I can't say it was the best thing I ever read. I can't say it was the worst. But I can say...I think I was a bit too old for it.
"Inheritance" plays as the ultimate fantasy of every bullied child - to be whisked away to a magical land where, with the help of loyal companions and a trusty sword, one can confront one's tormentors and find new strength. Delicate sensibilities might take offense at the child abuse detailed in the earlier chapters, in its brutal and inventive forms. However, "Inheritance" seems meant to be a YA novel, and thus the more violent sequences are relegated to two-sentence remembrances. For older, more mature audiences (and especially audiences with experience regarding any form of abuse), the depictions may lack emotional impact; but for a typical audience of pre- to mid-teens, the sequences walk a line that is decidedly PG-13 in all but the simple idea. Its use is a brave one, and despite the sequences' shortcomings, it gives a legitimate fuel for Kimberly's quest and keeps this book from becoming another magical-girl tale about a quest she would have no reason to undertake.
That being said, make no mistake: this IS a magical-girl story. Scrawny teenager gets drawn into a magical world by her animal familiar (the adorable Ip), who acts as her guide and guardian through much of the tale, and joins up with a group of like-minded companions to battle a sinister foe. It's just not one driven by romance or, in the worst cases, absolutely nothing. Still, those who had no patience for "Sailor Moon," "Star Wars," or "Lord of the Rings" need not apply.
(Yes, "Star Wars" is a magical-girl story. The fact that Luke Skywalker is a boy makes no difference.)
The actual writing quality is...decent. Some of the action is glossed over too quickly for my taste, and I could have done with some much more intensive character development in the early chapters. While Kimberly experiences highs and lows, we don't seem to ride the ride with her until the last third of the book, and her life with her family seems to be a mundane muddle punctuated by what masquerades as emotion. Perhaps appropriate, given her family life, but a slow and rather gummy start that belies its early incarnation.
Kimberly's companions in Auviarra smack soundly of a "Dungeons & Dragons" team - a ragtag band of warriors and half-breeds who carouse through the kingdom in search of fortune. (Although if anyone has seen the attempts Hollywood has made at the D&D franchise, one will understand that it's hard for any author to do any worse.) Even with this in mind, there is a reasonable amount of character development within the group for a first installment - a delightful twist as to the identity of one, and lingering unanswered questions about the past of another.
And the ending. If the book sneaks up on you as it did for me and wraps its vines and tendrils around your hands at the halfway point, you will find yourself very grateful that "Pursuit" is already available for immediate consumption, because the sudden surprise leaves you demanding answers and cursing yourself for obligations like work. Or sleep. Or personal hygiene.
On a purely subjective note referring to the paperback edition: those who spent most of first through third grades having Capitalization, Usage, Punctuation, and Spelling (CUPS) beaten into their brains might have a hard time with last two-thirds of the book. Capitalization errors abound, gremlins sneak in to pilfer the periods from the last sentences of many paragraphs, and one character is found wielding a "silvery bade." (I spent far too long trying to figure out what sort of new magical weapon that was.) Nothing that a few more passes through a proofreader (or in some cases, the spelling and grammar check on MS Word) couldn't fix, and for many readers they wouldn't inhibit comprehension, but such blatant errors tend to result in a book's sudden collision with my drywall. Except that I would have bent the covers in that case.
All that said, it's a compilation of good ideas and (at least once we get to Auviarra) snarky dialogue, and well worth a lazy afternoon or two.