When Ruby's mother never comes home, leaving her to take care of the small rented house, keep their job bringing lost airport luggage to people, and making it to school all on her own for about three months, Ruby thinks she's handling things fine. When the landlords discover she's been living like this, she's quickly taken away and given over to the care of her sister Cora, who, ten years older, married to a man who co-founded a Facebook-type online community, and a lawyer herself, hasn't been seen or heard from by Ruby since Cora left for university.
Estranged from a sister she was once incredibly close to and even dependent on, Ruby's determined to make it on her own. After all, she'll be turning eighteen soon and then no one can hold her. Sent to the expensive, elite private school Cora's husband used to attend, she's also determined not to make any friends. It's all temporary, she doesn't fit in. But her good-looking neighbour Nate slowly draws her into a real friendship - until she realises he's just like her, refusing to let anyone help when it really matters, and Ruby has to decide whether she really wants to be like her mother, running from those who need her, or like Cora, protective and compassionate.
I have mixed feelings about this book. The writing is fine enough, the pacing steady, and so on, but there was a very formulaic feel to the novel. It was like watching a typical Hollywood drama, or a Danielle Steele telemovie. It was just so neat. So tidy. Even when Ruby was visiting her old drug-dealer friend and on/off lover, there was no real grit. It wasn't that Ruby's story wasn't believable, but that Dessen herself had packaged it so nicely. I don't know anything about the author, but it felt like she was writing about something she didn't really understand.
Other aspects of the story, like the story arc itself, were horribly conventional and predictable. Sadly, there's nothing original here - unless you count the 'orrible gaff of saying "Organic free-trade" instead of "Organic Fair Trade" (p.133) - there's a BIG difference! (and you don't say something's Free Trade; it's the default, the whole idea is that Free Trade exploits people and Fair doesn't, therefore it's a selling point). The characters were clichés, even Ruby, who struggled to exude any kind of charisma, and I'm wondering whether there are any teen books out there that aren't about beautiful rich people. Why did Cora and her husband Jamie need to be so incredibly wealthy? Simply to provide the opposite extreme to Ruby's previous life? It came across as garish and insensitive. Why doesn't anyone write stories about the middle class? Or maybe I should say, why doesn't anyone want to read them?
Lock and Key is a terribly safe story. It attempts to examine issues of the heart, growing up, dealing with extremes - but other than making an effort to "show" rather than constantly "tell", it's heavy-handed and often boring.
Having beaten the book down so much, I do have to add that it was a pleasant read, fairly intriguing, and I did feel sympathetic for Ruby, Cora and Jamie at times - but I'm not terribly interested in reading more of Dessen's books. But I have little doubt that as a young teenager I would have really enjoyed this book, so it's probably an age thing.