this story. There is something edgy and sinister about A Pocket Full of Rye. This is not a "cozy" mystery. Sure, there is not blood or gore, but there is darkness, thirst for revenge, and calculating human horribleness.
And that's what I see in the mention of tepid tea and limp biscuits. No, I kid. But I do see in this opening that there is something just not right, and it is this feeling that runs through this story.
I can't say that I liked this story a lot, and I can't even put my finger on why this is. Maybe it is because of the murder method causes me to have questions, maybe it because the police investigation misses the mark so often, or maybe it is because of that horrible children's rhyme that is the basis for this story, but it is not a story that I enjoy re-reading a lot.
Nevertheless, I recommend it. The different relationship angles in this story are fascinating. Dark, but benefiting from Christie's acute eye for suffering that can be caused by family.
Approach with strong tea, and sweet, rich, fresh biscuits.
She poured out the tea and took the cups round with a couple of limp, sweet biscuits in each saucer.
That quote has very little to do with the plot of A Pocket Full of Rye, but it does set the tone of this story. There is something edgy and sinister about A Pocket Full of Rye. This is not a "cozy" mystery. Sure, there is not blood or gore, but there is darkness, thirst for revenge, and calculating human horribleness.
And that's what I see in the mention of tepid tea and limp biscuits. No, I kid. But I do see in this opening that there is something just not right, and it is this feeling that runs through this story.
I can't say that I liked this story a lot, and I can't even put my finger on why this is. Maybe it is because of the murder method causes me to have questions, maybe it because the police investigation misses the mark so often, or maybe it is because of that horrible children's rhyme that is the basis for this story, but it is not a story that I enjoy re-reading a lot.
Nevertheless, I recommend it. The different relationship angles in this story are fascinating. Dark, but benefiting from Christie's acute eye for suffering that can be caused by family.
Approach with strong tea, and sweet, rich, fresh biscuits.
June 14, 2018
"Sing a song of sixpence, a pocket full of rye,
Four and twenty blackbirds baked in a pie.
When the pie was opened the birds began to sing,
Wasn't that a dainty dish to set before the king.
The king was in his counting house, counting out his money,
The queen was in the parlour eating bread and honey.
The maid was in the garden hanging out the clothes,
When there came a litte dickey bird and nipped off her nose."
When Rex Fortescue suddenly falls ill after drinking his regular cup of tea at his office and dies shortly after, the police suspect foul play. Inspector Neele visits Yewtree Lodge, Mr. Fortecue's home, to interview the family and staff. Between a younger second wife, an son with which Mr. Fortescue was currenlty at odds with, a daughter who wished to marry but the fiance was not aproved by dad and a whole slew of characters with the staff, inspector Neele has no shortage of suspects and an abundance of motives. As the investigation progresses, Miss Marple inserts herself into the case and soon links the murder to a rhyme. Uncovering a complex plot, Miss Marple unmasks the culprit.
The seventh book in the Miss Marple series, 'A Pocket full of Rye' was originally published in 1953. Rex Fortescue is a ruthless business man with questionable practices. Accustomed to having a cup of tea at work, he falls ill quite suddenly and dies. A handful of rye is found in his pocket and soon his death is a confirmed case of poisoning through taxine. Inspector Neele is assigned to the case which leads him to Yewtree Lodge, the home of the the Fortecues. The house is surrounded by the plant needed to get taxine and now inspector Neele has a household full of suspects. Miss Marple reads about the murder in the papers and after another twist in the case, gets involved. As per usual with Christie, there were plenty of red herrings and misdirections. I greatly enjoyed the way in which the plot unravelled and found the characters intriguing and entertaning (especially Miss Ramsbottom, the sister of Mr. Fortecue's first wife). I love how the rhyme was incorporated into the narrative and how the culprit came to be revealed. This book is yet another favorite by Miss Christie and I absolutely love it. This book is a crime by rhyme and it was done masterfully. Highly recommended!
Four and twenty blackbirds baked in a pie.
When the pie was opened the birds began to sing,
Wasn't that a dainty dish to set before the king.
The king was in his counting house, counting out his money,
The queen was in the parlour eating bread and honey.
The maid was in the garden hanging out the clothes,
When there came a litte dickey bird and nipped off her nose."
When Rex Fortescue suddenly falls ill after drinking his regular cup of tea at his office and dies shortly after, the police suspect foul play. Inspector Neele visits Yewtree Lodge, Mr. Fortecue's home, to interview the family and staff. Between a younger second wife, an son with which Mr. Fortescue was currenlty at odds with, a daughter who wished to marry but the fiance was not aproved by dad and a whole slew of characters with the staff, inspector Neele has no shortage of suspects and an abundance of motives. As the investigation progresses, Miss Marple inserts herself into the case and soon links the murder to a rhyme. Uncovering a complex plot, Miss Marple unmasks the culprit.
The seventh book in the Miss Marple series, 'A Pocket full of Rye' was originally published in 1953. Rex Fortescue is a ruthless business man with questionable practices. Accustomed to having a cup of tea at work, he falls ill quite suddenly and dies. A handful of rye is found in his pocket and soon his death is a confirmed case of poisoning through taxine. Inspector Neele is assigned to the case which leads him to Yewtree Lodge, the home of the the Fortecues. The house is surrounded by the plant needed to get taxine and now inspector Neele has a household full of suspects. Miss Marple reads about the murder in the papers and after another twist in the case, gets involved. As per usual with Christie, there were plenty of red herrings and misdirections. I greatly enjoyed the way in which the plot unravelled and found the characters intriguing and entertaning (especially Miss Ramsbottom, the sister of Mr. Fortecue's first wife). I love how the rhyme was incorporated into the narrative and how the culprit came to be revealed. This book is yet another favorite by Miss Christie and I absolutely love it. This book is a crime by rhyme and it was done masterfully. Highly recommended!
February 28, 2015
Loved this - brilliantly surprising ending, and one of those ideal Christie solutions where everything turns on its head at the end and all the same facts suddenly look completely different. I would have given it four stars, except that Miss Marple didn't really (as far as I can see) have enough clues to lead her to the truth. She seemed to have magicked the truth out of nowhere. I know she's a genius about human nature, but I'd have liked a couple of more concrete clues to set her on the right path. Still...it's a novel by Agatha, and therefore in a league way above most books!
September 7, 2020
I listened to this book while working on a jigsaw puzzle with my family. We finished both and felt most satisfied!
I love that this book begins with making a cup of tea. The first sentence, "It was Miss Somer's turn to make the tea." Apparently, she was not very good at it, and was "the most inefficient of typists" to boot, with "a mild worried face like a sheep."
Growing up in England I learned that the water needed to come to a full boil to make a good cup of tea. Alas, "Poor Miss Somer's was never quite sure when a kettle was boiling. It was one of the many worries that afflicted her in life."
Miss Marple is renowned for her ability to winkle out the details from people. They confide in her openly, as she appears harmless. Indeed, people seem to fall over themselves to share their juicy bits of gossip or their opinions on things. One such person was the lonely Mrs. Emmett, the bank manager's wife.
"The necessity to talk grew upon Mrs. Emmett, and on that particular day it had burst its bounds, and Miss. Marple had received the full flood of the torrent." Mrs. Emmett's complaints about village life and the inhabitants in particular illustrate the nuances of class and how she did not fit in "the old guard of ladies" and she could not "associate with the wives of trades people" either. In short, Mrs. Emmett had become an unlikeable snob who lacked self-awareness and had managed to isolate herself.
Narrator, Richard E Grant reads her diatribe with such great expression and captures her disdain with particular feeling. One phrase in particular stood out to us, "Then, of course, there's a sprinkling of - well, you can only call them old pussies who love to potter round with a trowel and do the gardening." Mrs. Emmett fails to realize that her audience, Miss. Marple "an inveterate gardener" fits just exactly this description!
Overall, it was a wonderful read, with a cast of interesting characters and a complex mystery to unravel. It is one of my favorites of the Miss. Marple series. How wonderful to wile away the hours with family and 'old friends.'
I'll leave you with one final pearl of wisdom from Miss. Marple, which seems particularly apt, "One needs a great deal of courage to get through life."
I love that this book begins with making a cup of tea. The first sentence, "It was Miss Somer's turn to make the tea." Apparently, she was not very good at it, and was "the most inefficient of typists" to boot, with "a mild worried face like a sheep."
Growing up in England I learned that the water needed to come to a full boil to make a good cup of tea. Alas, "Poor Miss Somer's was never quite sure when a kettle was boiling. It was one of the many worries that afflicted her in life."
Miss Marple is renowned for her ability to winkle out the details from people. They confide in her openly, as she appears harmless. Indeed, people seem to fall over themselves to share their juicy bits of gossip or their opinions on things. One such person was the lonely Mrs. Emmett, the bank manager's wife.
"The necessity to talk grew upon Mrs. Emmett, and on that particular day it had burst its bounds, and Miss. Marple had received the full flood of the torrent." Mrs. Emmett's complaints about village life and the inhabitants in particular illustrate the nuances of class and how she did not fit in "the old guard of ladies" and she could not "associate with the wives of trades people" either. In short, Mrs. Emmett had become an unlikeable snob who lacked self-awareness and had managed to isolate herself.
Narrator, Richard E Grant reads her diatribe with such great expression and captures her disdain with particular feeling. One phrase in particular stood out to us, "Then, of course, there's a sprinkling of - well, you can only call them old pussies who love to potter round with a trowel and do the gardening." Mrs. Emmett fails to realize that her audience, Miss. Marple "an inveterate gardener" fits just exactly this description!
Overall, it was a wonderful read, with a cast of interesting characters and a complex mystery to unravel. It is one of my favorites of the Miss. Marple series. How wonderful to wile away the hours with family and 'old friends.'
I'll leave you with one final pearl of wisdom from Miss. Marple, which seems particularly apt, "One needs a great deal of courage to get through life."
April 5, 2019
3.75*
It’s the beginning of the month, which means time for another Christie book ;0)
I remembered this one quite clearly, having read it a few years ago. It felt somewhat different. On one side, we have a Miss Marple story, although our favourite old lady doesn’t come on the scene until around the middle of the book and stays in the background, and on the other a pretty ruthless murderer, hidden from sight until the very end.
The narrative is very deceptive, immersing itself in the life of this household, going from character to character, focusing on what looks like trivial things, until you realise the audacity of the killer. In theory, I loved Christie’s portrayal of all these protagonists, killer included, but on the other I didn’t ‘connect’ as much as I usually do.
It’s the beginning of the month, which means time for another Christie book ;0)
I remembered this one quite clearly, having read it a few years ago. It felt somewhat different. On one side, we have a Miss Marple story, although our favourite old lady doesn’t come on the scene until around the middle of the book and stays in the background, and on the other a pretty ruthless murderer, hidden from sight until the very end.
The narrative is very deceptive, immersing itself in the life of this household, going from character to character, focusing on what looks like trivial things, until you realise the audacity of the killer. In theory, I loved Christie’s portrayal of all these protagonists, killer included, but on the other I didn’t ‘connect’ as much as I usually do.
August 25, 2025
Fun, but forgettable. The plot is a bit tortured as Christie tries to get all the bits to conform to the classic nursery rhyme. (Sing a song of sixpence, a pocket full of rye, four and twenty blackbirds baked in a pie).
Still, another good distraction …
Still, another good distraction …
March 6, 2016
A most interesting fact about my interpretation of detective books is that I'm not able to appreciate and rate with the consensus how good the outcome of an investigation is. Many people swear by the cleverness of the murderer's alibi. Not me; it's not a deliberate choice, I simply can't appreciate the subtlety of a water tight crime. The way I see it, is that if the journey is good, and if there are startling revelations, and if I can put a face to a well depicted character, then the said book would have fulfilled its purpose of providing me with a roller coaster ride. A Pocket Full of Rye does more than tick all the boxes.
I did notice two jarring notes in this very entertaining book. First time ever, has Miss Marple been described as tall. I never imagined her as beyond 5 feet 10 inches, tops. Almost all female characters are regularly said to be tall. One impossible explanation that occurred to me was that the author somehow had the word ringing in her brain, and wrote the entire book in one sitting. The more plausible reason was that it was a reference to something from her life. She deliberately planted the word tall throughout her book. Anyway, I'll never imagine Miss Marple as taller than average, because she was old and she must have shrunk somewhat. Elementary, my dear.
The second thing concerned the last sentence in the book: "...successfully reconstructed an extinct animal from a fragment of jawbone and a couple of teeth." That was a haphazard phrase thrown in making the last line look very abrupt. Moving on, I'd like to say that this Inspector Neele person is a super Lestrade. He is allowed one generous, clever deduction, and that was the blackmail of Jennifer Fortescue by Mary Dove. I also thought it was too much that the author made of Mary an accomplice to thieves. Too much going on, I would have liked Mary Dove to remain impassive to the end. Perhaps the author, having pitted Neele's wits against Mary's impassiveness, just had to make the Inspector put one over Mary Dove.
Despite these middling things, I had great fun reading this mystery. This book is greater than the sum of its parts. The letter and photo scene near the end provided a vital clue but was also poignant. It was a little piteous to see tears in Miss Marple eyes.
I did notice two jarring notes in this very entertaining book. First time ever, has Miss Marple been described as tall. I never imagined her as beyond 5 feet 10 inches, tops. Almost all female characters are regularly said to be tall. One impossible explanation that occurred to me was that the author somehow had the word ringing in her brain, and wrote the entire book in one sitting. The more plausible reason was that it was a reference to something from her life. She deliberately planted the word tall throughout her book. Anyway, I'll never imagine Miss Marple as taller than average, because she was old and she must have shrunk somewhat. Elementary, my dear.
The second thing concerned the last sentence in the book: "...successfully reconstructed an extinct animal from a fragment of jawbone and a couple of teeth." That was a haphazard phrase thrown in making the last line look very abrupt. Moving on, I'd like to say that this Inspector Neele person is a super Lestrade. He is allowed one generous, clever deduction, and that was the blackmail of Jennifer Fortescue by Mary Dove. I also thought it was too much that the author made of Mary an accomplice to thieves. Too much going on, I would have liked Mary Dove to remain impassive to the end. Perhaps the author, having pitted Neele's wits against Mary's impassiveness, just had to make the Inspector put one over Mary Dove.
Despite these middling things, I had great fun reading this mystery. This book is greater than the sum of its parts. The letter and photo scene near the end provided a vital clue but was also poignant. It was a little piteous to see tears in Miss Marple eyes.
August 17, 2020
Sing a song of sixpence, a pocketful of rye, four and 20 blackbirds baked in a pie. When the pie was opened, the birds began to sing. Now wasn't that a dainty dish to set before a king?
A standard-issue Christie mystery, focused on rhyme crime (see what I did there?) Inspector Neal does a decent job sifting through the inevitable Possible Suspects for half the book until little ol’ Jane Marple that Christie has for three books called, the “old pussy” (and sometimes “the old tabby” comes to help him solve the crime.
Everything is mostly meant to be amusing, though in keeping with the rhyme, several crimes (i.e., murders) take place.
Random stuff that sticks in my mind now, but not for long maybe:
*One inspector says he is relieved that this particular (first) poisoning is done with Taxine, from Yewberries or their leaves instead of the usual weedkiller. I smiled at that, but it’s either funny or corny to you that this murder takes place on Yewberry Lane.
*This is one of several Christie murder mysteries in part based on children’s songs or nursery rhymes. So we need to get blackbirds baked into a pie somewhere. Check!
*And victims have pockets full of rye, too. Why rye? Why pie? Why die? Sigh.
*Everyone wants the first victim, Rex, to die. This is common in Christie so we can keep the number of suspects at a high level.
*In almost every single book from Christie people decide the murderer must be “mad” and (spoiler alert) almost never is.
* "The kettle was not quite boiling when Miss Somers poured the water on the tea, but poor Miss Somers was never quite sure when a kettle was boiling. It was one of the many worries that afflicted her in life." :)
I do like Agatha Christie; this is not her best work, but at maybe book 55, she knows what she is doing. This one just does not stand out for me. And I like just fine Jane Marple, who has that interesting combination of being charming and with a low view of human nature. And I did like the fact that the actual murderer she identifies was a surprise to me, clever old. . . woman (he says in contemporary, more respectful language).
January 5, 2025
Agatha Christie almost never fails me, this was another interesting murder mystery.
December 26, 2023
4 Stars. Just a touch from the top of Christie's Miss Marple oeuvre. I was wondering why. Perhaps it's because most of the members of the household in which the dastardly deeds take place are not sympathetic characters. Or perhaps it's because Miss Marple visits only fleetingly. A leading financier, Rex Fortescue, is at his office one morning and suddenly collapses. His is a painful death which is over mercifully soon. When his pockets are turned out, one is found full of rye grain! The poison is taxine from the berries of the common yew tree. But who's the culprit? Collectively we flounder as clues are checked by Inspector Neele. It is not until after the death of Gladys Martin, a young, impressionable maid in the household, she had worked previously for Miss Marple, that our heroine shows up and recites the old nursery rhyme. "Sing a song of sixpence, a pocketful of rye, four and twenty blackbirds baked in a pie." There may be a connection she says. Does it relate to the old Blackbird Mine in west Africa? And the possible theft of it by Mr. Fortescue from the MacKenzie family so many years ago? Is that it? Or something else? The ending's a good one. (Oc2020/De2023)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 3,330 reviews