2021 Reprint of the 1935 Edition. Leninism or Marxism? was first published as an article in 1904 under the title "Organizational Questions of the Russian Social Democracy" and later reprinted in pamphlet form titled Marxism vs. Leninism in 1935 by the Anti-Parliamentary Communist Federation.
Rosa Luxemburg's critique of Lenin's concept of revolutionary organization show the disagreements within the Marxist movements in Europe in the years preceding 1917; her comparisons with Blanquism and chillingly accurate predictions of the consequences of such organization in a successful revolution are incredibly important to an understanding of the differing interpretations of Marx at that time in relation to the State and its relationship with workers.
Rosa Luxemburg (Rosalia Luxemburg, Polish: Róża Luksemburg) was a Marxist theorist, philosopher, economist and activist of Polish Jewish descent who became a naturalized German citizen. She was successively a member of the Social Democracy of the Kingdom of Poland and Lithuania, the Social Democratic Party of Germany(SPD), the Independent Social Democratic Party and the Communist Party of Germany.
In 1915, after the SPD supported German involvement in World War I, she co-founded, with Karl Liebknecht, the anti-war Spartakusbund (Spartacist League). On 1 January 1919 the Spartacist League became the Communist Party of Germany (KPD). In November 1918, during the German Revolution she founded the Die Rote Fahne (The Red Flag), the central organ of the Spartacist movement.
She regarded the Spartacist uprising of January 1919 in Berlin as a blunder, but supported it after Liebknecht ordered it without her knowledge. When the revolt was crushed by the social democrat government and the Freikorps (WWI veterans defending the Weimar Republic), Luxemburg, Liebknecht and some of their supporters were captured and murdered. Luxemburg was drowned in the Landwehr Canal in Berlin. After their deaths, Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht became martyrs for Marxists. According to the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, commemoration of Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht continues to play an important role among the German far-left.
Luxemburg's "Organizational Questions" addresses the debate over the degree of centralization and autonomy which the workers' organizations should employ. These questions are still hotly debated today. It is short and worth the read. Read further only to understand the historical context of the debate.
The material conditions which Luxemburg and Lenin lived, and which contributed to their views, were in stark contrast. Industrialized Germany possessed a much larger working class, as well as a larger and more national owner class. Russia, which had scarcely begun to industrialize, possessed a small working class as well as owner class, but in industrializing countries the owner class includes a bulk of foreign investors. When the revolution in Russia succeeded, we could say definitively that Luxemburg underestimated the foreign character of capital ownership. Democratic Centralism was the first successful organizational structure of the working class.
Workers' States have, so far, only been established in the third world—in former colonies. The owner class is much weaker in these places. There are significantly fewer workers organizations as well. These are the conditions which Centralism has been most effective. In the first world Centralist orgs have played an important role, but they have so far failed. Maoists argue this is a historic necessity. Luxemburg, however, would argue that the historic conditions in industrialized countries compel the working class into a plurality of working class organizations, and that this plurality must be organized under one Social Democratic Party (Decentralized).
This is usually just a theoretical debate. We're all in the same struggle, and healthy orgs work together. Luxemburg's is just one view of many, but it's a valuable view to understand.
Fascinating article. On the one hand, it reflects a perspective that Rosa herself would acknowledge as a mistake, tragically far too late for both her and the rest of the German working class. On the other, with some things that should be looked at critically, it reflects a lot of valuable lessons for Marxists today, particularly in combatting sectarianism and disconnection from the struggle. The article bends too far towards spontaneity, but this has to be understood as how Rosa sought to fight against the strengthening opportunist trend in German Social-Democracy, who sought to stifle the revolutionary movement of the workers.
One of the most valuable tools that the ruling class has used across history is the tactic of division, pitting one layer of the oppressed against another. Just the same way, both the conscious and unwitting agents of the bourgeois try to divide the great Marxist revolutionaries, make their ideas seem opposed. For this case, it’s done by heaping on slander and distortions and erasing about 13 years of history. When it comes to Lenin and Rosa, both Stalinists and Reformists have played into this counter-revolutionary obscuring of Lenin and Rosa’s ideas in their own ways.
The fact is, Rosa and Lenin stood for the exact same principles. Points on this article that they both agree include: that no organizational form is a panacea; that the leadership can’t become disconnected from the ranks; that it is impossible to declare the revolution without the active participation of the masses. They also understood that open discussion directed at united action is the necessary way to build up revolutionaries. If they didn’t, why would Lenin publish this critique in the Bolshevik paper a year after the split at the second congress? They were both implacable in their struggle against opportunism in all its forms, in building the forces of the revolutionary working class and its ideas.
The fact that this article contains mistakes gives it a strength. It can be incredibly useful as a way to understand how even one of the greatest Marxists and revolutionaries in history could be wrong on one of the most key questions. The lessons of the past are not dry facts, they are the material result of the living breathing struggle. How you arrive at a point is inseparable from the point itself.
Luxemburg offers a robust critique of Lenin's theories on centralized leadership within a social democracy. In general, she seems to oppose centralized leadership of any kind and uses the Russian labor movement as a case study. Her argument is specific to the state of the Russian labor movement circa 1904, arguing that the movement's structure was highly vulnerable to cooptation from bourgeois opportunists. I appreciated her argument that you cannot distinguish or separate the social democracy, or its leadership, from the working class. However, I am not necessarily opposed to centralized leadership within a movement so long as it is comprised of the working class and allows the masses to partake in decision making. That being said, I think Luxemburg is right to warn that centralism is vulnerable to bourgeois cooptation that could potentially undermine a social democracy.
"[social democratic activity] . . . arises historically out of the elementary class struggle. It spreads and develops in accordance with the following dialectical contradiction. The proletarian army is recruited and becomes aware of its objectives in the course of the struggle itself. The activity of the party organization, the growth of the proletarians’ awareness of the objectives of the struggle and the struggle itself, are not different things separated chronologically and mechanically. They are only different aspects of the same struggle, there do not exist for the Social Democracy detailed sets of tactics which a Central Committee can teach the party membership in the same way as troops are instructed in their training camps"
Look, Rosa gets a pass because she wrote this in 1904 - before the Russian revolution proved that she is wrong. But modern day so-called socialists do not get a pass. The proletarian's "awareness of the objectives of the struggle" will not be shaped merely by the struggle itself. She goes on to use the upsurge of the St. Petersburg general strike of 1896 as an example that the masses do not need to be moved to revolutionary action by a party.
Yet, this was not revolutionary action - it was as she said, a natural reaction to worsening conditions. That is why a vanguard party must be understood not as a catalyst, but as a guide shaping the movement. The notion by Luxemburg, and unfortunately some in modern times that local organizations can reach out to other primary groups of socialists to form a party from the base up is proven to be a historically incorrect method for making a revolution. Where is the cohesion? Where is the political consolidation if all of these organizations have different aims and goals?
Organizations that begin with a local character end with a local character and are bound not to see the importance of national or international solidarity and any project that makes a claim against this, lets see how the political character of your community center is doing in 5 years.
Rosa incorrectly asserts that centralism means that there is no autonomy or democracy in an organization. This is blatantly false - consultation across a party is necessary for growth and a politically consolidated (centralized) party identifying and training local community leaders towards an ultimate aim is much more effective, and safer approach to revolution.
I mean absolutely no offense to this brilliant socialist mind - but spontaneous, uncoordinated uprisings of the proletariat are literally what got her murdered.
But here is the »ego« of the Russian revolutionary again! Pirouetting on its head, it once more proclaims itself to be the all-powerful director of history—this time with the title of His Excellency the Central Committee of the Social Democratic Party of Russia.
The nimble acrobat fails to perceive that the only »subject« which merits today the role of director is the collective »ego« of the working class. The working class demands the right to make its mistakes and learn the dialectic of history. Let us speak plainly. Historically, the errors committed by a truly revolutionary movement are infinitely more fruitful than the infallibility of the cleverest Central Committee.
This text had strong affinity with economism, which Lenin saw as rearing its head within the Menshevik camp of the RSDLP split. This is Luxemburg's response to the split and to Lenin's One Step Forward Two Steps Back, in which she effectively sides with the Mensheviks. Some have argued that the basis for her argument is a lack of understanding of the situation, and to be fair she is not fully across Lenin's political views in this time. But there is nevertheless a logic of her argument which genuinely had affinity with the Mensheviks. Trotsky took essentially the same position as Luxemburg, so we can't say that this was simply a total misunderstanding.
[It should be noted that it was only in 1935, not by Luxemburg herself, that this article was given the title 'Leninism or Marxism'. Though in Our Misunderstandings, a 1904 pamphlet responding to attacks on the Bolsheviks, Bogdanov did include a section called 'Rosa Luxemburg Against Karl Marx']
An underpinning of the debate leading to the split were ambiguities in the relation between spontaneity and consciousness, movement and party. Those in the Iskra camp who would become Mensheviks asserted the importance of leadership only with an underlying assumption of the tendency towards harmony between Marxism and the workers' movement. Lenin's What Is To Be Done initiated a breach in this logic by emphasising struggle and contradiction, between Marxism and the workers' movement and within the Marxist party itself. It would be Lenin's treatment of spontaneity and consciousness which Mensheviks would come to retroactively identify as the source of what they saw as Lenin's problems, which they initially had reservations about but thought not to press on for the sake of securing Iskra's leading position.
Lenin's emphasis on the need for strict demarcation between party and class in his definition of membership did not invent the idea of a 'vanguard party', but did stress the need for leadership to clearly demarcate itself. Martov thought that the unfolding of the working class movement would align itself with the vanguard once the vanguard was sufficiently organised, thus rigid distinctions which artificially separated vanguard from class were bureaucratic, inflexible, and not suitable for the logic of the movement. Lenin's arguments for centralism in contrast sought to clearly establish authority and accountability of both central committee and party divisions, so that the party could act clearly and coherently upon the spontaneous movement 'from without'. Blurring the lines here could only be an opening to opportunism.
Membership definition wasn't the absolute basis of the dispute, since in 1906 the Mensheviks would adopt Lenin's original definition of membership. That the Mensheviks reacted to Lenin's definition as bureaucratic rule-making hostile to the requirements of the struggle was symptomatic of their conception of proletarian hegemony as emerging out of the self-activity of the workers, self-activity which Lenin's organisational program was purported to crush. Self activity was conceived in abstraction from the struggle for hegemony of the revolutionary movement. For the Mensheviks, the workers had to be educated to take over leadership from the intelligentsia. Working class political activity was a school and Social Democracy an enlightened teacher. Self activity would imbue a consciousness of class and prefigure socialism, the task in the coming democratic revolution was to foster a sense among workers of their independent class interest. Anything which drew away from demarcation of working class independence and self-activity, such as Lenin's program of party concern for the 'people', was a concession to the concerns of bourgeois democracy and ceded proletarian independence, at the hands of domineering intellectuals. Lenin's organisational plan cemented this practice. Social Democracy ought to not to act in the name of the workers, but through the workers themselves. The task was to orient to forms of action which will contain a logic of development which has workers learn through practice the need to oppose themselves to the dominant classes in the struggle against tsarism. Thus, the RSDLP should be a radical opposition in the coming bourgeois revolution and not take power, it must represent the proletariat as radical opposition to all that is non-proletarian. By acting as opposition, revolutionary pressure will be brought upon the bourgeoisie: proletarian hegemony through self activity. Wanting the RSDLP to take power in the coming bourgeois revolution was an expression of bourgeois intellectual Jacobinism.
Luxemburg contributed to the debate along economistic lines which the Mensheviks were reanimating. Centralism of the party should only come along with centralism of the proletariat itself. Only after the workers have received appropriate training in the struggle should the party adopt forms appropriate to this level of struggle. She saw in Lenin's arguments an urging to blind obedience to the central committee when what was needed to the struggle itself to educate the workers into voluntarily accepting socialist discipline. Imposition of centralism will only crush initiative from below, whereas Menshevik proposals preserve flexibility. Not only does Lenin's obsession with party rules fail to prevent opportunism, but it is itself an opportunist danger by impositing bureaucratic domination of intellectuals upon the workers. Marxism prefigures the spontaneous workers movement in a way where the spontaneous movement must be accompanied in development so as to make stages of Marxist consciousness relevant to it. The message is to foster working class self-activity and organisation on its own terms, with Social Democratic organisation only to correspond to its level of development. Problems of Social Democracy are actually problems of the workers' movement, whereas for Lenin the problem very much lies not with the workers but with the Social Democrats.
For Lenin, Martov's membership definition opened up the party to not demarcating itself from, and therefore subordinate to, the spontaneous movement. Lenin sought to counteract this mistake with his proposal for the editorial board. The subsequent Menshevik campaign to overturn this congress decision rejuvenated narrow circle mentality and economist tailism. When Lenin talked about 'top down' organisation to overcome the existing limitations of the Social Democratic movement, the 'top' was always the party congress, and that at this level the majority view should be carried out. Far from seeking exclusivity, Lenin's argument for centralised leadership was that it was precisely by strengthening the party organisation, and achieving a greater influence on the masses, which was the best way given the conditions to raise the level of participation and consciousness of the masses, not substitute for it. The key concern for Lenin was how to best bring Marxist leadership to the revolutionary movement. His organisational proposals were not democratic, but they weren't incompatible with democracy (this is in the context of a broad understanding of meaningful democracy not being possible in the underground, democratic centralism was seen as something possible only in conditions of political freedom, while being something always sought after and mandatory when possible). That being said, some who fetishised the elective principle in the party supported Lenin's definition of membership, as clear lines of membership were required to determine who had the right to vote. Clear leadership was required to clearly demarcate responsibility; Martov's definition of membership would not lead to democracy but instead to self-enrolment in the party and therefore an abdication of responsibilities of leadership. The only sense in which Lenin was 'sceptical' of workers was insofar as the spontaneous strategic unfolding of the workers' movement was politically reproduced and reaffirmed by a Social Democracy that reduced itself to tailing rather than providing leadership to the movement, the expression of this tailism being economism. Spontaneous development produced new conditions which Marxists had to analyse, and produce innovative responses to in order to forge proletarian hegemony in the coming revolution. Lenin heaped praise on the spontaneous upsurges of the people with respect to its genuine contribution in this formula.
The Mensheviks were being opportunist by apologising for backwardness of revolutionary organisation by deference to the movement. Their tactical selection of the bourgeois opposition's protest campaign as the focal point for Social Democratic activity was blind to the strategic logic of political struggle. Without a proletarian confrontation with the state, the government's concession of some freedom to the Zemtsvos but not the workers would be a ploy to fragment the opposition. It was not liberal protest that would lead to revolutionary struggle, but only revolutionary struggle that might sustain the protest. Rather than spreading consciousness of the workers as vanguard of the people and as rival to the bourgeoisie for leadership of the masses, the Mensheviks focused workers' attention on the constitutional posturing of the liberals, subordinating workers to the bourgeoisie.
The Mensheviks thought their tactics clever means of positioning workers in a process of development towards political autonomy and building workers up to having a sense of their independent interests, that working class self-consciousness achieved fully in socialist consciousness was something elevated above reflexivity to circumstance. From this view, Lenin's dogged factional struggle could appear as a power grab. For Lenin, the unity of the working class could not be assumed but had to be forged in struggle, and situated in organisational forms which are always contested. Working class unity was not a unity of consciousness, but has a strategic logic, in contest, alliance, and leadership. Lenin's orientation to proletarian hegemony centred on the political struggle for state power, in which contenders define the agency of other parties so as to position them in a field of battle, whether an adversary or an ally to be won to leadership, shifting in the course of struggle. In this context, the ability to act independently as a class requires an organised vanguard equipped with Marxist theory that could analyse and act upon movements which are contested by adversaries. A concrete analysis informed by this logic was indispensable. Without this, working class self activity was merely an abstraction. Working class independence and self-emancipation were inseparable from proletarian leadership of the people in the struggle for power. Working class self-activity and self-organisation was not a prior requirement to hegemony of the people; it was by being raised to awareness of the tasks of leading the people that the working class achieved genuine independence.
In the end, the proof would be in the pudding: Menshevik ideas of self activity could fit any form of activity which saw them fixated on narrow trade union or similar prosaic work while subordinating themselves politically to the bourgeoisie, while it was the Bolsheviks who would achieve the greater following among class conscious workers and would form organisations that were actually more open than those of the Mensheviks. Comparatively, Luxemburg's Polish/Lithuanian party, instead of controlling local organisations, ignored them altogether, and did not achieve the level of following of the Bolsheviks. In the German situation, Luxemburg did not produce political coordinates sufficient to seeing the need to wage a serious struggle against the centrist tendency of the party, instead seeing these problems as things that could only be resolved when the spontaneous workers' movement is sufficiently developed. This was a tragedy considering what would happen a decade later.
"Não é partindo da disciplina nele inculcada pelo Estado capitalista, com a mera transferência da batuta da mão da burguesia para a de um comitê central socialdemocrata, mas pela quebra, pelo extirpamento desse espírito de disciplina servil, que o proletariado pode ser educado para a nova disciplina, a autodisciplina voluntária da socialdemocracia" "O socialismo socialdemocratico tenha um carácter coordenador, unificador, e não um carácter regulamentador e fechado. Porém, se este espírito de liberdade política do movimento, ligado a uma penetrante visão da unidade do movimento e da fidelidade aos princípios, tiver tomado lugar nas fileiras do partido, então os defeitos de qualquer estatuto, mesmo o mais ineptamente concebido, experimentarão, em breve, eficaz correção através da própria práxis"
Enorm skillnad på hennes tankar om taktik, strategi och partiformen mellan denna skrivelse och hennes skrivelse ”ryska revolutionen” 14 år senare. Inte konstigt kanske, för fjorton år sen var jag 8 liksom.
Inaccurate depiction of how Lenin's party worked, but it does have a really good analysis of the conditions of socialism in Germany at the time. Its also pretty interesting to see Rosa's idea of democracy in a revolution. I'm a DSAer so I take a lot of stake in that.
"The fact is that the Social Democracy is not joined to the organization of the proletariat. It is itself the proletariat. And because of this, Social Democratic centralism is essentially different from Blanquist centralism.
Similarly, the partisans of “pure economism” in the Russian Social Democracy want us to bow down before the “calloused hand” of labor.
More important is the fundamental falseness of the idea underlying the plan of unqualified centralism – the idea that the road to opportunism can be barred by means of clauses in the party constitution.
An historic current, however, will pass through the mesh of the most subtly worded paragraph.
Its perils are not the product of the insidious machinations of individuals and groups. They arise out of unavoidable social conditions."
Very clearly and concisely summarizes the problems with Lenin’s antagonistic approach to the soviets, but also provides many useful insights on the question of effective organization in general.
In many ways, this essay offers greater clarity on her position towards Leninist (an anachronism on my part) tactics than her later, better-known work The Russian Revolution. Written in 1904 under the title Organisational Questions of the Russian Social Democracy, the essay critiques the then-quite unknown Lenin's theories of social revolution, primary through his analysis in One Step Forward, Two Steps Backward.
One of Luxemburg's central criticisms of Lenin is his detachment of the revolutionary party from the proletariat itself. She says 'Social Democracy [which, at this time, tended to refer to parliamentary socialism] is not joined to the organization of the proletariat. It is itself the proletariat' (p.83). She adeptly identifies the autocratic tendency inherent in Lenin's concept of the Vanguard party (which she calls "Blanquist" after French socialist Louis Blanqui, who pioneered the concept of a socialist revolution carried through by a small organised elite), arguing with remarkable foresight the 'discipline Lenin has in mind is being implanted in the working not only by the factory but also by the military and the existing state bureaucracy--by the entire mechanism of the centralized bourgeois state' (pp.83-4). These words almost echo some of her later criticisms of the Bolshevik regime in 1918.
Luxemburg elucidates on the contrast between 'Social Democratic centralism' and 'Blanquist centralism'. The former, she argues arises almost autonomously amongst a large contingent of conscious workers and conditioned on the 'possibility for the workers to develop their own political activity through direct influence on public life, in a party press, and public congresses - that is, within the party. The latter however - which she identifies with Lenin - represents to Luxemburg arising inorganically from without the party. Indeed, Lenin distinguishes between the proletariat and the 'intellectuals in our party' as though they are two separate things, and there is an air of paternalism here.
In step with almost all pre-war Marxist scholarship, she posits the conditions for the development of a revolutionary proletariat are not yet ripe in Russia - on which she was proved incorrect by the events of 1917. There is also the argument to be made (and indeed, was made by Lenin) that Luxemburg here had misrepresented Lenin's arguments. Indeed, on paper, Lenin and Luxemburg did share a lot in common. But the pamphlet is useful in its in-depth critique of what became Leninism in practice, and an interesting historical document warning of its potential dangers as early as 1904, which were indeed vindicated after the October Revolution.