John Charles Fremont and his men set off on their first expedition on June 10, 1842; seemingly plagued with bad luck, they capsized their barge with their supplies only four days into the journey. Although they recovered most of the supplies, the hardships kept coming. Tom Chaffin's Pathfinder: John Charles Fremont and the Course of American Empire is an amazing narrative biography of John Fremont and his desire for westward exploration and the overall advancement of the United States. Chaffin sought to correct the often-romanticized version of Fremont and remains subjective by pointing out his successes and failures and does not linger on either long enough to sense a strong bias in one way or another. Chaffin notes, "It was Fremont's explorations in the West that led the era's penny press to award him his sobriquet "the Pathfinder" and secured his enduring association with places in and beyond the Rockies."
Tom Chaffin is an American historian who received his Ph.D. in History at Emory University. He taught many history courses at various universities and is currently a research professor at the University of Tennessee- Knoxville. Chaffin published numerous essays, articles, and reviews in journals such as New York Times Magazine, Time, Harper's, The Nation, and Oxford American.
John Fremont held many titles throughout his career, such as "explorer, Mexican War military commander, U.S Senator from California, 1856 presidential candidate for the newly formed Republican Party, Civil War-era Union general, entrepreneur, and territorial governor of Arizona." Nevertheless, it seemed as if he yielded controversy wherever he went. According to the introduction, Fremont is still a controversial figure; people either love him or hate him. Tom Chaffin begins Fremont's story with a brief overview of his upbringing and wonderfully transitions to the first expedition. The monograph centers mostly on the expeditions Fremont took West, and Chaffin drives home the conditions the men faced on each expedition, from freezing in the Sierras in the second expedition to almost starving to the point of consuming leather in the fourth expedition.
History is much more enjoyable when it does not feel like reading a history book. Chaffin took this unfrequented figure in American Westward expansion and brought him to life. As mentioned before, there is not a clear bias for or against Fremont as we learn of his times of revenge on Native Americans but also his willingness to work with them. The reader also learns of many poor decisions he made on his expeditions but also with his clear and concise topography of the areas he explored. His first expedition commenced in 1842, the second expedition in 1843-1844, and the third expedition in 1845-1846, and 1846, he assisted the United States in the Mexican War before being assigned as military governor of California in 1847.
The third expedition is the turning point of Fremont's career; he had just sent a report back to the White House discussing his findings in Oregon. However, in his journal, toward the end of the third expedition, he writes about understanding a war with Mexico is inevitable, and the view to make the Pacific Ocean the United States' western boundary was in sight, and he wanted to be the one to begin the campaign. Before the war began, there were warnings that the Mexican army were building a defense, and the settlers in Fremont's party all reasoned why they should proceed with a preemptive attack. Fremont refused, so they and Kit Carson planned a campaign without him. The party devised a plan to take California and defeat the Mexican Army that would attack north of Francisco Bay; they decided that if they could take control of Sonoma, the Mexican army would likely fail. Fremont knew his men were about to leave him, so he disbanded the explorers and decided to join them. They voted on a leader, and Fremont won unanimously; they were then on their way to take Sonoma, remembered as the Bear Flag Revolt.
In September 1846, Commodore Robert Stockton named Fremont "military commandant of the new U.S territory of California." Fremont had a problem with authority, and when General Kearny kept assigning orders, and he kept ignoring them, it led to the eventual court martial of John Fremont on August 22, 1847. He was found guilty of all charges and "ordered dismissal from the Army." The next significant events in Fremont's career seemed rushed, confined to the last 100 pages. There was his brief serving in the U.S. Senate and then his presidential nomination in the 1856 election as a newly formed Republican candidate and his role as a failed Union general in the Civil War. The abridgment of the information does not hurt Chaffin's argument as he does provide a solid basis of information, but it would be beneficial to know more about this aspect of his life as well. Obviously, with the title of Pathfinder, his explorations are the center of the monograph, but because it is a chronological biography, the other areas also deserved attention.
The book is well-researched and provides plenty of sources for further reading if desired. The story of John Fremont is very much neglected in the historiography of the American West, and Tom Chaffin's research fills the voids of many milestones in westward expansion that are significant yet not written about. Pathfinder would do well for a general audience as it is written as a narrative and does not involve complex theories. Although a long read, it did not drag out and was not repetitive of the same concepts. If anything, this monograph could become a starting point for further research into Fremont's life, perhaps focusing in-depth on his after-exploration years as Chaffin did with his expeditions.