The press release detailing Alison Wearing’s book, “Confessions of a Fairy’s Daughter”, had me pumped. At last, I might get some insight into how my four children felt growing up with a gay Dad.
“Confessions” is a combination memoir/biography with Part One detailing Alison’s life from childhood through to a young adult in Peterborough, Ontario. Part Two, “The Way He Saw It”, becomes biographical and is based on the contents of a box which her father gives her containing his diary, newspaper clippings, drafts of letters to friends and family, letters from friends, and notes to self during the first several years after coming out as a gay father. Part Three returns to a memoir format as Alison returns to live with her mother for a time and learns the emotions her mother experienced when discovering a love letter that her husband has written to another man and the dissolving of their marriage. Part Four, “The Way We See it Now” brings the reader to current times as the entire extended family gathers to celebrate her father’s seventy fifth birthday.
Alison describes a normal childhood with a vigorous sense of humour, (frequent belly laughs). Her father, an amateur choral conductor, has a passion for baking croissants, wearing silk pyjamas around the house and Gilbert and Sullivan. All is well with Alison’s world until her father takes an apartment in Toronto, spending weekends there, but remaining with the family during the week as he continues to teach at Trent University in Peterborough. Alison is puzzled why this is necessary but she begins to enjoy weekends in Toronto with her father, discovering new ethnic foods and being entertained by his friends at gay dinner parties.
Alison survives her father’s coming out, her parent’s divorce, her mothers remarriage and her father’s partnership with Lance, an Alberta farm boy. The first Christmas with her mother and her new husband, 2 brothers and 4 step siblings is described as kaleidoscopic as one of the step brothers decides to remove the tension by serving Christmas breakfast tea spiced with magic mushrooms. Christmas dinner did not happen until midnight, by which time the kids had spent the day playing poker, dying their hair pink and bonding as a new family.
She copes well with the border crossings from her mothers home to her fathers and back again and realizes that life with her gay father is far more entertaining and enjoyable than life with an heterosexual father. Her difficulty is with the rest of society as she watches the door to her father’s relationships with his brother and his sister slam shut. Toronto bathhouse raids and late 70s/early 80s attitudes force Alison to outwardly deny her father’s sexuality. She battles a Bulimia addiction, and deciding that she cannot escape Peterborough fast enough, she heads off to a language program at a University in France upon graduating high school.
The mood darkens further, as she writes from the contents of her fathers box of memoirs, revealing his despair and frustration after making the gut wrenching decision to pursue life as a gay man, reducing his time spent with his children and ending his marriage. He has discovered that yes, sex with a man can be as great as he imagined, but grows tired of meaningless one night stands and finds support from Gay Fathers of Toronto. Included are several letters from Arthur Motyer, a former colleague and friend from the mid 1960s, written on Mount Allison University letterhead, where Arthur taught for twenty-three years. Arthur, also a gay father, had already walked the road that Alison’s father was treading.
There are some surprise side stories such as a friendship with Pierre Trudeau as a result of her father’s life long association with the federal Liberal party. Step parents/partners of gay parents will admire Lance’s wisdom in giving space for Alison and her father’s relationship to continue to grow, never becoming a second father, but certainly a treasured and loved part of the family. Alison is unsure when having a gay father became as normal for her as having tea in the morning; perhaps it was when her six year old son describing how much two people love each other used the example of Granddad and Lance.
This true to life story takes place during decades of extreme change in Canadian gay, lesbian, bisexual, transsexual and queer history, (homosexuality was decriminalized the year Alison was toilet-trained). The Historian will appreciate the impact of Toronto bathhouse raids and Canadian society’s attitudes on an adolescent daughter of a gay man. Children of gay parents will relate to Alison’s experiences and Confessions of a Fairy’s Daughter is A MUST READ for every GLBTQ parent who has struggled to balance their true selves with love for and responsibility to their children.
I re read this book and enjoyed it every bit as much as the first time through, almost 2 years ago. Then I had the opportunity to attend her 70 minute monologue based on excerpts from the first section of this book. Very very well done.