Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Geddy's Moon

Rate this book
Tyler is an amnesiac, drifting aimlessly across the country, struggling to regain his lost memories. When he arrives in Geddy’s Moon, a sleepy town in the middle of the Kansas wheat fields, fragments of his past begin to resurface. But as he establishes new relationships in town, and spends time with the local librarian and her son, he finds himself tormented by nightmares that grow more unsettling each night. What horrific events took place before Tyler arrived in Geddy’s Moon? And could he have brought a terrifying – and possibly supernatural – danger along with him? As the pieces of his fractured memory begin to fall into place, he fears that it may already be too late to keep himself, and those he’s begun to care about, safe from a vicious evil.

483 pages, Kindle Edition

First published February 20, 2013

26 people are currently reading
343 people want to read

About the author

John Mulhall

10 books70 followers
John Mulhall is a storyteller. His debut novel, the supernatural thriller Geddy’s Moon, was a #1 horror best seller on Amazon, and also named one of the best of 2013 by Suspense Magazine. His follow up novel, Dark and Broken Things, a poignant psychological thriller, met similarly enthusiastic reviews. His first collection of poetry, A Beautiful Suffering, was released in 2918. He lives in Newbury Park, CA, where he is currently at work on a second volume of poems, as well as two new novels, several short stories, and a stage play.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
126 (42%)
4 stars
91 (30%)
3 stars
52 (17%)
2 stars
20 (6%)
1 star
6 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews
Profile Image for Darin White.
1 review7 followers
March 19, 2013
Mr. Mullhall deftly weaves a plot that is clearly palpable. Through masterful character development, the reader is drawn into the reality that this novel generates with thoughtful (dare I say), wicked intent. I found myself so completely drawn into the plight of the book’s protagonist, I felt as though I were recalling events from my own past. The supporting characters receive sufficient development for the reader to feel them, but not so much that they detract focus from the work’s hero - a delicate balance to achieve.

As a fan of the horror/thriller genre all of my life, I rarely discover material that departs from “tried and true” formulae. Geddy’s Moon is an intelligent redux of stories so many of us fans of horror love so well. With painstaking attention to detail, Mr. Mulhall introduces us to new and fascinating theories based on legendary themes. The descriptions of the settings and locations within the novel’s plot momentarily pull the reader into a fantasy world, only to crash them unapologetically back into the world of horror. It is an e-ticket ride that I enjoyed from start to finish.

It has been stated elsewhere in other reviews, but I’ll say it again here: This work does NOT possess the attributes of a Freshman effort. Let’s just hope that whatever nightmares Mr. Mullhall experienced to inspire this novel are not finished with him yet - we want more.
Profile Image for LadyCalico.
2,311 reviews47 followers
March 24, 2013
I usually avoid paranormal novels, thinking them to be paranormal romances, the dumbest literary idea anyone ever cooked up. However, when you dream up a really cool old fashioned monster instead of just making werewolves and vampires the greatest lovers in the history of the world--you can end up telling a pretty amazing tale. Mr. Mulhall accomplishes that feat and then some. Here's to a well constructed tale, that builds like great architecture, and doesn't have a leaky roof.
Profile Image for Dianna D.
5 reviews4 followers
April 1, 2013
Geddy's Moon, Kansas is a cozy little town far away from big cities like Los Angeles figuratively and literally, and a place some folks settle down for that very reason. Maybe that's why the town's sheriff is not as welcoming as some of the townsfolk when Tyler, a drifter who can't remember who he is or where he came from, wanders in to work as a laborer at a local farm. While the sheriff has a hunch he's hiding something and perhaps running from trouble, Tyler gains the friendship and trust of others as he begins to unlock his troubling dreams. The trickle of memories becomes a flood that cannot be stopped and brings him back to the start of a nightmare his mind had allowed him to forget so long ago. The suspense and horror start on page one and don't let up for a moment. Whomever or whatever terrorising this town and Fairview Park before it has no mercy on adults and children alike. And it will not stop, just like Geddy's Moon does not stop bringing the chills. Readers who grew up in the 70s/80s will be pleased over and over at the memories of their own childhood that are evoked just as Tyler's begin to resurface. However, any fans of horror or an exceptionally well told tale will enjoy this walk - or run - through the woods. The author John Mulhall brings each character, of this world or any other, to life and does the same for their surroundings without sacrificing the fast paced action. Highly recommended, although doors, windows and noisy back gates should be secured before reading. Maybe leave a light or two on as well.
2 reviews3 followers
January 9, 2013
Geddy’s Moon is so much more than just a supernatural thriller, it’s a study of relationships and the lengths we will go to in order to protect them. I found myself in constant awe of the twists and turns that John Mulhall took me on as the reader, and the genres the book straddled. Every time I thought all the questions had been answered and that there was nowhere else to possibly go, the author took me around another bend. I first read this book in pieces but found myself rereading it again after I finished, this time in just a few hours, still devouring every detail and picking up clues I somehow missed the first time. I was wrapped up in each character’s story and wanted to know more….How? What??? Why??? Even after reading the book two times, I find myself wanting to read it again to find anything else I may have missed, and to revisit the characters I grew to love and care about. I can only hope that there is a sequel coming. This is truly an amazing book and it is hard to believe that John Mulhall is a first time author. Don’t judge this book by its cover, it is so much more, let it take you on a journey you won’t soon forget.
Profile Image for Christopher Depalma.
1 review
December 14, 2012
So.......I have really worked hard over the past few years at being as honest as I can be, both with myself, and with others. I have come to realize the tremendous value in doing so. While reading this book, I found myself feeling very open to the idea that I was going to be as real as possible about my feelings, and Interest that occurred throughout the story. I started the book with no pre framed period of time that I was going to read it in, and found myself Naturally and organically re drawn to reading this book over and over again, to the extent that I finished the 469 pages in less then 48 hours. What I think that John has done Masterfully here, is bring the reader's to a story that at many times can seem very familiar, borderline Nostalgia , but deliver's such a great combination of twists, originality, and timing, which really ties this book into something very special. Reading this book can really give you a vacation from the daily grind, and set you down into a trip through an edge of your seat, rich in story and context, Horror/Suspense Thriller. Great Job!
Profile Image for Larissa.
542 reviews106 followers
April 12, 2013
Reviewed by Sarah

It's a mixture of nerves and excitement when I see a review option from a debut author and with this book there was just something that made me have to read it. The synopsis is very good and the cover is also enticing you in more. Reading the first chapter I had absolutely no choice but to carry on reading page after page.

The first chapter is way back into the past and believe me the last paragraph is the hook to get you reading the rest of this book. I won't give it away but it you like a cliffhanger mixed with massive plot clue then you're going to love it! I found myself reading this through on just a few sittings as it was just so page turning and you totally forget that this is a new unknown writer. The book is anything but predictable with the villain being ... I can't say that's too much of a spoiler.

If you like your books mixed with a lot of great character development and a credible villain then this is definitely for you. The synopsis in the end doesn't really do it credit and whilst it's quick to mention a Stephen King likeness in the style of the books, I think Mulhall is making a name for himself and is definitely a writer to look out for in 2013 and beyond.

If you're not a fan of creepy books then this isn't for you. Or just read it with the light on.

Great first book from John Mulhall and cannot wait to read more of his books in the future.

Originally Posted at Welcome to Larissa's Bookish Life
Profile Image for Greg D.
885 reviews22 followers
September 18, 2015
Overall, it was decent but not great. For most of the story it was engaging and suspenseful. Very creative. But, it just seemed to drag on. The author could have easily cut 100 pages from the book. There were also many things that were left unclear and disjointed. For example, there was a disconnect between the history of the creatures and their modern day appearances. And, it was difficult to determine what was a dream and what was reality? And, why did only a couple of kids know who Simon was, but not the others? Finally, the gratuitous and violent sex scene was really unnecessary. But, as with many amateur authors the obligatory sex scene is a must I suppose. On a positive note, the storytelling and character development were very well done. And, the epilogue made for a very interesting read. But, I will likely not rush out to purchase and read any sequels written by this author.

ADDENDUM: I have discovered that the publisher of this book (Blanket Fort Books) is going to great lengths at monitoring everyone's reviews on Amazon. They are asking some people to put "Spoiler Alert" in their reviews when there are really no spoiler alerts needed. Furthermore, I have a hunch they are downgrading everyone's reviews who gave this book a low rating. I am suspicious of any publisher who has nothing else better to do than to go around doing this. On the other hand, with only one book to their credit it makes it sense.
Profile Image for Babus Ahmed.
792 reviews61 followers
March 4, 2013
The book starts with the unearthing of something that should have stayed buried. A spate of murders, a trio of boys charged with stopping them. The story goes beyond just the overcoming of an evil entity and provides a history which is totally enthralling. I loved the fact our curiosity was satisfied within this book and yet there is still a place for a sequel and lose ends to be tied up. I make no apologies for being cryptic as you need to read the twists and turns without it being ruined by spoilers.

This generally well-written and action packed novel is fresh, atmospheric and delivers. Not one to miss!
Profile Image for Audra Ely.
1 review2 followers
March 10, 2013
What more could you ask for in a book? I cried, got angry, laughed,and thought my heart would beat out of my chest on several occasions. Geddy's Moon was amazing from start to finish and was full of suspense that kept me wanting to continue reading to see what could possibly happen next! Just when I thought I knew the outcome, author John Mulhall found a way to surprise me and pull my in deeper. If you are going to read this phenomenal book make sure that you designate time because you will not want to put it down. I can not wait for the next book from John Mulhall. He will be an author that I will await anxiously for the next book to be released!!!
Profile Image for Megan S Spark.
40 reviews11 followers
March 23, 2013
Well rated first novel-- & I found myself suspicious. Would this be a teen romp?? Reading the introduction, I found the author shares many of my own thoughts on reading and libraries, so that heartened me to dive in. Wow... What a wild ride this story is! I liked the characters, the sojourns to the past (oh I remember those 1980's too, ha) and I especially loved those scrappy kids. The literary quotes to introduce each chapter were well chosen, setting the mood to perfection. And we've a villain that is a villain through and through, with all of the terrors and ego that should come with the package. I enjoyed this, recommend it, and hope to read more from Mr. Mulhall.
Profile Image for Michael Kundin.
1 review1 follower
January 11, 2013
Geddy’s Moon is a tightly woven novel containing the perfect mixture of mystery and suspense. The deftly placed horror and paranormal scenes are guaranteed to keep you on the edge of your seat. I couldn’t put the book down, every spare moment was dedicated to the next page until the climax which, manages to satisfy and leave the reader wanting more. I sincerely hope there is a sequel in the works. Mulhall is a word smith worthy of a position in the horror genre next to Clive Barker and Stephen King.
Profile Image for eReaderPerks.
9 reviews49 followers
March 21, 2013
Wow! Ok, I am not just excited about the total gem of a book called Geddy’s Moon. I am even more excited because I have found an amazing talent in a brand-new-to-me author named John Mulhall and can’t believe this is his debut novel. Yay! A fabulous new author to read! My review of this book is up on my site at www.ereaderPerks.com. This is a can't miss Horror story and right this minute it's free on Amazon!
30 reviews
August 8, 2022
This book had potential but it was weird and meandered way too much. I love stuff that’s kind of out there. I’m a huge Stephen King fan and had high hopes for this one. But it disappponts all around.
Profile Image for C.K. Webb.
Author 15 books123 followers
June 10, 2013
GEDDY'S MOON was written by debut novelist John Mulhall and was published by Blanket Fort Books in February 20th, 2013. You can learn more about John by visiting his website at www.johnmulhall.com

Geddy’s Moon can be described with only one word… Masterpiece! The characters are full of life and can be seen by the reader as clearly as if they were standing right in front of you. The level of emotion achieved by the writer is a true thing of beauty and not something you easily find amongst debut novelists. I fell in love with the characters and found myself twisted up with every emotion they felt… I had to know more, I had to take that journey with them. I am so glad I did.

'Geddy's Moon' is a quaint little town in Kansas. Like so many small towns, Geddy’s Moon has a few secrets of its own and doesn’t plan on keeping them hidden for long. Tyler has been trying to recover his memory for some time when he finds himself in the windswept wheat fields of Geddy’s Moon; a new life ahead of him. He meets a woman and begins spending time with her and her son. On the surface, everything seems great, but it is what’s just beneath the surface that’s got Tyler on edge.

As each night in Geddy’s Moon brings more and more vivid nightmares, Tyler is unsure if those around him are safe; unsure if he is even who he thinks he is. As the dreams become more real, so do the childhood memories that began to race back in; memories that can’t possibly be real… or can they?

The story is complex, but well thought out. There are some horrifying moments, some brilliant twists-&-turns and the ending is, for lack of a better word, perfect!
I have seen so many readers comparing Geddy’s Moon to the likes of Stephen King and even Dean Koontz ( a pretty sweet comparison might I add?), BUT…

I WILL NOT BE DOING THAT…

However, I will tell you that Geddy’s Moon is a book unlike any you have read and though the narrative feels familiar, like an old friend whose face has faded in memory over time, but whose voice stays with you and lingers, John Mulhall has stood up and screamed to the rafters and he has done it with a voice ALL his own! A truly new voice has emerged… Horror fans take notice!

I am giving Geddy’s Moon a much deserved 5-spider rating and recommending it to anyone who isn’t afraid of the dark!

CK Webb for WebbWeaver Reviews http://bit.ly/HWQKW
Profile Image for Lia Burres.
Author 4 books6 followers
March 11, 2013
Spoiler Alert!:




A wonderful horror book with lots of Stephen King type writing. It didn't take much to grab me into this book. (Even though I'm not really suppose to read horror books as a rule from my husband, after watching Stephen King's The Mist and he said I slugged him... still don't think I did, really. If I had, my hand would had known it.)
Tyler, which didn't know anything of his past due to having amnesia, was in a town very far away. He had no idea how he got there, who he was, where he was from or anything else. All he knew is that he was trying very hard to remember who he was or even a simple part of his past. He was hired on as a farm hand on a farm that grew wheat. He had boarding at a cafe that offered a room to him. The old woman that ran it couldn't believe that he had done anything bad, but knew she felt sorry for him and allowed him to have a room above the cafe.
Soon, Tyler started seeing a girl from the local library that had a son that was about 10 years old. She tried to help by bringing him books that would help him learn about amnesia and even some things that she enjoyed reading. One of the books that she took to him to read, ended up recovering his memory. It was a book that he had written many years before and realized that his real name is Joel. The book was written as a fiction book, but in reality is was a non-fiction that he'd written about many years before in California as he was a child and so were his friends.
As a child, Joel and his two friends Richard and Tommy had to stop a serial killer. He was back and tracking Joel and he had to warn his lady friend that her son and her had to leave that they were in danger. The killer were coming for them due make Joel suffer.
You have got to read this if you're a fan of Stephen King or love wacked out horror stories. Very well written and on a scale of 1 to 10, certainly a 10!
Profile Image for Blayne Alexander.
1 review3 followers
April 24, 2013
I don't read a lot of fiction. I used to, but after falling head first into true crime books, rock star autobiographies and forensic medicine, fiction just never felt real anymore. (Same reason I can't watch dramas on TV). But Geddy's Moon has changed that. With very minimal exception John Mulhall is effortlessly able to put you in a scenario regardless of how awkward, uncomfortable or horrible with such realistic precision, that I can't even number how many public outburst this book caused. It takes everything I used to enjoy about horror / thriller fiction and wraps it in a new face, dripping in fresh blood, waiting for the lights to go out. But it's more than just horror / thriller. This book is so genre bending that even the slightest description of it feels like you're spoiling something. Don't ask anyone what it's about, just read it. If you're a fan of this kind of book then you won't be let down. If you're a fan of reading, then you won't be let down, simply because it's apparent all the way through that John Mulhall is LOVING that he's able to tell you this story. You can literally hear and feel the excitement in his words. That's the trademark of an epic storyteller.

When I finished 'Geddy's Moon' I picked up the next book on my list; "Just Kids" by Patti Smith. A rock star autobiography of sorts, and realized that I couldn't do it. I need some time. I am probably going to find another work of fiction first.

Just as Danny Elfman needs to look over his shoulder these days to keep an eye on what Trent Reznor is up to...so should the Stephen Kings and Dean Koontz' of the world. Watch out all you Robert McCammons, Peter Straubs, and Richard Mathesons - John Mulhall is at the party...and he brought treats.
Profile Image for Sarah (blissbubbley).
374 reviews
April 11, 2013
It's a mixture of nerves and excitement when I see a review option from a debut author and with this book there was just something that made me have to read it. The synopsis is very good and the cover is also enticing you in more. Reading the first chapter I had absolutely no choice but to carry on reading page after page.

The first chapter is way back into the past and believe me the last paragraph is the hook to get you reading the rest of this book. I won't give it away but it you like a cliffhanger mixed with massive plot clue then you're going to love it! I found myself reading this through on just a few sittings as it was just so page turning and you totally forget that this is a new unknown writer. The book is anything but predictable with the villain being ... I can't say that's too much of a spoiler.

If you like your books mixed with a lot of great character development and a credible villain then this is definitely for you. The synopsis in the end doesn't really do it credit and whilst it's quick to mention a Stephen King likeness in the style of the books, I think Mulhall is making a name for himself and is definitely a writer to look out for in 2013 and beyond.

If you're not a fan of creepy books then this isn't for you. Or just read it with the light on.

Great first book from John Mulhall and cannot wait to read more of his books in the future.

Review was posted on Larissa's Life
Profile Image for Stephanie "GeekGirlReads" Thompson.
104 reviews7 followers
February 27, 2013
I developed a deep love of supernatural novels at a young age when I was introduced to Stephen King and Anne Rice. I am now an avid follower of authors such as Charlaine Harris, Laurel K. Hamilton, Patricia Briggs, Yasmine Galenorn, J.R. Ward, and on and on. I am incredibly pleased to add John Mulhall to that list.

The description of Geddy's Moon does not do it justice!!! I was prepared for a cookie cutter supernatural storyline and characters. Well, there is NOTHING stereotypical or ordinary about it. The level of care John has taken in developing such rich characters, and unpredictable plot, clearly reflects how much he respects the craft of storytelling. Through his meticulous attention to detail, we're firmly planted right there with his characters, inside their heads, sharing each and every emotion no matter how raw or unnerving. I was flooded with memories of what childhood friendships, the ones we can never quite achieve as adults, meant in a much simpler time. Oh and lest we forget our childhood fears we're very quickly reminded of them. I am a 41 year old mother and found myself doing that “hop” into bed to avoid my leg being grabbed by that dark, scary thing we all know lurks there. Geddy’s Moon gets under your skin and in your psyche that much. And I, for one, can’t wait for MORE! Bravo John!
Profile Image for Michael Handron jr.
1 review4 followers
February 25, 2013
At the beginning of Geddy’s Moon, I was expecting to be set up for a predictable supernatural monster story with the usual cast of characters. I thought I already had a good idea of where the plot was headed but thankfully I was VERY wrong. Geddy’s Moon is a wonderfully paced and deeply engrossing novel that will have you in its grips till the last page. Turn off your phone and find a comfortable chair; because once you start reading, you won’t want to stop.

Geddy’s Moon quickly pulls you in as each new layer is revealed and characters are developed. You soon realize that there is much more depth to the story than is originally hinted at. You find yourself drawn to the very likable Tyler and his plight to find out the truth about himself, balanced with a growing sense of dread for those around him.

What I liked most about Geddys Moon is how Mr. Mulhall manages to blend the supernatural thriller with an unexpected rich and very believable coming of age story. There are great supernatural elements, interesting plot twists and backstory along the way that make Geddy’s Moon an extremely satisfying journey for all readers and not just fans of the genre.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book and I can’t wait for the sequel!
1 review1 follower
February 25, 2013
I recall falling in love with reading as a child when I discovered my first Stephen King novel.  I subsequently sought out as many King and Dean Koontz works as my young eyes could pour through.  There is nothing more captivating than reading mere words on a page and immediately being physically, emotionally and intellectually transported to places and times beyond your own imagination.

I was truly delighted to find such powerful transportability in John Mulhall's debut thriller.  He has an innate ability to paint vivd landscapes and effortlessly illustrate characters in a way that creates a visual and relatable story, reminiscent of the most revered authors of my youth.  I found myself mesmerized by the plot, immersed in Mulhall's plausible narrative and devouring the entire 400+ page text in less than 24 hours.  A true page turner, Geddy's Moon transitions the reader from past to present, dream sequence to reality and from storyline to storyline with such fluidity and ease.

I am now an ardent supporter of Author John Mulhall and eagerly await his next gift to us, the readers, who can thoroughly appreciate his incredible vision and capacity to entertain, intrigue and leave us wanting more.
Profile Image for Wendy.
9 reviews2 followers
February 23, 2013
As an avid reader for many years, I find my favorite books are a completely immersive experience that require me to re-orient myself to reality when the last word has been read, combined with a tinge of regret that it is finished. Geddy's Moon is one of these rare books. First, the characters are well developed and richly illustrated, which drew me into the story immediately. The periphery and landscape of the story held such detail that I was able to envision each scene. Lending to this immersive experience is the brilliant story line replete with its own original take on a timeless archetype of the Beast. Very often, immersion in a story is interrupted by too oft-used adjectives, incorrect contextual details, and the requirement to flip back through pages to get a particular character or story line straight. Geddy's Moon is guilty of none of these offenses, as the writing is exceptional. I am stunned that Geddy's Moon is John Mulhall's first work, and I hope the first of many. I will buy his next book the minute it is released. John Mulhall is now firmly on my list of favorite authors, and Geddy's Moon is the best read of the year so far.
Profile Image for Cindy Meyers.
14 reviews2 followers
May 15, 2013
I am typically a fast reader. In a regular week, I will read one or two books, and on a week's vacation, I can read four or more. Getty's Moon, however, took me several weeks to complete. The reason is simple: I was terrified the whole time and could only read in the daytime and in short doses! Even then, my adrenaline would be pumping so hard that I'd need a break. In my own defense, the terror genre is not frequented on my bookshelf for this very reason. I prefer classics and Pulitzer winners with some crime solvers thrown in for light reading. I am so happy that I decided to read Getty's Moon through to the end. John Mulhall wrote a great book. Simple. The story is well-thought out and well-told. The pace and format is just about perfect to provide both understanding and suspense. The dialog is superb. And my favorite part: no loose ends, a complete story with all my questions answered by the last page. I highly recommend this book to all readers, especially to those non-terror people. Just read it during the day and take your time! You'll be satisfied when you reach the last page- my favorite feeling when finishing a novel.
1 review1 follower
November 8, 2012
Reading John's book will make you wonder why he is a first time author. Where has he been?

Geddy's Moon is impressive writing, mainly in the artful development of genuine human characters and authentic events taking place in numerous time periods and settings. I found myself moved to tears in places, effusive joyful laughter in others and scared to the point of clenching my pillow and kicking the couch. John's book will appeal to those who want a thriller with a supernatural bend, but who also enjoy thought-provoking literature. I wanted to read more! Hopefully John's first book won't be his last.
Profile Image for Tony Banando.
51 reviews1 follower
February 28, 2013
Geddy's Moon is a supernatural thriller that is very tense and entertaining. It does a good job of setting up a narrative and slowly releasing details, making the threat very gripping and mysterious for most of the book while slowly ratcheting up the tension. The narrative also spans across several different times to give some history behind characters without letting the tension lag. The characters are well developed and interesting and really get you to root for them. The entire story culminates in an extremely exciting climax with a very satisfying epilogue. In short, pick up Geddy's Moon; you won't be disappointed.
1 review2 followers
November 12, 2012
John Mulhall’s debut supernatural thriller, Geddy’s Moon, is one of the best novels I’ve had the pleasure to read in a long time. Satisfying down to the very last word, the rich development of his characters, as well as the heart-pounding plot, kept me wanting more. This is an absolutely fantastic read for anyone looking for book that captures everything the horror genre should be and more, providing the reader with a beautifully written and touching piece of literature. John Mulhall’s first novel is sure to establish him as one of America’s best authors.
1 review1 follower
December 27, 2012
There are some books that have the ability to truly transport you to another place. To say that Geddy’s Moon has that ability is an understatement. The characters are so well developed, the dialogue so well written, the environments so clearly depicted, that you become part of Tyler’s journey, feeling you have a stake in it yourself. The added plus is that while being so descriptive, there’s no fluff, no filler. Every sentence has meaning and often hints at something you can’t wait to discover, easily tempting a second reading. I can’t wait to read more!
Profile Image for Katie.
1 review
February 10, 2013
I was lucky to read an Advance Copy of Geddys Moon, and I found this novel to be addictive! It's very rare that I get so emotionally invested in a story and its characters, and even more unusual for me to think about them when I'm not reading the book. But Geddy's Moon is a unique novel that is suspenseful and exciting! It had me from the first page and never let me go. I cancelled many plans just to be able to continue my journey through Geddy's Moon! Highly recommended!
Profile Image for Tina Muraski.
2 reviews
April 7, 2013
Wow, just wow!

A true page turner from the moment you start reading. A well thought out, well researched, well written story that draws you in and anxious to find out what happens next.

Not your "typical" monster story. A good blend of present and past, with a bit of "coming of age".

A must read!!!
Profile Image for S.B. (Beauty in Ruins).
2,670 reviews243 followers
September 3, 2022
Amnesia. It's one of the most overused tropes in entertainment history, overplayed to the point that it has become a soap opera punch line - and rightly so. While it can be effective when resolved in the right way, all too often it's drawn out for the sake of dramatic effect. Juliette's prolonged amnesia on Grimm is a perfect example of where a desperate attempt to generate a little genre fails miserably.

Tie that amnesia to the proverbial drifter, and you've dug yourself a literary hole that many readers won't care to escape.

Fortunately, John Mulhall understands the risk involved in building a story around a drifter's amnesia. While it launches Geddy's Moon, the amnesia here is exploited just long enough to help establish some mystery, and then promptly resolved. It ends up being one of those rare instances where the trope works, and where the story is stronger for using it wisely, allowing for a very nice narrative reveal. There's such a sense of anticipation created through Tyler's dreams and his snippets of memories, we not only care what's happened to him, we're desperate to understand just what he's tried so hard to forget . .. and why.

Mulhall's work here reminds of Jonathan Mayberry, a literary nod to the likes of King and Koontz, but one that stops short of being a homage or an imitation. It's more an acknowledgement of just how effective, how narratively compelling those older stories are, updated for a new generation of readers.

There's a great story here, built upon a solid mystery and a truly chilling sense of horror. It's a story with several twists and turns, many of them surprising, some of them even shocking, but all of them consistent with the progression of the story. There are no cheap twists here, and no forced gotcha moments. Mulhall evokes strong emotional reactions on the part of the reader, but does so fairly. More than that, it's a story driven by great characters, men and women who are already being developed the moment they first appear on the page. It's hard not to become connected to these characters, to identify and sympathize with them, which is (of course) key to making us care about those narrative surprises.

The pacing, for the most part, is excellent, with only the ending coming across as a little rushed. There's a lot of detail, and a lot of time invested in developing scenes and settings, but it all flows well. While I sometimes found myself impatient to get on with the story, to find out how it was all going to be resolved, that's not a comment on the pacing or the level of detail, but on my investment in the fate of the world created.

I hate to keep making comparisons, but if you're a fan of the 'classics' of King, Koontz, Straub, McCammon, and their peers, where the supernatural element is just as important, just as well-developed, and just as entertaining as the character element, then you are definitely going to enjoy the read.


Originally reviewed at Beauty in Ruins
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.