Judging by some of the other reviews, this seems to be a love it or hate it book. I really enjoyed it. I honestly don't understand what some of the negative reviews were for. The writing style was wonderful. Beautifully descriptive painting a scenery I could easily imagine myself in, feeling and smelling as the characters were, and tasting. This was a torturous book to read while pregnant. My mouth has been watering for the Orange scones with icing, the chocolate cherry muffins, and all of the other recipes and goodies mentioned. I feel like the people who negatively reviewed this book have little scope for the imagination. I would hate to be as nitpicky as they are. It seems as if they need everything fed to them and have no ability to carry on the story in their own minds. I suggest for them a walk in some nice, breezy air to clear their stuffiness away. I enjoyed the character of Kyla, particularly her interest in natural healing, herbs, and teas as that is a particular fondness of mine. I am interested to read her story in the next installment of the series. I also loved the neighbors. I want to go visit the B&B now!
The only reason I gave this 4 instead of 5 stars is because of the fact that right after Lily left her husband, she was already falling for another guy, and they wind up sleeping together without any commitment and with so many questions while she is still married. That is a particular sore spot for me as I value marriage, no matter what a pig Brad was. I would have liked this story more had Lily waited until the divorce was final and her own feelings were finalized with Brad and even with Ian, before hopping into bed with him. That is a weakness in society that I thoroughly can't stand. Had that been removed, this book would have been added to my personal book shelf collection.
While love is part of the story, the most important aspect for me was the friendship that grew and people still doing kind and selfless things for one another. That is such a rare thing to see these days, so it was refreshing to read about it, even if it was fiction. I would have liked to have had more resolution with the father situation, but other than that, I feel it was a well-written story. I am ready to go bake now as my mouth is still watering thinking about some of those goodies!