Getting the Marriage Conversation Right: A Guide for Effective Dialogue teaches you how to promote and defend traditional marriage in non-religious terms. It’s a great “how to” guide to answer those tough questions you’ve struggled with. Author William B. May shows you how to navigate the pitfalls and avoid making this a gay vs. Christian issue. May brings into the legal definition of marriage the rights of children, and provides sensible guidelines on how to avoid common traps that hinder communications for advocating public policy about marriage. Getting the Marriage Conversation Right includes a substantial section of FAQs at the heart of the conflict. Marriage is the only institution that unites kids with their moms and dads, and that has been recognized by every culture, society, and religion, each according to their own competencies. Getting the Marriage Conversation Right shows how to get that interest recognized in laws, societal institutions, and individuals, and begin to rebuild a marriage culture.
This is an excellent resource for helping you to articulate your position on traditional marriage. It is simply written and a quick read. It has a question and answer section which helps you to formulate answers to the most typical objections to traditional marriage. I highly recommend this to anyone interested in the subject.
While the sections addressing the concept of the “no right to children” were particularly interesting, he fails to fully explore the idea of why biological parents are necessary (believing it to be self evident) and that omission ultimately undercuts his core argument. Repetition stands in for detailed analysis, and while the work provides some insights into the argument for traditional marriage, it is clearly intended as a brief guidebook for winning arguments in a secular setting, not for explaining the Church’s teachings. I was dissatisfied with the brief treatment of adoption, but on the whole it provided a respectful treatment of the topic of same-sex marriage and clearly explains the author’s rationale for opposing it
Edit: By "he fails to fully explore the idea of why biological parents are necessary (believing it to be self evident)" I mean, he fails to explore the idea of why is is necessary for children to know and have a relationship with both their biological mother and biological father (believing it to be self evident)
This booklet (68 small pages of text) is helpful in the discussion of what marriage really is. The entire work is based on pitting the fact of marriage as "unit[ing] a man and a woman with each other and any children born from that union" against those who wish to redefine marriage as "the public recognition of a committed relationship between a man and a woman (or two adults) for their fulfillment." This is the thread that runs through this six part booklet. The use of secular arguments for traditional marriage (the book also provides Catholic support for these arguments) is meant to allow the defender of marriage to engage the conversation without explicitly relying on religious belief. The underpinnings of author William B. May's position are laid out in part four, "common traps" to avoid when arguing for traditional marriage compose part five, but maybe the most valuable section is the last part in which May gives short but solid answers to many questions proponents of same-sex "marriage" ask of those who oppose such a concept. Not all are as complete or extensive as I'd like to see them, but for purposes of what he is trying to accomplish, they provide a firm foundation and jumping off point.
I'm not sure anything provided here cannot be found elsewhere on internet sites promoting and defending traditional marriage, but the convenience of having a significant amount of information in a short and quick read that can be studied and referred to again and again or passed along is valuable. Volume discounts make this useful for mass distribution (e.g., parishes) or group study.
This short work is a valuable introduction to the current marriage debate but, for those who want to go deeper, other resources (like "What is Marriage" by Girgis, Anderson, and George) will be required.
This is a little book, makes for a quick read. Although I strongly believe in marriage before children, I couldn't agree with all of this. Yeah every kid wants a mother and father. No doubt about it. And yeah. society would probably be better with more people marrying before having the babies. Things do seem to loosey, goosey now. We don't think twice about the consequences of a child born to parents that aren't married or even living together. And no we can't over look the issues the child could face without both parents around. However this at times was very much an anti-gay book. I don't think we can just encourage more happily married people to go out and adopt the children that are orphans. When someone makes a commitment to a child, any child, that is such a huge sacrifice to the person making that commitment to that child. They have to put that kid first before so much other stuff in their life. You can' t just say we need to encourage this more. Won't happen like that. And yeah a gay couple can't make a baby by themselves, but that doesn't mean they can't be good parents and raise a happy child. There are some good things that do come out of living this way. Women and for that matter and men aren't stuck in unhappy, abusive marriages either. That should count for something. I don't think that kids being raised in an unhappy marriage are necessarily any better off being around the fighting etc. I agree if we all lived the life the way this author suggests, we could solve some of the world's problems but there are more issues to it than I think this author knows there are.
I received this in the mail from the great folks at Emmaus Road Publishing. This is a great Catholic publisher that is true to the teachings of the Church and prints many great books. In exchange for this book, I just had to write an honest review.
This 70 page book is a quick read, but it packs a powerful message. In this book, we get a definition of what is going on in our current society with regards to marriage, and how society is trying to rid itself of traditional marriage. This is sad indeed, because as the book states, "Marriage unites a man and woman with each other and any children born from their union." No other societal institution does that, and if traditional marriage was compromised, an institution would need to be created to fill the requirements of the quote above.
What I like best about this book is the Question and Answer section in the back. Even after reading through documents and books such as this, I still find that I have a hard time answering frequent objections and questions that people of the opposing viewpoint have. I also like that this book tries to answer the question from more than a religious standpoint. Those who disagree with us will always disagree with us if all we have to argue them is our "faith." Overall, I would give this book 4 out of 5 stars. It is orthodox, authentic, helpful, and necessary, but it wouldn't be a book I would actively seek out to read. Check out my other reviews at http://stuartsstudy.blogspot.com
I won this book on Goodreads First Read and I must have missed the description of the book. This is not a book about how to communicate within a marriage. It is a book about how to have a conversation about marriage, coming from a viewpoint of Christianity or specifically Catholicism. It is well written, and for someone who is Catholic, it would give very specific information if one is going to debate or discuss where the Church stands on marriage. Half of the book is spent on marriage vs. commitment for gays and lesbians. Because I am not a Christian, I had to sort of go back to my Baptist upbringing in order to review it and even read it from an unbiased viewpoint, it is meant for a different reader. However, Christians would most certainly find it to be informative, especially if they are going to have that conversation with liberal counterparts. I think that the title is misrepresenting its actual contents, but the writing is decent, with an attempt to be non-confrontational, the information is simply what we have heard before within arguments by more fundamentalist believers, but categorized to make for easier understanding. Because the book is not meant for readers such as myself, I will probably donate it to our local Catholic church, since it would be put to better use by one of the parishioners than gathering dust on my bookshelf.
This is a clear defense of marriage. It is written by a Catholic and is clearly consistent with Catholic principles. However, the logical discussion is not based on religious doctrine. It is only 70 pages and the last chapter is an extensive list of common arguments for the redefinition marriage and the rational responses that refute them. There is a lot of repetition in the book so sometimes I felt frustrated because the same point was made over and over. However, if you are using this book to prepare yourself to speak intelligently about the topic of marriage and why it must be between one man and one woman, the repetition drives home the key points. Definitely a good starting point for the discussion.
I guess I thought this was going to be something different. I thought it would be like tips for marriage conversations between a wife and husband, but it was not at all. I already agree with their thoughts on being married and starting a family. It's sad to see all the divorces these days and families tore apart. I think people get married too quick these days. I waited 5 years to marry my husband and there is nothing that we won't be able to get through together. Unlike many others divorce is not an option for us!