I bought this for my boy, and he has been leaving it on the shelf in our living room, so I was just sitting there and thought I would take a look. Now I feel compelled to share.
Mythos: Captain America: Paolo Rivera's art is pretty, all muted tones and gentle brush strokes, but Paul Jenkins writing doesn't do anything for me, but that could be because I am a long time fan of Captain America. I love the old geezer, and I've read countless versions of his origin story, even seen a couple in moving pictures, and this one, with its focus on the "Golden Generation," along with plenty of saccharine humility on Cap's part was an inauspicious beginning to the sequence of origin stories. Oh well, I really picked up the book to read Vision's creation again (it's been years), so I'll keep plugging away when the feeling takes me.
Mythos: Hulk: Booooorrrrrrring. Why even bother with the retelling of this origin? Throwing in an iPad for Rick Jones and making him a maintenance man, making Bruce a pacifist, cutting Bruce funding, these things added nothing worthwhile to the classic story. The art was pretty, though, just like the Captain America retelling. I am hoping that at least one of these chapters has more worth than some pretty art.
I can't really be bothered to break these all down. The art is pretty throughout, but only one story benefited from the updated, classy treatment -- Luke Cage. Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch & Ant Man and Wasp both suffered from packing too much emotional baggage into too short a space. Vision hit all the right plot points, but left me as cold as the android Avenger's emotions. And Thor was Thor: arrogant at first, less arrogant later on, bellicose at first less bellicose later on, thick at first, less thick later on. The best part of Thor was that we got to see Sif's hair shift from her mythologoical golden locks to her jet black Marvel locks, which was also the saddest part.
Great for someone who is new to the Avengers, but mostly annoying if one already knows these stories. It would have been better if the origins of Captain America, Hulk and Thor had been replaced by more peripheral Avengers. But my eight year old son enjoys it, so I suppose it works for the classic demographic if no one else.