After reading Undeniable, I have to admit, I'm a Madeline Sheehan fan for life, so naturally, I had to check out the Holy Trinity series.
I think Madeline Sheehan has come a long way as a writer since this book was written, but that's not to say The Soul Mate isn't a great book - it is!
The Soul Mate begins with a look into the past and a rather confusing analogy of the whole soul mate concept. I think the book jumps around a bit too much, without going into too much detail when it counted (like during some encounters between Gerick and Trinity, I wanted to know Gerick's reaction to her and wasn't awarded it). Also, the whole dystopian thing isn't really explained. I found myself completely confused about the events leading up to Trinity living in the gypsy camp. I wanted to know where her parents were and details about how and why the world was being overrun by Skin Eaters...
I have to give this book 4 stars despite my criticism on the lack of clarity and description with a few parts of the book, because what this book lacks in that aspect, it makes up for in believable, tragically-flawed and seriously hot characters. Madeline has an unbelievable knack for making readers love her characters one minute, and want to throw scalding water in their faces the next. As was definitley the case with both Gerick and Xan.
Despite an undeniable pull towards one another, Trinity and Gerick have a shaky connection at best. Gerick is unrelenting and demanding, not to mention constantly slutting around with gypsy-whore Onyx right in front of her! (In true Sheehan fashion, she gives it to you like it is without the sugar-coating, and if you don't like it, too bad!) You would think after realizing Trinity is destroyed over seeing Gerick and Onyx shamelessly mauling each other, this would be Gerick's cue to feel bad, stop repeating his mistakes and go begging for forgiveness on his knees to Trin, right?! Hells no! He follows up his bad behavior with snarky comments and selfishly blames his sexual trysts with Onyx on Trinity because she won't give in to his repeated attempts to seduce her.
Enter Xan. Beautiful, bronze, dread-head Xan.... Ahhh. Most cliche romance novels would have Xan entering stage left, saving the day and sweeping said damsel in distress off her feet, but no... frustratingly, that wasn't the case, and again, I love Sheehan for not going that route with her characters. Xan humiliates Trinity and makes her feel like an inadequate child while attempting to train her to fight and defend herself against the Skin Eaters since she doesn't have magic to defend herself like the others (and neither does Xan, but he's still an uber badass). Trinity is naturally drawn to him, but some stupid gypsy repellant Gerick instills upon them prohibits Trinity from deriving any pleasure from physical contact with Xan, which is a catalyst for both sexually frustrating, yet surprisingly HOT scenes.
Xan and Gerick predictably fight over and compete for Trinity in true caveman, er... gypsy fashion. Gorilla-like chest pounding ensues. You think I'm joking? Oh, that's right, I left out the part where gypsy men are allowed to 'claim' women (as early as 13 if they want), by dragging them, kicking and screaming, into their trailer for a few days, resulting in a Romani-recognized 'marriage.' There is something obviously disturbing about that, but Sheehan has a way of justifying their actions by offering glimpses into gypsy life as this dysfunctional but tight-knit community where options are limited, stakes are high, and competition is brutal (it's like The Bachelor/Bachelorette, but with a bunch of drunk, dysfunctional, magic-wielding gypsies). Fidelity is almost a joke when it comes to simply dating, but those who are loyal are fiercely so. Readers will have their hearts torn between Gerick and Xan, and the lengths they both go to, the sacrifices they both make, to keep her happy and safe.
I loved being caught up in the gypsy camp with these characters, including Becky (Trin's permiscuous BFF), Shandor, Hockey, the Horvath triplets, and even the spiteful bitch Onyx, who all added such dimension and layers to the complicated relationships among the clan. The Soul Mate is a story about a dystopian world, where the laws of the gypsies are ingrained in their culture. It's not about who you want to be with, but who you were born to be with. The Soul Mate is a story about risking everything in exchange for deciding who you want to be with. The price of free will comes at a great cost and fighting fate proves to have dire consequences.