I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest (non-reciprocal) review.
(Spoilers within)
PROS:
- I liked the two main characters, Luke and Anya, and they had some good lines. I particularly liked Anya's thought:
"Maybe she could throw the couch at him, all she'd need would be a forklift."
At the end I was genuinely interested in what would happen with Luke and Anya.
- The plot was quite good and I was interested in what was going on with the reaper and the graces.
- The world was constructed well enough to paint a pretty good picture.
- I really enjoyed the parts where they were attempting to solve the crime, as well as the confrontation near the end.
CONS:
- Sometimes the hatred made no sense to me. For example, in this part:
"What am I allowed to do?" He asked finally.
"Nothing we haven't allowed." Immogy said quickly.
Luke frowned at him, which always seemed to irritate Immogy more for some reason. As if to illustrate that, Immogy scowled at him. "Don't look at me like that, boy. If it were up to me, you wouldn't be allowed to look at me at all."
Luke nodded silently and tried to change whatever expression was on his face to a more neutral one. "I just want to understand what's expected of me."
"Really? Is that what you want?" Immogy asked, narrowing his gaze on him. "Does it matter what you want?"
To explain, Luke is discovering that he's going to be sent after a serial killer. He hasn't been out in the world for probably over a decade. He asks what he's allowed to do, and for some reason the question is treated as an offense. It just makes no sense. He's not defying orders, he's asking what permissions he has in order to complete the given task. It would make sense for them to want him to have a clear set of rules he must follow.
- Repetitiveness. This was a pretty big issue with the book. Here's an example:
Chapter 15
"She could probably argue temporary insanity. Yes, that was it, Anya thought, she was insane. Or maybe it was the bump on her head, or maybe she was still passed out on the floor of her apartment, hallucinating all this. No, probably not that last one, her feet were complaining too much.
She could blame it on the pills the doctors had given her, or on the bump on her head, or even the pain."
Or a smaller one:
"His muscles complained at the movement when he ordered himself to move..."
It wasn't just the same words or phrases being used close to each other, but many of the same descriptions or actions would be used again and again. If you start reading this book, try to count how many times there's darkness in Luke's eyes.
Another was having characters roll their eyes, which I thought was even a larger problem when characters of high status did it. For the average person, such as Anya, eye rolling might be expected. But when it comes to someone who is meant to be the leader of a country, eye rolling comes off as childish and seems like something they would avoid doing.
- It took me a long time to get into this book. I was probably about 35% in before the story picked up. Maybe around 65% in it started dragging again for another long while, and picked up at the end. Part of this was because of what I pointed out above; different points were constantly being pounded on over and over in the story.
There were also parts that I think could have been eliminated altogether. Chapter 1 could have been deleted entirely. The story starts off with Luke, then in chapter 1 it switches off to a bunch of different people, only to switch back again and stay with Luke almost the entire story. It was disorienting, and when the story finally got to Anya I don't think I'd learned anything in chapter 1 that I needed to know.
I liked the story, but how much it lagged at parts really brought it down for me. If I hadn't been reading it to do a review I probably would have stopped reading it early on; which is too bad because there are good parts in there.