This is a very peculiar, outlier of a book for me because it firstly has the severe flaw of having many elements of poor writing, both in the actual syntax of the writing and the elements of the tale, yet I am oddly intrigued and fascinated by the book enough to have read it several times.
The Binding is sort of what I'd expect to see on Wattpad or uploaded to DeviantArt in chapters--it's very raw, very much the kind of thing everyone who wants to be a writer would come up with when they're 16 and decide they're gonna write a novel. It could have benefited immensely from revision and editing, but there's something to the rawness, to that "I just sat down and write a story and put it on Amazon because I wanted to" vibe that makes it engaging for some reason that I cannot for the life of me fully comprehend or explain. I've put off writing this review for over two years purely because I just cannot express what it is that keeps me coming back to this book even though I can literally write a HUGE list of every error, awkward sentence, rushed plot point, continuity error, and convenient plot device used in just this 1 part of the trilogy.
I can only equate it to loving a bad movie but loving it anyway despite KNOWING it's got some severe flaws and isn't winning any awards but it just Has That Something.
The basis of The Binding is a pretty typical fantasy: Lily is a half-human elf princess from San Diego who never knew she was a princess because she was raised in the human world after her mother's assassination. On her 18th birthday she is rescued by an elf and told she's betrothed to him, an elf prince, and she has to use her elf powers of talking to the earth and plants and healing and her birthright as the willow clan's heir to take her place in part of a marriage-treaty and prophecy to save the land of Velesi from annihilation from both civil unrest and an unknown enemy of pure evil. Lily has her best friend, Tharin has his gaggle of relatives to map out his little crew, and there's a big dash of drama and insta-love and magic and cliche, corny, awkward pieces tossed in for good measure.
I think with some tweaking and revision, the basic concepts and character development are not bad--the book reads like a book and has the necessary pieces to feel like this is something that was thought out. The author has a lot of good ideas (and some cliche/typical/etc. kind of ideas), it's just that they often end up really raw or rushed which causes things to move at an unrealistic pace, suffer continuity issues, have conflicts within the information presented, have unnecessary fluff/bulk, or sound awkward with the inner dialog/thoughts/character's behavior. It almost feels like reading a manuscript that a very new, amateur author just churned out and submitted to see if the core of the story is worth revising.
But I won't harp on this too much because this book is in fact an author's very first attempt at writing a full length novel and it is self-published and is currently seven years old at the time I'm writing this review. It's clear to me this is a work of just pure passion and joy for the author, like someone writing a fan fiction--they enjoy the act of creating a story and writing it down and want to share it even though they don't have a degree in creative writing or a team to help them polish or even a promise of a paycheck at the end. I believe the author was middle age when she wrote and published this, but even so I don't hold the flaws of the book against her too much because there's something to her story that at the very least drew me in. It's just that it could have been something far better had the author had the resources of a editing team and agent behind her, cleaning up the awkward things, catching the errors, helping her sort through the jumble of her ideas to carefully select which ones were the ones that needed to be added and which needed to be cut.
For me, this is a kind of typical, basic, enjoyable, bad but good kind of cheap self-published Kindle book that just scratches a particular kind of itch. If you don't think too hard about the book it's a casual, easy-on-you sort of read that is everything a 12-14 year old fantasy book lover wants to read about and the kind of thing they'd think is amazing and probably daydream about writing because the heroine is kind of a Special Snowflake who will save the world with her kindness and smarts and willpower and she loves her best friend and wants to do the right thing and there's hot elves doing magic.
I honestly can't explain why a book that gives me the vibe of something I'd read weekly online chapter by chapter at the age of 13 is oddly endearing to me as a 23 year old. I can't explain it and I try not to question it too much because my brain might just pop if I look inward that hard, but it just goes to show that preference is a unique, highly subjective thing and that there's ample reason to take a risk on just about any book that seems remotely interesting because it might just appeal to you in a bizarre way you can't for the life of you understand.