Martinez's book strikes me as part confessional, part psychological release, part horror story, with frequently witty observations spiced in throughout. I am struggling even to write a review of it as it has left me conflicted re: did I like the book or dislike it? I don't know that I can answer definitively either way, except to say that I respect Martinez's effort and final product. I think I will take a different approach in this review and make a few lists.
WHAT I LIKED
1. His often astute observations about the people, places, and things in his life and how his views on them change (or stay the same) over time.
2. The way Martinez admits that sometimes his recollections are hazy, and certain he cannot really remember accurately. I believe that all of us are this way, much as we would be loathe to admit it.
3. The character portraits that he paints are vivid.
4. I can identify with his intense desire to move away from home, and not just a little ways away, but to put considerable distance between himself and his childhood (literally and figuratively). I further admire the fact that he actually followed through on it. Many people will talk about leaving their hometowns, but never work up the gumption to really do it.
5. Martinez's recognition that he must move away or he will go crazy, and if didn't move when he did, he might never leave.
6. The guts that it took to admit many of his failings, and even more so to basically air his family's dirty laundry for everyone to see.
7. Martinez has a very lucid and descriptive way of writing.
WHAT I DID NOT LIKE
1. He makes a few references to his therapist, but he never tells us why he ultimately decided to start seeing one, when he made that decision, and if those sessions have really helped him, and if so in what way.
2. At times, he seems to blame his father (and he absolutely has some justification in doing so) for almost everything that has went wrong in his life. Was his dad a good father? Not even close. Did he damage his son psychologically? Most assuredly so. But it seemed to me that, as Martinez fell into one vice after another, he was reluctant to admit that he himself was at least partially to blame. At one point almost at the end of the book, he admits to having an addictive personality. I am not sure that all of that can be pinned on his father, as bad as the man was.
3. He makes a few cryptic references to one of his girlfriends in Seattle, Rebecca, but she is never in the story. I would have liked to have seen him talk about his relationship with her, even if just a little bit to provide more context around what he did in Seattle.
4. He skips past ten years of his life. Why? It makes me think of someone who you know very well, see on a daily basis, and suddenly for whatever reason that person is removed from your life for a decade, then just as quickly reappears. It is hard to just pick up the pieces where you left off at.
5. What was the response to the long, somewhat defensive letter that he wrote to his sister Marge detailing his older brother Dan's fight? He said it changed his relationships with his family members, while that began the erosion of his relationship with Dan. He goes in-depth concerning he and Dan, but says nothing about how his relationships changed with his sisters or mother.
6. Despite him writing about it at length, I am still left somewhat puzzled by the way that he and Dan have cut each other off. At the end, the book seems to almost be a plea to Dan to resume communication with him.
7. Where does his relationship with his mother stand? At one point, I thought he was going to discuss it (when he briefly mentions that they were driving to San Antonio after his parents divorced and he asked her about her possibly being raped), but that never really happens.
8. Any of the friends that he had in Brownsville basically disappear later on in the story, and it makes me wonder if he ever saw any of them again or heard from them.
9. There is absolutely no question in my mind that he had a screwed up childhood, and it is no surprise that he did develop such personality and substance abuse problems as he grew up. Yet, a few of the things that he does talk about (like fights at school) do not seem too much different from
my childhood. Perhaps I am not fully appreciative of these instances; yet at times while I was reading I thought to myself "That (or something very similar) happened to me, although the setting was different."
10. His frequent asides became sort of annoying. He would start a chapter on something or someone, but then get side-tracked and veer into a backstory for several pages before returning to the present. Doing that a few times did not bother me, but Martinez does it frequently and it started to - in places - make the book drag.
11. Along with #10, the pace at times seemed uneven. At certain points, I was engrossed in the book; other times I was almost bored.
While writing this review, I had the rating at two stars. But I am changing it to three stars as perhaps I think that, at two stars, I am not being charitable enough to Martinez and appreciative of the difficult undertaking that writing this book must have been. I can completely understand why someone reading this would really like it; I can also see why someone would not like it. I do think that someone who grew up in the same area as he undoubtedly would be better suited to judge his work (at least the Texas portion of it). But, then again, everyone has different life experiences, even if they live in the same area. In the end, I feel sadness for Martinez and all that he had to endure - from his grandma, from his parents, from Brownsville, and - most of all - from himself.