What do you think?
Rate this book
The Story of Fish and Snail
Every day, Snail waits for Fish to come home with a new story.
Today, Fish's story (about pirates!) is too grand to simply be told: Fish wants to show Snail. But that would mean leaving the familiar world of their book—a scary prospect for Snail, who would rather stay safely at home and pretend to be kittens. Fish scoffs that cats are boring; Snail snaps back. Is this book too small for the two feuding friends? Could this be THE END of The Story of Fish and Snail?
Deborah Freedman, author of Blue Chicken, has created a sweet and playful story about friendship that truly jumps off the page.
★"Right from the title page, Freedman's latest makes a splash... This marvelous metabook shines in both concept and beauty."
-- Kirkus Reviews, starred review
"The theme of books as doorways into rich new adventures couldn't be more vividly conveyed, and the resolution of the conflict between two sweet friends provides encouragement for other "snails" to try new things." -- Publishers Weekly
Today, Fish's story (about pirates!) is too grand to simply be told: Fish wants to show Snail. But that would mean leaving the familiar world of their book—a scary prospect for Snail, who would rather stay safely at home and pretend to be kittens. Fish scoffs that cats are boring; Snail snaps back. Is this book too small for the two feuding friends? Could this be THE END of The Story of Fish and Snail?
Deborah Freedman, author of Blue Chicken, has created a sweet and playful story about friendship that truly jumps off the page.
★"Right from the title page, Freedman's latest makes a splash... This marvelous metabook shines in both concept and beauty."
-- Kirkus Reviews, starred review
"The theme of books as doorways into rich new adventures couldn't be more vividly conveyed, and the resolution of the conflict between two sweet friends provides encouragement for other "snails" to try new things." -- Publishers Weekly
40 pages, Hardcover
First published June 13, 2013
8 people are currently reading
1290 people want to read
About the author
Deborah Freedman
14 books209 followersOnce upon a time, I was an architect. But now I'd much rather build worlds in books. :)
I am the author and illustrator of 12 of them, featuring protagonists that include an earthworm searching for its purpose in life, a house that dreams of its origins, and a character that is almost too shy to appear in its own book.
My stories have been translated into ten different languages, adopted in classrooms across the country, and honored with many starred reviews and awards. I live in a colorful house in Connecticut, where I'm always busy at work on my next books.
I love reading books and telling you about them; I hate rating them! Let's just say that if I didn't like a book, it isn't here at all.
Website: www.deborahfreedman.net
—with tons of free resources for readers, and a sign-up for my eNewsletter
Bluesky: @DeborahFreedman.net
Facebook: Deborah Freedman, Author & Illustrator
Instagram, Threads: @FreedmanIllustrates
—stop by and say hi!
I am the author and illustrator of 12 of them, featuring protagonists that include an earthworm searching for its purpose in life, a house that dreams of its origins, and a character that is almost too shy to appear in its own book.
My stories have been translated into ten different languages, adopted in classrooms across the country, and honored with many starred reviews and awards. I live in a colorful house in Connecticut, where I'm always busy at work on my next books.
I love reading books and telling you about them; I hate rating them! Let's just say that if I didn't like a book, it isn't here at all.
Website: www.deborahfreedman.net
—with tons of free resources for readers, and a sign-up for my eNewsletter
Bluesky: @DeborahFreedman.net
Facebook: Deborah Freedman, Author & Illustrator
Instagram, Threads: @FreedmanIllustrates
—stop by and say hi!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 265 reviews
May 7, 2015
Wow, do I LOVE this book.
I'm a children's librarian and recently used this for a story time (ages 3-5). This is one of the most unique kids picture books I've read in a long time. It's funny, charming and tells the story of a special friendship between Snail and Fish.
I won't go into detail here, because you have to read it for yourself. Let's just say I've never read a kids picture book like this one. The parents and grandparents that attended my story time, were in agreement, that this was an unusual(in the best way) book. The adults loved it as much as the kids.
I highly recommend this story, which is good for one on one or for a group/story time.
GREAT BOOK - READ IT
I'm a children's librarian and recently used this for a story time (ages 3-5). This is one of the most unique kids picture books I've read in a long time. It's funny, charming and tells the story of a special friendship between Snail and Fish.
I won't go into detail here, because you have to read it for yourself. Let's just say I've never read a kids picture book like this one. The parents and grandparents that attended my story time, were in agreement, that this was an unusual(in the best way) book. The adults loved it as much as the kids.
I highly recommend this story, which is good for one on one or for a group/story time.
GREAT BOOK - READ IT
February 21, 2013
Let me start off my review with this-and then get into my thoughts on the work. I'm not quite certain that the idea these 2 characters who live in a book and can potentially leave the book for another book will sink in for younger children, so I would use this book for kids age 4 or older. I know on first run through the F&G, I had to go back a page a few times, and then I went "A-Ha. Clever" and really, it is VERY CLEVER! (Maybe for others it's obvious right away, but consider that I'm a sleep deprived parent of a fabulous 2 year boy. Cut me some slack!)
So Snail sits and waits, in the same spot everyday for his friend Fish to come home to their book and tell him stories of his daily adventures. EXCEPT for this day-Fish wants to SHOW and not simply tell Snail all about the adventure.
Predictably, Snail is not so certain he's ready to leave the safety and confines of his book. A tiff between the friends ensues and then the magic starts.
Freedman's clever illustrations take over the story, and boy are they pretty neat. The story becomes 3D plot set in a 2D picture book-and it WORKS. But then, all too soon-it's over. Which is why I think this a great picture book for older readers.
Kids after reading should be inspired to see what other adventure (or adventures) Fish & Snail are about to have, because a bit of a brick wall has been thrown up, we don't know where these 2 plucky characters are sailing off towards.
But again - that's OK-because the plot twist through art that Freedman creates is so delicious, I can't see how a teacher or librarian (or parent like me who plans and using this as soon as my little one can grasp this concepts here) would not use it to get some creative storytelling going. Have the kids imagine up the next book Fish & Snail sail off into, and what they encounter.
Here's a picture book meant to inspire and activate creativity in the right hands. Do pick it up and see for yourself.
So Snail sits and waits, in the same spot everyday for his friend Fish to come home to their book and tell him stories of his daily adventures. EXCEPT for this day-Fish wants to SHOW and not simply tell Snail all about the adventure.
Predictably, Snail is not so certain he's ready to leave the safety and confines of his book. A tiff between the friends ensues and then the magic starts.
Freedman's clever illustrations take over the story, and boy are they pretty neat. The story becomes 3D plot set in a 2D picture book-and it WORKS. But then, all too soon-it's over. Which is why I think this a great picture book for older readers.
Kids after reading should be inspired to see what other adventure (or adventures) Fish & Snail are about to have, because a bit of a brick wall has been thrown up, we don't know where these 2 plucky characters are sailing off towards.
But again - that's OK-because the plot twist through art that Freedman creates is so delicious, I can't see how a teacher or librarian (or parent like me who plans and using this as soon as my little one can grasp this concepts here) would not use it to get some creative storytelling going. Have the kids imagine up the next book Fish & Snail sail off into, and what they encounter.
Here's a picture book meant to inspire and activate creativity in the right hands. Do pick it up and see for yourself.
August 30, 2019
Snail waits patiently in his own book for his best friend Fish to bring back stories from other volumes in this meta-fictional tale. But when Fish wants to show Snail the other story, trouble ensues, and an argument breaks out between the two companions. Is this the end of their story? Or will Snail find the courage to leave his book and follow Fish into another one...?
Like the other two picture-books I have read from Deborah Freedman, Shy and By Mouse and Frog , The Story of Fish and Snail is a sweet, meta-fictional delight, one in which the characters themselves are involved with the storytelling process, and interact physically with the book in which they reside. I'm not sure why, but these sorts of tales seem more and more popular of late. I enjoyed the narrative of Snail and Fish, and appreciated the artwork, which captured the eponymous heroes and their changing expressions quite well. Recommended to anyone who has read and enjoys other Freedman titles, as well as to anyone looking for picture-books which break the fourth wall, and involve characters who are very much aware of their status as characters.
Like the other two picture-books I have read from Deborah Freedman, Shy and By Mouse and Frog , The Story of Fish and Snail is a sweet, meta-fictional delight, one in which the characters themselves are involved with the storytelling process, and interact physically with the book in which they reside. I'm not sure why, but these sorts of tales seem more and more popular of late. I enjoyed the narrative of Snail and Fish, and appreciated the artwork, which captured the eponymous heroes and their changing expressions quite well. Recommended to anyone who has read and enjoys other Freedman titles, as well as to anyone looking for picture-books which break the fourth wall, and involve characters who are very much aware of their status as characters.
July 2, 2013
Everyday, fish comes back to snail to tell him new stories he has found in other books besides theirs. But then one day, fish tells snail that he must come with him, that he has found another book so good he wants to show it to snail, not just tell him. But snail doesn't want to leave the book he's in.
Fish and snail exchange angry words, but when snail won't budge, fish takes a dive into the other book. But without fish, snail asks himself, how can we be The Story of Fish & Snail?
Looking over the edge of their book, snail sees the almost disappearing fish swimming in another book. And sure enough, snail takes the plunge into the new book, and finds fish, who is so happy to see his friend that their argument is forgotten. The two friends set off together on a new adventure exploring the new book.
This is just such a lovely story about courage, and taking chances and leaving the safety of what is known and familiar and venturing off to try something new and unknown.
But...
It is also a story that shows how one book is like the confines of a fish bowl, while many books open up an whole world, or in the case of fish & snail, a whole ocean of new and different adventures and people to meet and places to explore.
Some reviewers think this is too much of a metabook for the target reader of three to five years old, but I don't. They don't really have to get the metaidea. They already understand the idea of friendship.
I loved this book, I loved the story and illustrations. Both are done so gently and there is such a wonderful message about the importance of navigating the world with the help of a good friend. Using soft pastel hues, Freedman has created enchanting watercolor illustrations of The Story of Fish & Snail set against a black and white pencil (?) drawing of books on shelves.
The Story of Fish & Snail is a great read aloud story that will most likely elicit lots of discussion even with the youngest readers and it is a perfect summer book, especially for kids who may be about the begin school in September and may be feeling a little iffy about a new adventure and need a little encouragement before taking the school plunge like snail.
This book is recommended for readers age 3+
This book was obtained from the publisher
This review was originally published at Randomly Reading
Fish and snail exchange angry words, but when snail won't budge, fish takes a dive into the other book. But without fish, snail asks himself, how can we be The Story of Fish & Snail?
Looking over the edge of their book, snail sees the almost disappearing fish swimming in another book. And sure enough, snail takes the plunge into the new book, and finds fish, who is so happy to see his friend that their argument is forgotten. The two friends set off together on a new adventure exploring the new book.
This is just such a lovely story about courage, and taking chances and leaving the safety of what is known and familiar and venturing off to try something new and unknown.
But...
It is also a story that shows how one book is like the confines of a fish bowl, while many books open up an whole world, or in the case of fish & snail, a whole ocean of new and different adventures and people to meet and places to explore.
Some reviewers think this is too much of a metabook for the target reader of three to five years old, but I don't. They don't really have to get the metaidea. They already understand the idea of friendship.
I loved this book, I loved the story and illustrations. Both are done so gently and there is such a wonderful message about the importance of navigating the world with the help of a good friend. Using soft pastel hues, Freedman has created enchanting watercolor illustrations of The Story of Fish & Snail set against a black and white pencil (?) drawing of books on shelves.
The Story of Fish & Snail is a great read aloud story that will most likely elicit lots of discussion even with the youngest readers and it is a perfect summer book, especially for kids who may be about the begin school in September and may be feeling a little iffy about a new adventure and need a little encouragement before taking the school plunge like snail.
This book is recommended for readers age 3+
This book was obtained from the publisher
This review was originally published at Randomly Reading
June 28, 2013
Right from the title page you dive into this book with glee! On top of a tall stack of books (the top one open like an invitation), a perky, curious, golden fish accepts the invitation and dives right in. Water splashes up into the air creating a wonderful, whimsical world of pure magic and fun. This book is a remarkable underwater macrocosm where Snail waits patiently for his friend Fish to come and tell him a story. Fish is so excited (about Pirates) and says to Snail that today he cannot tell him the story but wants to actually take him to the story so he can experience the excitement of the tale himself. This request does not sit well with Snail who is apprehensive about leaving his book. He tries to relay his feelings and disinterest. "I don't want to go into other books," he says. "I like this book." An argument ensues and Fish swims off in a huff. "Fine, Snail. Good-bye. The end." Snail remains where he is not budging one iota. Snail musters up courage, looks over the side of the mountainous book pile and thinks about jumping off . "Fish?" he calls uncertainly and then he takes the plunge. With a huge splash (the height of the book pile) Snail disappears into the new book. Fish peers around the corner of the page ready to forgive his friend and start their adventure together.
The watercolour world of this book is truly stunning. The cartoon-like characters emit lots of emotion and become endearing to the reader. The book is encouraging us to step out of our comfort zones, take a risk and try to experience some new things. It also highlights the value of compromise and loyalty between two long-time friends. Hopefully kids will read this story and be encouraged to open the door of opportunities wide and encounter something new that will change their world forever.
The watercolour world of this book is truly stunning. The cartoon-like characters emit lots of emotion and become endearing to the reader. The book is encouraging us to step out of our comfort zones, take a risk and try to experience some new things. It also highlights the value of compromise and loyalty between two long-time friends. Hopefully kids will read this story and be encouraged to open the door of opportunities wide and encounter something new that will change their world forever.
July 31, 2013
This is a delightful book on many levels! The characters of Fish and Snail are incredibly adorable, and will appeal to children of all ages, even the adult ones. The storyline deals with friendship, compromise, and stepping out of your comfort zone to experience new things. But the most amazing part of this book are the illustrations.
In her two previous books, Scribble and Blue Chicken, Deborah Freedman experimented with her characters interacting with the physical page, and that becomes the story. For the reader, this interaction means you become part of the story by holding the page. In The Story of Fish & Snail, Freedman masters her interactive illustrations! The different views presented, the splashes, they are all so lifelike you almost feel like you are going to get wet. And again, she begins the story on the inside cover and it carries on to the back cover.
I hope Freedman writes many more books like this one -- I will wait at the bookstore to share in the delight!
In her two previous books, Scribble and Blue Chicken, Deborah Freedman experimented with her characters interacting with the physical page, and that becomes the story. For the reader, this interaction means you become part of the story by holding the page. In The Story of Fish & Snail, Freedman masters her interactive illustrations! The different views presented, the splashes, they are all so lifelike you almost feel like you are going to get wet. And again, she begins the story on the inside cover and it carries on to the back cover.
I hope Freedman writes many more books like this one -- I will wait at the bookstore to share in the delight!
August 13, 2014
Please add this to your books about friendship, because it is worth reading aloud and talking about with children. Having a friend can be wonderful, but when that friend chooses to do something new, and you want things to stay the same, sometimes friendships can fade away. Or sometimes, because of the friend, you make a leap and try something new! This is the story of fish & snail, and a beautifully illustrated one, too. Since it involves stories, Deborah Freedman has cleverly included a book on every page, where fish & snail live, of course. You’ll love what she does with this idea, snail staying, even clinging to the page, and fish, exploring. You’ll discover a nice surprise when you read the story.
January 30, 2013
Fish is an extrovert and snail is an introvert. Fish likes to explore other books and comes back every day to tell snail about his adventures. Fish decides that snail needs to come with him on an adventure, but snail is not happy about that idea. They, like many friends, have a fight and storm off. The ending will leave you cheering and your child wanting to read it again. Great for kids who are introverts and extroverts alike.
August 9, 2015
Fish and Snail live inside a book. When fish wants to venture outside his own book to find adventure elsewhere, Snail is having none of that. Fighting ensues and well, you'll just have to read the rest to find out the result.
I love the story, but I especially love the endearing illustrations and the unique perspective Freedman uses to show that Fish and snail are inside a book. Yet another Caldecott contender in my eyes.
I love the story, but I especially love the endearing illustrations and the unique perspective Freedman uses to show that Fish and snail are inside a book. Yet another Caldecott contender in my eyes.
August 15, 2013
Very meta but not much there beyond that gimmick. Cute artwork but I thought this story was going to be much better and it could have been. I would have enjoyed seeing Fish and Snail adventure through familiar picture book classics.
August 16, 2019
Nice illustrations, but the story starts out a bit confusing - Fish and Snail are characters in a book but that isn't made clear until a couple spreads in. A focus on bravery and friendship and trying new things.
November 24, 2017
I loved the illustrations! The artist used every inch of the paper to convey another dimension outside the book-within-a-book. Lovely story.
April 21, 2024
Good. Having the story actually take place in a book is a fun idea, and the art is great. The story is simple, but good.
November 14, 2017
This review was originally written for The Baby Bookworm. Visit us for new picture books reviews daily!
Hello, friends! Our book today is The Story Of Fish And Snail by Deborah Freedman, a lovely tale about friendship and compromise between two unusual friends.
Fish and Snail live together in their book, and are the best of friends. Every day, Fish goes out to explore the other books, but Snail prefers to wait where it’s safe and quiet until Fish comes home with stories to share. One day, Fish comes to tell Snail that he’s found an amazing book with a vast blue ocean, and pirates! He implores Snail to come with him to see. But Snail doesn’t want to play pirates (they are scary), he wants to pretend to be something safe like kittens instead. Fish snaps at Snail in frustration, and the two get into an argument that ends with Fish storming off to another book. But now Snail misses his dear friend. What is a timid Snail to do?
This is such a wonderfully unique book! The concept of Fish and Snail being characters in a library book that can explore other books is so neat, at gives the story a magical subtext that ignites the imagination. But the core story, that sometimes even best friends will fight, is perfect too. The best part was that the resolution showed compromise between the friends: Snail gathers his courage to follow Fish into the other book because he wants to make his friend happy; and Fish, touched, decides that they can play “kitten-pirate” so Snail feels more comfortable. It’s a great lesson in being compassionate and considerate of one’s friends, and it’s executed beautifully. The art is sweet, soothing, and fits the fantastical elements of the story just right. The length is perfect for baby Bookworm, and JJ loved this one! Totally Baby Bookworm approved!
Be sure to check out The Baby Bookworm for more reviews!
September 18, 2013
This talented woman wrote and illustrated this children's book of few words yet fills the pages with meaning that splashes deep. This story is held together by a friendship, but takes us through changes with unexpected outcomes. Books and stories are part of this wonderful tale, too, which makes it even more fun for this retired librarian/school teacher.
The artwork makes the tale come alive, filling the reader's mind with emotions of these two friends and corners to be turned where change can leave us guessing at times. This book is filled with watercolors in soft and perfect shades for splashing and friends. I loved looking at the pictures for they tell the story right alongside the words.
Reading Level: 3 - 5 Years
Deborah Freedman "was an architect once-upon-a-time, but now she loves to build worlds in books. Her first picture books were tiny and hand-made, written and illustrated over twenty years ago for her own young children. Deborah became especially inspired when her girls grew old enough to draw, after they began to create fantastical beings with endearing back-stories. She began then to play with their pictures, doodling around them and developing ideas that eventually matured into her first picture book, Scribble, published by Knopf in 2007. Her second book, Blue Chicken, was released by Viking in fall 2011, to three starred reviews and other honors.
"Lost in the arts for as long as she can remember, Deborah majored in art history in college at Yale and studied architecture at the Harvard Graduate School of Design. When she isn’t making picture books or daydreaming, she likes to wander through museums, the library, and the woods – at home in Connecticut."
As you can see on her website, Ms. Freedman also draws and scribbles. She has fun. You can find her at her website: http://deborahfreedman.net/home.html
And here is her blog: http://deborahfreedman.wordpress.com/
Book Information:
ISBN-13: 9780670784899
Publisher: Viking Juvenile, an imprint of Penguin Group (USA) Inc.,
a division of Penguin Young Readers Group, New York, NY
Publication date: 6/13/2013
Pages: 40
Product dimensions: 8.90 (w) x 10.62 (h) x 0.36 (d)
The artwork makes the tale come alive, filling the reader's mind with emotions of these two friends and corners to be turned where change can leave us guessing at times. This book is filled with watercolors in soft and perfect shades for splashing and friends. I loved looking at the pictures for they tell the story right alongside the words.
Reading Level: 3 - 5 Years
Deborah Freedman "was an architect once-upon-a-time, but now she loves to build worlds in books. Her first picture books were tiny and hand-made, written and illustrated over twenty years ago for her own young children. Deborah became especially inspired when her girls grew old enough to draw, after they began to create fantastical beings with endearing back-stories. She began then to play with their pictures, doodling around them and developing ideas that eventually matured into her first picture book, Scribble, published by Knopf in 2007. Her second book, Blue Chicken, was released by Viking in fall 2011, to three starred reviews and other honors.
"Lost in the arts for as long as she can remember, Deborah majored in art history in college at Yale and studied architecture at the Harvard Graduate School of Design. When she isn’t making picture books or daydreaming, she likes to wander through museums, the library, and the woods – at home in Connecticut."
As you can see on her website, Ms. Freedman also draws and scribbles. She has fun. You can find her at her website: http://deborahfreedman.net/home.html
And here is her blog: http://deborahfreedman.wordpress.com/
Book Information:
ISBN-13: 9780670784899
Publisher: Viking Juvenile, an imprint of Penguin Group (USA) Inc.,
a division of Penguin Young Readers Group, New York, NY
Publication date: 6/13/2013
Pages: 40
Product dimensions: 8.90 (w) x 10.62 (h) x 0.36 (d)
November 15, 2013
This is the story of Fish and Snail who were great friends. Every day, Snail would wait for Fish to return with a new story. This time, Fish returned with a great story, one so wonderful that Fish wanted to show Snail instead of tell about it. But Snail doesn’t want to leave the book they are in. Snail wants to stay right there and play kittens instead of pirates. The two start to argue and finally Fish declares that it is THE END and leaves the book. Snail was so sad. This was not the way the story was meant to end. So Snail leans farther outside of the page and sees Fish in a watery book below. Will Snail leave his safe book and dare to tumble down to the other ocean below? Will Fish return with more stories?
Freedman captures a story-within-a-story here with her setting of two characters living not just in one picture book but many. It is the story of two opposite characters who still manage to be friends, most of the time. There is the sedentary Snail who longs for the stories but not the real adventure. Then there is the irrepressible Fish who jumps and leaps literally off of the page. The pair make for a balanced friendship but also one with plenty of room for misunderstanding too. Their conversation and fight are written strongly and honestly.
Freedman’s art is gorgeous. Readers will recognize her as the author and illustrator of Blue Chicken. She uses similar splash effects in her art here. The blues are gorgeously green and filled with light. When Fish swims the bubbles take on a stronger form as Freedman lets the watercolor dapple the page. There is one beautiful image of Snail looking down to the other book that plays with perspective cleverly.
I’ve heard Caldecott rumblings for this one and with its playful yet artistic illustrations, I’d love to see that. In the end though, it’s also a great story about friendship, books and being willing to take risks. Appropriate for ages 3-5.
Freedman captures a story-within-a-story here with her setting of two characters living not just in one picture book but many. It is the story of two opposite characters who still manage to be friends, most of the time. There is the sedentary Snail who longs for the stories but not the real adventure. Then there is the irrepressible Fish who jumps and leaps literally off of the page. The pair make for a balanced friendship but also one with plenty of room for misunderstanding too. Their conversation and fight are written strongly and honestly.
Freedman’s art is gorgeous. Readers will recognize her as the author and illustrator of Blue Chicken. She uses similar splash effects in her art here. The blues are gorgeously green and filled with light. When Fish swims the bubbles take on a stronger form as Freedman lets the watercolor dapple the page. There is one beautiful image of Snail looking down to the other book that plays with perspective cleverly.
I’ve heard Caldecott rumblings for this one and with its playful yet artistic illustrations, I’d love to see that. In the end though, it’s also a great story about friendship, books and being willing to take risks. Appropriate for ages 3-5.
June 23, 2013
I love The Story of Fish and Snail. It's visually stunning, with a heartwarming story and a fantastic read aloud flow. Deborah Freedman has dazzled us once again with another book that delivers not only an engaging, well written story, but a design that is unique and breathtaking.
Fish and Snail live in a book. One day, Fish returns to the book with a new story that he wants to show Snail. This new story is filled with adventure and excitement, but Snail doesn't want to go and see it. He wants to stay in their book and play their usual games. Arguments ensue and Fish leaves the book in a huff. Snail is by himself, bemoaning just how their book can be called The Story of Fish and Snail if there is no Fish. He works up his courage and takes the plunge, diving into the unknown to follow his friend. Compromises are reached, conflicts resolved, courage is found and fun results.
The illustrations in this book are stunning. They make me smile, and I can't wait to share this little gem with my son. Fish and Snail are cute! Their travels outside of the book are wonderfully depicted the artist makes very effective use of color against black and white. Perhaps my favorite spread is the one showing the water splashing up from the page as Snail takes his big dive. The artist's unique design adds a three dimensional feel to the book. Much like her other works, this is one you simply have to see to fully appreciate.
The Story of Fish and Snail is a must have for any classroom, story time, or preschooler's personal collection. This will make an excellent book that is sure to be enjoyed over and over again as kids ponder the very notion that characters might actually leave their book. Just imagine. The endless possibilities.
Fish and Snail live in a book. One day, Fish returns to the book with a new story that he wants to show Snail. This new story is filled with adventure and excitement, but Snail doesn't want to go and see it. He wants to stay in their book and play their usual games. Arguments ensue and Fish leaves the book in a huff. Snail is by himself, bemoaning just how their book can be called The Story of Fish and Snail if there is no Fish. He works up his courage and takes the plunge, diving into the unknown to follow his friend. Compromises are reached, conflicts resolved, courage is found and fun results.
The illustrations in this book are stunning. They make me smile, and I can't wait to share this little gem with my son. Fish and Snail are cute! Their travels outside of the book are wonderfully depicted the artist makes very effective use of color against black and white. Perhaps my favorite spread is the one showing the water splashing up from the page as Snail takes his big dive. The artist's unique design adds a three dimensional feel to the book. Much like her other works, this is one you simply have to see to fully appreciate.
The Story of Fish and Snail is a must have for any classroom, story time, or preschooler's personal collection. This will make an excellent book that is sure to be enjoyed over and over again as kids ponder the very notion that characters might actually leave their book. Just imagine. The endless possibilities.
February 15, 2017
I really loved this story! The illustrations were most excellent and the story to accompany them was really great, too. :)
This was a book within a book, as Snail and Fish are book characters in the story.
Like I said above, the story was excellent, but I really fell in love with the illustrations. They were beyond wonderful in my opinion. It was really neat the way every page in the book, including the inside covers, was used to tell part of the story. :)
I especially loved the variety of expressions Deborah Freedman was able to give to Fish and Snail: their body language and facial expressions told the same story the text did, but in a very visual way. For this reason alone, I think this would be an excellent book for very young children. It'd be fun to hear what story they create for Fish and Snail based on the illustrations. And I think it'd be fun for them to see how their stories compare to the written story once they can read it. :)
This was a book within a book, as Snail and Fish are book characters in the story.
Like I said above, the story was excellent, but I really fell in love with the illustrations. They were beyond wonderful in my opinion. It was really neat the way every page in the book, including the inside covers, was used to tell part of the story. :)
I especially loved the variety of expressions Deborah Freedman was able to give to Fish and Snail: their body language and facial expressions told the same story the text did, but in a very visual way. For this reason alone, I think this would be an excellent book for very young children. It'd be fun to hear what story they create for Fish and Snail based on the illustrations. And I think it'd be fun for them to see how their stories compare to the written story once they can read it. :)
August 11, 2013
Each day, Snail waits for Fish to come home with a new story. Theirs is a friendship of opposites. Snail wants to sit at home and listen to stories of princesses or kittens; Fish dreams of adventures, pirates and secret treasures. Readers can guess from the title page, where a fish dramatically splashes into the pages of an open book sitting atop a tall stack of closed books, that this will be a story with plenty of meta elements in it, playing on the idea of a book-within-a-book. Trouble brews for the friends when Fish wants to show Snail the new book he found and Freedman’s illustrations create the emotional tension with dramatic lines and texture as the friends’ fight escalates. Snail’s disbelief when Fish actually jumps out of the book leaving him is matched by the reader’s utter astonishment when Snail tumbles down after Fish. Freedman captures great sense of perspective, angle and scale, bringing sense of story-within-a-story frame sharply into focus as Snail peers from his book down towering stack of books to the open book below. As in Blue Chicken (2011), Freedman excels in creating a sense of splashing water dramatically spreading across the page. But it’s the playful, imaginative exploration of the idea of books as worlds in themselves that will draw readers to this story for repeated readings.
February 9, 2015
The Story of Fish and Snail begins with Snail awaiting Fish's arrival with a new, exciting story. Fish is so thrilled about his recent adventure that he wants Snail to experience it with him. Unfortunately Snail is happy where he is and does not want to leave. Fish can't imagine staying in their usual book after what he has just encountered, a whole ocean full of fun and excitement! Him and Snail get in an argument and Snail finds himself alone while fish swims into his new book. Without Fish, Snail is not as happy in their usual book as he thought. He decides to leap into the new book after Fish and couldn't be happier!
This book is unusual. The Fish and Snail are aware that they live in a book and they are able to move from book to book. It puts an interesting spin on things because this is not a common thing in books. Although the theme of the story is common, the way that the Fish and Snail acknowledge that they are in a book puts a fresh spin on it.
Along with the creative story line, the illustrations are very unique. The use of color on top of black and white pencil sketches was different but it was effective in grabbing the readers eye. Overall the story was very interesting and unique.
This book is unusual. The Fish and Snail are aware that they live in a book and they are able to move from book to book. It puts an interesting spin on things because this is not a common thing in books. Although the theme of the story is common, the way that the Fish and Snail acknowledge that they are in a book puts a fresh spin on it.
Along with the creative story line, the illustrations are very unique. The use of color on top of black and white pencil sketches was different but it was effective in grabbing the readers eye. Overall the story was very interesting and unique.
August 6, 2022
Like The Giving Tree, I have mixed feelings about this book. If I read it as a child, I think I would enjoy the obvious friendship between the characters and the bright watercolor illustrations and the meta-awareness of the story within the book. As an adult, I see that Fish doesn't really listen to Snail when he says that he doesn't want to go anywhere. Or maybe Fish does hear this, but really doesn't want to accept it. Fish wants to get his way, wants Snail to change, is willing to leave Snail (maybe forever?) to assert his opinion about who's boss in the friendship. It's manipulative, really, and Snail falls for it (literally). Eventually, on the last page, I see Fish accepting Snail's preference for a kitten-related story, but only within the greater preference Fish asserted of leaving their story to experience another one. That's not cool. On the flip side, though, maybe the story could be a conversation starter about how Snail doesn't need friends like Fish in his life, who don't accept him for who he is, and maybe The Story of Fish and Snail needs a new book that completely belongs to Snail, without Fish in it.
But the artwork was certainly lovely and I did like the meta-ness of the story...
But the artwork was certainly lovely and I did like the meta-ness of the story...
December 7, 2013
Genre: Postmodern
Copyright: 2013
Have you ever seen a fish jumping out of a page or a snail rolling from one book to another? It is not about magic; it is about imagination. Another book from Deborah Freedman who tries to push readers beyond their imaginative limits! Two good friends, Fish and Snail, reside in a book, and every day Snail is waiting for Fish to come back and tell a new story. However, it happens one day when Fish encourages Snail to go on an adventure to another book, which is rejected by Snail and results in a fight between them. After Fish jumps to another book, Snail misses Fish and thinks maybe Fish is right. With courage, Snail rolls out of the old book and joins Fish in the new one. Both of them are happily playing pirate game together in their new adventure. Without many texts, this book tells a story about different aspects of friendship -- caring for one another, accepting differences, and enjoying others' company. The watercolor illustrations reinforce the texts, but they can also stand by themselves to tell a whole story. This simple and short story is told in an interactive way with beautiful illustrations that children will enjoy!
Copyright: 2013
Have you ever seen a fish jumping out of a page or a snail rolling from one book to another? It is not about magic; it is about imagination. Another book from Deborah Freedman who tries to push readers beyond their imaginative limits! Two good friends, Fish and Snail, reside in a book, and every day Snail is waiting for Fish to come back and tell a new story. However, it happens one day when Fish encourages Snail to go on an adventure to another book, which is rejected by Snail and results in a fight between them. After Fish jumps to another book, Snail misses Fish and thinks maybe Fish is right. With courage, Snail rolls out of the old book and joins Fish in the new one. Both of them are happily playing pirate game together in their new adventure. Without many texts, this book tells a story about different aspects of friendship -- caring for one another, accepting differences, and enjoying others' company. The watercolor illustrations reinforce the texts, but they can also stand by themselves to tell a whole story. This simple and short story is told in an interactive way with beautiful illustrations that children will enjoy!
August 25, 2013
This book might need a little explaining to your young dreamers, but then again, it might be interesting to hear their take on Fish & Snail.
Living together in a book, Fish is full of adventure and Snail likes the slower pace, the pace that involves staying in one place and sharing stories with princesses and kittens. Fish was cut out for more and when he finds a new book to be part of, a book with pirates, he tries to convince his best friend to join him.
This is where you can explain to your young reader that it is okay for friends to fight, because that is exactly what these two best chums do. Their fight is so epic that Fish leaves the book. Now what is Snail to do? His best friend is gone.
Deborah Freedman writes a clever tale showing that story characters just might have a mind of their own and want to create their own adventures. Told with the use of pastels set against the black and white world of books not yet opened, the reader is soon mesmerized by a very special world within a world.
Living together in a book, Fish is full of adventure and Snail likes the slower pace, the pace that involves staying in one place and sharing stories with princesses and kittens. Fish was cut out for more and when he finds a new book to be part of, a book with pirates, he tries to convince his best friend to join him.
This is where you can explain to your young reader that it is okay for friends to fight, because that is exactly what these two best chums do. Their fight is so epic that Fish leaves the book. Now what is Snail to do? His best friend is gone.
Deborah Freedman writes a clever tale showing that story characters just might have a mind of their own and want to create their own adventures. Told with the use of pastels set against the black and white world of books not yet opened, the reader is soon mesmerized by a very special world within a world.
September 17, 2013
This story follows two friends, a snail and a fish who live inside a book. While snail is content to stay in their book and play, fish wants to travel to all the other books. The pair embarks on a journey of friendship and adventure, and the illustrations are stunning! I've chosen The Story of Fish and Snail as my candidate for the 2014 Caldecott award for many reasons. For one, the illustrations are beautiful. Each page is unique and just as sweet and wonderful as the story. I also loved this book because of how intricate the illustrations are- while a snail and a fish may seem simple creatures to illustrate, the book world of the two characters is anything but simple. I also loved this book because of how different it is, both in story and illustration. Each page displays the fish and snail in their story book, as well as exploring the other books, and is fascinating to readers of all ages. I loved this book's illustrations, and I absolutely feel the craftsmanship and artistry of the illustrations are worthy of the Caldecott!
October 2, 2013
This is the first book that I read by Deborah Freedman, who is both the author and illustrator, and I absolutely loved it! The narrative and the illustrations were equally stunning and captivating. I excitedly logged on to our public libraries website to order her other work.
The Story of Fish and Snail is a unique adventure and shows that sometimes to be a good friend you have to give the occasional “little push.” Snail is a recluse that holds fast to the safety of is home. His greatest adventures are pretending to be a kitten and awaiting tales from his courageous friend Fish. One day Fish is unable to describe the awesomeness of his latest journey and insists on showing Snail. Snail couldn’t possibly leave the comfort and security of his rock and becomes irate at Snail for even suggesting it. Instead of apologizing and placating Snail, Fish argues back and swims off. Someone standing up to Snail and calling him out on his overly reticent ways is just he push he needed to step off the rock and seek his own adventure.
The Story of Fish and Snail is a unique adventure and shows that sometimes to be a good friend you have to give the occasional “little push.” Snail is a recluse that holds fast to the safety of is home. His greatest adventures are pretending to be a kitten and awaiting tales from his courageous friend Fish. One day Fish is unable to describe the awesomeness of his latest journey and insists on showing Snail. Snail couldn’t possibly leave the comfort and security of his rock and becomes irate at Snail for even suggesting it. Instead of apologizing and placating Snail, Fish argues back and swims off. Someone standing up to Snail and calling him out on his overly reticent ways is just he push he needed to step off the rock and seek his own adventure.
June 25, 2013
I won this through Goodreads First Reads. I just wanted to thank the author for signing the book ( The signature was adorable ). Now for the review:
This story is about two little book characters, snail and fish. They have a little misunderstanding and, consequently, go their separate ways. This little story handles the subject of friendship, adventure, and loyalty to being who you are! I believe the message in this book can inspire children and adults alike.
Definitely recommend it! I can't wait to show this book to my little nieces. Congrats to the author for creating such a wonderful, pure, and fun story. Happy Readings :)
This story is about two little book characters, snail and fish. They have a little misunderstanding and, consequently, go their separate ways. This little story handles the subject of friendship, adventure, and loyalty to being who you are! I believe the message in this book can inspire children and adults alike.
Definitely recommend it! I can't wait to show this book to my little nieces. Congrats to the author for creating such a wonderful, pure, and fun story. Happy Readings :)
July 11, 2013
I loved this book. Not only is it a sweet story about friendship and finding courage to step out of one's comfort zone for the sake of it, but the illustrations are so vivid. Fish and Snail live in a book, but Fish loves to visit other books. When Fish comes back from his latest jaunt he wants Snail to come with him on the next adventure. Snail refuses and the friends have a fight. Snail panics after Fish jumps into another book and has to decide if he values his friend enough to face his fears. I love the writing which is simple and straightforward, perfect for the story. The illustrations match the text beautifully, allowing the story to speak for itself. The facial expressions say it all. Wonderful book, great for sharing. Highly recommended.
August 24, 2013
Oh Snail!!! So many of us understand your hesitancy and fear to be a part of a different story. We too have been egged on by friends like Fish to try something new. We may have even had our friends feel frustrated with us when our fears lead to stubbornness and we just won't move to another place. I would love to use this book to encourage my 1st-2nd graders who may be in a "genre rut" to try something new like Snail did. Sure, Snail tried a new story by accident, but that didn't mean his enjoyment of the story was any less. I would also like to use this as a way to encourage peer recommendations as Fish was so diligently trying to do. The illustrations in this book are very well done and add so much to the book.
December 11, 2013
Genre: postmodern
Copyright: 2013
Two best friends, fish and snail are living in the same book. The snail is always waiting fish to tell him story. One day, the fish invites the snail to leave the book and go to the other book for a new story. However, the snail doe not want to leave and just want to stay at the book they live. They has a big argument about whether to travel to the other book. The argument is broken, and the fish jumps to the other book. The snail does not want to be alone so he jumps to the other book as well. They meets again and play together. It is special that characters in a book can jump to the other book. The author turns readers' thinking to another space and broadens readers' imagination.
Copyright: 2013
Two best friends, fish and snail are living in the same book. The snail is always waiting fish to tell him story. One day, the fish invites the snail to leave the book and go to the other book for a new story. However, the snail doe not want to leave and just want to stay at the book they live. They has a big argument about whether to travel to the other book. The argument is broken, and the fish jumps to the other book. The snail does not want to be alone so he jumps to the other book as well. They meets again and play together. It is special that characters in a book can jump to the other book. The author turns readers' thinking to another space and broadens readers' imagination.
July 13, 2013
This story was so adorable! :) Snail is the homebody that wants to stay in his "story" and not venture outside. Fish always comes back with a story for Snail, but today Fish wants to "show" Snail what he's seen. They have a teensy fight and Fish leaves. Will Snail venture into the world that has the ocean, pirates and adventures? You betcha!! Everything is right in their world and they make up. The illustrations are simply sensational, you can literally see the emotions on the faces of Fish and Snail! So cute!! I love the colors used in the book. Deborah Freedman is a new author for me and I am hooked!! I will collect all her books and eagerly await more. I give this 5 out of 5 YUPIs! :>
Displaying 1 - 30 of 265 reviews