Like a Flower in Bloom by Siri Mitchell

by Siri Mitchell

He Stole the Work She Loved. Will She Let Him Steal Her Heart as Well?It's all her uncle's fault. For years Charlotte Withersby has been free to pursue her love of plants and flowers by assisting her botanist father. But now that she's reached the old age of twenty-two, an intrusive uncle has convinced her father that Charlotte's future--the only proper future for a woman--is to be a wife and mother, not a scholar. Her father is so dependent on her assistance that Charlotte believes he'll soon change his mind...and then Edward Trimble shows up. A long-time botany correspondent in the South Pacific, Trimble arrives ready to step in as assistant so that Charlotte can step out into proper society--a world that baffles her with its unwritten rules, inexplicable expectations, and confounding fashion. Things aren't perfectly smooth between Trimble and her father, so Charlotte hatches a last gasp plan. She'll pretend such an interest in marriage that the thought of losing her will make her father welcome her back. Only things go quickly awry, and she realizes that the one man who recognizes her intelligence is also the person she's most angry Edward Trimble, her supposed rival. Suddenly juggling more suitors than she knows what to do with, Charlotte is caught in a trap of her own making. Will she have no choice but to leave her beloved flowers behind?

Genres: Historical Fiction, Christian Fiction, Romance, Historical, Historical Romance, Christian, Fiction

Paperback

First published December 31, 2014

About the author

also published under the name Siri L. Mitchell & Iris Anthony

Siri Mitchell graduated from the University of Washington with a business degree and worked in various levels of government. As a military spouse, she has lived all over the world, including Paris and Tokyo. Siri enjoys observing and learning from different cultures. She is fluent in French and loves sushi.

But she is also a member of a strange breed of people called novelists. When they’re listening to a speaker and taking notes, chances are, they’ve just had a great idea for a plot or a dialogue. If they nod in response to a really profound statement, they’re probably thinking, “Yes. Right. That’s exactly what my character needs to hear.” When they edit their manuscripts, they laugh at the funny parts. And cry at the sad parts. Sometimes they even talk to their characters.

Siri wrote 4 books and accumulated 153 rejections before signing with a publisher. In the process, she saw the bottoms of more pints of Ben & Jerry’s than she cares to admit. At various times she has vowed never to write another word again. Ever. She has gone on writing strikes and even stooped to threatening her manuscripts with the shredder.

Reviews

[Lindsey (Books for Christian Girls) · Rating 5 out of 5]

About this book:

“He Stole the Work She Loved. Will She Let Him Steal Her Heart as Well?
It’s all her uncle’s fault. For years Charlotte Withersby has been free to pursue her love of plants and flowers by assisting her botanist father. But now that she’s reached the old age of twenty-two, an intrusive uncle has convinced her father that Charlotte’s future—the only proper future for a woman—is to be a wife and mother, not a scholar.
Her father is so dependent on her assistance that Charlotte believes he’ll soon change his minds…and then Edward Trimble shows up. A long-time botany correspondent in the South Pacific, Trimble arrives ready to step in as assistant so that Charlotte can step out into proper society—a world that baffles her with its unwritten rules, inexplicable expectations, and confounding fashion.
Things aren’t smooth between Trimble and her father, so Charlotte hatches a last gasp plan. She’ll pretend such an interest in marriage that the thought of losing her will make her father welcome her back. Only things go quickly awry, and she realizes that the one man who recognizes her intelligence is also the person she’s most angry: Edward Trimble, her supposed rival. Suddenly juggling more suitors than she knows what to do with, Charlotte is caught in a trap of her own making. Will she have no choice but to leave her beloved flowers behind?”


Series: As of now, no.


Spiritual Content- Bible reading; A new rector & sermons he preaches (he’s also constantly writing down things for future sermons); Church going; Talks about God; ‘H’s are capital when talking about God; Talks about different books of the Bible; A Scripture is quoted in the Note from the Author.


Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘hush’, a ‘wretched’ and two forms of ‘stupid’; A few mentions of gambling & debts.


Sexual Content- a semi-detailed kiss; Mentions of Miss Templeton believing she’ll die in childbirth because of her small hips (she has a plan for a scandal, but when her maid tells her what that entails, she quickly dismisses that plan.); Mentions that fatherhood will never be a part of a man’s life (he was told he can’t have children by the many doctors he went to.); The Love, falling in love, and the emotions are so light! More about that in the final thoughts.
*Note: Scandal is caused in a garden club when Charlotte draws the pistils and stamens of a flower (ladies even faint, it’s so taboo!) the teacher tells her that they don’t draw those and if they ever refer to them, the call them “the man and his wives” (to which Charlotte adds “They are running a veritable harem in that flower.”); Mentions of pistils and stamens.

-Charlotte Withersby, age 22
1st person P.O.V. of Charlotte
Set in 1852
356 pages {Read the Acknowledgments! ;D }

~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Three Stars
Early High School Teens- Four Stars
Older High School Teens- Five Stars
My personal Rating- Five Stars
*happy sigh* *happy dance* Oh. Oh. Oh! Miss Siri Mitchell’s style of writing is so different than most authors I review. No guy’s P.O.V! Ha! You know what that means? A whole lot less Sexual content! That’s what! You don’t even miss it! In “Like a Flower in Bloom”, it doesn’t get any hint of romantic till 50 pages near the end (She’s looking for a husband, but there’s no kisses or touches between her and the suitors). Charlotte was too busy being upset at Mr. Trimble to notice he’s cute! And oh my goodness! I laughed so hard at the two of them! Charlotte is just so witty, sassy (but not like sassy-sassy) and innocent! I found myself feeling all the same emotions she felt!
Now, I find flowers interesting but some might not…let me quote you from the Note from the Author:
““I have this great idea for a book about painting, and women, and botany!” I told my agent and my editor. It wasn’t until I planned my research that I started having second thoughts. Because to understand science, you actually have to read about science. And I did. I read about botany, about the history of botany, and about the histories of the botanists who comprise the history of botany. I started my research back in the 1700s and read about what happened well into the 1900s. What a challenge I set for myself with this book: to have a main character who lived and breathed science, yet make the botany interesting to people like me who have no particular interest in it.””
And I think Miss Siri succeeded in that challenge. Very well.

This book is released tomorrow!(1/6/14) Think you’d like it? Go buy it!



Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...



*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Author for an honest review, which I did.

[Olivia · Rating 5 out of 5]

Oh, what a lark!

I don't read as quickly as I used to anymore...perhaps I'm to blame, or it's the disappointing books I keep picking up. But, in this case, I started it and devoured it in about 13 hours (probably would have been quicker if I didn't need my sleep).

I was delighted and exasperated by Charlotte's character. She has no desire to get married, and only takes up the challenge by her uncle because she truly must rid the house of Mr. Timble and his meddling ways in helping her father.

I smiled on nearly every page, and was help captive until the end. Even the botanical science didn't bore me. The characters all managed to speak of it in the most interesting ways, and speaking of characters...what a rollicking group of people. They were all entertaining in their unique ways, and lest you think this is predictable, there are twists along the way. There was also spiritual content spattered throughout that I was happy about, and it was pieced so well with the rest of the story. I was disappointed in one phrase of "in God's name" used when someone was giving a pronouncement.

While there is focus on the equality of men and woman (which, is totally how God intended, but in no ways means the roles are the same), it is refreshing and not in the frustrating way other historical books have presented that time frame. You'd just have to read the book to see what I mean ;)

And so we're left with the romance, which was absolutely frustrating, yet adorable. There were a couple kisses and conversations about not being able to have children. All-in-all a refreshing read compared to a lot of romance books.

If you need a comic read, with some heavy topics and fascinating characters, then grab this one up. You won't be disappointed!!

[Christian Fiction Addiction · Rating 5 out of 5]

It's a good thing I read this book at home and not out in public, because I am quite certain that I spent much of the time smiling and laughing my way through the pages, and therefore likely looked as if I'd taken leave of my senses! However, I simply couldn't help myself, as Charlotte Withersby is truly one of the most entertaining characters to come along in some time. Her lack of social awareness and her naive perspective on life had me in stitches - not to mention the witty dialogue that took place between Charlotte and her father's new assistant Edward Trimble. As you read through the pages, you will definitely see glimpses of yourself as she stumbles from one social faux pas to another! And Siri Mitchell's descriptions of people are hysterical, such as when Charlotte's uncle (in a complementary manner) describes Charlotte as "Sturdy. Sound. Snugly put together". Now, if that isn't every girl's dream description, I don't know what is! (I tried this compliment out on my wife and for some reason it didn't go well). And the most amazing part is that you will walk away from this book not only with a good dose of happy endorphins, but also thinking about the importance of being true to ourselves. We need to live for God and for what he wants for our lives, not with a focus on pleasing someone else, no matter how important to us that they are. Only then can we find contentment in the unique and wonderful person God made each of us to be!

"Like a Flower in Bloom" is a winner in every way, with an engaging plot, delightful characters, and a romance that is unlike any I've ever read before. Fans of historical fiction are going to gobble this one up and beg for more. Well done, Siri Mitchell!

5 out of 5 stars.


Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc.

[Sarah · Rating 5 out of 5]

Siri Mitchell is an amazing writer. I've loved most of her books because they capture a time in history and interesting professions.
This book was funny. I needed this laugh.
It also made me want to reread those books on botany that I loved when I was in school.

[Beth · Rating 5 out of 5]

Quirky, witty and altogether fun! :)

Charlotte Withersby’s dearest wish is to study her beloved blooms as a botanist. She wants to be left alone by her uncle, society and most certainly by her father’s new assistant, an interloper named Mr. Trimble. In a time when women’s views and expertise in botany are not given credence, Charlotte must rely upon the name of her father, a well-known botanist, to publish her own work. When her uncle and father insist that she take on society to snare a husband, Charlotte is sure Mr. Trimble’s lackluster help will soon bring her back to her position as her father’s assistant and put all of the marriage nonsense to rest. What Charlotte doesn’t account for is finding actual suitors, nor is she prepared for the questions that be thrust into society will bring – is her merit in her work or does it lie within herself?

Siri always chooses to write about historical elements that are usually not anything that I’ve read about in another novel. She is a brave author in the sense that she chooses to tackle story elements and character traits that are not widely used. In this case, it was the science of botany. The botany details are fascinating and add a lot of depth to Charlotte’s character development and intellectual tendencies. Charlotte’s quirks are so unique to her character. Siri’s characters and settings are never the norm, which is why her books continue to be a delight to read.

This novel is more on the humorous side, and nowhere is that more evident than in the main character, Charlotte. She is quirky, and if I may, sometimes a bit odd. At first, I wasn’t sure how to take her, but as I read on, she grew on me. There is a possibility that she may not be for everyone; there were times that I was exasperated with her, but at the same time, she is extremely refreshing. She is everything that society is not – she is blunt, unpretentious and lacks the knowledge of all of the social niceties that are expected of her. In her heart of hearts, she wants to take care of her father and wants to be valued for her intellectual abilities, and moreover, wants herself to be enough, no more, no less.

There were also some compelling side characters present in this story. I loved her new-found companion, Miss Templeton - the scenes with her were full of humor, and I loved how she took Charlotte under her wing and had a feeling that she found Charlotte refreshing as well. Their friendship and back-and-forth banter was entertaining to read. Her uncle, her self-named chaperone during all of her social outings is rather enigmatic at first, but as the story progresses, his character and background are revealed, and I was pleasantly surprised by the depth in the interactions between him and Charlotte.

Mr. Trimble may not be the conventional hero, but I felt that he fit well within the story, and his character is very endearing. Despite being declared the enemy by Miss Templeton, it’s soon very clear that he isn’t the usurper that he appears to be and that he has his own reasons for becoming an assistant to a reclusive botanist. I wanted more interaction between him and Charlotte, and while the enemies turned lovers storyline sometimes wears on me, it works well in this story, and provides some humorous and also heartfelt exchanges between him and Charlotte.

Whenever I pick a Siri Mitchell novel I know that I am in for something unique and fascinating. She always takes on topics that stand out, this story lives up to the standard I’ve come to expect in Siri’s novels. Although I’ve enjoyed all of her novels, this one definitely stands out as one I’ve enjoyed most. With a quirky main character, a sweet romance and a fascinating look at the world of botany, Like a Flower in Bloom is a favorite read of the year so far.

[Hannah · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 stars
A lightheartedly serious tale of a young woman who suddenly has normalcy ripped out from under her feet. For eight years she's devoted her life to helping her father with his botany, his correspondence, and keeping a roof over their heads. But when her uncle mentions that it's time for her to marry, her father abruptly hires a young acqauintance who happens along at the right/wrong moment...to do Charlotte's work!...and then sends Charlotte out to find a man in society.
Only, Charlotte has spent all her life working for her calling in botany and has no concept of how to survive the polished, dishonest barbs of society. But for her unexpected new friend Miss Templeton, she'd have no allies on this quest of hers to convince her father that her work actually was important to him and that she doesn't need to marry.

[Staci · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.5 stars! Delightful and entertaining!

I am not one to typically be impressed by a light read. I want depth and learning when I read. Siri has managed to deliver both lightness and depth at once with Like a Flower in Bloom. I adored the dry humor used throughout the novel as well as the many educational insertions about plants. I found myself smiling and laughing as I read. A thoroughly enjoyable read.

A huge thank you to Relz Reviews and Bethany House for the novel. It was a pleasure to be a winner of a giveaway. The opinions expressed are my own.

[Carissa (Regency Woman) · Rating 5 out of 5]

1852, England. Charlotte Withersby cannot believe her ears. Is it possible that her uncle really intends for her to join society? To find a husband, settle down, and give up her beloved study of botany? It seems too cruel to be true except that her father also agrees with him, to the point that he has hired a young man to take her place at his side. Having lost her mother at an early age and also been cloistered away from society for so many years, Charlotte lacks tact and societal graces. However, she is still able to attract two men of the village in which she lives. Except that Charlotte's motivations are actually governed by choosing men she hopes will not be pleasing to her father and that he will take her back as his assistant and caretaker. She cannot bear to let Edward Trimble, the young man now working at her father's side, change everything in their lives, and not even the encouraging words of her new friend, Miss Templeton, can entirely uplift her spirits. Everything she loves, everything she does that is of value, is in danger of being snatched from her, but Charlotte little realizes the true peril of playing with a man's heart to achieve some other purpose. Her road, for a little while, is set on a different path, one that will challenge her to branch out into new experiences and perhaps learn a little discernment along the way.

I love this book. I'm just going to state it, plain and simple, because I don't get to say it often enough! I'm fond of Siri Mitchell's writing in general, but had yet to read one of her books that I could rate as 5 stars, at least until this very moment. Like a Flower in Bloom is a success in every way. Charlotte is charming in her lack of societal graces, her lack of pretense and her blunt honesty. She is an ISTJ if ever there was one, on the Myers-Briggs scale of personality typing. And I think I found her most intriguing because I rarely ever read a female character with this type. Highly introverted, highly intellectual, and brutally honest. It doesn't matter to her whether something is done this way in society if that something is absurd and has little bearing on her life. Why don't people understand botany? How can they possibly consider an artistic rendering of a flower to be accurate when it is missing its stamens and pistils? She is refreshingly delightful in her blunt nature, and because Ms. Mitchell crafted her with also a generous heart, I came to adore Charlotte.

One of the things I admire most about Ms. Mitchell's books is her ability to change her writing voice. Not all authors manage this feat successfully, but her voice in this book is completely different from her voice in Love Comes Calling set in the 1920s, which is different from her voice in A Constant Heart set during the reign of Elizabeth I. She lends authenticity to each of her novels by this remarkable ability to change out her writing voice, but by far, my favorite of her voice's used to this point is the one she chose for Charlotte. I was there, walking with Charlotte through her journey, feeling her pain as she is being forced into a new life not of her choosing, but the ending was delightful. As with most romances, the reader knows how the book must end, but I felt like I was in a race to get there because even though I knew what would happen, I was desperate to see just how it would happen.

If there is a downside, which there really isn't, it's that I didn't get to know the hero very well, obviously Edward Trimble. Oh, you engage with him regularly, and his interaction with Charlotte is delightful, but he has some secrets that he's keeping and because of that, you don't know him. I didn't truly mind that about him, though, because he is quite likeable anyway. As are all the characters, from her uncle who dared to go into something other than botany to her eccentric father to the kindly Miss Templeton to the absurd young men who take an interest in Charlotte . . . the wealthy aristocrat with his collection of stumps and the widower parson possessed of 8 children. The characters, the plot, the setting, it was all pure delight. As was the history lesson of how an intelligent woman in the 1800s might find her scientific research purloined and published by a man instead. I had no idea that sexism was so terribly rampant. I suspected it had to be, but I had never read a book like this before that made the truth of sexism so perfectly clear.

Finally, readers should know that Ms. Mitchell always writes in the 1st person, so if you struggle with that style of writing, as I used to struggle, bear that in mind. She does it the best of any author I have read so if you're branching out into 1st person, her work is a good place to start. I truly congratulate Ms. Mitchell on her quality work in her latest novel, a book I shall treasure for a long time to come and recommend to all lovers of historic fiction.

- I received this book free from Bethany House in exchange for an honest review.

[Virginia · Rating 4 out of 5]

What a good historical romantic comedy! Very well done. I was very surprised and intrigued! I never knew botany could be so interesting. ;)

~My Review~

When I first saw his book, I was amazed at how bright and vibrant the book cover was! I was also amazed at how much I really enjoyed reading this story. It was very captivating and very well written.

I do so love reading about extraordinary women who defeated the odds. There were many women who didn't want to conform to the "norm" but were willing to step out in faith and take a risk to follow their heart's aspirations. I would count Siri Mitchell's heroine along with famous women such as Madame Curie and many other women in history who overcame the odds. I like how Siri Mitchell really gives the reader a glimpse of what it would have meant for women living in this time period. It makes me thankful for the sacrifices women before me went through so that many opportunities could be opened to women today. I was inspired!

I honestly didn't know botany could be so interesting to read about in fiction. The author did a well done job of really capturing my attention when it came to the botany life. It was really amazing and I truly enjoyed myself reading about Charlotte's world. I thought it was very intriguing to learn about the different flowers and such.

All of the characters in this book were just delightful to read about! I found myself being totally immersed into the story and I would be laughing my head off at the many different scenes in this story. It was like a historical romantic comedy at its best!

I'm really looking forward to reading more from Siri Mitchell. Like a Flower in Bloom was filled with adventure,humor,and a taste of romance. I highly recommend this wonderfully written tale.

* I received this book from Bethany House Publishers through Netgalley. All opinions expressed are completely my own and I was not required to give a positive review.*

Originally Posted on My blog, https://ablogfromtheheart.wordpress.c...

[Kav · Rating 5 out of 5]

Oh mercy, but I've been wrestling over how to review this book because it's sooooooo good I'm sure I can't convey it in all it's wonderfulness with mere words. You need to see my grinning face and happy dancing feet and feed off my enthusiastic aura in order to get the full effect Like a Flower in Bloom had on me.

Hysterically funny. Honestly, I chortled and chuckled my way through the whole book. Sometimes I even had to stop and let loose with a hearty guffaw before I could continue reading. The dialogue is priceless. So is Charlotte and long-suffering Mr. Trimble who seem to always be talking at cross purposes.

Mitchell takes a satirical look at the oh-so-prim-and-proper Victorian era and the absurdity of their social niceties by dropping poor, hapless Charlotte into their midst. She's an intelligent woman, a scientific thinker, but might as well be in a foreign country without the benefit of knowing the language for all the ease with which she navigates the unchartered waters of high society.

Using first person narrative gives the reader the full effect of every nuance as we only see things happening from Charlotte's perspective. But we're also a bit socially wiser than the heroine so we understand the implications of a phrase or a look long before Charlotte does. Somehow that makes the read even more fun. And sometimes poignant. Because as much as this is a cunning comedic masterpiece, it is also a pointed look at what it means to appreciate yourself -- and others -- for who they are rather than what society expects them to be.

I'm positive that everyone is sure to be as enraptured with Like a Flower in Bloom as I am. It's not only one for the keeper shelf, but a book I will undoubtedly read more than once because it is just that clever.

Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc.

[Debora Wilder · Rating 5 out of 5]

A delightful “fish out of water” novel!

I absolutely love the characters that Siri has created for this novel. When she introduces Charlotte it is very easy to understand who she is and what her focus for her life is. Then we are introduced to her uncle and her whole existence is turned upside down. The journey she embarks on to try and learn all that she feels is now expected of her is a joy to go on with her. There are multiple times throughout the book that I found myself laughing outright.

The other characters are equally well developed and a lot of fun to get to know and try to understand. After meeting most of the characters it is a wonderful surprise to realize who is able to give her the best advice as she tries to transition to her new role.

I personally don’t know what most flowers are, or the different parts of them, so I really can’t speak to the accuracy of the botanical terms used. I am sure that the research Siri did to write clearly about this very detailed subject was intense. I must applaud her attention to research and presenting the topic so thoroughly.

I received a free copy of this book from the author in exchange for my honest opinion.

[Diane Estrella · Rating 5 out of 5]

Best book written by the author to date. Loved it!

[Anne Osterlund · Rating 5 out of 5]

Charlotte takes care of her father. She is a botanist in her own right, helps him with his work, pays the bills, files all his records—in alphabetical piles around the house, and even—once a year—has been known to dust.

Then thanks to a meddling uncle, her farther realizes she is well past the age for a typical coming out and decides all at once that Charlotte must stop working and find a husband.

Balderdash! Of all the dreadful ideas!

And to top it off, young Edward Trimble—her father’s long distance botany correspondent and friend, who of course has really been corresponding with Charlotte, shows up at their doorstep just in time to take over all the tasks Charlotte has been taking care of since her mother’s death.

Of course, he’s certain to muck them up.

Isn’t he?

Charlotte just may have to hurry him along.

A wonderful story about a passionate young woman who loves both botany and her father. And who is determined not to allow the social strictures of courtship to interfere with her life. Reminiscent of Eva Ibbotson’s novels and Deeanne Gist’s Tiffany Girl. Pure pleasure combined with an intriguing element of history and characters well worth falling in love with.

[Prairie Sky Book Reviews · Rating 5 out of 5]

Nearly everyone can admit to an admiration of the color, mystery, and sheer imaginative variety of one of the most beautiful and smile-inducing elements of our world… Flowers! Not everyone, however, possesses the passion and enthusiasm for botany that Charlotte Withersby does – in fact, her entire life revolves around researching, documenting and collecting flowers. Just who is Charlotte Withersby, you may ask? She is the delightfully unorthodox heroine of a new Bethany House historical novel, brought to life by author Siri Mitchell in her latest inspirational release, Like a Flower in Bloom.

Set in England in 1852, this captivating story captures the struggles of one young woman who, although fictitious, represents true historical circumstances surrounding the study of botany. According to an author’s note from Ms. Mitchell, up until the mid-1800s the primary contributors to the specific field of science were women and clergy, both parties largely interested in illuminating God and enriching faith. After this time, however, professional academics began to take control of the majority of botanical studies – predominantly leaving women out of the picture. With this fascinating background, a personal story is brought to life through the first-person eyes of Charlotte Withersby, researcher and assistant to her acclaimed botanist father. Holding tight to this identity, Charlotte’s life is turned inside out and upside down when her replacement unexpectedly turns up on their doorstep – leaving her free to pursue the socially acceptable activities required but foreign to her. The list includes attending parties and other social functions, dressing accordingly for each occasion (without wearing the same outfit twice) and, oh yes, finding a husband before she falls any further into the abyss of old-maidenhood… The only problems? Charlotte doesn’t want to leave her research behind, she has no interest in being married, and she can’t tell the difference between a travelling suit and an evening gown.

With refreshing wit and whimsy, Ms. Mitchell weaves a unique and engaging story filled with unexpected humor and enchanting characters. A meandering plotline takes its time reaching the climax, but each chapter along the way is entertaining and amusing. Various themes portrayed are certain to resonate with many readers, including discovering the true source of your personal worth, and living according to your life-purpose - not the desires of others. The biggest faults may be that humor occasionally borders on eye rolling silliness, and random comments approach inappropriate content for Christian fiction. Overall, however, Like a Flower in Bloom is a unique delight written in a fun and engaging voice. If you enjoy historical fiction in the inspirational genre, sympathize with characters who just don’t ‘fit in’, and have ever admired a flower – well, this book is for you!

Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc.

[Nidofito · Rating 2 out of 5]

Ok, this book doesn't really deserve two stars but for me, at least in terms of enjoyability, it did.

First of all, I got increasingly mad at the doormat attitude of the heroine and the way the men around her took advantage of her. At the end, everything was resolved and apologies were given and accepted (fortunately) but I got mad at the book for making me mad. So essentially, I was angry at the book for making me emotionally invested in it. Does my logic make sense to you? No? It doesn't to me either. The thing is, the source of my anger, i.e. being taken advantage of by family, was a very sore subject for me and I turned increasingly bitter as I read book. I did not like reading about something I despise IRL presented to me in fiction.

Second, I am annoyed (to put it mildly) at the portrayal of women who are completely socially inept. If done in moderation and in lesser degree, I enjoy it and find them cute and humorous as there a few scenes in the book that I laughed heartily at. But there comes a point where funny becomes sad. And that was the case here with our heroine.

Third, NO ROMANCE! wtf? I thought it was HR. Granted it's Christian romance but there was little indication that there might be those kinds of feelings involved.

Lastly, the fourth reason (and this one hit deep since I am an environment student) was the fact that the heroine made imaginary illustrations for flowers she hadn't herself seen. I rely heavily on plant identification guides when I go out on fields and I am horrified if that ever happened to me in present time.

I enjoyed the hero's character much more. He seemed sensible despite his earlier life only mentioned as a footnote and despite him spending most of the book as a critical teacher rather than a possible LI.

[Martha · Rating 5 out of 5]

Charlotte’s life is happy. She wants for nothing when you open this book, but in the first chapter, I was intrigued. Her uncle’s description of Charlotte caused me to laugh. “You’re a handsome girl, Charlotte. Sturdy. Sound. Snugly put together. It shouldn’t be too difficult to launch you.”

This paragraph will give you an idea of the humor and characters you will be reading in this hilarious novel. The romance is light, like light enough that a family that chooses not to read any books with romance will still find this reminiscent of Jane Austen’s classics. This means, it is there, but more unspoken and very discreet.

This book is hilarious! Charlotte is a very unique character. She is logical, pretty, but doesn’t see herself that way. She loves botany in a time period where it was not popular. She is unskilled in etiquette of proper society. Her life has been fulfilled with her writing, organizing her father’s writing, but each of you will see yourself in her. This is even if you are totally different!

Siri Mitchell can take a character that is nothing like yourself, and you will see yourself in it. This talented author will not disappoint. She takes the study of plants and has woven in a romance without telling you. You create the story in your mind’s eye and it is good!

What did I love about this story the most? I related to Charlotte’s love for her family, writing and a desire to make them happy. You will ask yourself if she will make others happy, or realize that her decision will affect her life for the future. It was something that I related to and hopes you would as well.

This book was given to me for review by the author. The opinions contained herein are my own.

[T · Rating 3 out of 5]

The audiobook for this was great, and the narration of Elizabeth Sastre was absolutely fabulous, so I'm writing this entire review with a British accent in mind. The main character Charlotte was very eccentric and I loved the passion she had for both her dad and her plants. Plus her naivety at social conventions made me laugh out loud.

And honestly, this book was really different. I mean, I've never read a historical novel where the main character is such an accomplished botanist and scientist. I could tell that a lot of research went into this, and there were a few geeky jokes made that made me giggle. And the dialogue between Charlotte and Mr. Trimble kept a smile in my face too. That, and Charlotte's schemes with her new friend Ms. Templetom who made me laugh quite a few times. In addition, I found it cool that Charlotte always compared things to botany, and there were quite a few insights made in this book that surprised me.

But the problem is that the majority of the book was about Charlotte's social failings, and while it was funny, it began to get tiresome because every "funny" encounter followed the same pattern of Charlotte not understanding certain rules, and then insulting someone or saying something "shocking". But that didn't bother me as much as the fact that those social misunderstandings went on for too long in my opinion, and the book could've been a lot shorter. And I felt like we didn't really get to know the love interest Mr.Trimble well enough, but in the end, everything worked out.

In conclusion, a sweet and humorous story. I definitely liked it.

[Callie · Rating 5 out of 5]

I have read several of Siri Mitchell's books, and I have to say, I love how well-researched her historical fiction is! "Like A Flower In Bloom" was no exception. This book follows the story of Charlotte Withersby, a young lady who aspires to be a botanist, as her uncle and father decide it is time for her to put botany aside and find a husband. Mr Trimble takes over as botany assistant to her father, and she soon concocts a plan, along with a new friend, to get rid of Mr. Trimble.

This book was set in an era a couple generations from Jane Austen, but to me it has that same sort of feel as on of Jane Austen's books as we follow Miss Withersby as she enters "society" in England. I also loved the romantic maneuvering and human nature angles that Mitchell included in this story.

Although I found myself getting irritated at Miss Withersby's arrogance at times (maybe she was just supposed to be naive, but her character also seemed a bit arrogant to me), I still thought she was pretty lovable. I wish that through the story she had recognized that maybe she doesn't know best about everything, but I still thought the ending was satisfying. I also found myself laughing throughout the book, and I think it was a very enjoyable read! If you like historical fiction or Jane-Austen-esque fiction, be sure to check this one out!

Note: I received a copy of this book for free from the publisher in exchange for this review. This is my honest opinion.

[Rachel · Rating 5 out of 5]

Delightfully charming and a glimpse into a world traversed by so few in the writing world. I found it quite enjoyable in so many ways. The plot was intriguing and mysterious, the characters uniquely fun, and the main character Charlotte a bundle of laughs as she tries to learn about proper ettiquiette and how to be a lady in society. I love Charlotte's tomboy-introvert charms and say-it-as-it-truly-is personality. The male main character was a fun twist of Darcy/Gilbert...fun and inferiatingly male.

I found myself, quite unbeknowingly, to learn a lot about botany and nature and caring for plants and the study of plant life through this character. Siri Mitchell did accomplish her goal of making a reader who is totally uninterested in learning the details of plant-life and making me VERY interested! :) And of touching on subjects historically going on in this century such at the beginnings of women's rights while making it feel fresh and new and personal to her characters. It was a marvelous story, wonderfully written, and one I shall have to add to my personal collection! :D

[April · Rating 5 out of 5]

To be honest a book about botanist, well I just wasn't sure... But I am a big Siri Mitchell fan, so I had to get it. And am I ever so glad I did! I loved this novel. From the beginning I was captured by the characters and the story. Charlotte, was absolutely delightful! Her complete honesty, unknown trespasses against society codes/standards, all made for a highly entertaining read. While I was not laughing out loud, I found this to be a quiet humorous story. In truth, I felt as if I could picture all of it happening and had an almost movie like reel going through my mind.

All the characters were wonderful and add so much to the novel. And surprised, yes, delightfully so was I by Mitchell's way of writing about botany and this time in history where it is fascinating and fun! Very hard to put this one down and completely enjoyable reading all the while! Bravo, Mitchell!

[Anna Hurtt · Rating 5 out of 5]

I absolutely LOVED this book! Charlotte, the main character, is such a hoot. An eccentric botanist released into the wilds of high society. What could go wrong? This was such a fun read. I was swept up in the story completely. The last few chapters gave me the warm fuzzies. All the other characters are wonderful, too... Very deep, multi-faceted, and unique. This is probably the best Regency that I've ever read. :)

5 stars for a brilliant story that kept me up too late! If you enjoy Regency-era, extremely witty, first-person novels, snatch this one up!

(I received a copy of this book through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review, which I have given.)

[Anne (In Search of Wonder) · Rating 5 out of 5]

The quirky characters in this book, and certain other elements, reminded me of The Importance of Being Earnest. So much fun! It gets very close to being either satirical or caricature-like without quite going there.

I was also reminded of My Fair Lady as I was reading. The MC's complete social ineptitude (really, her ineptitude for anything but botany related issues) and her complete unawareness of that ineptitude come across as charming, and they help create a vulnerability that later softens her a little bit. And, of course, the leading man is able to help her through her difficulties, but he's so much nicer than Henry Higgins!

I was particularly impressed by how Siri Mitchell allowed the reader to see Mr. Trimble falling in love with Charlotte, even though the entire novel was written from her perspective and she had absolutely no idea he was even attracted to her, let alone falling for her. That was some skilled writing right there.

In fact, the skillful writing is why I give it 5 stars. This isn't your run of the mill romance novel. If that's what you're looking for, you might not like it because you might not be able to get past the eccentricities of the characters and the style of this book. But if you appreciate fine writing -and love a little eccentricity- you'll really enjoy this book!

[Jenn Sands · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book was a real delight. I listened to it as an audiobook and was totally drawn in by the characters and story.

[James Pate · Rating 5 out of 5]

Charlotte Withersby lives with her father and her cranky housekeeper in nineteenth century England. Her father is a botanist, and Charlotte collects samples for him, writes and illustrates his books for him, and takes care of his bills and his correspondence. She loves her work, even though, sadly, she does not get any credit for it. Her uncle, an admiral who left botany to sail in the Opium Wars, thinks it is time for Charlotte to get married. Edward Trimble arrives to perform Charlotte’s daily tasks, while Charlotte enters the social scene in search of a husband. Charlotte resents Mr. Trimble and does not want to get married, so she hatches a plot with her new friend, the social butterfly Miss Templeton, to appear like she’s looking for a husband, in hopes that her father will change his mind and let her come back to her work. Charlotte manages to get two admirers, notwithstanding her bluntness, her tendency to take things literally, and other social faux pas she commits. Meanwhile, Mr. Trimble offers her social tips, and we learn in the course of the book where he learned the art of playing the social scene.

Like a Flower in Bloom is narrated in the first person, from Charlotte Withersby’s perspective. Her manner of narrating is very English, and thus formal and sophisticated. But she can also be hilarious, at times, especially as she tries to make sense of etiquette and the rules of socializing. For example, when Mr. Trimble challenges her that her walk is all wrong because she looks like she is in a hurry to get from one place to another, she replies that walking is for that very purpose—-to get from one place to another! Those who like the TV show Bones will love this book! Charlotte reminded me a lot of Temperance Brennan!

The dialogue in the book had a sort of Aaron Sorkin feel to it: rapid, witty. It reminded me somewhat of The Newsroom, especially scenes in the show where people interact with the socially-awkward, and also lovely, Sloan Sabbith.

In a note at the end of the book, the author, Siri Mitchell, comments on botany in the seventeenth-nineteenth centuries, the Opium Wars, and introversion. Her comments on introversion were especially endearing to me, especially her statement that “Perhaps my novels always speak to questions of worth because so often I doubt my own” (page 361). Her comments on the history of botany, however, puzzled me a bit, because I had a difficult time making sense of them in terms of the plot of the book. According to Mitchell, there was a division between people who studied botany to understand God through creation, and people who treated botany as more of a secular discipline. Mitchell seemed to express a preference for the former theological approach. The thing is, Charlotte appeared to me to lean more towards the latter approach, focusing on the classification of plants. Occasionally, Charlotte contemplated the theological significance of botany—-as when she reflected that everything, however strange (strange plants, and herself), has a place in God’s world—-but it seemed to me that she had those kinds of reflections when she was inspired by discussions with others, particularly the rector; left to her own devices, her approach was rather secular. Later in the book, Charlotte wonders what the meaning of her work is and how it even teaches people about God, and that puzzled me somewhat, since her work prior to that point did not seem to be about theology. That could be Mitchell’s point: that it should have been. Even though that passage confused me, it still was important in the story, for it is not surprising that Charlotte’s attitude towards her work would be different when she returns to it after time away.

I should also note that Charlotte becomes more of a feminist, expressing the sorts of sentiments that would appear in Betty Friedan’s The Feminine Mystique. I consider it a good thing for an evangelical book to express those sentiments.

Notwithstanding my confusion in areas, I am giving this book five stars. As a person with Asperger’s Syndrome, I appreciated reading Charlotte’s journey to navigate her way through social mazes. And one of the book’s key themes resonated with me: the theme of accepting people as they are, even if they walk to the beat of a different drummer.

The publisher sent me a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

[(Jen) The Artist Librarian · Rating 5 out of 5]

Some of my favorite historical fiction are books that have “unique” plots, so I thought I’d enjoy Like a Flower in Bloom. I absolutely loved this book –I can’t believe I haven’t read more of Siri Mitchell’s work! But even if you aren’t interested in botany, Charlotte is a feisty heroine and her quick witted retorts and banter with her rival will have you smiling (and/or chortling) throughout the novel!

The dialogue is snappy and sassy in all the right ways! I called this book my “Best Wittiest-Banter-Ever In a Novel” in my 2014 Best Reads for a reason! It’s so “quoteable” … I don’t know if it’s because I had an e-book ARC, but I highlighted so much! The following exchange below is one of my favorites. It’s almost subversively unexpected for CBA but nevertheless tasteful and clever so I still found it funny. (If there are any fellow “Gaters” out there, it reminded me a bit of Capt. Samantha Carter’s memorable discourse in her Stargate SG-1 debut):

“It was just a joke, I assure you.”

“Yes. Exactly. That’s exactly how I feel. As if all that I’ve done and all that I’ve accomplished are to be set aside for some more suitable assistant simply because I’ve got pistils!”

“Pistils …?”

“As if they’re somehow considered less worthy than stamens!”

“Stamens …?”

“Can you see how this is quite vexing?”

“I can see that you’re highly incensed.”

“Extremely.”

He stood once more and then bowed. “Extremely incensed. I think, it more accurate, perhaps, to say that it is you whom I am ultimately assisting.”

If he hadn’t usurped my position then I might have appreciated the sentiment. “Thank you, Mr. Trimble.”

Much of the humor in this story stems from the protagonist’s obliviousness to societal rules. While Charlotte is an intelligent young woman –her knowledge of plants and botany rivals or surpasses those around her– the death of her mother and her subsequent work with her father has left her a bit out of touch with society’s expectations. Taking on many responsibilities after mother’s death, she’s also a bit overprotective of her father (which makes for good character growth when she realizes this). There was only one moment (well, two, actually), that was a bit of a stretch that she’d be that obtuse to social cues, but I felt that it was still believable!

Reminding me partly of Mr. Knightly (Emma), with a bit of Professor Higgins (My Fair Lady), and all Mr. Trimble, Edward is the perfect foil to Charlotte. His command of societal manners, customs, and behaviors hint to something more than just a simple New Zealand sheep farmer. He’s also quite witty and his intelligence matches hers. Easily one of the best heroes I’ve read in a recent historical romance. Edward and Charlotte’s unintentional years long correspondence gave them a history or friendship, that when becoming “rivals” in real life once in England, made for a delicious sort of tension. The artist in me also loved the details of botany illustration and the difference between that and ... other art (oh my, the painting lesson). In fact, chapter 21 has my favorite parts (sorry, no spoilers!), with Mitchell using drawing and sketching to frame two touching, memorable scenes.

The whole book reads like a lighthearted romantic (historical) comedy –I kept thinking how amazing it would be to see it as a movie (must be that dialogue)! But at the same time, it poignantly touches on the roles of women, societal expectations, individual worth in Christ, and the importance of allowing God to work in your life. A wonderfully researched novel –even the author’s note is fascinating to read– I wholeheartedly recommend!

[Disclosure: I received a complimentary digital ARC from the publisher via Netgalley.com]

[Erin H. (ITIO Book Reviews) · Rating 3 out of 5]

Actual rating: 2.5

A huge thanks to Bethany House Publishers and Siri Mitchell for sending me a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest, unbiased review.

I have a secret penchant for books about botany-loving protagonists. Now that I’ve told you, it’s not much of a secret anymore. It’s all good. I’ve never read one of Mitchell’s novels, but I wasn’t impressed with this one.

Sheltered, intelligent Charlotte Withersby assists her father in picking and classifying different plants for his work. Since the passing of her mother, she has spent an exorbitant amount of time writing correspondences for him, illustrating plants for him, cleaning up the house for him, etc. Everything she has done has been for him. When her uncle declares that she needs to start looking for a husband, her father agrees, much to her chagrin. At the same time, her father hires a new assistant, the young and handsome Mr. Trimble. Charlotte can’t help but hate the man that has stolen her life’s work. She devises a plan to pretend to be interested in finding a husband in order to steal her job back, but everything doesn’t go as she’d originally planned.

MORAL RATING:

G: Excessive descriptions of plants and one kiss…your elderly grandma could read this and you wouldn’t be embarrassed! Yay!

THE GOOD:

I tried to keep an open mind about this book while I was reading it. Like I mentioned earlier, I love books about botany-loving protagonists. Plants are so interesting! I believe that this plot held great promise, but it fell short for me. The writing was decent and the cover is beautiful, but the characters didn’t grab my interest like I would’ve liked.

I liked the ending of the novel, but I don’t think it was altogether worth reading just to read the last thirty pages.

THE BAD:

My first complaint lies in the pacing of this novel. I can always appreciate a well-researched historical romance, but this novel was filled with too much botanical, scientific information. It was clear to me that Siri Mitchell didn’t have a great grasp on the scientific world of Charlotte Withersby. There was almost an overload of information. As a result, this novel moved at an alarmingly sluggish pace. It took about 200 pages for me to somewhat interested in the plot and that is never a good sign! If I hadn’t been given a copy of this novel, I wouldn’t have finished it. Even so, I skimmed quite a bit.

While I could understand that Charlotte Withersby was a scientific kind of woman–not known for her knowledge of customs or manners–I couldn’t understand her stupidity in social situations. She had absolutely no understanding of how to relate to other people. It’s not like she’s been stuck inside her house her whole life! I found myself annoyed with her throughout this novel.

The romance in this book was not well-founded and seemed completely unnecessary. Romance was one of the main plot points, but there wasn’t much development in Charlotte and Mr. Trimble’s relationship throughout the novel. I didn’t care about them and that made me sad.

MY VERDICT:

Overall, I’d give this novel a 2.5/5! It was well-written, but the characters aggravated me at times and the plot moved too slow for my enjoyment. I may pick up one of Mitchell’s other books another time, but I wasn’t impressed by this one.

For more reviews, check out: ITIO Book Reviews

[Jessica · Rating 5 out of 5]

It's been many months since I picked up a Siri Mitchell book to read. I hadn't planned on reading another of her books for a while but I couldn't resist reading “Like a Flower in Bloom” when I saw it on the library shelf the other day. I didn't expect to like this one very much when it first came out last year but I added it to my “to read” list anyway. I've never really had a huge interest in botany, though I do love flowers, but something just grabbed my attention and I knew I absolutely had to read it a.s.a.p. It may have been the cover that peaked my interest. I mean, It's pretty much perfect. The colors and font and that beautiful dress... it really captures a persons fancy. Then I read the back and I found I couldn't wait to read it. In fact, I started reading as soon as I got home from my library trip. There is nothing better than a good book on a Sunday afternoon.

I loved Charlotte's character. It's rare to read about heroines that aren't strictly emotionally driven characters. Most of the time, girls tend to be emotional creatures, whether in books or in real life. Even when they are strong, warriors, they are usually also vulnerable. Charlotte wasn't like that. She was factually driven. She found it difficult to accept anything that didn't serve a functional purpose or that wasn't based solely in the intellectual realm. Though she enjoyed flowers, it was in the scientific sense through the study of botany. She would have been a hard, cold character had it not been for all the changes she experienced throughout the book. In fact, the reader is given nothing more than a glimpse into her life before things start to change for her. I liked watching her journey into not simply working as a botanist, but also in beginning to expand her circle of friends and broadening her world to not remain strictly in all things scientific. Her character softened over the course of the book without ever truly losing what made her Charlotte in the first place. She became more feminine and girly, able to appreciate some of the finer things in life while still remaining true to herself in the end.

Edward Trimble was by far my favorite male character. Right from the start I was rooting for him. Having grown up with sisters, he really was the only available candidate that was capable of helping Charlotte grow into a more refined young woman. Granted, he didn't always have the most amazing advice or carry out everything to perfection, but he did quite a good job at running everything without being unlikeable. His cartoons were adorable, his personality was wonderful, and I loved that he fit into Charlotte's and her father's lives without being out of place or creating further chaos for them.

The faith message in this book was subtle which I found I appreciated greatly. It wove seamlessly into the plot and characters lives as if it were nothing more than a comforting cup of tea. And yes, I realize that is quite “fanciful to say.” ;)

This book was so refreshing to read. It wasn't average or ordinary. It wasn't yet another western or regency themed book (not that I don't enjoy those books as well), it was a book filled with unique characters, and a gripping storyline. I even found a love of botany that I didn't know I possessed. This book is by far, one of my new favorites and is definitely going on my wish list. I need it on my shelf with the rest of my collection of adventures.

[Hope Fields · Rating 4 out of 5]

Charlotte wants to continue working for her botanist father, but he has other plans for her future. Will she find a way to follow her heart and fulfill society's expectations?

4.5 stars.
Siri Mitchell's newest book Like a Flower in Bloom completely surprised and delighted me with its wit and humor! Charlotte completely refreshed me with her literal and blunt way of speaking things, and in a way convicted me of the many times that I have deceived people into believing that I think a certain thing when in fact I think quite the opposite. I love it how Mitchell brought out this theme of truth and the different ways others interact with those around them in the novel. I appreciated that the author addressed how wrong and useless the common belief that it is better to tell people what they want to hear instead of what the truth is.
I was completely entertained reading this light yet serious novel and loved all the characters because they were believable. I especially appreciated and loved the many facts about botany and the proper way to pick and preserve plants and flowers. I definitely enjoyed learning more about botany through Charlotte's eyes.

Overall the novel was very appropriate and no inappropriate scenes were discussed in detail. There was an element of romance to this book but we do not see or really even come to fully know about it until the last 40 pages or so. Also, there were some great spiritual applications discussed as well as truths that could be gleaned from simply reading this novel.

I had previously read Siri Mitchell's book She Walks in Beauty and fell in love with her writing! I will definitely be reading more of her books because of the relative and profound truths that I can apply to my life about my place in society as well as issues about pleasing people or God.
One of my favorite quotes from the novel that to me seems to sum up Charlotte's personality and the theme of the book:
"The truth is that I have tried my best to fit in with science, for which my sex has apparently made me ill-suited, and I have done my best to fit in with society, for which my passion for botany has made me equally ill-suited. The truth is that I seem to fit neither here nor there, and I deem it best, at this moment, to take myself upstairs. If you will excuse me."

This statement that Charlotte declared to her father and Mr. Trimble demonstrates her blunt way of putting things, her realization of her frustration with society and the human race, and the serious yet funny way of how she so honestly tells others how she is feeling and what she wants to do...like go upstairs at that moment instead of talking more.

Definitely recommended for mature adult or older teen readers who enjoy historical and inspirational fiction!

[Angela · Rating 4 out of 5]

I always (with one exception) love Siri Mitchell's books. Her research is thorough, the characters are believable and completely fit in with their historical setting, the stories are original, and the lessons learned are memorable. For all those reasons, I couldn't wait to start reading her latest, "Like a Flower in Bloom" and it didn't disappoint.
Charlotte Withersby has been helping her father with her botany work as long as she can remember. After the death of her mother, Charlotte took over the general running of things and spurred her father on in his studies and research. Everything comes crashing down after two events: her uncle suggesting she needs to get a husband and a botany correspondent, Edward Trimble, arriving at their door.
Suddenly, Mr. Trimble is asked to stay on as her father's assistant, freeing her up to look for a husband and get married. In anger and frustration, Charlotte comes up with a plan: she will pursue husband hunting with such delight and fervor that her father will realize his mistake and throw Mr. Trimble out.
Things immediately begin to go wrong. Charlotte is not accustomed to 'polite society' and breaks nearly every social rule. She finds herself with two suitors, each with their own problems in her eyes. She longs to write, illustrate, and begin assisting her father again but she holds herself back, convinced he will see his mistake before she has to choose which of her suitors to marry.
Then there is the mysterious Mr. Trimble. For a sheep farmer from New Zealand, he knows an awful lot about servants, polite conversation, ladies fashion, and acceptable behavior. Who is he really and what else can Charlotte do to get rid of him?
I absolutely loved Charlotte. She's one of my new favorite heroines. Her literal way of conversing and interacting with people made me laugh. The book is written in first person and just her way of seeing and describing everything around her brought a smile. Charlotte reminds me a lot of Temperance Brennan from the 'Bones' TV show.
I also loved the history and information in the area of botany. I don't know much about plants but Mitchell's descriptions really made the flowers and landscape more easy to picture. The colorful cast of secondary characters provided more laughs and enjoyment. I felt like I was watching, not reading, the action.
As with any novel written in first person there are times when I wished I was inside Mr. Trimble's head instead of Charlotte's but those times were few and far between. The conclusion was perfect and I closed the book completely satisfied at a story well told. Highly recommend.

I received a copy of this book in return for an honest review. The thoughts and views expressed are my own and were not influenced in any way by the publisher.

[Sarah Morin · Rating 5 out of 5]

Our heroine, Charlotte, is wildly entertaining. Author Siri Mitchell makes the humor really work by telling the story her Charlotte’s romantic entanglements from 1st person. Charlotte is book-smart—or shall I say plant-brilliant—as a botanist. But she’s clueless about the rules of society in 1850s England. She can’t dissemble at all to blend in, and when society doesn’t make sense to her, she says so. There are multiple times Charlotte prides herself on an interaction gone well, when I as a reader groaned and smiled because I saw how poorly it actually went when you read between the lines.

This combination of genius and total lack of comprehension both confound and draw in those around her. First, her well-meaning father and uncle, who have “neglected” her by allowing her to sit out the marriage market and study science, and now are shoving her forcibly into the social game. Then there is her new friend, the social butterfly Miss Templeton. It’s hard to tell just how smart Miss Templeton may be herself, because she is so much better at coyly hiding it, but she certainly can play the period ditz when she chooses. How to describe their friendship? Hm, imagine Cher from Clueless adopted Mary Bennet from Pride and Prejudice.

Of course the person who is most vexed and enthralled by our heroine is our hero, Mr. Trimble. And he’s an odd assembly of parts himself. Is he a New Zealand sheep farmer, botanist, secretary, runaway from a ne’er-do-well family, or what? And how does he know so much about high society that he feels he has the knowledge (and the gall) to lecture Charlotte not wear a dress with inkstains to a ball, or how to dance a waltz?

But the most insufferable part of this man is he took Charlotte’s job as her father’s assistant. I loved being in Charlotte’s mind as the highly frank and intellectual creature wrestled with having a new and traditional female role forced on her. She doesn’t take the loss of her scientific passions lying down. But her attempts to get her old position back by conniving to win suitors and make her father see how much he really needs her only land her in more trouble.

This book hinges on the question of the era, “What do women want?” And author Siri Mitchell does our two female characters the honor of recognizing it may be different for each woman. The men in our story all mean Charlotte well, but only some of them gradually become aware that by telling Charlotte what she wants instead of letting her decide, they may be trampling the flower in bloom instead.

Entertaining, good variation of pace, touches on themes both light and deep.